Mountain Project Logo

New and Experienced Climbers over 50 #42

philip bone · · sonora · Joined Dec 2011 · Points: 15

Photo: Yosemite Rivers Aliance

Guy Keesee · · Moorpark, CA · Joined Mar 2008 · Points: 349

I read this morning that the Trump administration is exploring oil deposits under JT, they think they can drill from outside the park with minimal surface damage...

MM you know that the crude is very deep along the edges of the San Andreas fault. Edge drilling cannot go that deep.

I watch “Land Man” and Billy Bob explains it all to that lawyer babe and the hot owner of the company.    “Twenty thousand feet deep” he reckoned for 400 million— Only a 10% chance.

The drilling rig needs to be set up almost in the center of HVCG. Those dirtbags will need to go.


APRIL FOOLS 

Cherokee Nunes · · Unknown Hometown · Joined May 2015 · Points: 0

And it’s painful to see once classic routes, completely overgrown and unapproachable.

People vote with their feet. But good news, in another 20 years those climbs will be new FAAs (First Ascent Again). Joking but not really.

Time will tell, but not to me. In another two generations this will all be summed with a historical footnote. They won't care about someone else's great grandfather's rock climbing legacy, it will be a simple resource issue.

And at some point, society will collapse and the notion of rock climbing will revert to the crazies.

Emil Briggs · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2013 · Points: 140
x15x15 wrote:

Nope... Wrong... ROFLMFAO!!!

Well if the story about Kristi Noems husband had dropped today instead of yesterday I would have thought it was an Aprils fool joke. I'm still sort of like "Are you shitting me?"

Nick Goldsmith · · NEK · Joined Aug 2009 · Points: 510

Bingo..  how about the president of the United States is in a sworn deposition for raping a 13 year old child.  And his party still supports him and won't vote to impeach.  

apogee · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 0

I heard Boot Flake fell off today...how many times is that, now?

Lori Milas · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Apr 2017 · Points: 250
Cherokee Nunes wrote:

People vote with their feet. But good news, in another 20 years those climbs will be new FAAs (First Ascent Again). Joking but not really.

Time will tell, but not to me. In another two generations this will all be summed with a historical footnote. They won't care about someone else's great grandfather's rock climbing legacy, it will be a simple resource issue.

And at some point, society will collapse and the notion of rock climbing will revert to the crazies.

I don’t know how I got so sentimental about this place but I don’t want anything touched. Last year when I was climbing one of Randy’s great routes, I watched a pack of kids walk right by with their pads and backpacks, and not even look up at this soaring rock. They were headed toward a boulder which, at least in my opinion, didn’t compare.

So many of these existing routes that once were oncethe subject of super heroic feats are literally disappearing – – I guess we can’t stop time.

But just to add a small layer onto what we have been discussing here, a friend of mine weighed in on the subject this morning… “Remember, those early climbers never intended to repeat a route. They just brought the minimum gear needed to make it to the top one time. They were not thinking about creating classic masterpieces for future generations. Whereas these days we are thinking about all the climbers we hope will visit our route and we put a lot of time into placement of bolts and potential falls, etc.”

Guy, Landman is pure pleasure and Billy Bob has never been better. Can’t wait until the next season comes out.

Cherokee Nunes · · Unknown Hometown · Joined May 2015 · Points: 0

So many of these existing routes that once were oncethe subject of super heroic feats are literally disappearing – – I guess we can’t stop time.

Nor should we. The very idea those guys get to freeze time in JT, or anywhere else, is so patently ridiculous I can't believe people still pretend to believe such things. Its simply not sustainable. Time will forget all of this.

GabeO · · Boston, MA · Joined May 2006 · Points: 302
ed esmond wrote:

What happened to your flue pan? Looks like someone ran into it, hard!

GO

Old lady H · · Boise, ID · Joined Aug 2015 · Points: 1,375

Just heard a terrific quote on NPR...

"I fear standing still more than I fear falling". 

