Mountain Project Logo

This trend is horrible. And needs to stop

E MuuD · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2018 · Points: 191

LOL! Y'all sound like Norm and Cliff from Cheers! Ah, the good old days...  

J A · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jun 2006 · Points: 45

Many of the most engaging forms of climbing involve sustained sections or situations where you push through, relying on your skills, including your ability to assess and trust your skills, to keep you from falling, because any fall would be dangerous or fatal.  Those more engaging types of climbing are diverse.  They includes some ice climbing, some routes on desert formations, a lot of technical alpine – not just on a given pitch, but also in the challenge to be able to keep moving fast enough through all the pitches to be safe and so on.  A sparsely bolted slab can seem like an artificial, unnecessarily dangerous simulacrum of the realities of that kind of climbing.  Setting aside concerns about either the cost of bolts or the absurd romanticism of ground up route setting, it is.  The minimalist slab bolt ethos has its roots in thinking of climbing as always striving towards being able to tackle more serious climbing. Climbing those slabs can help you learn how to approach more serious climbing routes by forcing you to assess whether or not you have the gymnastic and mental skills to do a run-out that will mean injury or death if you fall.  If the most serious negative consequences of any pitch you do is the possibility of having to abandon a cam or a draw to bail, you won't progress to more serious, engaging and ultimately, more satisfying climbing.

E MuuD · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2018 · Points: 191
J A wrote:

Many of the most engaging forms of climbing involve sustained sections or situations where you push through, relying on your skills, including your ability to assess and trust your skills, to keep you from falling, because any fall would be dangerous or fatal.  Those more engaging types of climbing are diverse.  They includes some ice climbing, some routes on desert formations, a lot of technical alpine – not just on a given pitch, but also in the challenge to be able to keep moving fast enough through all the pitches to be safe and so on.  A sparsely bolted slab can seem like an artificial, unnecessarily dangerous simulacrum of the realities of that kind of climbing.  Setting aside concerns about either the cost of bolts or the absurd romanticism of ground up route setting, it is.  The minimalist slab bolt ethos has its roots in thinking of climbing as always striving towards being able to tackle more serious climbing. Climbing those slabs can help you learn how to approach more serious climbing routes by forcing you to assess whether or not you have the gymnastic and mental skills to do a run-out that will mean injury or death if you fall.  If the most serious negative consequences of any pitch you do is the possibility of having to abandon a cam or a draw to bail, you won't progress to more serious, engaging and ultimately, more satisfying climbing.

I don't need to flirt with death to have fun - or to progress.  I personally don't NEED that experience and have no interest in seeking it out on purpose. 

Tony Danza · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Feb 2024 · Points: 5
Ben G wrote:

What is with this prevailing trend for long runouts on “easy” routes. Some even dozens of feet  before a clip. Especially slabs. I don’t get it.

Easy for who??? The people that can climb much higher grades? Are they the ones that will take a break from climbing 11s and 12s so they can do a 5.6 or 5.7 route? Or 5.4 - 5.5 route?

Fritz Wiessner never climbed 5.11 or 5.12 and he seemed ok on runout slabs.. but of course he still had sticky rubber, nuts and cams, and a nylon rope, otherwise I don’t know how he would have managed to not die.

Lynn Hill’s first climb ever, like first time roping up ever, she *led* a runout slab at Big Rock in SoCal. People were built differently I guess.

Matt Ehn · · CA · Joined Oct 2010 · Points: 476
E MuuD wrote:

I don't need to flirt with death to have fun - or to progress.  I personally don't NEED that experience and have no interest in seeking it out on purpose. 

Great. There are many other routes to do.

Some people never want to lead. Some hate crack/OW/slab/sport/bouldering/mountaineering/whatever. 

People can seek out what they prefer - the world is your oyster. 

E MuuD · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2018 · Points: 191
Eric Craig wrote:

Yes they were! We were very fortunate to have those experiences. 

   Well hopefully you're still have new experiences! 

Tal M · · Denver, CO · Joined Dec 2018 · Points: 6,886
Tony Danza wrote:

Fritz Wiessner never climbed 5.11 or 5.12 and he seemed ok on runout slabs.. but of course he still had sticky rubber, nuts and cams, and a nylon rope, otherwise I don’t know how he would have managed to not die.

