New and Experienced Climbers over 50 #42
|
|
to those proclaiming to need more safe sport routes: |
|
|
Daniel Shively wrote: Daniel, was this Mt. Locke that you posted on April 2? |
|
|
Lori wrote about the routes on the west side of Little Hunk: |
|
|
Lori Milas wrote: Lori, it seems like you have your heart set on this, but, wherever you get your octopus from, you are still supporting the removal of that critter from the wild. As I said, I had freshwater aquariums, and it was a fun hobby. But, I chose to only stock fish that were captive bred, not wild caught. And, bred some myself. These were essentially domesticated fish, selected for various traits, and had departed considerably from their wild ancestors. Pets. Maybe what you really should set your sites on, is learning to dive, and visiting the octopuses garden in person? In the shade? Under the sea? Oh dear. Now I'm stuck. Helen |
|
|
Ward Smith wrote: Ha! That reminds me of when a guidance counselor called me in in high school and asked me what I wanted to be. I said " An emperor" (I had been reading a bunch of books about Napoleon) He had absolutely no comeback. Being a teen ager, I was thinking " Yeah, you moron, you are going to guide me? The conversation quickly faded out and he never called me back, no advice on how to become one or prepping for college. It turns out I could have really used a good counselor. |
|
|
M Sprague wrote: Presumably unaware of your recent reading matter, one wonders whether he might have thought that your ambition was to become a particular variety of penguin. Would certainly have been difficult to advise upon! |
|
|
Alex Smith wrote: That’s a ridiculous assumption. WTF is a “documented ascent” on any route in Joshua Tree?!? A tick on the Proj? Lots and lots of people climb and don’t use ticks on MP.
Then a crappy little 5.9 put up decades ago by a guy with no gym training and vastly inferior shoes isn’t even something they’d ever bother with in the first place. |
|
|
Old lady H wrote: The only day of my diving career was a coral reef in S Thailand and the highlight of the day was when my guide pointed out an octopus about 3' away that was so unbelievably camouflaged I never would have noticed it. Watching the octopus watch me and then seeing it casually move along after it deemed us as no threat was a memorable experience. Almost brushing a scorpion fish with my clumsy hand was another memory of the day, my dive instructor luckily saw it and pulled me back! If any creature on earth came from another planet it is the octopus, the intelligence of them is literally out of this world. |
|
|
Been trying to buy new rock shoes. I have been in Scarpa force for decades. size 45. The two pairs I have been using the most have many resoles on them and are getting tired. the Quantic was on sale so I gave that a try. Its only slightly aggressive looking compared to other curved shoes out there. super painful and small so I tried it again in 45.5. still too small. Just processed that return. Now I am not confident that If I find a Force in 45 or 45.5 that it will not be too small. no local climbing shops. Wondering if they changed their sizing or if it was simply the different model? |
|
|
I wore the Force for years and finally found their replacement in the Scarpa Origin, it's sold as an entry level shoe(whatever the hell that means) and is a flat and stiff shoe. Cheap too. It's my comfy all around shoe that really supports my big toe on small crystals. And to add on sizing, I typically wore a 43.5 to 44 for years and find all of my newer shoes are 45 to 47 now. I think I dealt with breaking in pain better BITD, that or sizing has changed |
|
|
You type as if that were a problem, lol. Documented ascent of a 5.9 hahahahahahah! |
|
|
We have a tendency to miss subtlety in text. The guy has his own perspective. That’s ok. Keeps the conversation interesting. |
|
|
Funny that Good to the Last Drop causes so much consternation. For the record, there are 2 bolts on the bottom of the climb, then a perfect size 7 hex that is bomb proof, then about a 20 foot runout to the last bolt. If someone did want to add a bolt, it had damn well better be done ground up, on stance, on lead. If you think you would have wanted to stop and put more bolts in doing a proper job, more power to you, now go do it in 70s climbing shoes. Sometimes a route determines how it is protected, not the climbers. |
|
|
Jan Mc wrote: Word. I remember doing that route with you. We'd done a couple routes already when you suggested we do it. I guess it was my turn to lead. Anyway, at the base you handed me a #7 hex. "Here, you might want this." It is, truly, a perfect placement. |
|
|
