Mountain Project Logo
To save paper & ink, use the [Hide] controls next to photos and comments so you only print what you need.

Excommunication

5.13a, Trad, Sport, 380 ft (115 m), 5 pitches, Grade III,  Avg: 4 from 20 votes
FA: Greg Child, et al.
Utah > Southeast Utah > Castle Valley > Priest
Warning Access Issue: RAIN, WET ROCK and RAPTOR CLOSURES: The sandstone around Moab is fragile and is very easily damaged when it is wet. Also please ask and be aware of Raptor Closures in areas such as CAT WALL and RESERVOIR WALL in Indian Creek DetailsDrop down

Description

This is the spectacular bolted route on the North Face of The Priest. It climbs unique calcite features similar to those on Holier Than Thou on The Nuns.

Greg Child apparently bolted this route in September, 2002. He established the route "ground-up"—which I think is a bit misleading, because he basically made a bolt ladder out of it. True, it was ground up, but it was not free, nor was it bold. There are several holes in the rock with missing bolts, so apparently he (or maybe someone else) decided to take bolts out after the fact.

Mr. Child apparently worked on freeing it for a long time. A magazine article in Rock and Ice from early '03, which has pictures of the route but makes no mention of the route in the article, describes the line as a "project." Rumor has it that Mr. Child hiked up there 64 times(!!) to work on it...that sounds a little unbelievable to me. The summit register mentions the first (aid) ascent, but the register doesn't record when it was freed.

The April 2005 issue of Rock and Ice lists the route as a "new route" in the Moab area, rating the 5 pitches as 12b, 12a, 13a, 11c, and 10c, but calling the overall route "13b". It also claims the route was thus-far unrepeated, despite attempts from two "strong teams." I wonder who those teams are. Rumor has it, Eric Decaria checked it out, but decided not to work the route because he didn't like all the glue on it.

Here's what I thought:

In April '05, Clay Cahoon and I made an ascent, which we guess is the 2nd, but who knows? It took us 3 total days of effort. On the final day we each freed every pitch starting from the ground, and we both redpointed the crux pitch.

P1: 5.12b (9 bolts, 90 feet) First of all, I would say that this pitch (and the next one) is all of 12b. It's not like the easy 12's at Indian Creek; I would say it's on a par with Sacred Ground on Castleton Tower, which is pretty stout.

The pitch climbs the bolted arete, using actual arete moves. The arete keeps your attention due to its sharp nature, and the fact that it seems like it is always windy right there. A couple hard, thin moves get things started, then it eases a bit above a horizontal crack.

The crux comes higher with a hard clip and balance-y arete moves. There are 9 bolts, a drilled angle, and no glue on this pitch.

P2: 5.12a (6 bolts, gear, 70 feet) This pitch is a bit easier, but a lot scarier. Your rope actually has to cross the arete on this pitch, so the thought of falling is terrifying. You're still climbing on the arete, but now things are starting to get exposed.

The first bolt is on the left side of the arete, then all the rest are on the right, even though you mostly climb on the left side. About 40 feet up, the holds on the arete peter out, but fortunately, a dihedral crack appears on the right. The crux involves getting from the arete into the crack. I broke a hold on this section, but another good hold appeared underneath it, so the pitch still goes.

Once in the crack, some sharp calcite jams lead to the fat ledge at the base of the crux pitch. There are five or six bolts on this pitch, and you'll want a small cam (0.2 camalot), but you can get by with one 0.5.

P3: 5.13a (9 bolts, 90 feet) This is the money pitch. Fortunately this pitch climbs up the center of the face on calcite, so it's not quite as scary or windy.

A few easy arete moves past two bolts get you firmly established on the face. The climbing is very reminscent of just-past-vertical limestone, such as that found at the VRG. The climbing gets increasingly harder until a series of crux deadpoints, or tenuous reaches near the 6th bolt.

After a good rest at a horizontal crack (lots of glue that seems unnecessary), a couple more very hard moves with heart-break potential stand between you and the next cush ledge (about 9 bolts...90 feet).

P4: 5.11c (4 bolts, 40 feet) This short pitch contains an interesting combination of wingate and calcite features before the holds dead end at a less-than-vertical slab which forms the crux.

Clay and I both climbed this differently, and we had different opinions on the accuracy of the grade. If you made it this far, it should be no problemo. Belay on the shoulder of The Priest.

