Mountain Project Logo

Replacing the lightweight climbing approach shoe

Josh Rappoport · · Natick, MA · Joined Sep 2017 · Points: 31
Mike Larson wrote:

The TX4 Evo ST is essentially the TX3 with a slightly different midsole. The weight is almost exactly the same, both clocking in around 360g. The toebox geometry is a slightly different, but not enough for me to notice. 

I have TX4 EVOs and they seem much clunkier and stiffer than the TX3s.  Also, the TX4 EVO ST doesn't seem available currently in my size...

PatMas · · Las Vegas, NV · Joined Jan 2017 · Points: 40
Jesse Scarborough wrote:

Everyone I know who has used a BD shoe says they're trash. I think all their non-safety stuff has really gotten quite shit since their VC buy out. 

BD approach shoes look great on paper. In reality I'm pretty sure that I could build a better shoe with cardboard and duct tape. I bought 3 pairs of BD approach shoes directly from BD in 2023/34, all three had obvious visual defects where stitching missed the materials it was trying to join, or the sole wasn't fully attached from the factory.  BD support did not want to give me a full refund and return shipping for them because they were "used" aka I had worn 1 pair for a short hike before realizing that there was a hole in the shoes lining. 

David L · · Austin, TX · Joined Oct 2024 · Points: 0
bearded sam wrote:

Has anyone tried the Arcteryx Konseal or Vertex speed?

I like my Konseals. I tried a lot of approach shoes before finding these to fit my feet the best (narrow heels but wider forefoot). Leather is nice because it breaks in properly to the shape of the foot. I mostly bought them for underfoot protection on boulder-hopping and class 3 scrambling but they climb up to 5.easy just fine too. I'm sure some people would be comfortable on 5.8 in them. They run about a half size (US) large, and my size 12 pair (non-GTX version) weighs 990g with the insoles swapped to something more robust. The arc'teryx insoles are trash, just a thin floppy piece of foam.

I will try on TX1s at some point with the idea that they might fill that underfoot protection role with more toe room and hiking comfort when I don't need as much edging performance.

Daniel Roctapod · · NY · Joined Jun 2025 · Points: 1

If you can find them, Salewa Wildfire 2. They use really sticky Pomoca rubber—who make BC ski skins.  

Cosmic Hotdog · · California · Joined Sep 2019 · Points: 462
Tyler B wrote:

For context I do light trail running in Altra Lone Peak 12.5s and use the discontinued Altra Grafton’s in a very very comfortable size 13 for cragging with no real technical approach. All of my old Lone Peaks have blown out a the pinky MTP joint. My feet run super hot and they’re also very wide so I’m really sensitive to narrow shoes and prolonged abuse on the toes and feet. 


I was only able to do an A/B with whatever REI had this summer. I believe that was the TX4 EVO ST. I basically brought in all my old shoes(OG TX2s, Altra Graftons, boulder Xs) and compared them to *brand new *Rapid LTs, TX4s EVO st?, 5.10 guide tennies, and Scarpa Cruxs. I have wide feet and the Rapid LT was the least bad option and felt the widest of the bunch but only by a small margin. The TX4s were too heavy, too stiff and a bit too narrow for what I was looking for.

  •  I spent the summer using Rapid LTs for alpine rock, they not the most comfortable for long hikes but not crazy uncomfortable, are kind of heavy for dragging up the wall but were pretty worth it for the routes with tricky 4th class and low 5th sections on the approach/descent.  They really shined on one of the routes that involved 250m of 4th/ low 5th class down climb scrambling to get off the mountain.
  •  They stayed in the duffle bag when I went crack cragging, I would never wear these shoes to the crag, they are too narrow and uncomfortable. The mesh on the sides does stretch a bit and molds the foot but not quite as much as the OG TX2 because they’re much more enforced on the side 
  • I think they are overkill for somewhere like Squamish were an OG TX2 or lighter shoe is my preferred option for multi-pitch routes.  The OG TX2 only worked for me because they were so so light and that old mesh REALLY stretched out and allowed my foot to become more comfortable.  My scale puts the OG TX2s at lower weight than my Altra lone peak 8s. 
  • The Rapid LT is the kind of jack of all trades master of none shoe cause it’s not crazy heavy, is a bit wider than the competition, has nice mesh ventilation that molds a bit to the foot but is stiff and burly enough that it’s a big step up from the TX2. 

