Mountain Project Logo

Chipping vs. Gluing

Kevin Piarulli · · Redmond, OR · Joined Nov 2013 · Points: 2,293
Claudine Longet wrote:

I had a line that had 50' of really fun 5.9 jugs, then a 10' section of glacier scrape featureless blankness, then another 50' of technical 5.12

I ultimately walked away.

But I was seriously considering bolting 2 gym holds on to make it go. I figured if I used a 5 piece the only real damage would be a sleeve that could get filled. This would have been minimal damage compared to either glueing or chipping but definitely would have caused more conniptions. 

I have a route where after 20' of one and 2 finger pockets there is a Thank God end of crux flake. The flake flexes if you hit it without being flush to the stone. We all are aware of how to reach for it, but if we publicize it it will need reinforcement first.

I also have a rule about comfortizing. If it makes my fingers bleed it goes. Unless it's a feature of the route. 

- Why not put an anchor midway? 50 feet of 5.9 jugs sounds like a fun route to me. Then put a 5.16 project extension if the top half really needs to be climbed.

- Could you remove the flexing Thank God flake? Sounds unsafe, and there's nothing wrong with a route becoming harder.

pkeds · · Broomfield, CO · Joined Feb 2006 · Points: 30

I think either is fine. Plenty of rock to go around. Go rip it!

Shane F · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Aug 2014 · Points: 1

I have climbed a lot on limestone, check my tick list. I personally I like sharp edges in pockets. The Final where I have done the most climbing in the past years is sharp but the developers have done a pretty good job of taking a light touch approach to comfortizing. I don't like the pockets at wild iris, they are less positive and get "slimy". To each their own but in the end leave as much of the natural rock as possible.

Claudine Longet · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2020 · Points: 0
Kevin Piarulli wrote:

- Why not put an anchor midway? 50 feet of 5.9 jugs sounds like a fun route to me. Then put a 5.16 project extension if the top half really needs to be climbed.

- Could you remove the flexing Thank God flake? Sounds unsafe, and there's nothing wrong with a route becoming harder.

I considered it, but it would be a one star pitch in an area of 4 star routes. The blankness is really, really blank too. Utterly featureless including even recesses. Like a huge chalkboard. Some A0 bolts would be the only plausible tactic, so I deferred instead to some possible future human mutations, perhaps adding gecko dna.

The flake on the other route will survive many ascents as you need to climb a long .11D section just to get to it, meaning gumbies won't be pulling horizontally on it unless they Batman up 40'

Although laying here thinking about it, I might just bolt the flake down, maybe with a big washer. Like you see on roadcut stone holding the rock back. I'm really good at camouflage, no one would see it from the ground.

Trevor Taylor · · Seattle, WA · Joined Nov 2020 · Points: 0
JCM wrote:

In this specific case (Wild Iris) we aren't just talking about one route, but an entire area that is enjoyed by many and played a role in the advancement of  US difficulty standards. I won't claim it is world class, but it is a great destination that wouldn't be nearly as good or as popular without filing down pockets. Its not just about a few people complaining - it is one of the gems of US sport climbing basically not existing as a worthy climbing area if not for comfortizing. Would that be worth it to you, to avoid the sacrilege of filing down a few mm of limestone on the edge of sharp pockets? 

Wild iris is one of my favorite climbing areas but I agree it would be like climbing razorblades without comfortizing

Gumby boy king · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Oct 2019 · Points: 547

Lots of interesting take here. I guess does everything have to be climbed? Or if it needs that much cleaning etc... Was it better of being left alone? 

John Tuttle · · Just a dude, playing a dude. · Joined Mar 2020 · Points: 245
Gumby boy king wrote:

Lots of interesting take here. I guess does everything have to be climbed? Or if it needs that much cleaning etc... Was it better of being left alone? 

I think the vast majority of climbers have little conception of how the sausage is made lol.

Do you think Harding, Merry and Whitmore should have abandoned the FA of The Nose because the upper corners required days and days of excavation of dirt and chipping (pins) and drilling to finish?

Do you think Lynn Hill would criticize those who de facto chipped the great roof or changing corners with pins for her to allow the FFA, her greatest single achievement in climbing?

You see, the free Nose is mighty fine tasting sausage and virtually all climbing is completely dependent on such grey areas that alter the rock and remove vegetation.

Otherwise it ALL should have been left alone and climbing (or any any other visitation to wild places) wouldn't exist.