P5: 5.10+ R (2 bolts, gear .75-2, 40 feet) The summit pitch. It would be possible to link 4 and 5, but the rope drag could be really scary.

Start up a nice crack that is formed by a car-sized flake leaning against the wall. When you gain the top of the flake, you get to stem up a rotten corner. Thankfully, Mr. Child left two bolts here to reduce the pucker factor. The rock is bad, and you're smearing on it...yeehaw.

All in all, both Clay and I thought this was an outstanding route. It is entirely unique. The climbing consisted of good movement, spectacular position, and mostly excellent rock. To top it off, all of the pitches have great ledges which make it more enjoyable to work the route. I have no doubt this route will get harder with time as key holds snap off and calcite footholds get even more polished.

As for the glue...I don't feel that this route is "manufactured" because it's not like key holds have been glued on where none existed before. In many cases the glue is there to reinforce large features that offer good rests. These holds are not critical to allowing the route to be free climbed; if the glued holds did break off the route would still go, it just might be more pumpy.

This may cause you to wonder, well why glue these holds at all? Good question. Perhaps he thought it was a matter of safety, as many of these rocks are large enough to kill someone if they did peel.

All in all, I highly recommend this route, and I tip my hat to Mr. Child...well done!

Protection

About 12 QDs, Camalots (1 each) 0.2, 0.5, 0.75, 1, 2.

Photos [Hide ALL Photos]

Looking up at the sweet calcite features on the cruxes of P3. I'd recommend extending the draw shown with 3 total quickdraws (only 2 were used in this picture).
[Hide Photo] Looking up at the sweet calcite features on the cruxes of P3. I'd recommend extending the draw shown with 3 total quickdraws (only 2 were used in this picture).
The Priest
[Hide Photo] The Priest
Heading up P2
[Hide Photo] Heading up P2
Noah M on P1
[Hide Photo] Noah M on P1
The bolted arete of Excommunication.
[Hide Photo] The bolted arete of Excommunication.
Proper arete moves on P1
[Hide Photo] Proper arete moves on P1

Comments [Hide ALL Comments]

[Hide Comment] Also, this route can be rapped with a single cord. May 10, 2005
[Hide Comment] Absolutely amazing route, one of the best I've ever done. A few notes to the excellent description. It's really cold up there. All day shade and a constant wind, even when it was sunny and 78 degrees. Second, there are a lot of bolts, but you can't cheat through it. Virtually none of the crux moves can be pulled past, so be prepared to lead it all. The crux pitch is devious and hard to figure out, but fair at the grade in my opinion. The first two pitches are more stiff at the grades. The second pitch is very scary, as the arete is sharp due to the calcite covering. I don't know if different bolt placements are possible, but it is worth considering by a qualified person. Overall, committing, intimidating, and brilliant climbing. Oct 19, 2009
[Hide Comment] This gets my vote for the best route is Castle Valley. Really nice belay ledges and awesome climbing. I had heard that this route was really hard and had broken but we found it very pleasant. 5.13a solid. Apr 10, 2014
Nick Sullens
Yosemite
[Hide Comment] I thought the first pitch was 12b/c, height dependent, and incredibly good. The second pitch felt harder than 12a, but less scary than I thought it would be. The crux pitch is one of the finest sport pitches anywhere. Mar 22, 2018
Brent Barghahn
Flagstaff, AZ
 
[Hide Comment] On pitch two, you can back clean the second bolt once the third is clipped and the rope runs nicely around the arete. Nothing sharp or scary about it. The forecast was a high of 65 in Moab and we froze all morning on the first pitches. Apr 15, 2019
Noah McKelvin
Nomad
 
[Hide Comment] The best desert free climb ever Oct 8, 2020
Renee Globis
Salt Lake City, UT
[Hide Comment] Hi, I'm just reminiscing this holiday season, and came across your article...I thought I may be able to shed some light on your stats. The route was established on or about mid-August 2002. Greg Child freed the route on or about August 23rd, according to my recollection. You will have to believe me because I was the belayer, Jay Smith was also with us, and Simon Carter filmed us all. Greg and I, started the route on or about early July....hiking up...scoping it out, then, one, two three pitches by the end of July. Then, the route became more difficult. We proceeded to establish the route, (I belayed and Greg climbed...just he and I); about 21 days into it, he successfully freed it with Simon Carter (filming) and Jay Smith who also helped him a few days here and there, whereas I needed a break! So, I actually can calculate about 23 days for the routes' completion, on my end. I will always remember the day he freed it!

