Mountain Project Logo

Half Dome's Snake Dike is being retrobolted - get involved!

Terry E · · San Francisco, CA · Joined Aug 2011 · Points: 43
Tony Danza wrote:

I suggested tar and feathering.

NPS banning Erik Sloan from Yosemite would be a legal solution.

Ricky Harline · · Angel's Camp, CA · Joined Nov 2016 · Points: 147
Ken Trout wrote:

Surprising and fantastic.  5.7 bolted for 5.7 climbers.  Thank you Eric Sloan...and Eric Beck & Co!

I am a 5.7 climber and a committed coward and I swapped leads with a buddy, taking all the odd pitches on Snake Dike. 

If my punter ass is fully able to lead it and didn't desire any additional bolts then uhhhh... Yeah maybe it doesn't need any more bolts. 

Em Cos · · Boulder, CO · Joined Apr 2010 · Points: 5
Li Lin wrote:

I strongly support Erik Sloan’s bolting efforts on Snake Dike.

The argument that “runout and mental pressure are part of the route” should not be used to force unnecessary risk onto everyone else. Your extraordinary experience should not require sacrificing other climbers’ safety. That is like forcing your religious doctrine onto people who do not share your faith.

If you want the original runout experience, you are completely free to skip any bolt you want. Nobody is taking that choice away from you. But removing or opposing protection that could prevent serious injury or death takes that choice away from others.

More bolts give climbers options. They do not force anyone to clip them.

should not be used to force unnecessary risk onto everyone else.

No one is forced to take on the risk of any particular climb, or any climb at all. One could argue that leaving the ground at all is an "unnecessary" risk. We all take these completely "unnecessary" risks to enjoy the sport we love. Everyone will draw the line of how much risk appetite they have in a different place. There's no need to alter every existing climb to meet your arbitrary line. Climb the climbs that meet your needs, and leave the others alone. 

That is like forcing your religious doctrine onto people who do not share your faith.

No, that is like having a place of worship available for those who choose to walk into it, while anyone who does not share your faith can choose not to walk in. 

Andrew Richardson · · Sacramento · Joined Jan 2021 · Points: 1,949

I climbed Snake Dike in my first year of trad climbing. I had yet to successfully redpoint 10a on gear anywhere despite several attempts. I don’t think I’d even sent 5.9 in the valley actually … but I had done CRG classic Dinkum on my fourth try by then though!

Belayed by my first climbing mentor, I led every SD pitch onsight comfortably. I was not good back then (or now), but it was one of the most fun days and greatest adventures I’d had on rock in my burgeoning trad climbing career. It was a perfectly appropriate introduction to runout slab climbing.

I share this only because I know A LOT of people in this thread had a similar experience a month ago, a year ago, or 50 years ago. The cruxes of the route are safe, the runouts casual, and I don’t know if there’s a better 5.7 in the state (maybe Corrugation Corner?) though I’m far from a classics completionist. It is not a death route to the 5.7 climber in any way! 

Eric Craig · · Santa Cruz · Joined Sep 2024 · Points: 5

Hey Andrew, first person I ever heard refer to a pitch or route as casual, was Dale Bard. On quite  few occasions I think. 

Ricky Harline · · Angel's Camp, CA · Joined Nov 2016 · Points: 147
NateB wrote:

This what you're planning on using?  If so - sorry bud - this DQ's you from being the right person for this job.  

Hopefully in the mad rush to be the cool kid who saved Half Dome, the patch job doesn't turn out to be 100x worse than the bolting.  What's needed here is special tooling (not a tuning fork) and experience.  Hopefully everyone can be a little patient until that shows up.  It appears Erik has left a for-real challenge.

What's the problem with steel stick? It's extremely commonly used by route maintainers when patching holes. I've seen maybe four or five different route maintainers (most of them far more prolific are respected than myself) use it on various projects I helped out on not including my own use. 

If you have some knowledge about why it is subpar you want to share with the class? Because I think its usage is as close to status quo as anything gets in the informal route maintainence world. 

P.S. the color of Steel Stick works particularly well on granite 

Dustin Stephens · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jul 2010 · Points: 1,770
Steve Schneider wrote:

This defacement of a classic route is completely unacceptable. I have called Erik twice to give him my take on this rape of half dome.  He is out of hand and completely blowing it. I have just come onto this thread after a 9 day ascent of Atlantic Ocean wall and have not read everything here, but I can tell you that the locals are outraged and ready to try to fix his damage.  Erik Sloan is a rogue and a vandal, and I wish there was a way to talk some sense into him.  

