Half Dome's Snake Dike is being retrobolted - get involved!
|
|
woodhead wrote: This may have consequences you didn’t consider. Those consequences are a large reason why we should police ourselves. The government is NOT your friend! |
|
|
NateC wrote: Seriously. What the heck are you thinking, Woodhead? There is literally zero positive outcomes that can come from notifying the authorities. No one is banning Sloan from the park. And the NPS is not going to remove the bolts. Instead you're risking unwanted attention that could easily morph into unwanted regulations. Just dumb. |
|
|
I don’t get it, shoes, chalk, harness, rope = good style. Actually having something to clip the rope into = bad style? |
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: If you really don't get it after 14 pages of discussion in this thread alone, I'm not sure how else we could articulate it. |
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: Correct, no notes |
|
|
The NPS already knows. This has been on national news for at least a day. I do like the idea of open communication with land managers - but not necessarily asking them to do anything. I'm sure they would appreciate if a recognized leader in the community (YCA?) would come to them say, "We know what Sloan did. We know about Beck's updated thoughts. We think we currently know what the community wants to do about it. Here is how we are guiding. Let us know if you need anything." I'm super impressed with how the park is handling chopped bolts in Joshua Tree. Likewise, I've personally seen the forest service respond with surprising restraint to a power drilling / trail building incident in a wilderness years ago. This isn't your grandpa's federal departments. |
|
|
Cosmic Hotdog wrote: It just sounds like a bunch of boomers complaining about things being different than they’re used to. I understand they’re confused and scared but their arguments aren’t very convincing. |
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: Style is how you choose to climb a route (leading vs following, onsight vs redpoint, etc). Style doesn't affect other people. Ethics involve modifications to the rock that affect other climbers. Adding over a dozen closely-spaced bolts to an iconic old school trad climb without the permission of the FA or any semblance of community support = bad ethics. Intentionally starting a bolt war that will damage the rock and could cause new climbing/bolting restrictions = bad ethics. Using a crappy type of bolt because it's difficult to remove = bad ethics. Using a power drill in a wilderness area where it is illegal to do so = bad ethics. Clipping bolts or trad gear on any of the many other routes with abundant protection, and leaving the route as you found it = fine style and good ethics. Climbers just barely dodged some very harsh restrictions on bolts (and even trad rap anchors!) in wilderness areas a couple of years. People like Erik Sloan increase the risk of similar restrictions in the future. If you want more safely bolted climbs, you should understand that Erik's actions are short-sighted and self-defeating, and will ironically prevent the development of climbs that are better suited to you. Half Dome is within designated wilderness inside a national park, and we are lucky to be able to bolt there at all. Edit: The link above is in reference to the proposed restrictions on climbing from a couple of years ago, not the newer proposed rules that were coincidentally released the day after I made this comment. |
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: You nailed it with the opening "I don't get it..." And that's ok, read and learn |
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: The "confused and scared" insult is rich coming from someone who openly doesn't understand the issue being discussed and finds the route too scary in its current state (it's also too scary for me at the moment haha). People from many different generations have left thoughtful comments here and on the other thread, and you have not engaged with these comments in any meaningful way. I'm a millennial, and I'll be surprised and satisfied if my generation ends up with a legacy anywhere close to that of the boomers. They gave us the counterculture, huge advances in civil rights and environmentalism, rock and roll, the anti-war movement, less restrictive attitudes towards sexuality, nuclear disarmament, and perhaps the most significant and consequential advances in American rock climbing to date. What has yours done? Sorry for thread drift, but I have a weird gripe about the use of "boomer" as a dismissive insult, and I'm hoping someone will return the favor in another 30 years or so when people are using "millennial" in the same way ("They gave us dubstep and memes I guess..."). |
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: Imagine calling Yosemite pioneers "confused and scared" while advocating for a safety blanket on a route that has stood as a masterpiece for over 50 years. Dismissing this as a "boomer" issue proves you completely lack any understanding of climbing history, ethics, or wilderness preservation. This is not about being scared of change, it’s about respecting the minimalist style of the 1971 first ascent. In that time, the runouts have become a defining feature of the route, not a design flaw. If you lack the mental fortitude or the skill to handle the route as it was created, the solution is to train harder or climb something else. You don’t dumb down a historic, world class asset to match your personal comfort level and gym bred expectations. |
|
|
Collin H wrote: It's what they use when they lack the imagination to do anything other than call names. A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds. |
|
|
NateB wrote: I've had great results in hell gate limestone, and lil cottie white granite with steelstick. So have many, many other people. The trick is mixing in with small bits of the same rock you're patching on. Little trick I learned from James Garrett, who's mentorship is exactly why I feel responsible to get up there and help. Not sure who you are, but it's obvious you dunno what you're talking about. |
|
|
As a boomer, I’m not confused and scared regarding changes in climbing. I started climbing with sneakers or leather boots, a length of 1-inch webbing to fashion a swami belt, a couple of biners for rapping, pitons, and belaying by wrapping the rope around my back for friction. Helmet? Really? Belaying gloves? Please. Plastic holds? Who saw that coming in 1971? Climbing is totally different today and orders of magnitudes safer, thanks to modern gear. We don’t need to add bolts to make a climb safer. All old climbs are already safer. |
|
|
Charlie Kissick wrote: Yeah I hear this all the time. “Back in my day the only protection we had was rocks we attached to slings. We used to call them rockslings. Freddie Dickson [some obscure person no one had ever heard of] made them in his garage.” And then you continue talking about the right way to climb “your” route with rockslings. Just because you were there first doesn’t mean you own the rock and we all have to climb it with rockslings now. |
|
|
reading comprehension is at an all time low |
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: Yeah and I hear it all the time: I'm ENTITLED to do every route I want to do IN ABSOLUTE SAFETY. I'm ENTITLED to stick clip the second bolt and still say I led the route because, because I want to have led it even though I'm not mentally strong enough to have really done it. I want to be safe and I'm ENTITLED to it. So all routes have to be dumbed down to my level. Just because you can't step up to the adventure of it; just because you don't have the ability and the mental strength doesn't mean that you own the rock and every route has to be REDUCED to your comfort level. |
|
|
NateB wrote: Ironic |
|
|
People make drama about everything; more and more I understand why route developers and maintainers just say nothing the vast majority of the time. Someone's always gonna complain about something. Steel Stik is all over the Valley and California in general. Maybe sometimes it fails, but I have never had one of my patched holes fail to my knowledge, or any of the others I've seen patched. I am happy to admit that there are probably superior products-- I'll definitely be checking out Ski's recommendation. But to say Steel Stik is totally inadequate is just silly. It works fine. |
|
|
NateB wrote: It depends. The application here is to fill a hole in granite. No critical load bearing involved, no moving parts, no high vibration, etc. So a number of the characterized limits of SteelStik™ Epoxy Putty are vastly excessive: 4000 PSI strength, withstanding 500 PSI water, and temperatures exceeding 350 deg F. More interesting might be whether it is more prone to separation from the granite hole (and so water penetration) due to expansion / contraction from day-to-day heating / cooling compared to other fillers. And for the pro-bolt crowd, these attributes may be helpful when reusing the patched area to install a bolt: drillable, tap-able, machinable. |