Massively helpful man, thank you for taking the time to cover all these details!

Matt Ehn · · CA · Joined Oct 2010 · Points: 476

Just b/c a shoe/product is discontinued does not mean you need to "replace" it.

eBay, Poshmark, FB marketplace, etc and a bit of time will find what you desire. Oftentimes for way less than you'd pay normally. (try searchtempest.com for searching also)

Matt Gravier · · PA · Joined Feb 2024 · Points: 0
Heyzeus wrote:

I run Xero's Trail Mesa 2 as my everyday shoe, I don't think they climb that good on rock ( Chuck Taylor's work better) and was always interested in the Scrambler, so maybe the Scrambler rubber is better? The Xero Piro is pretty good though, and lighter, but also more barefoot, so one has to be even more mindful about rocks and stuff poking the sole.

I love xero shoes but the rubber they use is not sticky or grippy at all. I’ve slipped and skidded on low angle rock and hiking trails bc of how slick they are. I haven’t used their scramblers but they’re using a sole from Michelin, not sure if they’re grippy bc of the tread or bc of the rubber. But I’ve started migrating over to Astral shoes. They’re water shoes, but their rubber is much better for traction and I have a lot more confidence when scrambling with them. 

Logan Peterson · · Santa Fe, NM · Joined Jan 2015 · Points: 403

I've had surprisingly good luck with BD approach shoes myself. Pair of full leather Missions lasted years. But maybe they gave up on QC about the time they decided that everyone needs neon footwear.

Zachary Cleary · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2015 · Points: 43
Matt Ehn wrote:

Just b/c a shoe/product is discontinued does not mean you need to "replace" it.

eBay, Poshmark, FB marketplace, etc and a bit of time will find what you desire. Oftentimes for way less than you'd pay normally. (try searchtempest.com for searching also)

I mean… “sure”. A quick search of all platforms show none my size.

Eventually the shoe supply will run out and I run through and approach shoe each season! The mental exercise here was trying to find something similar at the moment.

Karl Henize · · Boulder, CO · Joined Aug 2013 · Points: 653
Matt Gravier wrote:

I love xero shoes but the rubber they use is not sticky or grippy at all. I’ve slipped and skidded on low angle rock and hiking trails bc of how slick they are. I haven’t used their scramblers but they’re using a sole from Michelin, not sure if they’re grippy bc of the tread or bc of the rubber. But I’ve started migrating over to Astral shoes. They’re water shoes, but their rubber is much better for traction and I have a lot more confidence when scrambling with them. 

The rubber on the Xero Scramblers is not on par with typical approach shoe rubber. It might be stickier than other Xero shoes, but I don’t like using them on anything wet or fourth class.

For a minimalist approach shoe, I like the Be Lenka Trailwalker resoled with Vibram Megagrip Elite.  The original outsole is fine up to fourth class, dry rock.  It is much better for scrambling on rock than the Xero Scrambler, in my opinion.

I am excited by the announced, but not yet released, TX Setter.  Seems like it might be good option for people who want to climb fifth class rock in approach shoes.

Rob Duckles · · Superior, CO · Joined Jul 2013 · Points: 30

Rock and Resole put Unparallel Dot rubber on a pair of Altra Superior 7's for me, and I really like the result. It's probably my dream lightweight climbing approach shoe.
Pros: best smearing friction I've ever experienced in approach shoes, good ground feel, but still enough padding to be comfortable with sharp rocks on the approach/deproach. Really comfortable, noticeably lighter than almost every approach shoe. Runnable.
Cons: wide toe box and soft midsole will never be ideal for edging, the sticky Unparallel RH rubber is less durable than something like Megagrip.

I would +1 that Xero shoe rubber (incl. the Michelin rubber Scrambler) feels far less sticky than Vibram Megagrip. I wish Xero would come out with a sticky approach shoe, because I do otherwise like their products.

Adam W · · TX/Nevada · Joined Dec 2019 · Points: 532

The Xero scramblers work for me but the approach i'm doing is on incredibly sharp limestone that anything on the planet will stick to I have no idea how well  the Michelin sole works on slippery sandstone or other surfaces.

Jack Kelly · · Las Vegas, NV · Joined Oct 2017 · Points: 765
Daniel Roctapod wrote:

If you can find them, Salewa Wildfire 2. They use really sticky Pomoca rubber—who make BC ski skins.  

