Mountain Project Logo

New and Experienced Climbers over 50 #42

WF WF51 · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Oct 2020 · Points: 0

It would be interesting to hear from the Gunks contingent. 

What would you like to know? 

bryans · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jun 2006 · Points: 642
Lori Milas wrote:

Guy, Randy… I have some heartfelt thoughts on bolting here in Joshua Tree and the preservation of history.   I’ve done so much hiking and exploring of routes that Based strictly on the bolting of a route I can almost know the life and times of the FAs.  

Buenos Aires was done in 1974. I have never heard of the two guys who did the FA – – are they even alive? Yet Here we are 50 years later and that piece of real estate is frozen in time.  Can’t be touched or modified to meet the needs of climbers today. I understand why it’s a tough problem.

I’ve been lucky to climb mostly with Bob who remembers the history of most of these routes. He describes just very different headspace for the earliest climbers here and I have a mixture of admiration and awe. But then on a day like yesterday I was happily moving up the face of that rock(on top rope) I traveled a long way before finally seeing that first bolt I was astonished – – couldn’t believe anyone would do that.  Today I realize no one is going to climb Buenos Aires cuz unnecessary risk taking is not a thing anymore. So there it sits.  

I don’t see the harm in one more bolt but I don’t get a vote.  

—-

Dragons gave a pretty good overview of WHOOP. I do wear it 24 seven. I had to satisfy myself that EMF‘s were minimal with the device. Had the experience of definitely feeling weaker when I wore an Apple Watch.

I don’t know whether it measures a strain or stress. I’m sure it’s not always accurate but it knows when I take a walk and it knows when I crank it up on the rock. It knows when I take a breath.  It also is surprisingly accurate with. letting me know if I’m getting rundown or sick.  It’s been comforting to have this device follow me over the last six months— especially the recovery aspect, my recovery scores were way off September through December and I knew I was not healthy. Then mid January my numbers started to normalize.  So I understand the device and what it offers and it’s just become quite normal for me – – I don’t need anything more.

I think the plan I am on would replace this device if it broke and when they upgrade, they give you the upgrade for a song.  

https://www.mountainproject.com/route/stats/105722104/buenos-aires

I can't believe I'm the first one doing this days later, but it's very easy to search a route name and see if people are leading it before asserting that nobody is leading it. And I bet that across the board (this is definitely area and route specific) maybe 5 to 20% of people even bother to add ticks to MP - if they even have MP accounts in the first place. So this is obviously an undercount.

Also if you don't lead routes in the first place, it's not a great idea to opine on style and ethics and history. Luckily dozens of people already made this point. Me, I rarely lead even PG-13 routes but I am SO glad they exist for SO many reasons: not only are they bold statements from the past but they inspire others to future achievements. 

PS - it is crazy to say "unnecessary risk taking is not a thing anymore" when you climb at J Tree where on a daily basis people lead R rated routes. Do you ever look around? Is this some weird kind of boomer nostalgia where you tell yourself future generations simply are not as badass as yours? 

Guy Keesee · · Moorpark, CA · Joined Mar 2008 · Points: 349
philip bone wrote:

The line between sport and trad can be blurry. Also, hybrid routes are quite common. The distinction between retro-bolting and rebolting is clearer. Not everyone agrees with, or abides by, the first ascent ethic, around here at least. I'm told permits for new bolts in J Tree are not being issued. I wonder if the scale of Yosemite makes maverick actions less obvious? It would be interesting to hear from the Gunks contingent. 

So Philip Bone to be crystal clear about this topic.

People in your neck of the woods go and add bolts to established climbs?

Do you think the line between Sport and Traditional climbing is blurry? How so?

I’m genuinely curious about this, local customs do matter.

When I have climbed in the “ Gunks” I knew that every climb was “traditional” the fixed angle pins with chains said it all.

Edit to add 

Tim K said

Speaking of unadulterated hogwash.

So you don’t think what I said is true? I take young super strong, V10 outside, capable folks out all the time. We start at the beginning- how to repel, how to belay, how to place stoppers and hexes, anchors, everything

I have always enjoyed this “Mentoring” because teaching the young/new is what my elders taught me is the right thing to do. What is different with the gym climbers/boulders is you get to show people who are very strong how “IT” all works.

What has been your experience?

Edit to really add: 

Brad ….. I agree with most of what you say except for me there is a huge distinction between the two -Trad (I 8 that by the way and I just use the term Climbing) and Sport.
You want to say sport is defined by “closely spaced bolts” and that’s a good definition.

