Mountain Project Logo

A vote to stop using threadlock in climbing applications

Jim Titt · · Germany · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 490
old5ten wrote:

i think there is a serious misconception here as to what threadlocker is/does and how strong it actually is.  in it's original (non-climbing) version threadlocker  is used for bolts in situations that deal with vibrations, think machinery that rattles around.  blue/removable for small bolts (think the type of stuff on your computer, bike, etc.) and red/permanent for bigger stuff (something that's 1/4" to 3/8" would fall into that category and be on the bigger side of application; yes, we have other threadlocker colors - good luck finding one of those at an ace, hd, etc. in the US).  one could think of it more in terms of retention (preventing the falling out/loosening of stuff) rather than strength (dealing with tampering issues)

in reality the difference in terms of strength and the ability to remove between no threadlock, blue threadlock, and red threadlock is relatively small.  try a simple test, take three quick links (1x no threadlock, 1x blue, 1x red) and put each in a vise.  do an easy finger tighten, then do a similar tighten on all three with a decent sized wrench (let's arbitrarily say 10" crescent wrench and 180deg+, but you decide).  if you want, wait a night.  undo each one the next day.  chances are really good that you'll not find a huge amount of difference between the three.

in terms of tampering prevention on something like a quicklink you're looking at an arms race.  if you set up at home, in a vise, with a big (long lever wrench) and you crank hard there's a really good chance that nobody in the wild will be able to undo (steal or replace) your quicklink unless they come in with some really industrial hardware. these quicklinks will not go anywhere, regardless of threadlocker/color.  note that anyone with even a small wrench can simple unscrew the nut on a wedge or head on a sleeve and just take everything if they have access and are so inclined.

so where does threadlocker come into play?  well, if you're not concerned about theft (ie not torquing quicklinks into oblivion), but are concerned about loosening quicklinks (i for one have 'tightened' down quite a few by hand or with a short wrench over the years), then using threadlocker is actually quite a reasonable way to go.  

   

Rather than performing a simple test you can look at the Loctite manual, low-strength ca 3% increase in breakaway torque, medium ca 25% and high strength 45-75% increase. Those of us who use a fair amount of threadlocj would consider that accurate from own experience of loosening fasteners but it's nice to know it's accurately measured rather than believing random internet noise.

old5ten · · Sunny Slopes + Berkeley, CA · Joined Sep 2012 · Points: 5,861
Jim Titt wrote:

Rather than performing a simple test you can look at the Loctite manual, low-strength ca 3% increase in breakaway torque, medium ca 25% and high strength 45-75% increase. Those of us who use a fair amount of threadlocj would consider that accurate from own experience of loosening fasteners but it's nice to know it's accurately measured rather than believing random internet noise.

yep, and we can also look at the size of the fasteners and get a good sense of what those percent increases actually mean in absolute terms... (and yes, as mentioned before, i use threadlocker frequently ;-)

climber pat · · Las Cruces NM · Joined Feb 2006 · Points: 301
Anna Brown wrote:

Since I didn't install this bolt, I can't say definitively what the gray substance is on the threads of the bolt I remove and I can't say definitively if it's the cause of the bolt failing. 

But, it got me to see that adding a threadlocker is not ideal because of future issues that it may cause. I vote for everyone to stop adding it to bolts/quicklinks.

The red Loctite says it's "designed to lock and seal threaded fasteners permanently " and is "only removable once cured by heating parts up to 500°F".

What is your rational for not using lock tight on quick links?

Having had quick links stolen before I started using lock tight I am unlikely to quit.  They can still be easily removed with a wrench but not removed by hand. Tightening them down very tight on the on the bolt in the field was not adequate. 

Stealing the quick links made the rappel anchors much less safe.

old5ten · · Sunny Slopes + Berkeley, CA · Joined Sep 2012 · Points: 5,861
Anna Brown wrote:

The red Loctite says it's "designed to lock and seal threaded fasteners permanently " and is "only removable once cured by heating parts up to 500°F".

i highly recommend actually testing this with a quicklink in your vise.  there's a good chance you'll find that the actual torque you apply when tightening is a much bigger factor than the loctite and that a quicklink installed with red loctite is removable without heat (once again subject to how much torque you applied in first place).

edit (over posting limit): i once again want to emphasize that how much something is torqued down is much more of a factor than threadlocker (at least with quicklinks which can be tremendously torqued down in a vise, less so with bolts).  so, in real terms - if i take a quicklink (no threadlocker), stick it in a vise, torque it into oblivion and then install it, you will have a much harder time removing that quicklink than if i use red loctite and tighten a little bit beyond hand tight.  when you're out in the wilderness area you'll be cursing the one without loctite and be psyched to deal with the one with red loctite.  it's not the loctite that is the enemy (and as noted before it would have been in the wrong spot).

having replaced hardware for over two decades, including a fair amount in wilderness (mostly tuolumne and john muir), without power tools, i empathize with your general sentiment.  it sucks to be out there, graciously offering your time, your sweat, and your money, only to be thwarted by the inability to do the job - whatever the reason is.

