Mountain Project Logo

New and Experienced Climbers over 50 #43

ed esmond · · The Paris of VT... · Joined Jan 2010 · Points: 0
M Sprague wrote:

Hugs Ed, you and Rick look close as brothers. I think one would be hard pressed to find much of a better friend than you. You can trust your instincts.

Spriggy,  From the heart thanks, I know you completely and totally understand.  All one can do is be their best in any situation. You are the master of compassion and I sit at you feet.

ed ”that man is a genius! ” e

ps. I think our good friend Ward, could use someone “nipping at his heels..”. Just saying… 

Li Hu · · Different places · Joined Jul 2022 · Points: 55
Lori Milas wrote:

LIke it or not, AI is here, these super stars are here... we can turn away, or hold them closely and be a part of the movement. 

I'm just learning what I can--which has been so fun--and holding it all with open hands.  

AI is just a software tool to help solve problems.

Currently, it’s very good at software tasks and designing electronics, mechanical devices with guidance.

In my own work, I currently use Sonnet 4,6 DeepSeekV4 Pro and embed Qwen3,6 onto my projects.

Higher end Opus 4,8 and Fable5 didn’t provide enough advantages over Sonnet integrated with mine own brain.

It’ll be a while before a model will replace native intelligence. I’m predicting something 5 times bigger than Mythos and as effIcient as Qwen at the same time before a model can beat a smart entry level engineer. That’s possibly a couple decades away assuming China and India and hopefully Africa can catch up fully with the west. After everyone is on parity, it’ll be a united effort towards singularity. That’s the software side.

Guessing some form of new hybrid/quantum model will be developed. Huge models will do most of the actual programming/training work with massive amounts of highly intelligent humans guiding them.

But, at the moment and for years to come, likely won’t actually replace humans.

I honestly think it’ll be like the “paperless office” promises of the 1980s and create many more jobs once the idiot billionaires realise they still need workers and will have to pay them more.   

Emil Briggs · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2013 · Points: 140
Daniel Shively wrote:

Etienne had a boxer buddy for a summer of hiking, her name was Luna and she was wild and full of energy. Luna moved to Arizona.  Phyl, I appreciate your contributions to the Snake Dike threads, I hope that many readers there know that you speak from a lifetime of experience. 

Li, yeah being out in nature with loved ones keeps everything in perspective for me. I imagine we all share similar feelings when out in wild places. 

Cheers to all!

Cute puppy pics are the best of the internet.  Sometimes I think that's where we should have stopped.

Todd Berlier · · Orangevale, CA · Joined Jan 2026 · Points: 0
Emil Briggs wrote:

Cute puppy pics are the best of the internet.  Sometimes I think that's where we should have stopped.

Li Hu · · Different places · Joined Jul 2022 · Points: 55
Daniel Shively wrote:

I get what you’re saying here but I think that one of the main concerns is that most “smart entry level engineers” don’t perform tasks that require using anything near the limits of their potential. All the machine has to do is perform at an adequate level and at least anecdotally this is already happening. I think the tech jargon for describing this is multi-agent orchestration. 

The biggest single problem that I see with AI/data currently is the unprecedented level of overvaluation and the co-factors of over promising the lifespan of critical infrastructure coupled with mass scale resistance to actually paying to use upgraded and subscription platforms. 

I’m sure when the bubble bursts big tech will cry “too big to fail” and the money printer will go brrrrrrrr and Americans will be left paying the tab, again.

As with “paperless office” promises, every AI company is overpromising.

It’s the next step, yes, but not nearly what people are being told.

“overpromise” makes money, telling people “it’s a new tool” isn’t going to affect the stock market   

Li Hu · · Different places · Joined Jul 2022 · Points: 55

Whilst sitting in a coffee shop waiting for me Latte, I asked the Opus 4,8 model (most powerful available on my iPhone… what I had shared with you folks already… reply:
“On the actual question — will smart humans still be needed to guide AI — this is genuinely contested, not something I’d claim confident knowledge of. The case for “yes, for a long while”: systems-level judgment, knowing what to build and why, debugging emergent failures, and integrating across messy real-world constraints (like your RK3588/ROS2 stack) are still hard for models to do unsupervised. The case for “less than people think”: agentic coding tools are already automating large chunks of what used to require a human in the loop, and that trend has been moving faster than most predicted a year or two ago. I’d hold that uncertainty rather than anchor on a parameter-count milestone — it’s not the variable doing the work.”

I had insulted the model, it even cited my “puppy robot” work from a disconnected thread using my API key with Microsoft Copilot not Claude Code… 

It “threatened” me, a slight departure from older promises of a “paperless office”.  