We climb in a grey zone. If it brings us to a few summits we are blessed.

Patrik · · Third rock from Sun · Joined Jun 2010 · Points: 30

Is limestone the only type of rock that occasionally is "comfortized"?

Tim Stich · · Colorado Springs, Colorado · Joined Jan 2001 · Points: 1,516

For some reason I read this thread title as "Chipping vs. Gulag" comrade.

David K · · The Road, Sometimes Chattan… · Joined Jan 2017 · Points: 434
JCM wrote:

In this specific case (Wild Iris) we aren't just talking about one route, but an entire area that is enjoyed by many and played a role in the advancement of  US difficulty standards. I won't claim it is world class, but it is a great destination that wouldn't be nearly as good or as popular without filing down pockets. Its not just about a few people complaining - it is one of the gems of US sport climbing basically not existing as a worthy climbing area if not for comfortizing. Would that be worth it to you, to avoid the sacrilege of filing down a few mm of limestone on the edge of sharp pockets? 

Me, personally? Yes, that would be worth it to me. There are thousands of miles of cliffline that have great climbing without modification--nobody is holding a gun up to my head and telling me I need to develop that specific area.

But I've never been there and I have no skin in the game. I'm not complaining about Wild Iris or judging people for filing down pockets there, because I'm willing to be overruled by people who have been there and are invested in the area. It is their choice to make, not mine.

All I am saying is that you shouldn't pretend it isn't a choice--that it's something you have to do. If you make a choice that's different from the choice I would make, fine. I'm not trying to be the dictator of climbing. I'm just saying that when people stop seeing that they have choices and taking responsibility for those choices, they stop thinking about what they're doing. And with rock, the damage done by poor choices is permanent, so you really should think very hard about what you're doing before you do it.

RRR · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Aug 2020 · Points: 0
Shane F wrote:

Glue is only for bolts. If a flake or loose rock can be removed by hand without tools it should be removed. If a large death block is precarious or very clearly dangerous bring the tools necessary to remove it. Comfortizing holds, in my opinion, is unnecessary. If it is so thin it will cut you, it will probably break anyway. Otherwise deal with the pain.

Sounds like you've never had to make the decision to leave or remove a booby trap, "put you out of the game for 3 weeks finger slicing crystal" before. You'd do the same as me if you had.

David K · · The Road, Sometimes Chattan… · Joined Jan 2017 · Points: 434
Glowering wrote:

This is similar to some bolting discussions where some people approach it from a positions of principle rather than pragmaticism. i.e. the principled stances are chipping (or bolting) is never okay or the other side may say chipping is fine. The pragmatic stance is more nuanced and based on thinking things through and making decisions based on reason. Why is chipping to be avoided? IMO opinion the main reason is because you may be robbing some people of the chance to do the route as nature created it. Chipping a route to make it easier robs someone of the chance to do it in it's natural state. That's bogus. Chipping to remove a sharp crystal in a pocket is a different story. Will anyone in the future really want the sharp crystal there?

You're asking this as if it's a rhetorical question, but it isn't. The answer, if you think about it, is obviously yes. You think in the entire future of humanity there will be nobody who likes the challenge of gritting their teeth through painful holds? Sure, that person is a weirdo, but since when is this a sport for normals? There are plenty of people who enjoy doing types of climbs that would be absolutely miserable for me.

Also, lest I be accused of being an idealist: there are cases where I'd be totally on board with drilling/chipping manufactured holds, or bolting/gluing on holds. There are quarries where the entire wall was manufactured by miners, so there's not really a ton of reason to say that climbers shouldn't make a few more small modifications. Bolting a splitter crack might be excusable if it's the only crack in a grid-bolted area. Things that are travesties in one context might be totally excusable in another context.

Interestingly, I tend to err on the side of removing loose rock rather than bolting/gluing it. My first choice would be to leave it alone, but if you really think it's going to come off, and in a dangerous way, then removing it seems to be a smaller change because it's just speeding up what nature was going to do eventually.

David K · · The Road, Sometimes Chattan… · Joined Jan 2017 · Points: 434
RRR wrote:

Sounds like you've never had to make the decision to leave or remove a booby trap, "put you out of the game for 3 weeks finger slicing crystal" before. You'd do the same as me if you had.

Are you seriously acting as if cutting your finger on a rock is some sort of unique, life-changing experience? What condescending nonsense. I can't speak for the person you're responding to, but I've cut my fingers up plenty.