Simon Carter was filiming, (Greg had already freed the most difficult pitch with Jay Smith a day or so earlier, and this was just to finalize the route.) As we started the climb, let's just say August 23rd, 2002; Greg was almost to the first anchor with a good size ledge, but not much for protection. A classic run out by old school climbers. A rattlesnake was staring at me in the face at eye level with his teeth about to bite my neck. I screamed bloody murder and dished out rope to Greg and ran away from the spire. Greg, knew instantly that something was wrong. I kept giving him rope, he arrived at the first anchor; and we communicated that he is coming back down to deal with the snake. He came down and picked up the snake with a stick and tossed him away into the desert. We started again. Well, that damn snake arrived right back and planted himself in the middle of all out gear and backpacks and was not about to budge. Greg came down, again! This time he got the snake with his hands and went waaaay further away, and told me how they are super territorial. Third time is a charm, and he, Jay Smith and I, all proceeded to climb the route. Greg nailed it. As we approached the last pitch, (we had not established it, yet), Greg offered the final pitch to me, and Jay agreed. I was so frickin' excited. I put in two (2) bolts, hanging on solid hooks with our bosch drill. As Greg and Jay got to the top, they both said I did an impressive job! I was so excited...what a great climb and great job by all! Then, all the sudden...these airforce jet planes that come out of Grand Junction peeled by us, as we were all celebrating. They did a pass by, twice! It was exhilarating! As you may know, Jay Smith is an ex-Navy Seal! I wondered, if he had something to do with it, but he said no...just luck or timing! Anyway, we wrote in the journal and headed; mission accomplished. Just a side note...we saw five (5) rattlesnakes that day from top to bottom! The experienced showed me Greg's true valuable colors of determination and ethics. I have no comment about any 'glue' considerations to the route. My opinion is that, if it will save a life while challenging yourself on an insurmountable climb, then its okay by me! Set the record straight. You can always verify this with Simon Carter or Jay Smith, or Greg, of course! Thanks for the recognition of the route! It is amazing and I hope that many more continue to challenge and enjoy its spice of life! Peace out,
Renee Globis Dec 26, 2020
Mike Anderson
Colorado Springs, CO
  5.13a
[Hide Comment] Renee, thanks for embellishing the description with your memories. It's great to have the first-person account for the record. What a cool route! Dec 28, 2020
Isaac Kroger
Little Rock, AR
 
[Hide Comment] Some notes:
For P1, a #2 in the horizontal protects getting to the first bolt.

For P2, I second Brent's comment about back-cleaning draw 2 after 3 is clipped. This was trivial to do and allowed the rope to run nicely around the arete. There was a draw left on bolt 2, presumably for this reason. If this is to remain fixed, it should be upgraded.

The calcite on P3 is very different from the waxy, white calcite of Indian Creek. Instead, it's much more reminiscent of tufa climbing. I found this pitch to have some of the most unique and enjoyable climbing around!
On P3, I'd recommend clipping bolt 5 with an alpine draw or using 3 total quickdraws of extension so that it can be clipped while your foot is still on the large, glued jug. A long stiffy draw might be useful for hanging this on lead.
P3 had 2 distinct crux sections. The first is on razor-thin crimps. Bring plenty of skin. The second is on tufa-like rock with weird holds and technical footwork. Edging shoes were appreciated.

Finally, this route is commonly used as the rappel route for the other routes on the Priest. Some of the anchor bolts have a quicklink with a single chain link on the end, rather than a rappel ring. Upgrading to rappel rings would be trivial and prolong the life of these stations. I'll try and replace these when I return. Let us know if you get to it before I do. Oct 26, 2022
Lior Dahan
Boulder CO
[Hide Comment] This route is awesome.
My opinion about the grades: if the second pitchis 12a the first will be at least 12c/d as it's much harder. Either way both of them are beautiful foot work climbing. Pitch 3 is also awsome and I think 13a is appropriate.

There is nothing scary about pitch 2 as the second bolt is very easy to unclimp (without downclimbing) and the rope runs nicely through the arete.

Descende: we were able to rap to the the ground in 4 raps using 70m rope by rapping from the anchor of pitch 4 to the anchor of pitch 2. May 23, 2023
[Hide Comment] Amazing route! The last pitch wasn't bad, the rock on the "rotten corner" must have cleaned up. Only used a .5 for p2 and #1 & .75 for the last pitch. Oct 18, 2024