Mountain Project Logo

A vote to stop using threadlock in climbing applications

Original Post
Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

I replaced a modern stainless bolt last night that I believe would not have needed replacement if it hasn’t had threadlock added when it was first installed.

This is my theory on why the bolt failed.

I believe the rock behind the hanger was not hammered flat enough when it was installed and varying forces on the hanger crushed granite crystals behind it over time causing the hanger to spin.

At that point, it appears someone probably put a wrench on the bolt to tighten the nut down and, because of the thread lock, they applied too much force and compromised the bolt inside the hole causing the bolt to also start spinning.

I was not able to get the nut off even when I cranked down the bolt on a bench vice and ended up cutting the bolt to get the good hanger off. 

The threadlock that I finally noticed on the bolt was gray in color.

I believe this bolt would have lasted 50+ years if the nut had been able to tightened in order to secure the hanger in place.

This is the 3rd modern bolt I’ve replaced this summer where we couldn’t remove the nut and the bolt was spinning in the hole. I thought the issue was damaged threads but I’m now seeing that they all probably had a threadlock applied.

I had to return to cut off a quicklink with a Dremel last fall which I couldn’t open with a wrench. I’m guessing it had a threadlock applied also.

K Go · · Seattle, WA · Joined Oct 2017 · Points: 170

Could that have been some sort of corrosion? At least on cars, every time I've used blue or red loctite it maintains its color pretty well (at least enough to be recognized) even on brake or suspension components that get absolutely blasted with road grime. There is also a purple loctite which is the weakest one (I've never used it), maybe that looks gray after a while. 

I've experienced that on several bolts before, where the rock eroded behind the hanger but I couldn't tighten the nut at all so the hangers are still spinning years later. Not sure if corrosion or loctite, but the effect is the same. 

Another question: does anybody use nylon-insert ("Nylock") nuts on climbing bolts? They cost a bit more but solve the problem of loosening from vibration in some applications, and are still easy to re-tighten later. We use them all the time in engineering instead of blue loctite. 

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

It did not appear to be corrosion. There is something gray on the threads which you can see in this photo. I could not break the nut at all in the vice with a large crescent wrench.

Jay Goodwin · · OR-NV-CA-ID-WY · Joined May 2016 · Points: 15

I don't think that is threadlock, which is red or blue. Might be some kind of epoxy (e.g.JB Weld). I have never heard of anyone using such an epoxy product to lock down a nut on a climbing bolt to keep it from loosening, but I can imagine someone thinking it would be a good idea. Clearly, it is not.

climber pat · · Las Cruces NM · Joined Feb 2006 · Points: 301

I use lock tight on quick links because they get stolen.  I make it so someone has to bring a wrench to take a quick link.  I never use lock tight on the bolt itself.

ClimbBaja · · sandy Eggo · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 116

Mil-Spec colors are blue for medium strength (aka: removable) threadlocker, and red for high strength (aka: permanent). Most manufacturers, if not all, conform to this color code. Blue threadlocker should allow the nut to be removed with additional torque applied. Red threadlocker might cause the bolt to snap before releasing. Red can be released by applying heat with a propane torch. The use of blue threadlocker works well on wedge anchors. I'm not aware of any reason that red is preferred, except to prevent theft of the hanger. I weld a tiny bead on the tip of wedge anchors prior to installation for that purpose.

There is a gray threadlocker, infrequently used for special applications, such as, head bolts going through water jackets, if I recall. More likely, someone used JB Weld epoxy putty, a commonly used product. Incredibly tough stuff. I've repaired cracked aluminum transfer cases and motorcycle engine cases with JB Weld.

Another possible cause of nuts binding to the threaded stud is galling. Stainless steel threads have a tendency to gall (fuse) under high torque. If the threads are not lubricated or the manufacturer's lubricant is removed, galling is quite possible. 

I'm assuming that the bolt was a SS wedge anchor? How were you able to extract it from the rock with the nut still on it? Perhaps it's time to add a nut splitter to your tool arsenal. 

philip bone · · sonora · Joined Dec 2011 · Points: 15

The bolt looks bent and the threads look stripped. 

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

Yes, it was a stainless wedge bolt.

I’m not sure what they locked the nut down with but the nut did not come off. Isn’t epoxy shiny when dry? The material on the threads is not shiny, it has a matte finish. It’s knot epoxy putty, it’s not that thick. It looks more like a paste that was applied and dried on the threads.