Blind dude who runs marathons and half marathons. Has had specially trained guide dogs in the past, and is currently testing out AI glasses. Still has a human accompanying him, for safety.

That quote, though, applies pretty broadly, and to most, if not all, of us on here! 

Helen 

Guy Keesee · · Moorpark, CA · Joined Mar 2008 · Points: 349

Lori said….. 

But just to add a small layer onto what we have been discussing here, a friend of mine weighed in on the subject this morning… “Remember, those early climbers never intended to repeat a route. They just brought the minimum gear needed to make it to the top one time. They were not thinking about creating classic masterpieces for future generations. Whereas these days we are thinking about all the climbers we hope will visit our route and we put a lot of time into placement of bolts and potential falls, etc.”


Lori. Your friend is speaking about “sport climbing” I believe. That’s a whole different thing altogether. When speaking about ethics in climbing I feel that the distinction between the two is key to understanding the ethics involved.

Adventure climbing is “pure” - if I might use the term- exploration. You see something big, beautiful and unknown. The sort of thing one dreams and wonders about with fear and curiosity. Real danger (imagined or real) exists.
One must possess the necessary skills to be successful.

Sport Climbing is quite different. The stone has been inspected closely (or should be) before the bolts are added- by any means- in the exact location needed. The finished product should be as perfect as possible with regard for safety and convenience.

I think this has been hashed out in the last 25 years or so and we climbers know the rules.

There is a place, not far from JT, an early “sport” venue where the FA folks rap bolted in a bunch of roots. Hardest climbs in SoCal they claimed, even made a guide book- hoping to make some money. Only thing is the climbs didn’t “go” and many qualified people worked on them and declared them “bull shit”. Fast forward a decade, some “locals” went and closely inspected these climbs on TR. They found 2 great climbs buried under the grid bolting. So they pulled the old bolts and raped placed new ones- in the correct spot's - creating two really good routes.

Now if the original roots had actually been climbed- free climbed- it would have been wrong to pull the bolts.

Bottom line….. Rap bolted “sport climbs” get worked on if needed.

And I would say that all those young Boulder people would sell their souls to learn how to get the rope up there. I know this cause I get asked to show/teach the secrets all the time.

Good topic for thoughtful discussion. 

Kristian Solem · · Hulett, WY · Joined Apr 2004 · Points: 1,085

"They were not trying to create masterpieces for future generations."

That, Lori, is unadulterated hogwash.

Randy · · Lassitude 33 · Joined Jan 2002 · Points: 1,285
Lori Milas wrote:

So many of these existing routes that once were oncethe subject of super heroic feats are literally disappearing – – I guess we can’t stop time.

But just to add a small layer onto what we have been discussing here, a friend of mine weighed in on the subject this morning… “Remember, those early climbers never intended to repeat a route. They just brought the minimum gear needed to make it to the top one time. They were not thinking about creating classic masterpieces for future generations. Whereas these days we are thinking about all the climbers we hope will visit our route and we put a lot of time into placement of bolts and potential falls, etc.”

I don't believe either one of these statements is true. 

The climbs are still there, and with a very few exceptions, people are still climbing them... as long as fixed hardware is upgraded and/or replaced... which a few dedicated climbers are actually undertaking.

Many people putting up routes in the past were out trying to spy classic lines and nab them before someone else did. We wanted them to become classics (even if often they were not).  Once the route was established we absolutely wanted others to climb it and tell us how great it was (even if it wasn't). If the routes were good, we absolutely wanted to (and did) repeat them. While this was not true for everyone establishing routes, it was the prevailing attitude. 

Since bolts were put up on the lead with hand drills, bolts were placed on natural stances -- where you could let go with two hands. This often meant placing bolts sparingly and where actually needed to protect hard moves. As Guy mentioned, the concept of thinking out placements of bolts and falls is much more a sport climbing ethic -- routes that are generally not amenable to lead bolting due to steepness of the rock or lack of stances.