Five bolts in 110 feet is definitely a climb. If those bolts were placed on Rap I would call it a travesty.

I cut my teeth At Suicide Rock- the origin of bolted climbing. I don’t consider any climb at that place a sport climb.

Later all …. I think I have exceeded my limit. 

Brad Young · · Twain Harte, CA · Joined Apr 2009 · Points: 1,267
philip bone wrote:

The line between sport and trad can be blurry. Also, hybrid routes are quite common.

It's only blurry if one insists on just two definitions, "sport" and "trad." Like certain internet sites which have their digital heads up their digital rear ends.

So many kids these days think a climb is "sport" if it's all bolt protected.

Ah, no, that's not how it works.

A sport climb is a closely bolted face climb. You know, so you can focus on the sport and not the danger?

An all-bolt protected route that has let's say five bolts in 110 feet and that's all the protection? That's not a sport climb, it's a traditionally protected (or bolted) face climb.

Sport climbs are a single sub-category.

Trad (stupid phrase, actually) encompasses several categories - gear protected routes, traditionally bolted routes, and routes protected by bolts and gear.

Go back to your roots old friend (not routes in this case). You were climbing long before "sport climbing" was a thing and you already know all this.

And goddammit, where's a handy cloud to shake my old man's fist at as I curse at all the world's foibles?

apogee · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 0

The recent Enormocast/Taps (Last Rites) episode threw out the idea of tossing out the distinctions of 'trad' vs 'sport' climbing at this point in the evolution of the sport (or whatever you wanna call it), and now there's just 'rock climbing'. I understand the rationale for that argument, but I do think the distinctions are still useful (likewise, wish there was a better word for 'trad'...this is stooopid). Of course, they were ranting under heavy influence of scotch, and they are from Colorado. Jes' sayin'.

Edit:

Here comes the bloviation…

Brad Young · · Twain Harte, CA · Joined Apr 2009 · Points: 1,267
Guy Keesee wrote:

So Philip Bone to be crystal clear about this topic.

People in your neck of the woods go and add bolts to established climbs?

Do you think the line between Sport and Traditional climbing is blurry? How so?

I’m genuinely curious about this, local customs do matter.

When I have climbed in the “ Gunks” I knew that every climb was “traditional” the fixed angle pins with chains said it all.

Edit to add 

Tim K said

Speaking of unadulterated hogwash.

So you don’t think what I said is true? I take young super strong, V10 outside, capable folks out all the time. We start at the beginning- how to repel, how to belay, how to place stoppers and hexes, anchors, everything

I have always enjoyed this “Mentoring” because teaching the young/new is what my elders taught me is the right thing to do. What is different with the gym climbers/boulders is you get to show people who are very strong how “IT” all works.

What has been your experience? 

Guy, I can tell you exactly what people in our neck of the woods (in the Sonora Pass area) do, since I do a fair amount of it with Phil (and I think he's at his post limit for the day).

In the last few years both of us have gone back to some of the routes THAT WE PUT UP (that is to say he or me did the first ascent) and added bolts. I've done this with maybe four or five routes that I put up and Phil started doing it last year to some of his. I've helped him retro in multiple cases.

Here's an example of a "correction" to the 2013 guidebook that I posted to the Sonora Pass Climbing web site in this regard:

"85. Change, pages 220 and 221 (route A, "Ma Bone"):  Phil Bone has been looking over some of his older Potter's Rock routes and considering changes. Although the climb Ma Bone is not "R" rated in the book, this is a close call. The route's crux moves are made far enough above a good cam that a fall there could break an ankle. On September 18, 2025, Phil added a lead bolt halfway through this crux (Brad Young helped). This makes for a much more pleasant lead."

In another case I'd established a route decades ago that friend called "four out of three stars" (we use a three star system up here and he really, really liked the climb). I'd hand drilled the route and put in three bolts in 150 feet (it's 150 feet of perfect, perfect 5.7 granite slab). I got to thinking about how inaccessible that kind of runout made the climb, which really is quite good quality. So I went back and re and retro-bolted the route. I replaced the three original bolts with 3/8 stainless and added three more lead bolts, leaving a still-spicey, but much, much better route.

Phil's post may not have made it clear that there's been no adding bolts up here EXCEPT BY THE ROUTE'S FIRST ASCENT AUTHORS (sorry to shout, but this really matters).

