Mountain Project Logo

New and Experienced Climbers over 50 #42

Guy Keesee · · Moorpark, CA · Joined Mar 2008 · Points: 349
philip bone wrote:

Guy, are you saying that sport climbs are open to retro-bolting by community consent?

Well from what I have experienced that would be a big yes.

In Bishop at the China Wall a young person died falling while trying to clip bolt #3 …. It took about 3 days for locals to get to adding a bolt.

At Willie after 3-4 broken ankles happened while trying to make an awkward clip - due to a hold breaking off- the boys wasted no time in fixing that one.

No general outrage over adding bolts.

I also think that there is a “time limit” - the farther in the past the more likely it is now “community property”.

I have done exactly what you describe - adding the bolts immediately after the FA - on repel. After all you got the drill right there with you, why knott

I see, by reading between the lines, that you folks face similar issues in your neck of the woods and have arrived at an understanding.

So who is the culprit who you can’t mention?

dragons · · New Paltz, NY · Joined Aug 2011 · Points: 993
Lori Milas wrote:

...

A route I am most excited about is Torturers Apprentice. It’s on a beautiful massive wall that I think of as the surface of the moon.  Charles Cole was in on this one. Charles was also involved on the route next to it, Gun Shy.  It’s astonishing the lack of bolting on the first half of the route.  Way to my right on this same wall is Randy’s The Compassion of the Elephants. Bob did the FA on Groundhogs Day and several others. So that entire wall was built out by incredible climbers. But I’ve never seen a soul there.

(Me waving from the top, this was a big accomplishment) 

That looks so beautiful, Lori. It makes me want to go to there.

Sorry you're having so much trouble with your knees. I hope it works out.

PS Nice post, Cherokee!

apogee · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 0

These examples raise the question to me...who is the 'community'?

Is it defined after a polling of most all users of an area express their voice on the idea of retrobolting? Or a small group of motivated individuals who believe they are representing the 'community', without any true polling of most users?

If there is a way to create the former, I could be convinced (though the tyranny of the majority always rubs me a little wrong), but it's the latter that seems to be the source of most route changes, without any real consensus, and saying they are acting on behalf of the 'community'. That really rubs me the wrong way.

Lori Milas · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Apr 2017 · Points: 250
dragons wrote:

That looks so beautiful, Lori. It makes me want to go to there.

Sorry you're having so much trouble with your knees. I hope it works out.

PS Nice post, Cherokee!

It is beautiful, dragons. I think you’d love it. It’s kind of a wonderland back there with its own unique plants and trees.  Come stay with us and we can go explore!  

Nick Goldsmith · · NEK · Joined Aug 2009 · Points: 510

We did a sauna this evening.  Ice is finally out.  Pond is beautiful and the water is just as cold as it was last week when covered in ice.. 

Brad Young · · Twain Harte, CA · Joined Apr 2009 · Points: 1,267

Burn pile today - mostly consisting of the small stuff from the cedar that fell over with that last big snow. Add in all the other miscellaneous debris that dropped then and there's even a "feeder" pile. Glad we had enough rain to get this done before next winter!

Jay Goodwin · · OR-NV-CA-ID-WY · Joined May 2016 · Points: 15

No books, Brad?

Donald is VERY DISAPPOINTED in you.

dragons · · New Paltz, NY · Joined Aug 2011 · Points: 993
Lori Milas wrote:

It is beautiful, dragons. I think you’d love it. It’s kind of a wonderland back there with its own unique plants and trees.  Come stay with us and we can go explore!  

Thanks Lori, that is very kind of you! One day, I hope!

Brad Young · · Twain Harte, CA · Joined Apr 2009 · Points: 1,267
Jay Goodwin wrote:

No books, Brad?

Donald is VERY DISAPPOINTED in you.

Dammit Jay, I almost spit out my morning coffee.

Randy · · Lassitude 33 · Joined Jan 2002 · Points: 1,285

Kris,

Read your post about Liquid Sky, which was named after the 1982 cult Film of the same name. Oddly enough, today's paper had this obituary for Slava Tsukerman, the Director. 

GabeO · · Boston, MA · Joined May 2006 · Points: 302

Cherokee I love your post.  I think my two favorite climbs I've ever put up are a sport route that i put a lot of time, thought, and effort into, and a trad route in the middle of nowhere that i left the way i found it aside from a sling on a tree at the top, for someone else to have the same experience i did (it may well never be repeated, though it's a decent line, due to access issues).