Danger and risk are part of what make rock climbing the soulful and introspective physical and mental grapple that it is.  Some routes are there for those who are ready. Options include getting somebody else to lead it, hiring a guide from YMS, or hiking on to the next route.  There is no argument that is worthy for desecrating such a big time classic.

Thanks for chiming in Shipoopois!

Chris Crump · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Aug 2025 · Points: 0

Who? 

Anti-bolters vs Pro-bolters

When?

July 4th 

What?

Battle Royal 

Where?

White House lawn

Bring your hexes

Glowering · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Oct 2011 · Points: 16
Erik Sloan wrote:

What a great route I"m so excited to see this become a modern classic - and for all the whiners worried that there are not enough runnout slab pitches left in Yosemite don't worry - there are still plenty!

As lame as it is he added so many bolts, his attitude and motivation on display here is perhaps even worse. What a total douche bag.

"I"m so excited to see this become a modern classic" - translation, even though this was already a super classic climb, done by thousands of people. I the great Erik Sloan will make it become a modern classic. You're welcome. Here's where to send your money.

"whiners worried that there are not enough runnout slab pitches left in Yosemite don't worry - there are still plenty!" - translation, even though there are plenty of slab pitches in Yosemite and I could go out and do a first ascent and equip it however I want, people would be fine with it, and actually do something for the community, I'm going to butcher an existing climb thousands of people have climbed and appreciate as it is, and you're a whiner if you don't like it, because I don't have the courage, ability, or vision to do a FA of another line

Stiles · · the Mountains · Joined May 2003 · Points: 845

So, so many words.  Too many words.

Words should be like bolts---as few as possible and all worthwhile

Salamanizer Ski · · Off the Grid… · Joined Sep 2005 · Points: 24,464
Ricky Harline wrote:

What's the problem with steel stick? It's extremely commonly used by route maintainers when patching holes. I've seen maybe four or five different route maintainers (most of them far more prolific are respected than myself) use it on various projects I helped out on not including my own use. 

If you have some knowledge about why it is subpar you want to share with the class? Because I think its usage is as close to status quo as anything gets in the informal route maintainence world. 

P.S. the color of Steel Stick works particularly well on granite 

I don’t like SteelStik. It works ok on basalt, but I don’t think it blends all that well with granite. It fades to a grey blob and doesn’t hold anything in it very well. The good stuff for granite is InstaCrete. On nice white Yosemite/Tahoe granite, you will have a really hard time spotting it so long as you take the time to prep the hole and profile/texture the patch. Using putty sticks is superior to the runny epoxies like AC100. Those can work, but they’re harder to use, the color is off and you have to burn a tip for every patch.

With putty sticks, it’s all in the prep. And that InstaCrete has chunks of black rock in it like concrete, so when it degrades with time, it just looks and blends better.


InstaCrete

Ricky Harline · · Angel's Camp, CA · Joined Nov 2016 · Points: 147
Salamanizer Ski wrote:

I don’t like SteelStik. It works ok on basalt, but I don’t think it blends all that well with granite. It fades to a grey blob and doesn’t hold anything in it very well. The good stuff for granite is InstaCrete. On nice white Yosemite/Tahoe granite, you will have a really hard time spotting it so long as you take the time to prep the hole and profile/texture the patch. Using putty sticks is superior to the runny epoxies like AC100. Those can work, but they’re harder to use, the color is off and you have to burn a tip for every patch.

With putty sticks, it’s all in the prep. And that InstaCrete has chunks of black rock in it like concrete, so when it degrades with time, it just looks and blends better.


InstaCrete

Ski with the real deets again.  Appreciate ya, thanks 

Allen Sanderson · · On the road to perdition · Joined Jul 2007 · Points: 1,100
Salamanizer Ski wrote:

I don’t like SteelStik. It works ok on basalt, but I don’t think it blends all that well with granite. It fades to a grey blob and doesn’t hold anything in it very well. The good stuff for granite is InstaCrete. On nice white Yosemite/Tahoe granite, you will have a really hard time spotting it so long as you take the time to prep the hole and profile/texture the patch. Using putty sticks is superior to the runny epoxies like AC100. Those can work, but they’re harder to use, the color is off and you have to burn a tip for every patch.

With putty sticks, it’s all in the prep. And that InstaCrete has chunks of black rock in it like concrete, so when it degrades with time, it just looks and blends better.