The bolt felt like it wobbled in the hole when I turned it, so I agree it was bent before we started touching it. 

And, yes threads are stripped. There was enough threading exposed on this bolt for me to attach the YABR to it and the forces of our pulling and the bend in the shaft caused threads on one side to flatten. I was able to spin it with my drill before pulling it. That YABR is an amazing tool! I had my buttonhead removal tools with me so the bolt would have come out one way or another. 

Also, after we pulled it, I put it in a vice to try to get the nut off which damaged the threading. I never could remove the nut! I used my biggest crescent wrench on it and couldn’t get any movement out of it.

old5ten · · Sunny Slopes + Berkeley, CA · Joined Sep 2012 · Points: 5,861

a number of thoughts on this:

- i use threadlocker frequently, mostly on quick links

- to me, that pic doesn't show threadlocker and it would have been applied in the wrong (useless) spot

- sticking the stud in a vice to loosen the nut is pointless, it will rotate with relatively little force.  in an ideal world you'd grind two 'flat' and parallel surfaces into the stud before clamping it with the vice...

E MuuD · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2018 · Points: 191
old5ten wrote:

... - i use threadlocker frequently, mostly on quick links ...

Why?

Patrick Heddins · · Chattanooga, TN · Joined Sep 2011 · Points: 1,105

Could be that the bolt that was used was prone to “galling” or cold welding. I had a whole box of this crap brand called “red heads” and if you wrenched it too hard fast and tight, you would cold weld the nut to the bolt, and then by continuing to wrench, you just start spinning the bolt in the bolt hole. I’m guessing these cheaper brands just use lower quality stainless, or have different metals between the nut and bolt, both increasing your chances of galling.

Solution is to wrench slower, make sure your hardware is clean, and spend the money on the higher quality wedge bolts. 

Jim Titt · · Germany · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 490
Jay Goodwin wrote:

I don't think that is threadlock, which is red or blue. Might be some kind of epoxy (e.g.JB Weld). I have never heard of anyone using such an epoxy product to lock down a nut on a climbing bolt to keep it from loosening, but I can imagine someone thinking it would be a good idea. Clearly, it is not.

Sealey SCS222S is grey and I know others exist, I've a German one in my cupboard. If you think threadlock is only red or blue then your knowledge of the subject is sadly lacking! Green and violet to mention just a couple of Loctite version.

Peter Thomas · · Denver, CO · Joined Jul 2018 · Points: 355

id guess it was likely galling rather than threadlock that caused the problem. I’ve experienced this with stainless links and bolts that were badly galled, but have not experienced fully seized threads from thread lock. Threadlock is a nuisance if bolts get loose and need to be retightened, but often a little outward force is enough to create some expansion in the bolt, and overcome the threadlock. 

I had a similar bolt recently, and your post motivated me to cut the nut off to look. This one was definitely galled. I think one benefit of thread locker is that it helps lubricate the threads making galling less likely. If you cut the nut off, I’d be curious what the threads look like on your bolt.


Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

Peter,
Now I'm motivated to cut!!! I'll be right back with photos....

Salamanizer Ski · · Off the Grid… · Joined Sep 2005 · Points: 24,464

Probably JB Weld. When it breaks or is crushed, it’s a matte grey. Who knows, the point is, it’s a dumb idea.

I’ve never used thread lock on quicklinks. It’s totally pointless because those things can be welded shit with enough torque. If anything, I use anti-seize to keep them from rusting shut. Which is a real problem for non stainless. 

timothy fisher · · CHARLOTTE · Joined Nov 2017 · Points: 35

IDK if folks are using thread locker to avoid spinners or to make them tamper resistant. I think a conventional lock washer would be a better choice to prevent spinners. A top quality bolt properly placed and tightened is maybe better still. 

A permanent thread locker i think is a horrible idea on a wedge bolt. A glue in is the better way to go for tamper resistance.

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

Here are my photos after cutting the nut off.

There’s some significant thread damage at the spot circled in the first photo.

The grey gunk is visible in the threads on the shaft but not in the nut. It is also more visible on the shaft below where the nut was positioned.

This bolt is at the top of a cliff where hikers and teenagers go so a threadlocker makes sense if the bolts had been tampered with in the past.

These anchor bolts are used often by SAR/fire dept organizations and were most likely placed by a member of one of those groups. This bolt had a beefy 30kn hanger on it.