There is a tremendous amount to be said for both approaches, and in my opinion the rock itself suggests which is appropriate more often than not.

I just finished bottling all my syrup for the season today. Came out to a bit over seven gallons. That's pretty damn good for seventeen taps, especially given that it was a short season because of the cold winter.

Here's a bottle from each of my five batches this season, in order of production from left (golden/delicate) to right (dark/robust): 

GO

Victor Creazzi · · Lafayette CO · Joined Nov 2022 · Points: 0
Randy wrote:

I don't believe either one of these statements is true. 

The climbs are still there, and with a very few exceptions, people are still climbing them... as long as fixed hardware is upgraded and/or replaced... which a few dedicated climbers are actually undertaking.

Many people putting up routes in the past were out trying to spy classic lines and nab them before someone else did. We wanted them to become classics (even if often they were not).  Once the route was established we absolutely wanted others to climb it and tell us how great it was (even if it wasn't). If the routes were good, we absolutely wanted to (and did) repeat them. While this was not true for everyone establishing routes, it was the prevailing attitude. 

Since bolts were put up on the lead with hand drills, bolts were placed on natural stances -- where you could let go with two hands. This often meant placing bolts sparingly and where actually needed to protect hard moves. As Guy mentioned, the concept of thinking out placements of bolts and falls is much more a sport climbing ethic -- routes that are generally not amenable to lead bolting due to steepness of the rock or lack of stances.

And, as others have pointed out, if you started climbing in the last couple decades, often learning climbing in a gym and transitioning to sport climbing, your expectations about protection and risk might be very different -- and only one point of view.

There were also bolts placed on aid to pass a section not to protect future free climbing. When I started climbing a bolt was the least reliable thing that you could clip into many of which were homemade and none were bigger than 1/4", usually very shallow. I remember clipping into more than one that was a piece of aluminum tubing with a nail driven into it, likely 30 or 40 years old, talk about galvanic corrosion! A friend of mine fell pulling out 3 bolts and hit the ground. Fortunately he was uninjured.

J Westgate · · Nh · Joined Nov 2023 · Points: 0

Gabe, you maDe seven gallons of syrup off of 17 taps? That’s impressive   We usually average around half a gallon per tap. We are definitely going to be short of that this season. Close to two thousand gallons of syrup off of 5,00 taps. Better than ice climbing 🤪

apogee · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 0
Victor Creazzi wrote:

When I started climbing a bolt was the least reliable thing that you could clip into many of which were homemade and none were bigger than 1/4", usually very shallow. 

 Case in point: taken at my local crag yesterday:



Old lady H · · Boise, ID · Joined Aug 2015 · Points: 1,375

So, for those of you who put bolts in, bitd? What do you anticipate for bolt replacement? Will that just be whatever, whenever, by anyone who thinks they know what they are doing? Should funky homemade stuff exempt from an okay from who ever put it in?

I'm assuming this will be a part of ASCAs mission, maybe already is.

Trad, well, for myself, that has also included routes with essentially no protection at all. Or maybe a sparse bit of gear, that is next to useless. That's when I've been happy to tag along with the truly good climbers, lol!

But?

When I am on top rope, I then have access to everything in reach, which often includes "trad" routes adjacent. 

I must say, those routes are often looking pretty neglected, and not climbed much, if at all. Filling in with plants, which I detour past. There's still gear routes that are popular .....but others got preempted by bolts, even without the actual line being bolted. Just an observation. Anchors or no anchors, makes a big difference, too. Old school walkoffs, vs climb and get lowered? That changed the perception of a lot of places, and how often anyone climbed anything at all there.

Helen

Edit to add, one of my first climbing experiences was a bigass free hanging rappel from the seldom visited side of our local cliffs.

Off of sagebrush anchors. Betcha not many have that in their roster!

Ward Smith · · Wendell MA · Joined Oct 2020 · Points: 26
Old lady H wrote:

Off of sagebrush anchors. Betcha not many have that in their roster!

A couple of my friends had just finished a trad route in Hueco Tanks when one of them turned around to see that the one called The Droid had set a rappel up on a clump of bushes.  When questioned, The Droid said “It would take a month of Sundays to pull that clump of bushes out.”  He was such a bad downclimber that we then used the tactic of letting him rappel to the ground with all the gear, and then tossing the rope off after him.

He is heading out to Arizona with me in a week and a half.   All 1/2 inch stainless bolt anchors so hopefully no shrubs will be involved!