And, as others have pointed out, if you started climbing in the last couple decades, often learning climbing in a gym and transitioning to sport climbing, your expectations about protection and risk might be very different -- and only one point of view.

ed esmond · · The Paris of VT... · Joined Jan 2010 · Points: 0
Brad Young wrote:

Daniel Shively wrote:

It's both.

I can give two examples of why tradition matters and why it involves both:

-  the "worship of ashes" - which I presume means admiring those who came before/those who made the routes in question, and also;

-  the "preservation of fire."

There could be literally hundreds of examples, but just two.

First, regarding a famous climb, The Bachar-Yerian in Tuolumne Meadows. Rated 5.11c X.

It's famous. Why? Not because it's a great quality 5.11 face climb. It's famous because its a great quality 5.11 face climb AND for  its incredibly bold history AND for the extreme courage/boldness and just "go" that one must have to lead it (I've never been on it). All of this in the very best traditions of our sport.

All of this would disappear - just evaporate - if The Bachar-Yerian was retro-bolted. Not every climb needs to be accessible to every climber.

Second, here's a photo of a similar situation, but regarding a route which is unknown other than to a small niche of climbers.

The two climbers are on a route called Daedalus. It's on Machete Ridge on the West Side of Pinnacles. Rated 5.8 R A1, it's actually almost an X, with 30 foot free-climbing runouts on merely good quality Pinnacles rock (excellent rock there can still break off).

The route was put up in 1976 by Glen Denny and Gary Coliver. These two put up a series of routes at Pinnacles which are way beyond bold - routes that see very, very few ascents. Routes that could kill you. Routes that are wildly famous (and, frankly, infamous) to those who know the park's climbing history.

This ascent was by two 25 year old climbers who, like me, are huge Pinnacles fans. They were making the route's third ascent. In 2025.

The two on this route? They were fanatically cautious. On a mere 5.8. And they pulled it off wonderfully. They were damn proud too once they'd finished.

They weren't proud because they'd done a 5.8 multi-pitch.

They were proud because they had the fire; fire enough to go for broke on a route which, like The Bachar-Yerian, absolutely requires going for broke. They'd done what legends before them had done and they'd done it in equal style.

All of which is a massive, massive difference from "just" another 5.8.

There are plenty of routes of all types to choose from (plenty!!). Not everything has to be dumbed down to a lowest denominator.

EDIT: And no, I obviously do not have any strong feelings on this issue ;)

One should add that B-Y is "famous" because it was done by a larger than life climber who didn't shirk away from publicity; and was a subject of a great piece of writing by John Long.

Without these two added factors it would just be another crazy, dangerous, rarely repeated first ascent by a very strong, very bold climber. Which is an achievement in own right.

 I'm not saying it should be retro-ed, nor am I saying it isn't a great route; but I don't understand why it's always held up as a touchstone for what climbing should always be.

I can't believe any reasonable person actually thinks retro-ing bold, iconic routes like B-Y is a good idea.  

ed "Reverse Osmosis is sugaring's version of retrobolting...  And don't get me started on burning dead dinosaurs instead of renewable wood.  What's next, adding high fructose corn syrup? ;)" e*

ps. Gabe: that pans been around a long time, current shed isn't its original home.  

* Bad attempt to parody most of the retro-bolt discussions above...

Emil Briggs · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2013 · Points: 140
Tim K wrote:

Speaking of unadulterated hogwash.

Yup. Kids warm up on stuff that was cutting edge BITD. And it's not just well bolted sport routes. Plenty of youngsters doing hard runout stuff too. Maybe not as large a percentage as BITD but the overall climbing population is so much larger now the absolute numbers are greater.

apogee · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 0
ed esmond wrote:

 I'm not saying it should be retro-ed, nor am I saying it isn't a great route; but I don't understand why it's always held up as a touchstone for what climbing should always be.

B-Y may have been held up at one time as the 'way climbing should always be', but this was at a time of heated debate about ethics and style. At this point, I see B-Y simply as one way to experience climbing, and have great admiration for the people who prefer this approach. It's perfectly acceptable to me that there are many, many routes I will never climb- and it's wonderful to me to know they are out there, and how they came to be.