Lynn Hill’s first climb ever, like first time roping up ever, she *led* a runout slab at Big Rock in SoCal. People were built differently I guess.

I’ll cut myself some slack for not starting my climbing career the same way one of the best and most groundbreaking climbers of all time started theirs

Clint Helander · · Anchorage, AK · Joined Dec 2007 · Points: 617

I find it surprising that you expect routes to be catered to your level of ability and risk. Instead...why not find routes that suit your nature? As the old bumper sticker says "remember when sex was safe and climbing was dangerous?"

ddriver · · SLC · Joined Jul 2007 · Points: 2,523
Clint Helander wrote:

I find it surprising that you expect routes to be catered to your level of ability and risk. Instead...why not find routes that suit your nature? As the old bumper sticker says "remember when sex was safe and climbing was dangerous?"

I thought it said "climbing is hard but it's easier than growing up," or that could have been my shirt.

tom donnelly · · san diego · Joined Aug 2002 · Points: 426
Alan Rubin wrote:

This is not at all a 'new' phenomenon---easy slab routes with no or minimal protection have been around since the early days of climbing ( when they weren't thought of as being easy), long before bolts for climbing were a 'thing' --the Iydwal Slabs in North Wales, for example. As a result such climbs are part of the 'fabric' of climbing. 

Still, I agree that not all easy/moderate slabs should be bolted to require very long runouts--as said above, a mix of reasonably protected and runout routes seems a reasonable 'compromise'. Also those establishing such routes should give consideration to who the likely future climbers of their routes will be. As an example, the Tuolumne domes do not have an abundance of slab routes below 5.10, especially ones that have possibilities for reasonable ( or any) natural protection. So, in my opinion, it is disappointing that back in the 70s/80s, several of the top climbers of the day---operating at the 5.11/12 level, chose to solo several 5.7-8  slabs---and then 'officially' claim them as first ascents, and therefore, according to the established climbing ethics of the time--and now, 'freezing' them in that unprotected status 'for all time'. I consider this to be very selfish behavior ---and I doubt that those routes are frequently, if ever, climbed---and never by parties operating in that grade range, while they likely would have been popular, and filled a 'need' for for climbs at that level, if they had been reasonably bolted. If these had been crack climbs, or otherwise naturally-protectable, this wouldn't be an issue, but on such 'blank' slabs it makes all the difference. It would have been much better had those climbers 'quietly' soloed the routes for their own satisfaction, but left the 'for the record first ascents' for future parties who would likely have bolted the routes in a manner more appropriate for people climbing at such grades:

I have likely said the same thing, however I'm not sure there are very many such Tuolumne routes done as a solo.  Far more common are R routes with some pro.  Anyway, there are many moderate well protected routes that have been done since that time even in Tuolumne (a national park) and thousands upon thousands of sport routes added since then in California.  Not every route needs to be well protected.  Tuolumne would lose its natural atmosphere if it became even more popular for climbing.  So I don't think these soloed routes are something to worry about.  But if you really care, some of the people who did the first ascents of the R and X routes are still around if you want to ask them about adding pro.

tom donnelly · · san diego · Joined Aug 2002 · Points: 426
Eric Craig wrote:

Hi Alan, that route is kinda "PDH". 5.10.

So I wrote earlier that " run outs ARE part of TRADitional climbing ", and an important part it is. But I have nothing against easy/moderate sport climbs. I will even tip my hat to those who put the effort into establishing them....good on ya.

Dumbing down adventurous trad routes with bolts is seriously FU. Two climbs I know of,  both previously kinda "R", but protectable with mildly creative placements, have been converted to semi sport routes. Ruined really. Chockcraft, i.e. placing nuts, IS  part of TRADitional climbing too. So one step in avoiding this is learning to use nuts. They work in places no cam will. 

So what is being done with these added bolts, besides complaining about them on the internet?

