Type: TR, 40 ft
FA: unknown
Page Views: 1,496 total · 12/month
Shared By: e Dixon on Aug 14, 2008
Admins: Leo Paik, John McNamee, Frances Fierst, Monty, Monomaniac

You & This Route


11 Opinions

Your To-Do List:

Add To-Do · View List

Your Star Rating:


     Clear Rating

Your Difficulty Rating:


-none- Change

Your Ticks:

Add New Tick
    -none-

Description

Climb the face on the right side of the south face, passes one drilled pin and ends at the same belay as Right X.

Location

Right side of the south face, just right of Right X.

Protection

Typically toproped. One drilled pin.

Photos

eli poss
Durango, Co
  5.9+
eli poss   Durango, Co
  5.9+
This would be a 4 star classic if it was lead-able. Would it rustle anybody's feathers too much if some bolts were added to make it lead-able? I wouldn't imagine people would mind too much considering there is already a drilled angle in place. Sep 21, 2015
Matthias Holladay
Shiprock, Navajolands
Matthias Holladay   Shiprock, Navajolands
IDK, Eli,

...some folks are pretty adamant about altering routes established on lead, and I've heard this one was.

BTW, it IS capable of being led. Sep 21, 2015
eli poss
Durango, Co
  5.9+
eli poss   Durango, Co
  5.9+
Huh, it seemed like this route is designed to be TRed, it seems kind of weird put up a TR route on lead, and with the only a single drilled angle 1/3 way up, I'd consider this more of a free solo than a lead. Do you know who the first ascentionist/ route equipper was on this one?

FWIW, I am one of the folks that would be hesitant to altering a route put up on lead, even with FA permission, but I have a hard time believing this specific route was indeed put up on lead. Sep 23, 2015
Matthias Holladay
Shiprock, Navajolands
Matthias Holladay   Shiprock, Navajolands
Again, in 1988, when I led it, I'd heard it had been put up on lead.

But sure, it'd be nice if wasn't an X-rated route...what do X-Rock regulars think? Sep 24, 2015
My 2 cents is like The Itch and Red Book all doable leads, just sketchy. I think X Rock is better as it is, instead of making it all sport. Plenty of that around here anyway. Oct 4, 2015
-mn
-mn  
Below the pin there's a bomber yellow Alien (if memory serves), and after the crux, there's a red Alien or maybe a 0.75 - again if mem.... Also, there's descent pro down low in some horizontals. Really, a pretty casual lead - "4 stars", ha ha. Oct 12, 2015
eli poss
Durango, Co
  5.9+
eli poss   Durango, Co
  5.9+
Perhaps I follow a different line than you, but I don't recall there being a red Alien placement after the crux, and I was not suggesting making it a sport climb but rather a bolt protected trad lead.

If I were to bolt it, I'd only be adding 2 bolts above the drilled angle and none below. It would still be a bold lead, in my opinion, especially given the nature of the route, and a fall certainly would not be fun but also wouldn't kill you.

Edit: after doing a lot of thinking and reflecting, I came to the conclusion that adding bolts to this wouldn't be the best decision as it may set a precedent that "adding bolts to existing climbs is okay". Later, more bolts might be added and this climb deserves better than to become a safe bolted sport route. Oct 14, 2015