Remember, we can always pull the plug…

Todd Berlier · · Orangevale, CA · Joined Jan 2026 · Points: 0
Li Hu wrote:

Whilst sitting in a coffee shop waiting for me Latte, I asked the Opus 4,8 model (most powerful available on my iPhone… what I had shared with you folks already… reply:
“On the actual question — will smart humans still be needed to guide AI — this is genuinely contested, not something I’d claim confident knowledge of. The case for “yes, for a long while”: systems-level judgment, knowing what to build and why, debugging emergent failures, and integrating across messy real-world constraints (like your RK3588/ROS2 stack) are still hard for models to do unsupervised. The case for “less than people think”: agentic coding tools are already automating large chunks of what used to require a human in the loop, and that trend has been moving faster than most predicted a year or two ago. I’d hold that uncertainty rather than anchor on a parameter-count milestone — it’s not the variable doing the work.”

I had insulted the model, it even cited my “puppy robot” work from a disconnected thread using my API key with Microsoft Copilot not Claude Code… 

It “threatened” me, a slight departure from older promises of a “paperless office”.  

Remember, we can always pull the plug…

Li, your wonder, awe and naivete I feel like you represent with AI and Lori's appreciation for it, is what scares me the most.

What are you two most afraid of when it comes to AI?

Jan Mc · · CA · Joined Aug 2013 · Points: 0

Todd, what are you afraid of with AI?  Like Li said, it is a tool.  The fact that its creators are trying to advertise it as something else is the problem.  Not what it actually is.

Lori Milas · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Apr 2017 · Points: 250

I was browsing through my old pictures for one of John Long, posing on a rock, with a cigarette.  I never found it, but I did find a great article from 1978.  Don't know if you can expand it here, but to read of John Long, John Bachar, visitng John Gill just to try to manage some of his routes... there are stories here that John Gill should have been telling us.

https://imgur.com/a/pumping-sandstone-0fjjW

I get a lot of history from Bob, but it will never replace being there to watch in real time.  I have read John Long's book Icarus Syndrome, and many of his articles... so prolific and entertaining.  

John wrote on the Snake Dike situation, and his thoughts on why 'it should stay dangerous'.  In a Safety-Obsessed World, Routes Like ‘Snake Dike’ Are Monuments to the Trad Era

But actually, while I am so interested in John's adventures, I didn't know the impact John Gill had on everyone.  I know just a tiny fraction of his story.  I hope we get a lot more.  

"Sixteen years ago John demolished the current free standards by soloing The Thimble."  Really?  I thought it was all bouldering for John.  This is amazing history. John, if you're reading can you fill in some gaps?

Todd Berlier · · Orangevale, CA · Joined Jan 2026 · Points: 0
Jan Mc wrote:

Todd, what are you afraid of with AI?  Like Li said, it is a tool.  The fact that its creators are trying to advertise it as something else is the problem.  Not what it actually is.

Personally, I'm afraid of deep fakes becoming too believable and the manipulation that can occur. I mean we literally have a large portion of people in this country that don't believe the election results of 2020 with no physical evidence. I mean when physical evidence is manufactured...fuck...the power the willfully ignorant people hold freaks me out.

Lori Milas · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Apr 2017 · Points: 250
Todd Berlier wrote:

Li, your wonder, awe and naivete I feel like you represent with AI and Lori's appreciation for it, is what scares me the most.

What are you two most afraid of when it comes to AI?


I am still trying to get my thoughts around this whole scene.  It's powerful and it's thrilling.  

One of my initial thoughts is that mind-blowing intelligence and science is happening right now and THAT is the real business of the day, of our country and the world, and our President and Congress have no idea how large or powerful it is.  They are gushing over the wrong paint in the reflecting pool.  Or whether the PM of Italy begged for a picture with Donald Trump.  Meanwhile, the speed of advancement in science is beyond comprehension.  

I'm ignorant but catching up.  I just spent a week with my new good friend, Gemini, uploading and interpreting piles of business, asking complicated questions requiring reading and interpreting pages of data, where each were read and answered in under 5 seconds, getting suggestions for follow up research...this much work would have taken several months for me to research and isolate myself.

I now have my own personal assistant... agent?... and that is just one big toe in the water.  I am very clear that the information is not perfect.  But understanding where LLMs were just a few years ago, and are NOW, is mindboggling.  

And as was forecast by Jensen, no sooner that we hand off tons of busy work, we have just made space for more productive work, or more time hiking and climbing (for me).

I'm sure there are bad players, but I don't recoil in fear.  Besides it's not practical... AI is here.  

Who the good guys are and the bad guys... and who we must like or disapprove of in order to stay within the good graces of the political party we chose... has caused me to be deeply suspicious.  So, I have taken a long step back, and just opened up my curiosity to see what I see without prejudice.  i have mostly focused on Elon lately, since he is so despised.  I watched a long explanation of the new 'Terafab" he is building, that will put our data centers into space, instead of on terra firma.  What really gets to me is that while our government is so painfully unaware or lacking in any solutions, guys like Elon are just doing it themselves, with their own money, their own stoke.  So, I think we are in a new era, where capitalism and innovation rule.  