Old lady H · · Boise, ID · Joined Aug 2015 · Points: 1,375

Lol! 

Well, this got fun (yes, actually fun).

Within the framework of absolute truths, that routes should be left "as is", "sport" climbing is assumed to be bolted safely, and pad people secretly lust in their heart to climb "real" climbs.....

There is just a metric shit ton of nuance in between all of this, some of it pretty interesting.

My highly esteemed friend Jay put up a bunch of stuff at City of Rocks, bitd. He did choose to revisit a route and add some bolts. Now it is a super popular route. He also very humorously has a hefty bunch of redacted route names over there (totally makes me smile). So, just one guy, with nuance in the choices he made back then.....and later.....and the reactions of the masses to it all.

But, at COR?

Managers have swapped out anchors on single pitch to mussy hooks, not without controversy for the "dumbing down" of climbing.

Camping has gotten more and more managed over the years (with old timers grumbling about "back in the day we did whatever we wanted"), as has fire policy and even just dogs on leashes. Infrastructure has been constructed, on and on.

That's just people management, for the most part.

But, some day, managers will have some interesting decisions to face, between respecting the past, and modernizing. What to do with the rebar route on Bath rock? More interesting, what about the fixed piton that is part of the rather spicy start of a very classic route (with a boulder to slam into in the mix)?

Is it still reasonable, going forward, to put up routes that end up "mixed"? Mostly bolted, but a bit of gear?

2 routes are a great contrast. Conceptual Reality is one of the very first routes with bolts added, and those bolts are very safe spacing. 

For the top part, that is bolted. 

The bottom, needs gear (if the climber chooses), as it's a super fun crack climb. 

That one, HAS to stay as is. It's historic, safe, and honestly, super fun. 

A couple newer, easier, routes, however, appear to be sport climbs if you are standing there sussing them out, with bolt lines visible. Until someone discovers the significantly spicy fact that, they are actually mixed. 

Yes, that is on the climbers. 

But being there when these weren't in any book or online, yet....

Yeah, got to watch some head scratching, lol!

At my local crag?

Sorry, but, I do think that it's both. Some were done to be great climbs, when the bolting started, but others, especially the easier ones, they only put it some bolts, not very generously, and they are neither safe nor good enough to justify that bolting. But done, is done.

Originally?

My local stuff was considered practice for the "real thing", which meant mountains. Truly dangerous stuff. It was all climbed with no fixed pro at all, and, you gad to top out and walk off. My friend told me that top out was often the hardest part.

Needless to say, he (and others) were horrified with the rise of "sport" stuff.

For my friend, that outrage lasted years.

But then came his children. And grandchildren. 

Well, okay. He softened to that call from the future.

For myself?

My local shuff is still just shitty, unsafe, climbing, for the lower grades. 

But then again?

If I can climb my local crap?

I'm climbing on far more difficult rock than anyplace else I've been so far.

Best all, Helen

philip bone · · sonora · Joined Dec 2011 · Points: 15

The line between sport and trad can be blurry. Also, hybrid routes are quite common. The distinction between retro-bolting and rebolting is clearer. Not everyone agrees with, or abides by, the first ascent ethic, around here at least. I'm told permits for new bolts in J Tree are not being issued. I wonder if the scale of Yosemite makes maverick actions less obvious? It would be interesting to hear from the Gunks contingent. 

phylp phylp · · Upland · Joined May 2015 · Points: 1,152
Daniel Shively wrote:

I’d think that the BY being located on one of the most beautiful granite faces on earth may have something to do with its mystique too.  (Obviously a projection of my love for Yosemite and its environs.) 

The rock on all of Medlicott is wonderful.  So many good routes from left to right!

Norm Larson · · Wilson, Wy. · Joined Jan 2008 · Points: 90

Indeed!!!

This topic is locked and closed to new replies.

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.