The wildfires have a really severe design defect if you do a lot of climbing/scrambling involving cracks:

Those cords coming out of the rubber are an integral component of the eyelet structure (the stitching over them is a "tunnel"). They get absolutely obliterated by any kind of jamming in large cracks (and the lacing system is pretty difficult to jury-rig without them). The TX shoes have a similar weakness in the lacing system, but are slightly less vulnerable to abrasion low on the sides.

I loved everything else about these shoes--super comfy, climbed well--and would buy them again in a heartbeat if it weren't for that. 

Shay Subramanian · · Boulder, CO · Joined Apr 2017 · Points: 10
bearded sam wrote:

Has anyone tried the Arcteryx Konseal or Vertex speed?

I had a pair of the Vertex Speed Lows and loved them for scrambling up to like 5.6 slab. Only reason I went back to Mutants is bc I had a discount code and they were like half the price. I will say they are more of a running shoe you can scramble in than an approach shoe.

Noah L · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Oct 2023 · Points: 0
Tanner James wrote:

Sportiva has a new TX1 coming out soon which if I remember correctly will be the lightest approach show on the market. The mutant is my single favorite trail shoe of all time and while I’m bummed it’s discontinued the replacement looks pretty equally as great. Additionally they have a totally new shoe coming that is a full dedicated running shoe with an approach sole which looks rad. 

any details on the dedicated running shoe with approach sole? This sounds awesome

Ellen the Felon · · Boulder, CoLoRAdO · Joined Nov 2020 · Points: 316

BD Tag LT are amazing but also discontinued :(( Theyre literally like 1" thick combined when bundled up with a hair tie inside a route pack 

Ethan H · · Tucson, AZ · Joined Apr 2019 · Points: 34

I got the same size in TX1 that I wore in TX3 and they fit about the same. The TX1 has a squarer toe box, which I like. 

that guy named seb · · Britland · Joined Oct 2015 · Points: 241

Any one had a look at the mammut almasca?

Echo Echo · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Apr 2020 · Points: 0
Rob Duckles wrote:

Rock and Resole put Unparallel Dot rubber on a pair of Altra Superior 7's for me, and I really like the result. It's probably my dream lightweight climbing approach shoe.
Pros: best smearing friction I've ever experienced in approach shoes, good ground feel, but still enough padding to be comfortable with sharp rocks on the approach/deproach. Really comfortable, noticeably lighter than almost every approach shoe. Runnable.
Cons: wide toe box and soft midsole will never be ideal for edging, the sticky Unparallel RH rubber is less durable than something like Megagrip.

I would +1 that Xero shoe rubber (incl. the Michelin rubber Scrambler) feels far less sticky than Vibram Megagrip. I wish Xero would come out with a sticky approach shoe, because I do otherwise like their products.

I had an old pair of superior 4.5 resoled with zagama sole, it’s really nice. Grips well on rock and the wet ground where I usually climb and keeps a nice wide toe box with zero drop. Obviously not optimal on small edges but if the edges are that small I’m probably going to need rock shoes/boots and gear anyway, 


climbed n4 in Norway with them recently with no trouble. For me this is the way for future approach shoes. Shame they discontinued the Grafton as that had potential to be really good with a second version. 

Matt Bauman · · Allenspark, CO · Joined Dec 2023 · Points: 441

I have Konseals and Vertex Speeds, very different shoes.  Konseals are a fairly heavy leather hiking shoe with a very stiff sole, I love them but not for climbing (just hiking).  Vertex speeds are a very light running shoe with sticky rubber sole, a great descent shoe to clip to your harness but not the most comfortable (roomy in the toes but very narrow midfoot).

The new Black Diamond Norda shoe is also more of a running shoe like the Vertex speed but it’s much wider and much more comfortable, and the sticky rubber soles have little rubber spikes to help in loose terrain (kind of weird).  Too bulky to be a descent shoe clipped to your harness.  I’ve only used these shoes once so far and not sure how I like them yet but they are extremely comfortable (unlike most other shoes).

I love the original TX4’s but the new gen Evo’s are incredibly uncomfortable on my weird feet (too narrow and rigid).  I scored a brand new in box pair of OG TX4’s that I haven’t even worn yet, for the future happy feet!

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

Climbing Gear Discussion
Post a Reply to "Replacing the lightweight climbing approach shoe"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.