You didn't HAVE TO do anything. You made a choice. I'm not saying you made the wrong choice, but at least take responsibility for the choice you made.

M M · · Maine · Joined Oct 2020 · Points: 3

Comfortising= chipping/altering the rock. I've been involved but lets just call it what it is. How about gardening? Gardening=ripping out vegetation&cutting down trees. Making up happier names is fine, its like a secret climber language!

splitclimber · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jan 2007 · Points: 30

 if we can't agree on definitions, how are we to discuss and argue about these nuisances. The post above is a clear example of this.

RRR · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Aug 2020 · Points: 0
David K wrote:

Are you seriously acting as if cutting your finger on a rock is some sort of unique, life-changing experience? What condescending nonsense. I can't speak for the person you're responding to, but I've cut my fingers up plenty.

You didn't HAVE TO do anything. You made a choice. I'm not saying you made the wrong choice, but at least take responsibility for the choice you made.

Not sure what part of me admitting to comfortizing holds to make them not slice your fingers open, is me not taking responsibility. If you like sitting out for a month while your finger heals, then youre the man! Sorry, but I dont have time for that shit. Your argument is ridiculous at best.

@M Montoya

Your definition of comfotizing is about as sincere as a me calling you a Nazi for disagreeing with me. Comfortizing is comfortizing. What if I do it all with my boots, and just smash and kick away until the razor edge or crystal is all gone? Is that just a well traveled route at that point? Im just speeding up the process, and giving the second ascentionist that same experience as the 200th ascent.

Jim Titt · · Germany · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 490
David K wrote:

You made a choice. I'm not saying you made the wrong choice, but at least take responsibility for the choice you made.

You sure are keen on calling justifications excuses. Nobody on here is evading their responsibilty or denying they comfortize holds and they have given their reasons for deciding to do so.

John Tuttle · · Just a dude, playing a dude. · Joined Mar 2020 · Points: 245
HUGE Tradifan wrote:

All of the actions being discussed in this thread are simply excuses to climb more rock and are exceptions to a clean climbing ethic. 

While we should always seek to limit our impacts a big part of my point is that a "clean climbing ethic" is still fraught with many hypocrisies. Really it's about stopping the steady destruction of climbs ie pins in Serenity Crack and leaving no trace of subsequent ascents. Preservation of existing classic climbs was paramount.

But if we are to climb at all then routes will be cleaned and loose/dangerous rock removed. Pockets will be comfortized and bolts will be drilled. This is not inconsistent with a minimal impact ethic in my biased opinion.

After the FA then the routes should be preserved in that state. The mountain sure as hell didn't care a pocket was filled or some bits installed. We shouldn't be "holier than thou" and make a mountain of a few thimblefuls of rock dust and lichen. An infinitely greater amount of rock and veg will never be disturbed.

Time better spent stopping uranium mining in Bear's Ears.

Mark Frumkin · · Bishop, CA · Joined Feb 2013 · Points: 52

hillbilly, everything you said is an excuse! Justifying bad selfish behavior.

Whether I'm on the trail or on a climb I do everything to mitigate my presence. I want the next person to never know I was there! I want them to have the feeling that they are among the first to be there. 

  

Gumby boy king · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Oct 2019 · Points: 547
John Tuttle wrote:

I think the vast majority of climbers have little conception of how the sausage is made lol.

Do you think Harding, Merry and Whitmore should have abandoned the FA of The Nose because the upper corners required days and days of excavation of dirt and chipping (pins) and drilling to finish?

Do you think Lynn Hill would criticize those who de facto chipped the great roof or changing corners with pins for her to allow the FFA, her greatest single achievement in climbing?

You see, the free Nose is mighty fine tasting sausage and virtually all climbing is completely dependent on such grey areas that alter the rock and remove vegetation.

Otherwise it ALL should have been left alone and climbing (or any any other visitation to wild places) wouldn't exist.

We climb in a grey zone. If it brings us to a few summits we are blessed.

I see how the sausage is made, but what if there was another way the sausage could have been made?? Without damaging the rock? Maybe the nose doesn't go free until the year 2169, but we will never know...

This also begs the question, if our lord and savior, royal robbins, was creating the climbing manifesto today, would gluing, chipping, etc... be accepted?

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

General Climbing
Post a Reply to "Chipping vs. Gluing"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.