...but, that frustration you feel is part of the job and the situations you encounter where not everything goes to plan is endless.  there are stripped nuts and threads, completely rusted/frozen quicklinks (way worse than red loctite), wrong drill bit sizes, glues that dry too fast, nozzles that are too short, stupid/unconventional things people did on the install (yep, those 1/4" buttonheads were drilled at a 45deg downward angle), days that are too hot, thunderstorms that hit you four hours too early, wrenches that are too short, sockets that are the wrong size, hell - why is this metric and not sae -, access that is more difficult than you thought, things that miraculously detach from your harness even though you could have sworn they were solid - it's literally endless and you will encounter those situations time and time again... in an ideal world every rebolting mission would be quick, easy, and accomplished the first time around.  reality is much different...

today's plan was to replace a bolt by leading up a mixed (gear/bolts) route next door and do the replacement top down (generally more comfortable, easier).  my partner and i get to the base, he thought i have the rack, i thought he had the rack.  so much for top down, we replaced ground up...

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

My concern is with threadlockers that are not easily broken with a wrench. My concern is with the threadlockers that are meant to be permanent bonds, that are effectively welding the threads to the nut forever.

  • Will the new climber you mentor know/understand the color/strength differences of threadlockers or will he/she simply buying a bottle of "Loctite" and inadvertently applying RED on all their future installations.
  • Will the next person touching a bolt with threadlocker applied take the time to recognize that you added a threadlocker (maybe red) and will they understand the implications of applying significant force to a locked down wedge bolt nut? Will they try to fix a spinning hanger on an otherwise solid bolt and instead compromise the bolt by using all their muscle?
  • Will the next person who works on the anchors know they have to bring special tools to cut off the quicklink (if locked with red or some other permanent substance)? It takes a lot of time and effort to arrive at a wall to do maintenance work and nothing is more frustrating than to not have the tools you need to complete the job. In a wilderness situation, no batteries are allowed so any removal has to be by hand.
climber pat · · Las Cruces NM · Joined Feb 2006 · Points: 301
Anna Brown wrote:

My concern is with threadlockers that are not easily broken with a wrench. My concern is with the threadlockers that are meant to be permanent bonds, that are effectively welding the threads to the nut forever.

  • Will the new climber you mentor know/understand the color/strength differences of threadlockers or will he/she simply buying a bottle of "Loctite" and inadvertently applying RED on all their future installations.
  • Will the next person touching a bolt with threadlocker applied take the time to recognize that you added a threadlocker (maybe red) and will they understand the implications of applying significant force to a locked down wedge bolt nut? Will they try to fix a spinning hanger on an otherwise solid bolt and instead compromise the bolt by using all their muscle?
  • Will the next person who works on the anchors know they have to bring special tools to cut off the quicklink (if locked with red or some other permanent substance)? It takes a lot of time and effort to arrive at a wall to do maintenance work and nothing is more frustrating than to not have the tools you need to complete the job. In a wilderness situation, no batteries are allowed so any removal has to be by hand.

Most of your arguments apply to bolts, not quick links.  I think your opinion is colored by whatever nonstandard stuff that was applied to the bolts you are having to deal with.  

A simple adjustable wrench will undo the gates on the quick link with the weaker lock tight and I believe also the strong over too.  Perhaps you should do an experiment with blue and red lock tight to see for yourself.

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

I’ve had one issue with a quicklink also. Last fall, I had to buy a battery powered Dremel and cutting blades to cut off a quicklink that was welded on during an anchor upgrade project.

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

I happened to look at a photo which shows the other bolt on the anchor I updated Monday night.

Lots of grey gunk on that one. Here’s a cropped photo to focus on the detail around the nut.

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

I don’t know what the substance is on that bolt. I’ll look more closely next time I’m at the wall.

At this wall, my guess is that it was not added because the hardware unscrewed itself, but instead because there is an abundant amount of hiker/teenager traffic. 

Jim Day · · Fort Worth, TX · Joined Jan 2020 · Points: 3,164

Hard to tell but it seems most likely the threads were galled.  3/8" ss wedge bolts gall really easily, especially if the threads are dirty or damaged.  Blue loctite of wicking green locktite (like loktite 290) would help reduce the chances of galling.  So would some green grease but I don't hear of people using it.

I made a video of me struggling to unthread some ted loktite quicklinks a while back which mr rogers had sent me.  He also sent me jb welded quicklinks which were way easier to unthread:



Mr Rogers · · Pollock Pines and Bay area CA · Joined Aug 2010 · Points: 92

Was going to link the video of this test you did Jim! Thanks again for participating in that experiment.

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

Great video. Thank you for sharing! 

Andy B · · TooSun · Joined Mar 2006 · Points: 746
old5ten wrote:

having replaced hardware for over two decades, including a fair amount in wilderness (mostly tuolumne and john muir), without power tools, i empathize with your general sentiment.  it sucks to be out there, graciously offering your time, your sweat, and your money, only to be thwarted by the inability to do the job - whatever the reason is.

