Mountain Project Logo

Replacing the lightweight climbing approach shoe

Original Post
Zachary Cleary · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2015 · Points: 43

I just found out that Sportiva is ending/not rereleasing for a while the TX2 or Mutant for a while. With the ending of the TX Guide as well, what're folks using for a lightweight sticky shoe? I know some of those were ended for tariff reasons but to end their whole spectrum of lightweight sticky shoes seems crazy when they were doing it the best! And from what I've seen, doesn't seem like much else on the market compares. I'm more specifically wondering what people are replacing the TX2 with.

They just came out with the TX1 with a wider toe box and it's not doing it for me. 

ST Perliks · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Aug 2026 · Points: 0

Ikr, it’s wild! Sportiva discontinuing the TX2s, TX Guides, and Mutants all at once leaves a massive gap for lightweight sticky rubber, sounds like the tariff issues forced their hand on production lines and the new TX1 is way too wide and bulky..

grug g · · SLC · Joined Jul 2022 · Points: 0

BD just came out with a new shoe line. I don't know anything about it but could be interesting to look in to. 

Brennan J · · California · Joined Aug 2021 · Points: 20

The scarpa rapid lt are lightweight, not much heavier than my running shoes and they climb well. If I care about weight and not climbing ability, for less technical approaches, Altra lone pine (or the + with vibram rubber), work great.

Tyler B · · Spokane, Wa · Joined Oct 2016 · Points: 20

Following this thread because I also want a replacement for my TX2s. 

I can comment on the Scarpa Rapids LT that they are heavier and much stiffer than the TX2s but lighter than the TX4.  They are a good shoe and inspire confidence but are much beefier shoe than the TX2s.


My scale puts the difference at about a 140g/ 5oz difference in weight for a pair of 46.5 TX2s vs a pair of 46 Rapid LTs.  

Jesse Scarborough · · Oakland, CA · Joined May 2016 · Points: 110
grug g wrote:

BD just came out with a new shoe line. I don't know anything about it but could be interesting to look in to. 

Everyone I know who has used a BD shoe says they're trash. I think all their non-safety stuff has really gotten quite shit since their VC buy out. 

giraud b · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2022 · Points: 0
ST Perliks wrote:

Ikr, it’s wild! Sportiva discontinuing the…Mutants

*I don’t think they will taking into account their are one of the flagship shoes of the company. On wet days they are my go shoes in mountain terrain. I actually climbed and did canyoneering with them. In my case they last a long time.

My preferred shoes along the Bushido & the Akasha.


*https://www.reddit.com/r/trailrunning/comments/1mpe0vu/la_sportiva_mutant_discontinued_buy_them_while/

grug g · · SLC · Joined Jul 2022 · Points: 0
Jesse Scarborough wrote:

Everyone I know who has used a BD shoe says they're trash. I think all their non-safety stuff has really gotten quite shit since their VC buy out. 

Completely anecdotal opinion there.

I like a lot of their stuff and it has worked out great for me. Cams, ropes, backpacks, shirts, pants...

wisam · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jan 2012 · Points: 60

I actually really liked their tag and session shoe. Wouldn’t take either on something serious but both were great for casual stuff.

The tag was super light and package and perfect for red rocks type stuff and the session works great for craiging.

Loved the collapsible heel which makes them great for a slip on between climbs.

Wouldn’t take either to the Tetons or bugaboos but for red rocks or the creek they are perfect!

Cosmic Hotdog · · California · Joined Sep 2019 · Points: 462
Tyler B wrote:

Following this thread because I also want a replacement for my TX2s. 

I can comment on the Scarpa Rapids LT that they are heavier and much stiffer than the TX2s but lighter than the TX4.  They are a good shoe and inspire confidence but are much beefier shoe than the TX2s.


My scale puts the difference at about a 140g/ 5oz difference in weight for a pair of 46.5 TX2s vs a pair of 46 Rapid LTs.  

hey Tyler how did you find the fit of the Scarpa Rapids vs. the TX4s (specifically TX4 Evo if you had those)?

I've read that the Scarpas have a wider forefoot than the TX4 Evo so I'm trying to get a sense of how much wider. It's probably worth a trip to REI to find out

Isaac Mann-Silverman · · Oakland Ca · Joined Nov 2020 · Points: 0
Cosmic Hotdog wrote:

hey Tyler how did you find the fit of the Scarpa Rapids vs. the TX4s (specifically TX4 Evo if you had those)?

I've read that the Scarpas have a wider forefoot than the TX4 Evo so I'm trying to get a sense of how much wider. It's probably worth a trip to REI to find out

---

They are wider than the Evos but not as wide as the OGs

Cosmic Hotdog · · California · Joined Sep 2019 · Points: 462
Isaac Mann-Silverman wrote: Cosmic Hotdog wrote:

hey Tyler how did you find the fit of the Scarpa Rapids vs. the TX4s (specifically TX4 Evo if you had those)?

I've read that the Scarpas have a wider forefoot than the TX4 Evo so I'm trying to get a sense of how much wider. It's probably worth a trip to REI to find out

---

They are wider than the Evos but not as wide as the OGs

awesome, thanks dude!

Josh Rappoport · · Natick, MA · Joined Sep 2017 · Points: 31

TX3s might be my favorite shoe of all time, and I would to know what could be a good replacement?

