Mountain Project Logo

Bolting cracks at Red Wing in MN

Original Post
Luke Streich · · Bend OR · Joined Mar 2019 · Points: 0

Greetings internet hive mind,

There have been a couple easy cracks bolted recently at Barn Bluff in Red Wing MN - Barney Rubble and Forearm Smash. I don't know who bolted them, and this isn't an indictment of that person or persons. Barn Bluff is basically a limestone sport crag, and there are few bolted easy routes on the south side of the bluff. These two lines seem to fill that gap.

There have been cycles of bolting and chopping on the cracks at RW before. The crack lines are often chossy and dirty, but having cleaned up a couple of them recently, I think that's because all of RW is chossy and dirty. It's just that no one takes the time to clean these particular routes. They actually climb pretty well, and with modern gear the protection is fine. My vote is to leave this stuff unbolted. This preserves a fun experience for those of us who want it, and encourages just a little bit of boldness. 

Btw, if we're wanting to preserve/improve the RW experience, a dremel tool to restore some friction on the super glassy feet on climbs like Sleeping Bat might be in order. It would do at least as much good as more bolts.

Tyson Ferryman · · Bailey, CO · Joined Oct 2006 · Points: 573

Agree with not bolting cracks that have good gear.

Although, I do find it personally annoying to have “mixed” routes that require only a piece or two of gear at predominantly sport crags. Just put in another bolt. Or two.

On that note, IMO what would be better at RW would be for some bolts to be added to some of the contrived run outs on some routes. The rock at RW is choss and we are all heavily relying on holds not breaking and the existing bolts to keep us off of the ground. A couple of additional bolts here and there would alleviate some of this. Others, I’m sure, will disagree and say that the first ascensionists have installed the perfect number of bolts in the perfect locations on all of the routes there; I get it. On that note, in general it seems the climbing community gives first ascensionists waaaay too much “authority” and “ownership” to “mess up” a route as they see fit and I guess the community is stuck with their dictatorial will for all of time?! Seems silly. It is a community owned resource after all, it seems like the community should have some say in how routes are developed and modified in the interest of safety and sustainability. Flame on!

Tyson Ferryman · · Bailey, CO · Joined Oct 2006 · Points: 573

More of the same:


https://www.mountainproject.com/route/105824533/relentless

Prolly won’t last too long; get it while it’s hot. 🤣

Gavin Purcell · · Minneapolis, MN · Joined Nov 2015 · Points: 1,068

Forearm Smash, I wish whoever chopped it had left one or two bolts in the bad section.

Relentless already had a few bolts close enough to clip and the direct finish without any would be 5.12 climbing above small gear in limestone.

Bolting Barney Rubble also completes Pretty in Pink adding two more moderates to the Winter Wall. The top of Barney Rubble could have been left unbolted, but why.

Eric Stone · · Minneapolis, MN · Joined Jul 2019 · Points: 865

My vote is to open all routes for bolting at Red Wing. I've led a few of the routes out there on gear only and having bolts there wouldn't have changed the experience for me. In fact, there were bolts on some of the routes I led gear only. It's a quarried limestone sport crag. Also, I support doing a little manufacturing to reduce the glaze, glimmer and gloss on the polished climbs. That's very likely a minority opinion we share and not something I'd spend any time doing myself. 

wisam · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jan 2012 · Points: 60

I’d vote to add a few bolts to the runouts on the sport routes instead.


would have totally support adding supplemental gear to the trad routes with bad gear.  Forearm smash mostly protected well but I’d be ok with a bolt or 2 in the middle where the rock was bad.


haven’t done relentless but if the gear is bad as the description says then I’m ok with the bolts there. 

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

Midwest
Post a Reply to "Bolting cracks at Red Wing in MN"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.