tom donnelly wrote: Sure looks like Mt Locke to me! Wahoo Gully prominent front and center, right? Brother Jim and I climbed it one winter/spring day LONG ago, meaning to ski it back down. A bitter, strong, freezing wind followed us up to the top. The Wahoo was so frozen by the time we got up that we chose to go back down the low angle south facing aspect that is partially visible on the left side of the summit. Good day, good memories... (Can't seem to get Dan's photo from April 2 to come along with the text) |
|
|
Jan Mc wrote: Honestly I have not understood why people have gotten so worked up about this, except maybe that they are extrapolating to the broader issue of "add bolts or don't add bolts". I am firmly in the don't add bolts unless you have permission camp because: 1. There are thousands and thousands of routes to choose from. If something is too scary for you, choose another route. I've never done the last pitch of Super Chicken, for example, and I am perfectly OK with Rick A deciding not to change the bolting on it after a long debate about it on Supertopo. Even though I was in the camp of, "well if you did add 2 bolts to the pitch, it would probably get done more". But it's perfectly OK that it still only gets done by the climber that can do it. 2. Not only is "not every route meant for every climber", but "not every 5.9 route is meant for every 5.9 climber". When I was a better climber I did probably hundreds of 5.9 R routes. Those routes were meant for me, and the climber I was then. I enjoy having to really pay attention, while at the same time feeling quite comfortable in knowing there is no reason that I should fall (except if I don't pay attention). I still do a lot of routes with mandatory runouts, at the level that is appropriate for me NOW, and I still really enjoy that aspect of climbing. In fact, one of the MOST FUN aspects of gear routes, routes that you can put a piece anywhere you want, is the game of how often you want to place gear. Just the other day, I did a gorgeous 5.8 hand crack and it was so secure and so in my comfort zone that a couple of times, I had to force myself to stop and put in a piece after 30 feet, just because I know that it's the sensible and responsible thing to do. The whole "add a bolt, people can skip it if they want to" argument is ridiculous. It completely changes the nature of the challenge. And if a challenge isn't one of the biggest attractive factors in climbing, in why some people climb at all, then why are so many people so freakin' obsessed with the grade they climb, and how hard the climb is. "Project" is just another word for a challenge. It's great that there are a lot of sport routes for people to climb to challenge themselves safely on things they cannot comfortably onsight. But that's only one aspect available to climbers. Some climbers love the physical aspect, some love the technical aspect, some love the mental aspect. These are all just flavors of challenges for different people. Some climbers love projects, others have no interest in them. Would any one climb there if all the routes in Joshua Tree were 5.7 sport bolted slabs? Variety is the spice of climbing, people. Seems pretty obvious. |
|
|
Wow, what a treat. I cringe when I mention a topic that has so much disagreement but the conversation is so enlightening. The only reason (as far as I know) that Good To The Last Drop has been hashed over so much is because when I was trying to work through my list of all the routes that included David Houser as an FA, this one was on that list. And I couldn't get it done. No one would take the risk. Finally someone did, I got to top rope it, but I kept thinking 'what's the big deal'? But I kept hearing "If only it had one more bolt...". So that was my introduction to the issue. I argued (again) with a friend who is a really good climber here, for whom this is a big issue. He has a deep reverence for 'old times'. He's a fan of Bachar, of Mike Waugh, Cosgrove... all the early gang. He wants to climb routes exactly as intended, ground up, just the way they were initially climbed. He believes anything else is self-serving. that sentiment dovetails with my pondering of 'where are the climbers' here in Joshua Tree? I thought this place was packed with climbers before! Perhaps they are just not interested in doing things the way they were done bitd. I know several climbers who aren't interested in risking their lives for a climb...they head to sport climbing areas. Is there a climber alive today who WANTS danger? (I'm sure there are still a few).. They want to work their route, get a great workout, and get home safely. So I came in today to have another look at Jan's route. No one was climbing Intersection