Now obviously a first ascentionist adding bolts to a route that they put up is a very, very different thing than what most of this conversation has been about (adding bolts to routes that other people established). I think that this type of conduct has been universally accepted by the climbing community?

One possible exception has recently emerged here though - a series of routes at Table Mountain which, when established 30 years ago felt reasonably closely bolted, but don't feel that way now, when measured by modern standards. Each of these had 20 feet of 5.8 climbing over jagged talus to the first bolt (and are then middle 5.10 above that).

These routes were slipping into oblivion (which does happen to some routes everywhere, Lori). So Phil and I reached out to the first ascentionist on these routes (he lives in Oregon now). We identified what we thought was the issue and asked if we could add new lead bolts to the routes to make the starts less intimidating. That FA author gave his enthusiastic permission to doing so (although I've been so focused on getting the new Pinnacles guidebook done that we haven't made time to act on this permission yet).

Again, if/when we get to doing this, it will be with explicit permission which I have also always believed is universally accepted by the climbing community?

Now, can we get back to talking about how the orange f#$kface is f#4king things up instead of having these interesting types of climbing-centric conversations? (See what you started, Lori?)

EDIT: And, directing this comment to Guy in particular, climbers of your caliber (longevity and sense of tradition - not raw climbing numbers at our current ages) really should try out our granite. Which is just coming into season right now.

Unlike kids these days, who seem to need crowds and lines of climbers, we've got some incredible stuff here - rock that would blow you away - and if we see other climbers on it we either know them or we're shocked that someone else found the place and then we're social. Approaches from 45 seconds to ten minutes to longer and much longer.

(And I should be sorry about the kids-these-days comment. Lots of 20-something year old climbers live and/or climb up here - we've got an excellent if small climbing community.)

Cherokee Nunes · · Unknown Hometown · Joined May 2015 · Points: 0

Is this some weird kind of boomer nostalgia

Why you gotta be like that?

Nick Goldsmith · · NEK · Joined Aug 2009 · Points: 510

I have gone back and fixed most of my fuck ups  on my FA's.   John Psyco Sykes  retroed a bunch of his old climbs. Its the cool thing to do these days.  One of my favorite stories was when some of the North Carolina locals  heard someone up on the cliff with a  ryobi gas powered power drill.  They went ballistic and vandalized the drillers gas can and yelled up at the offending climber. "Arnie is going to kick your ass when he finds out about this"  Turns out the guy with the power drill was in fact Arnie..... 

Jay Goodwin · · OR-NV-CA-ID-WY · Joined May 2016 · Points: 15
Lori Milas wrote:

 

But just to add a small layer onto what we have been discussing here, a friend of mine weighed in on the subject this morning… “Remember, those early climbers never intended to repeat a route. They just brought the minimum gear needed to make it to the top one time. They were not thinking about creating classic masterpieces for future generations. Whereas these days we are thinking about all the climbers we hope will visit our route and we put a lot of time into placement of bolts and potential falls,

Sounds like utter bullshit to me

Nick Goldsmith · · NEK · Joined Aug 2009 · Points: 510

its actually very true. In the old days we wanted to get up the route as cheaply as possible. We also did not want other climbers to think we were wimps so we tended to make sure there was some scary  parts to the climb. These days many first ascensionists try to leave behind a climb that is aesthetic, climbs well, is protected in the right places but still exciting and hope that folks will enjoy this contribution to the area.   Personally when I do a ground up FA I go back and move  bolts if needed or add  bolts untill it climbs the way I feel is as close to a masterpiece as possible. Then I report the climb. It is not finished untill it's perfect. The goal is for this to be my favorite climb rather than a total scarefest that I never want to touch again but will be tickled pink wherever someone bails or askes me to add bolts to it while I scorch them for being light weight. 

Brad Young · · Twain Harte, CA · Joined Apr 2009 · Points: 1,267

As with many activities in life, I think there were a wide, wide mix of thoughts, ideas and motivations for those putting routes up during the time period we're talking about. Perhaps as many motivations as there were climbers?

Unquestionably some were establishing climbs that they hoped would last and become popular. Especially when the FA was a gorgeous or very obvious line.

Others? Others were just climbing, doing what they felt like doing with not much consideration for what would come in later years. On this latter point, I wrote this into the history section of the Pinnacles guidebook (based on the comments of a friend of mine who started climbing there before I did):

"According to John, bolting gear was hard to acquire during these years, and ¼ inch bolts were not only readily available, they were also easy to place.  As a result, they often ended up being used to protect easier sections of climbs.  Well aware that climbers now consider ¼ inch bolts at Pinnacles unsafe at best, Barbella commented: “Back then, we just had fun climbing.  We didn’t think anyone would ever be on these routes in 20 years.”