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

I’d much rather have the opportunity to tighten down a nut to fix a spinning hanger than to have to replace a bolt entirely because a threadlocker was applied and the nut can’t be tightened.

Give climbers in the future the opportunity to remedy an easy to fix issue with a wrench vs setting the stage for a whole bolt replacement which involves hiking in a lot of tools and a lot more time.

This was the storm cell bearing down on us as we raced to replace the bolt after work this past Monday. Thankfully, it turned north and we stayed dry but it added a lot of pressure.

To me, adding a threadlocker in a climbing application should be a last resort to deal with actual tampering issues, it shouldn’t be a default on bolt and quicklink installations to prevent issues that haven’t happened yet. If adding a threadlocker is your habit, know that it causes future issues that are probably not on your radar and may not be ones you end up fixing years later.

Colonel Mustard · · Sacramento, CA · Joined Sep 2005 · Points: 1,257

I’m such a troll, I thought this topic was about locking threads online.

old5ten · · Sunny Slopes + Berkeley, CA · Joined Sep 2012 · Points: 5,861
Anna Brown wrote:

I’d much rather have the opportunity to tighten down a nut to fix a spinning hanger than to have to replace a bolt entirely because a threadlocker was applied and the nut can’t be tightened.

Give climbers in the future the opportunity to remedy an easy to fix issue with a wrench vs setting the stage for a whole bolt replacement which involves hiking in a lot of tools and a lot more time.

This was the storm cell bearing down on us as we raced to replace the bolt after work this past Monday. Thankfully, it turned north and we stayed dry but it added a lot of pressure.

To me, adding a threadlocker in a climbing application should be a last resort to deal with actual tampering issues, it shouldn’t be a default on bolt and quicklink installations to prevent issues that haven’t happened yet. If adding a threadlocker is your habit, know that it causes future issues that are probably not on your radar and may not be ones you end up fixing years later.

i think there is a serious misconception here as to what threadlocker is/does and how strong it actually is.  in it's original (non-climbing) version threadlocker  is used for bolts in situations that deal with vibrations, think machinery that rattles around.  blue/removable for small bolts (think the type of stuff on your computer, bike, etc.) and red/permanent for bigger stuff (something that's 1/4" to 3/8" would fall into that category and be on the bigger side of application; yes, we have other threadlocker colors - good luck finding one of those at an ace, hd, etc. in the US).  one could think of it more in terms of retention (preventing the falling out/loosening of stuff) rather than strength (dealing with tampering issues)

in reality the difference in terms of strength and the ability to remove between no threadlock, blue threadlock, and red threadlock is relatively small.  try a simple test, take three quick links (1x no threadlock, 1x blue, 1x red) and put each in a vise.  do an easy finger tighten, then do a similar tighten on all three with a decent sized wrench (let's arbitrarily say 10" crescent wrench and 180deg+, but you decide).  if you want, wait a night.  undo each one the next day.  chances are really good that you'll not find a huge amount of difference between the three.

in terms of tampering prevention on something like a quicklink you're looking at an arms race.  if you set up at home, in a vise, with a big (long lever wrench) and you crank hard there's a really good chance that nobody in the wild will be able to undo (steal or replace) your quicklink unless they come in with some really industrial hardware. these quicklinks will not go anywhere, regardless of threadlocker/color.  note that anyone with even a small wrench can simple unscrew the nut on a wedge or head on a sleeve and just take everything if they have access and are so inclined.

so where does threadlocker come into play?  well, if you're not concerned about theft (ie not torquing quicklinks into oblivion), but are concerned about loosening quicklinks (i for one have 'tightened' down quite a few by hand or with a short wrench over the years), then using threadlocker is actually quite a reasonable way to go.  

   

Anna Brown · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Mar 2015 · Points: 9,761

Since I didn't install this bolt, I can't say definitively what the gray substance is on the threads of the bolt I remove and I can't say definitively if it's the cause of the bolt failing. 

But, it got me to see that adding a threadlocker is not ideal because of future issues that it may cause. I vote for everyone to stop adding it to bolts/quicklinks.

The red Loctite says it's "designed to lock and seal threaded fasteners permanently " and is "only removable once cured by heating parts up to 500°F".

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

Fixed Hardware: Bolts & Anchors
Post a Reply to "A vote to stop using threadlock in climbing app…"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.