Rock, no one was on any part of Old Woman... the parking lot was nearly empty. It's QUIET. Kind of a difficult scramble this time for me, having to occasionally bend my knee. But there it was, Good To The Last Drop, proud and .... empty. While there I sat at the base of Chalk Up Another One and fondly remembered that climb with Bob... another Houser route that I enjoyed so much. And hard for me. It was a big day, even without the threat of death. :-) So, you can leave everything exactly as it was 50 years ago... as a monument to what was. Very few people are going to climb it. ----- Daniel, thank you for your detailed post. You filled in some blanks. Tom... as for the routes on Little Hunk... this is an area I feel possessive of. It's ok with me that no one goes there... but I always wonder why not? IT's my idea of incredible climbing, and for slab lovers it's a feast. Plus, it's a little different trees, flora, rock.. feels very hidden. --- Helen, This IS a dilemma I'm going to work through. We passed a law here in CA and Washington prohibiting octopus farming--I'm a part of that. This fellow got his octopus from a live fish market, which we have here as well. So that's a possible source and a way from preventing a little one from being someone's dinner. There are hobbyists who raise octopuses and breed them. Don't know where I fit quite yet. Tony told me yesterday he's buying another new car. This will be his 4th car since we met (8 years ago). ("What? What's wrong with this car?") He's happier and more lit up than I've seen him in awhile. Some people need a new car to get excited about life. Some people need a new bowling ball. Some people need a new octopus? Fish market. |
|
|
I am always amazed that some think MP is some sort of end all, be all, guidebook. I was at the Manure Pile- probably the most climbed chunk of rock in the Valley- and MP has about 40% of the climbing covered. Using the “tick list” seems to be even more suspect in determining when the “last” documented ascent happened. ————————————————————— Lori - I would advise against having an Aquarium especially a salt water one. The technology has improved significantly in the last 2 decades. Everyone have a good weekend Later all |
|
|
Lori Milas wrote: You ask 'where are the climbers' in Joshua Tree? When I went to climb in Joshua tree this winter I saw dozens of trad climbers, mostly congregating around the hidden valley campground and intersection rock. I also saw and met many climbers around Indian cove campground and at split rock pullout. These weren't boulderers, they were trad climbers, and they were of all ages from 20s to middle age and older. I think maybe climbing in Joshua Tree is seasonal (winter when it is cooler). Also probably is more populated with climbers on friday to sunday. That was just my experience. I also saw and met dozens of climbers near the Gunsmoke traverse area. It was a party out there. |
|
|
My search for new shoes ordering blind on the internet has not been working so In my infinite wisdom and navigation prowess I decided that Smuggs was on the way to REI in the big city just outside of Burlington ;) I know that Parasol in NH would have been a sure bet today but that was in the wrong direction. Ice is all done in New England except for some isolated dark shady spots at higher altitude and stuff really high in the whites. It did set up last night so that was a positive. Most of the hike in was pretty soft and I met a party of 3 that had gotten skunked on two of the likly spots but both of those were near the road and not at the top of the pass. By the timer I left the road just past the height of the pass it was set up nicely. I climbed about 500ft of steep crunchy styrofoam snow to the gully. the last 60m was nasty scree and glazed rock. there is a nice 5.9+ that goes up the center of that buttress on the right. Fritz tried it BINTD and backed off. don't remember who got it first.. When I got to the ice it had melted out into a slightly overhanging shrund it climbed a lot trickier than it looks.. the wind was really honking in there probably more than 50mph.. Wind was so intense it was making me dizzy. The start of P2 looked pretty undermined and burly. Just getting there from where I was looked like it was more work and risk than It was worth so I bailed. It was a nice day for a hike but time to put a fork in it.. The shoe shopping adventure went well. A different model scarpa at the same size 45.5 as the mail order pair that was way too tight was very comfortable. Possibly too comfortable.. second guessing myself.... it was good to try them on and now I know that if these stretch out too much I can drop a half size and be good .. |