EDIT: one of my favorite Pinnacles stories comes from this climber. In later years, when his very strong daughter began visiting Pinnacles, she asked him for advice about climbing there (he'd moved away from the place 20 years earlier). His only comment was: "yeah, don't climb my routes."

M M · · Maine · Joined Oct 2020 · Points: 3
philip bone wrote:

The line between sport and trad can be blurry. Also, hybrid routes are quite common. The distinction between retro-bolting and rebolting is clearer. Not everyone agrees with, or abides by, the first ascent ethic, around here at least. I'm told permits for new bolts in J Tree are not being issued. I wonder if the scale of Yosemite makes maverick actions less obvious? It would be interesting to hear from the Gunks contingent. 

Nobody is getting away with any maverick behavior at the Gunks for sure if that's the question. The trad routes there are so abundant and good that you almost never hear anyone wishing for more bolted protection. 

philip bone · · sonora · Joined Dec 2011 · Points: 15

Trad is a term in common usage. What it means is blurry when combined with sport tactics. More than a couple of routes that I established have been retro-bolted w/o my ok.

I miss the Gunks guys in the conversation.

Jay Goodwin · · OR-NV-CA-ID-WY · Joined May 2016 · Points: 15
WF WF51 wrote:

It would be interesting to hear from the Gunks contingent. 

What would you like to know? 

I wanna know

Have you ever seen the rain

Coming down on a sunny day

Kristian Solem · · Hulett, WY · Joined Apr 2004 · Points: 1,085

When I was working on the California Needles guidebook that Kevin Daniels published in 2016, I reached out to many of the area's pioneers looking for stories, attitudes, ideas about ethics, generally what made them tick. I got back lots of great stuff. Bonnie Kamps even gave me excerpts from her late husbands wonderful journals. I used his pages documenting the FA of Spook Book in the guide.

I think this quote from Roy McClenahan is gold. Liquid Sky was a visionary route. I say "was" because in about 2018 an individual saw fit to retro-bolt it. In this person's opinion the belays were not in the right locations, so without having the vision to see why Lechlinski and crew pushed that first belay up as high as they could, he removed said belay and moved it down lower to a more comfortable spot. Then he had to add a new belay halfway across the magnificent sweeping expanse of rock with a real crux out at the pitch's end. Lechlinski's interpretation of the route, with a long soaring uninterrupted second pitch, depended on the first belay being high up above the convenient ledges. In a day when climbers are doing ever longer pitches and linkups, someone saw fit to cut down a climb that was ahead of its time into bite sized pieces. 

Anyway, here are Roy's words about the climb, and the focus of their bold style, written several years before the climb was defaced:

" In early summer of 1983 Mike Lechlinski and I stood beneath Magician's unclimbed west face. Waiting silently overhead was his proposed project: Liquid Sky. This was just two years after the historic first ascent of the Bachar Yerian in Tuolumne Meadows. Liquid Sky kicked off Mike’s bold string of visionary first ascents here in The Needles. It followed a hanging path of crescent shaped depressions and reared three rope lengths above. We saw that it would sometimes be too steep to let go of the rock for drilling from natural stances. We would take tension from hooks placed over small edges while we leaned back to drill just as Bachar had on his route. Before traversing rightward on the second pitch I initiated this approach and punched in the second bolt. So this climb took a lot of work spread over a few days’ effort on lead. It was the dawn of the sticky rubber revolution; our shoes were some of the first Boreal Fires to arrive in the United States. Despite their dramatic advantages the crux 5.11 friction traverse seemed impossible in the afternoon sun. Success came only during the stickier conditions of morning shade. Liquid Sky was a movie which depicted some very strange goings-on when aliens arrived in the New York art world.

In creating our routes we were drawing much from the examples and accomplishments of Robbins, Higgins, and Kamps, likewise hoping to emulate and contribute to a minimalist ethic where bolting was concerned.  We were not setting out to make dangerous climbs; rather we were putting our best collective foot forward in the service of a respected tradition."