Brian in SLC · · Sandy, UT · Joined Oct 2003 · Points: 23,021
Old lady H wrote:

So, for those of you who put bolts in, bitd? What do you anticipate for bolt replacement? Will that just be whatever, whenever, by anyone who thinks they know what they are doing? Should funky homemade stuff exempt from an okay from who ever put it in?

I'm assuming this will be a part of ASCAs mission, maybe already is.

Interesting question.  Especially in light of the recent Kalymnos accident/fatality.

I guess I'm fortunate that at least some of the older hardware I put in has been popped out.  The old button head stuff from hand drilling.  Was never that comfy with 1/4" so at least bumped up to 5/16.  I dimly recall...

In the City/Castle, there's a pretty good effort for sniffing out and replacing aging hardware.  The CRAG folk.  In other areas, been fairly well managed by the LCO's.  Here in Utar in the SLC area, the SLCA has a pretty robust crew and plan and really gets after it.  And...there's good resources for it (ASCA) as well as Petzl hosting a bolting thing every year now it seems to share best practices.  Well funded by the local climbing community.

Glad to have switched to all stainless quite a few years ago.  There's still some older plated stuff out there but some has been replaced.  Maybe most.  I had a few routes upgraded in the Uintas a couple years ago and got a look at the hardware, which, still looked pretty good to me.  But...they're popular routes so nice to not worry.

Fortunate to a have a few folks "who think they know what they are doing."  Ha ha.  As much as some of us knew when we placed the fixed hardware in the first place.  Or way more.

It'd be pretty sobering to have someone have a train wreck, and, maybe even perish, on a route that you established.  And even if remotely related to aging or failed fixed hardware...whew.  Tough sledding.  I mean...caveat emptor...but...still.  Would tend to be a pretty big bummer.  Maybe a main part of the reason folks try to keep current for best practices and hardware.

Lori Milas · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Apr 2017 · Points: 250

I left for a hike this morning to 'somewhere else' from my regular trail. This place is quiet, hidden, solitary... I've stopped wondering 'where are the climbers'? But am still wondering will I be able to come back here to climb again?

10 am still total shade and actually cold.  

I've had a fantasy I've never shared... what would it be like if I could climb right next to Kris (Solem), like RIGHT next to him, footstep for footstep.  I think I might actually be able to climb a route of his, if he slowed down, and no one heckled.  Here's the route on this wall I would toggle along with him:

This is a great place to daydream.  And really, how can you NOT acknowledge the climbers who have been here and climbed here in the past.  

-----

So, speaking of daydreaming... my interest in octopuses was only that, an interest (I thought).  Then I thought, hmmm, I wonder if it's possible to have an octopus for a pet.  Thinking about the cruelty of pulling such an intelligent and sensitive animal out of the ocean, no.  But then, thinking further, what about those that have already been captured, sitting in buckets in Asian grocery stores... or that have been already caught and need adoption?  

Well, many weeks/hours of research later... maybe this could be a reality. (Can't climb with Kris, but could own an octopus   ).  It's a big deal... setting up an aquarium, not only lots of cash, but it has to 'mature' for 3 months, running fully, before you can add your octopus to the water.  I understand they are little escape artists, so lots of protections there.  

And here's the heartache, even before it begins:  they only live for about a year.  Maybe a little longer, but you don't know how old they are when you get them.  It's not easy to 'age' an octopus.  So I would know going in that I will have bonded with this creature, grown to love him/her, and will lose him quickly. I'm already sad. 

There's lots of advice to take over the next few months, lots of people to talk to.  In the meantime, this week Tony and I will start looking at aquariums.  If we set one up this month, it would be July before we could bring home an octopus.  Starting to feel like setting up a nursery, anticipating the arrival of a little one.  

Lent has been incredibly wonderful this year... even without attending church one time.  Tomorrow, Easter.  Happy Easter everyone! 

  

Old lady H · · Boise, ID · Joined Aug 2015 · Points: 1,375

Get a Seychelles tortoise. NPR story lately, a big guy is closing in on 200 years old.

Nick Goldsmith · · NEK · Joined Aug 2009 · Points: 510

Finally talked Isa into going ice climbing. Fist time this year and 2nd climb of the season..  The skiing has been too good for her to bother with neanderthal ice climbing. She had a blast..  And we took Kermit for her first spin of the  vani season. 

climbing was fantastic

this climb is called Parasol Gully because of the way the  wind forms big umbrellas. 

the hike across to Table rock was arduous. Boot pack was just soft enough to  let you fall through every 5th step... 

 

This topic is locked and closed to new replies.

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.