Adam W · · TX/Nevada · Joined Dec 2019 · Points: 532

I mostly use the Xero Scrambler low or Xero Aqua X Sport for approach and development work.  I have a wide foot and every actual marketed "approach" shoe i've bought has been returned for being too narrow...may try the TX1 since it looks wider but don't have high hopes.  

Heyzeus · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jun 2021 · Points: 0
Adam W wrote:

I mostly use the Xero Scrambler low or Xero Aqua X Sport for approach and development work.  I have a wide foot and every actual marketed "approach" shoe i've bought has been returned for being too narrow...may try the TX1 since it looks wider but don't have high hopes.  

I run Xero's Trail Mesa 2 as my everyday shoe, I don't think they climb that good on rock ( Chuck Taylor's work better) and was always interested in the Scrambler, so maybe the Scrambler rubber is better? The Xero Piro is pretty good though, and lighter, but also more barefoot, so one has to be even more mindful about rocks and stuff poking the sole.

Mike Larson · · Los Angeles, CA · Joined May 2006 · Points: 70
Josh Rappoport wrote:

TX3s might be my favorite shoe of all time, and I would to know what could be a good replacement?

The TX4 Evo ST is essentially the TX3 with a slightly different midsole. The weight is almost exactly the same, both clocking in around 360g. The toebox geometry is a slightly different, but not enough for me to notice. 

Tanner James · · Tahoe · Joined Dec 2019 · Points: 1,778

Sportiva has a new TX1 coming out soon which if I remember correctly will be the lightest approach show on the market. The mutant is my single favorite trail shoe of all time and while I’m bummed it’s discontinued the replacement looks pretty equally as great. Additionally they have a totally new shoe coming that is a full dedicated running shoe with an approach sole which looks rad. 

Alex Brown · · Carbondale, CO · Joined Feb 2020 · Points: 0

I was eavesdropping on a conversation about the Mutant at the La Sportiva retail store recently. According to whichever employee was talking, the mutant is only discontinued for as long as it takes to move production (from China to Vietnam? Or vise versa) due to tariffs. This group of shoes has some specialized machinery that is not so trivial to move, retrain, and restart production on. In the meantime though, the mutant used their "white" running shoe rubber compound that can also be found on some of their other shoes. I've been big on the Ultra Raptor (also seemingly discontinued for a bit), but there are more. 

Tyler B · · Spokane, Wa · Joined Oct 2016 · Points: 20
Cosmic Hotdog wrote:

hey Tyler how did you find the fit of the Scarpa Rapids vs. the TX4s (specifically TX4 Evo if you had those)?

I've read that the Scarpas have a wider forefoot than the TX4 Evo so I'm trying to get a sense of how much wider. It's probably worth a trip to REI to find out

For context I do light trail running in Altra Lone Peak 12.5s and use the discontinued Altra Grafton’s in a very very comfortable size 13 for cragging with no real technical approach. All of my old Lone Peaks have blown out a the pinky MTP joint. My feet run super hot and they’re also very wide so I’m really sensitive to narrow shoes and prolonged abuse on the toes and feet. 


I was only able to do an A/B with whatever REI had this summer. I believe that was the TX4 EVO ST. I basically brought in all my old shoes(OG TX2s, Altra Graftons, boulder Xs) and compared them to *brand new *Rapid LTs, TX4s EVO st?, 5.10 guide tennies, and Scarpa Cruxs. I have wide feet and the Rapid LT was the least bad option and felt the widest of the bunch but only by a small margin. The TX4s were too heavy, too stiff and a bit too narrow for what I was looking for.

  •  I spent the summer using Rapid LTs for alpine rock, they not the most comfortable for long hikes but not crazy uncomfortable, are kind of heavy for dragging up the wall but were pretty worth it for the routes with tricky 4th class and low 5th sections on the approach/descent.  They really shined on one of the routes that involved 250m of 4th/ low 5th class down climb scrambling to get off the mountain.
  •  They stayed in the duffle bag when I went crack cragging, I would never wear these shoes to the crag, they are too narrow and uncomfortable. The mesh on the sides does stretch a bit and molds the foot but not quite as much as the OG TX2 because they’re much more enforced on the side 
  • I think they are overkill for somewhere like Squamish were an OG TX2 or lighter shoe is my preferred option for multi-pitch routes.  The OG TX2 only worked for me because they were so so light and that old mesh REALLY stretched out and allowed my foot to become more comfortable.  My scale puts the OG TX2s at lower weight than my Altra lone peak 8s. 
  • The Rapid LT is the kind of jack of all trades master of none shoe cause it’s not crazy heavy, is a bit wider than the competition, has nice mesh ventilation that molds a bit to the foot but is stiff and burly enough that it’s a big step up from the TX2. 
Evan Gerry · · Redding, CA · Joined Nov 2016 · Points: 15

I find the Rapid to be about as wide (in the forefoot) as my original TX4. My feet have pooched out since and I need that wider toe box. They are plenty grippy and the lace to toe is great for when you need to crank them down. They are not very stiff though and are definitely more on the hikey side than climbey. The tread pattern is great on snow though unlike the TX4 dots. I wear the mids, oddly the Rapid LT heel cup did not work for me.

bearded sam · · Crested Butte, CO · Joined Apr 2011 · Points: 145

Has anyone tried the Arcteryx Konseal or Vertex speed?

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

Climbing Gear Discussion
Post a Reply to "Replacing the lightweight climbing approach shoe"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.