I remember when John McCain was running for President, opposite Obama.  At that time McCain stated that he didn't own a computer and didn't want to.  Meanwhile, Obama was mass texting young people and using every kind of communications technology available at that time to appeal to voters.  Feels like that again.  

M M · · Maine · Joined Oct 2020 · Points: 3
Daniel Shively wrote:

I’m not afraid of AI, I understand the concept of tools. I don’t understand why its creators misrepresent it. This causes me to be skeptical. Do you know why it is advertised as not exactly what it is? I mean, if lawn mowers were advertised as snow blowers I would be skeptical about why that is happening too. 

Todd, I’m going to create deep fakes of me climbing all of your first ascents and date them 13 weeks prior to your ascent and steal your glory and legacy as a westside bouldering legend. LOL

Todd is an Ai bot that already stole all the FAs from a guy named Bob so this would be a good twist in the ongoing Ai saga.

My big beef with it is that by most accounts it is ruining education in the schools. Most recently I heard a coworker talking about his teenage daughter doing some art that Ai suggested to her. Now maybe I'm just an old fashioned moron but it seems to me that this is about the same thing as coloring inside the lines.

Jan Mc · · CA · Joined Aug 2013 · Points: 0

Todd, sounds more like you are afraid of stupid people --- as we all should be.  And I agree that AI can be used to lie to those people.  But then a lot of our society is based on being lied to so on that basis it is really hard to understand what we should believe.

Lori, John Gill has spent a lot of time on this thread talking about his experiences, including that visit be JB and JL.

apogee · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 0
Jan Mc wrote:

…sounds more like you are afraid of stupid people --- as we all should be. 

The sheer number of them makes this especially terrifying.

x15x15 · · Use Ignore Button · Joined Mar 2009 · Points: 285
apogee wrote:

The sheer number of them makes this especially terrifying.

And too many unknowingly represent themselves as smart!

Brad Young · · Twain Harte, CA · Joined Apr 2009 · Points: 1,267
apogee wrote:

The sheer number of them makes this especially terrifying.

As Albert himself may have said: 

"Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe."

Carl Schneider · · Mount Torrens, South Australia · Joined Dec 2017 · Points: 0

I've been using Copilot quite a bit at work lately. The last task was to analyse the Australian Core Skills Framework Reading, Writing, Oral Communication and Numeracy levels for a whole bunch of units of competency in the Certificate III in Correctional Practice, the levels of our knowledge assessments and the levels of our Standard Operating Procedures. This sort of work can be quite accurate and quick.

On a personal level, I used Copilot in 'speaking mode' (rather than typing) to calculate the cost of a whole bunch of LP records.  I'm about to buy a good quality sound system (record player, amp, speakers) and decided to buy new LP records of all of Led Zep and all of Pink Floyd. Rather than me going to the web site and wading through pages to find the albums and add up all the prices I prompted Copilot with prompts like 'get familiar with all the studio albums of Zed Zeppeklin, not re-mixes, not compilations, not live albums, just studio albums'. Then I said, 'go to {web site} and add up all the prices of all the Led Zep studio albums'. I had to cut it off quite a bit to say things like 'shut up, don't explain the prices, just add them up, give me the total.' I then had to prompt quite a bit for it to give me a table of the album names and prices but it was quite quick. My wife was a bit astonished at how rude I was to him.  I'm the same with Siri, I shout at her a lot in the car, mainly to say 'SIRI, PLAY THE NEXT SONG!!!'.

I also used it recently to tell me what route I would have done to get to where this picture was taken. It confidently told me a place I'd never been, so in the end I had to upload my logbook from thecrag.com as a 'csv file to narrow it down.

Notice how I managed to bring this back to about climbing???  Hmmm? 

Ward Smith · · Wendell MA · Joined Oct 2020 · Points: 26
apogee wrote:

The sheer number of them makes this especially terrifying.

“Think of how stupid the average person is.  Then realize that half of them are stupider than that.”  George Carlin

Nick Goldsmith · · NEK · Joined Aug 2009 · Points: 510

AI almost blew up my van.  I asked it very specifically if the suburban model #  bla bla cook stove that I was installing needed a regulator between the propane tank and the stove. AI said no. The suburban model # bla bla  has an internal regulator.  turns out that most propane stoves need a high pressure regulator coming from the tank and a low pressure regulator that is part of the stove itself. without the high pressure regulator between the tank and the stove as soon as I turned the gas on it blew all the seals in the stove.. 

Norm Larson · · Wilson, Wy. · Joined Jan 2008 · Points: 90

Nick you should of known that. So should AI. 

This topic is locked and closed to new replies.

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.