...but, that frustration you feel is part of the job and the situations you encounter where not everything goes to plan is endless.  there are stripped nuts and threads, completely rusted/frozen quicklinks (way worse than red loctite), wrong drill bit sizes, glues that dry too fast, nozzles that are too short, stupid/unconventional things people did on the install (yep, those 1/4" buttonheads were drilled at a 45deg downward angle), days that are too hot, thunderstorms that hit you four hours too early, wrenches that are too short, sockets that are the wrong size, hell - why is this metric and not sae -, access that is more difficult than you thought, things that miraculously detach from your harness even though you could have sworn they were solid - it's literally endless and you will encounter those situations time and time again... in an ideal world every rebolting mission would be quick, easy, and accomplished the first time around.  reality is much different...

today's plan was to replace a bolt by leading up a mixed (gear/bolts) route next door and do the replacement top down (generally more comfortable, easier).  my partner and i get to the base, he thought i have the rack, i thought he had the rack.  so much for top down, we replaced ground up...

When you know, you know. Lol, grumble...

Anna, thank you for all the hard work you all have been doing over in NM! I'd have to agree, however, that Loctite is sometimes a good idea, especially on popular routes in windy areas where draws may often be up for a while, or on anchor setups in similar conditions. It's not that hard to loosen nuts tightened down with Loctite.

Tom Rangitsch · · Lander, Wy · Joined Jan 2007 · Points: 1,741

Slight thread drift here, but I think germaine to the discussion.  

I generally use blue loctite for routes around Lander.  Most of the development in the last 15 years has been with stainless wedge anchors.  There are many permadraws or in situ draws that are left on for quite some time.  There has been a fair bit of loosening that occurs with this set up, some from falls, but I think much of it is the wind moving the fixed draw back and forth for months or years at a time.  Never had this problem with plated steel years ago as it's more malleable and I think less likely to loosen.  Are lock washers a better solution for this specific problem?  I've heard mixed opinions on this.  Loctite is an easier solution as you don't have to buy an extra nut or washer for each bolt

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

Thank you all for having this discussion with me and to Peter for the nudge to cut the nut off to see what was actually inside. I do agree that whatever material was applied to the bolt was most likely not why the nut wouldn’t disengage.

I’m feeling better about blue Loctite after reading more also, but how about leaving the  “permanent” threadlock at home? I don’t have huge muscles and these tools are heavy!

I appreciate you all out there in the world. Thank you for being such a great part of the climbing community and for all that you continue to teach me in these threads.

jbak x · · tucson, az · Joined Jan 2006 · Points: 5,079

Anna... I thank you for your concern and actually getting out and doing the work.

I have to 2nd Andy Bennett 's post about loctite being a good idea. In fact I always use it. As both Andy and old5ten said, loctite just isn't all that tight. Even the red. I have removed dozens (200 ?) of red locked nuts and only 2 or 3 spun the stud. So I cut the nut with a Dremel. No big deal. The bolt in your original picture looks epoxy puttied... whole different deal.

A bigger concern IMO is loose nuts. I have twice been hit in the face with hanger/quickdraw when a loose nut decided to instantly release when I took a hang. You instantly fall 15 feet and your eyebrow is bleeding. (Not your eye if you are lucky.) Both times were unlocked nuts on routes put up by relative newbies. Now that's only twice in 35+ years of sport climbing, but still... a shock when it happens.

Wind and expansion can work a nut off too if there is a perma or anchor leaning on the nut. I have seen anchors laying on the ground. Same for permadraws. When you clip a draw on a bolt you are looking right at the hanger and likely to notice a loose nut. But less likely on a perma or anchor because your eye is not focused on the hanger. Loctite helps counteract all of this.

Ken Tubbs · · Eugene, OR · Joined Sep 2018 · Points: 1

Anna - I realize your kit is already heavy enough but if you are encountering nuts with Loctite very often it might be worth adding one of these to your kit

I should have added something for size reference but it's about 7-8 inches long. It's refillable with a standard butane canister.

A cigar torch might also work and would be quite a bit smaller.

A little bit of heat goes a long way in getting red Loctite to loosen.

Cocoapuffs 1000 · · Columbus, OH · Joined Jun 2008 · Points: 50

Certain types of threadlock are also corrosion inhibitors.  So they might ironically make old bolts easier to remove.

Salamanizer Ski · · Off the Grid… · Joined Sep 2005 · Points: 24,464
Ken Tubbs wrote:

Anna - might be worth adding one of these to your kit

Now that is an under appreciated and under utilized piece of kit worth having. 

ClimbBaja · · sandy Eggo · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 116
Salamanizer Ski wrote:

Now that is an under appreciated and under utilized piece of kit worth having. 

When that fails to do the job, there is this under utilized piece of mountaineering equipment: 

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

Fixed Hardware: Bolts & Anchors
Post a Reply to "A vote to stop using threadlock in climbing app…"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.