InstaCrete

FWIW in my limited experience in filling holes in granite, once filled I press/pound granite pebbles into the patch. That makes the patch quite hard to see.

Salamanizer Ski · · Off the Grid… · Joined Sep 2005 · Points: 24,464
Allen Sanderson wrote:

FWIW in my limited experience in filling holes in granite, once filled I press/pound granite pebbles into the patch. That makes the patch quite hard to see.

That works sometimes. but what happens when the chunks fall out? I’ve seen a lot of patches where whatever chunk of rock they put over the hole broke loose and left an ugly hole. Really though, it’s all in the prep and application. Patching a hole in rock is like matching the texture of a drywall patch, then matching the paint color from a paint chip and getting it to look seamless. Not a skill everyone has. 

Allen Sanderson · · On the road to perdition · Joined Jul 2007 · Points: 1,100
Salamanizer Ski wrote:

That works sometimes. but what happens when the chunks fall out? I’ve seen a lot of patches where whatever chunk of rock they put over the hole broke loose and left an ugly hole. Really though, it’s all in the prep and application. Patching a hole in rock is like matching the texture of a drywall patch, then matching the paint color from a paint chip and getting it to look seamless. Not a skill everyone has.

They don't if mixed in with the patch material. That is they are not just a "top" coating but integral to the patch material. But as you note it’s all in the prep and application and not a skill everyone has.

woodhead · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Feb 2016 · Points: 85

I really like Snake Dike and personally think historic routes like this should be preserved as close to their original character as possible.

From Yosemite climbing regulations:
https://www.nps.gov/yose/planyourvisit/climbing_regulations.htm
“Drilling protection bolts for climbing is permitted in Yosemite as long as it is done by hand. Motorized power drills are prohibited.”

Based on that, I’ve sent a message to Yosemite National Park Climbing Management asking them to look into the recent bolt additions and whether they comply with the park’s policy.

If I hear back from NPS, I’ll share any relevant response here.

 

Peter Williams · · San Francisco, CA · Joined Jan 2016 · Points: 0

What an asshat.

A big part of the reason a lot of us climb is to experience risk. Snake Dike is a popular mega-classic BECAUSE it involves risk. Until the bolts are removed, Sloan ruined that.

There's sport climbing areas, laser tag arenas and Minecraft for people who don't like risk. Removing all risk from a classic trad route defeats the purpose.

I wondered for a while why someone whose livelihood depends on climbers would pull such a douchebag move but then I figured out the answer:

He's an asshat.

LucasSpiegel · · Castle Rock, CO · Joined May 2010 · Points: 850

Who is this ENTITLED CLOWN that thinks he can grid bolt an all time classic like Snake Dike? What a tool

Stiles · · the Mountains · Joined May 2003 · Points: 845
woodhead wrote:

Based on that, I’ve sent a message to Yosemite National Park Climbing Management

If I hear back from NPS, I’ll share any relevant response here.

Ooohh, bringing the Man into our petty squables.  I'd say any response is a highly relevant response.  Please do share all that the Goverment has to say.  

Something we dont need is more oversight and regulation from an overworked administrative staff. 

One way to wrangle Sloan, which will entangle wrangling us ALL.   

Charlie Kissick · · Unknown Hometown · Joined May 2023 · Points: 0
Glowering wrote:

As lame as it is he added so many bolts, his attitude and motivation on display here is perhaps even worse. What a total douche bag.

"I"m so excited to see this become a modern classic" - translation, even though this was already a super classic climb, done by thousands of people. I the great Erik Sloan will make it become a modern classic. You're welcome. Here's where to send your money.

"whiners worried that there are not enough runnout slab pitches left in Yosemite don't worry - there are still plenty!" - translation, even though there are plenty of slab pitches in Yosemite and I could go out and do a first ascent and equip it however I want, people would be fine with it, and actually do something for the community, I'm going to butcher an existing climb thousands of people have climbed and appreciate as it is, and you're a whiner if you don't like it, because I don't have the courage, ability, or vision to do a FA of another line

This is what really gets me. It would be one thing to do it secretly then slink away. Or another to do it and sheepishly say “sorry” like Bluto after smashing a guitar. But to shout out from the mountain top like some sort of savior is a shocking example of someone who is completely oblivious or, more likely, sociopathicly uncaring of what anyone else thinks. 

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

Northern California
Post a Reply to "Half Dome's Snake Dike is being retrobolted - g…"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.