Ben G · · San Antonio, TX · Joined Aug 2023 · Points: 19
Sofa King Watt wrote:

Basically Ben, you need to get better. Or you can always play Pickleball. I hear it’s a lot safer 

Well…that’s exactly what I’m trying to do... without getting hurt

Tal M · · Denver, CO · Joined Dec 2018 · Points: 6,886
Clint Helander wrote:

I find it surprising that you expect routes to be catered to your level of ability and risk. Instead...why not find routes that suit your nature? As the old bumper sticker says "remember when sex was safe and climbing was dangerous?"

Not to defend the OP because theyre definitely loudly showing how green they are at this point, but unless I’ve misunderstood the conversation, I think they’re advocating for more routes that suit their nature. Unfortunately if you live somewhere without a good amount of rock, there’s a chance you’re stuck with whatever was developed before your time. So the conversation has to start involving a bit of zero-sum-game attributes

Rob Dillon · · Tamarisk Clearing · Joined Mar 2002 · Points: 727

I finished my little rant, exasperated.  Gramps sat back in his rocking chair, his gaze somewhere off in the middle distance.

“Let me get this straight. Climbing up a rock cliff is supposed to be safe, and if it isn’t, it must be somebody else’s fault?”

almostrad · · BLC · Joined Jul 2015 · Points: 18
Todd Berlier wrote:

has anyone brought up snake dike, yet?

No but we're about half a page away from the Bacher Yerian I can feel it

Ben G · · San Antonio, TX · Joined Aug 2023 · Points: 19
Robert S wrote:

Ah, E-Rock!

On a regular basis, I climb and guide there.

Yes, the runouts are ridiculous, and the bolt spacing is whacked on not just moderates but harder routes as well.

I have never fallen on Mystery and Imagination, for example, but I have stopped leading it, especially for clients. The three bolts over about 60', not counting the sketchy scramble to get to the start, just aren't worth risking my neck anymore.

Given that E-Rock now regularly sells out and climbers drive a long way to get there, there should be warnings.

The person who said it's easy to set up topropes there is so wrong. He's not lying, but he's discounting the fact that most people don't know how to make extended anchors off gear or bolts.


The description on that route says “Consider this a free solo climb with bolts for the second half”   

Tony Danza · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Feb 2024 · Points: 5
Tal M wrote:

I’ll cut myself some slack for not starting my climbing career the same way one of the best and most groundbreaking climbers of all time started theirs

Everyone starts more or less the same level. No one is a born climber more so than anyone else. Anyone can climb 5.6 their first day out. Maybe you didn’t lead your first route like Lynn did, but otherwise, you probably did start your climbing life like her or Fritz.

And for all the talk about risk on runout slabs, how often have people actually gotten seriously hurt on one? Yes the snake dike incident from a couple years ago. That’s one. Out of a thousand ascents of snake dike per year. So one catastrophic incident after fifty years and people want to equate snake dike with a death route.

I think our society has come to view risk, any risk, as unreasonable, and that attitude has filtered into climbing, whereas there is value to risk, as many others have stated. 

Jared AE · · The, road · Joined Nov 2022 · Points: 733

This thread is missing something…… anyone heard from tradiban?

F r i t z · · North Mitten · Joined Mar 2012 · Points: 1,190
Tony Danza wrote:

I think our society has come to view risk, any risk, as unreasonable, and that attitude has filtered into climbing, whereas there is value to risk, as many others have stated. 

I agree with you, but consider it darkly ironic that the same society condones and even celebrates handing car keys to a sixteen-year-old.

As always, Phyl has impeccable insight upthread. She also is one of the most highly-educated people in this thread, so it's not like her perspective is coming from a 19-year-old bro whose risk tolerance is skewed by an inchoate prefrontal cortex.

I hope people take the time to read her post with an open mind. 

F r i t z · · North Mitten · Joined Mar 2012 · Points: 1,190

Also, Ben, you're too young to be wasting your time on slab! Take advantage of that early 20's metabolism and go get on some steep limestone, nawmean? Once you become a corpulent trad dad like me and most of the people who have responded, when you have an inverse strength-to-weight ratio, then you can come back to the low-angle dog-paddling.

After all, the only reason we embrace the vertical hagiography of runouts is to assuage our wounded egos because we can no longer climb 5.10c vert, amirite? /s

But in all seriousness, you should take Tal up on his offer, because he is a genuinely nice dude with a vision for cool routes.

This topic is locked and closed to new replies.

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.