Jim Malone · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Mar 2021 · Points: 35

I've enjoyed the bolting discussion discussion.  I've put up a number of slab routes ground up over the years and been back to many of them to add bolts now that I'm old and have a power drill (I would never add bolts to others routes without permission, which I have done).  Most of them got retro bolted on lead but I did retro a few on rappel.  My feeling about rap bolting is that if you do it you better place plenty of bolts and put them in not stupid places and if you fuck up you should return and fix it.

 One of my retrobolted slab routes somewhere on the west side, feel free to add bolts in not stupid places if you want.
Emil Briggs · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2013 · Points: 140
apogee wrote:

The recent Enormocast/Taps (Last Rites) episode threw out the idea of tossing out the distinctions of 'trad' vs 'sport' climbing at this point in the evolution of the sport (or whatever you wanna call it), and now there's just 'rock climbing'. I understand the rationale for that argument, but I do think the distinctions are still useful (likewise, wish there was a better word for 'trad'...this is stooopid). Of course, they were ranting under heavy influence of scotch, and they are from Colorado. Jes' sayin'.

Edit:

Here comes the bloviation…

To quote GWB on another Trump speech "That was some weird shit". 

Rich Ross · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jun 2019 · Points: 0
philip bone wrote:

I miss the Gunks guys in the conversation.

Yeah, whatever happened to those Gunks guys?   

tom donnelly · · san diego · Joined Aug 2002 · Points: 426
Kristian Solem wrote:

...
I think this quote from Roy McClenahan is gold. Liquid Sky was a visionary route. I say "was" because in about 2018 an individual saw fit to retro-bolt it. In this person's opinion the belays were not in the right locations, so without having the vision to see why Lechlinski and crew pushed that first belay up as high as they could, he removed said belay and moved it down lower to a more comfortable spot. Then he had to add a new belay halfway across the magnificent sweeping expanse of rock with a real crux out at the pitch's end. Lechlinski's interpretation of the route, with a long soaring uninterrupted second pitch, depended on the first belay being high up above the convenient ledges. In a day when climbers are doing ever longer pitches and linkups, someone saw fit to cut down a climb that was ahead of its time into bite sized pieces. 

Anyway, here are Roy's words about the climb, and the focus of their bold style, written several years before the climb was defaced:

" In early summer of 1983 Mike Lechlinski and I stood beneath Magician's unclimbed west face. Waiting silently overhead was his proposed project: Liquid Sky. This was just two years after the historic first ascent of the Bachar Yerian in Tuolumne Meadows. Liquid Sky kicked off Mike’s bold string of visionary first ascents here in The Needles. It followed a hanging path of crescent shaped depressions and reared three rope lengths above. We saw that it would sometimes be too steep to let go of the rock for drilling from natural stances. We would take tension from hooks placed over small edges while we leaned back to drill just as Bachar had on his route. Before traversing rightward on the second pitch I initiated this approach and punched in the second bolt. So this climb took a lot of work spread over a few days’ effort on lead. It was the dawn of the sticky rubber revolution; our shoes were some of the first Boreal Fires to arrive in the United States. Despite their dramatic advantages the crux 5.11 friction traverse seemed impossible in the afternoon sun. Success came only during the stickier conditions of morning shade. Liquid Sky was a movie which depicted some very strange goings-on when aliens arrived in the New York art world.

In creating our routes we were drawing much from the examples and accomplishments of Robbins, Higgins, and Kamps, likewise hoping to emulate and contribute to a minimalist ethic where bolting was concerned.  We were not setting out to make dangerous climbs; rather we were putting our best collective foot forward in the service of a respected tradition."

So what will be the long term outcome for that route?

Jay Goodwin · · OR-NV-CA-ID-WY · Joined May 2016 · Points: 15

Permits for bolting in Joshua Tree are not being issued or at least are a very long time in coming and you can thank the Trump administration for that. You'll recall that the new administration imposed a federal hiring freeze on Feb. 20, 2025. That hiring freeze remains in place.

In JT, a permit is required for placing a new bolt, maintaining an old bolt, or removing a bolt - i.e. you need a permit for all things bolt related. The process of issuing a permit requires environmental review by Cultural Resources, Wildlife, Vegetation for impact to these resources.

The Branch Chiefs for all three of these resources retired or left NPS prior to or within a year of Trump 2. Because of the hiring freeze, it took over a year to fill the veg vacancy, and the Wildlife and Cultural positions are currently vacant. Because of Trump, there's no one there to complete the environmental review. So no permits.

And Philip, I'm really sorry for adding bolts to your routes without your permission, but Lori made me do it. :)

This topic is locked and closed to new replies.

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.