Mountain Project Logo

Walkie Talkies Have Ruined Climbing for Me

Eric Craig · · Santa Cruz · Joined Sep 2024 · Points: 5
John Tuttle wrote:

"Old man shakes fist at Cloud".

Are you making fun of me?

It's ok if you are. A good day for it in fact.

Chris White · · Boulder · Joined Mar 2006 · Points: 15

When the rope comes tight, start climbing.

Walkie Talkies are dumb. 

Dan D · · Colorado · Joined May 2021 · Points: 17

I climb based on vibes.

Good vibes? Climb 

Bad vibes? Take

Medium vibes? Watch the climber 

Spooky vibes? Take off belay 

Etc

Bill Lawry · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Apr 2006 · Points: 1,914

The second to last radio-climbing experience I had:

We'd finished P2 of Purblind Pillar and my partner was leading the third.  The leader of the pair behind us made his way to the ledge, anchors in, and quietly - almost a whisper - calls on the radio "off belay".  Made me a little embarrassed about having yelled at that same point "Off Belay!" 

We continue up the climb, unexpectedly creating distance between us and the party behind us.  Not a flex there - we are not fast.

After the descent and picking up our dropped packs, we can hear that party on the last pitch of the route yelling back and forth - loudly.  For whatever reason, the radios weren't working.  I've experience this the last time I used radio where anchoring back in an alcove made the radios almost useless. Or maybe dead battery.  Or dropped radio.

Radios are great if used in a reasonable way.  Just be prepared to communicate or intuit without them.  Whatever it is, it will happen. 

Stiles · · the Mountains · Joined May 2003 · Points: 845

Theyre a tool.  Like a PLB.  Can be abused.  Can be used wrong.  Can be useful.  Can be a crutch that gets pulled from underfoot.  Another piece of phaff to add to the kit.    

Kindly be conscious of not allowing your experience to impact my experience, eh :D  

And l shall conscientiously perform the same kindness, Brothers and Sisters of the Rope

Jason · · Hillsboro, OR · Joined Sep 2012 · Points: 15

I love how this whole thread is about being annoyed at overhearing someone's conversation at the crag. We should all just recreate in total silence

Stiles · · the Mountains · Joined May 2003 · Points: 845
Jason wrote:

I love how this whole thread is about being annoyed at overhearing someone's conversation at the crag. We should all just recreate in total silence

Hear, hear!!

Cherokee Nunes · · Unknown Hometown · Joined May 2015 · Points: 0

 I love how this whole thread is about being annoyed at overhearing someone's conversation at the crag. We should all just recreate in total silence

Right, stfu!   

Caleb · · Arboreal Alpine Villager · Joined Jun 2013 · Points: 290

We’re all entitled to leave a climbing area and avoid other climbers, but some folks are really piling on the bad vibes.

There’s a lot of annoying things people do at crags.  But my experience isn’t sacrosanct.  Sometimes I need to pet the crag dogs, chill with the babies, listen to the crag speakers, and maybe take some beta from a stranger.  There are good parts to all those things.  

Ease off on the petty grievances.  That’s the spirit of selfishness at the route of your own complaints.  It just ruins it more.

Mike-Mayhem · · North Bend, WA · Joined Sep 2015 · Points: 70
Caleb wrote:

We’re all entitled to leave a climbing area and avoid other climbers, but some folks are really piling on the bad vibes.

There’s a lot of annoying things people do at crags.  But my experience isn’t sacrosanct.  Sometimes I need to pet the crag dogs, chill with the babies, listen to the crag speakers, and maybe take some beta from a stranger.  There are good parts to all those things.  

Ease off on the petty grievances.  That’s the spirit of selfishness at the route of your own complaints.  It just ruins it more.

This is the attitude that has ruined climbing for me! This activity was built on petty grievances!!!

Marc801 C · · Sandy, Utah · Joined Feb 2014 · Points: 65
James Harvey wrote:

After 34+ years of climbing you will rarely find me climbing near ANYONE anymore.

Except for my wife. 

And if we are cragging alone and someone shows up, that’s usually our exit cue. There is NO safety in numbers at the crag.

Someone climbing our intended route? Plenty of others to choose from elsewhere. Or we should have been there sooner.

Rocky-talkies don’t bother me as much as people do.

You must be fun at parties. 

TJ Bindseil · · Lakewood, CO · Joined Apr 2020 · Points: 15
Caleb wrote:

We’re all entitled to leave a climbing area and avoid other climbers, but some folks are really piling on the bad vibes.

There’s a lot of annoying things people do at crags.  But my experience isn’t sacrosanct.  Sometimes I need to pet the crag dogs, chill with the babies, listen to the crag speakers, and maybe take some beta from a stranger.  There are good parts to all those things.  

Ease off on the petty grievances.  That’s the spirit of selfishness at the route of your own complaints.  It just ruins it more.

Best post here.  If I’m on these forums too much I forget how awesome it is to be out climbing.  Climb on my friends 

apogee · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 0

Contrarian views for the sake of being contrary are annoying AF. However, contrarianism (as a term) is too often applied to any view that steps outside of the so-called 'conventional wisdom'. C'est la vie.

rgold · · Poughkeepsie, NY · Joined Feb 2008 · Points: 526

I have Rockie Talkies and use them at the Gunks as well as other places.  Between all the channels and the privacy codes, I have never once had someone else on my system.  I think a lot of folks use the out-of-the-box, and so they all end up on the default channel with no privacy codes activated.  No surprise you're getting crosstalk under those circumstances.

I spent many years heaping scorn on radios for climbing. Then karma caught up with me--my hearing deteriorated in my seventies, and I now need hearing aids. But hearing aids are very expensive, and I'm not going to wear them when climbing, so radios it is. Now that I'm using them, I have to grudgingly admit that they are really quite useful for a host of circumstances. Yeah, I used to belong to the "when the rope comes tight, start climbing" school of minimalism. Been there and done that, and it works most of the time. But even in relatively pleasant conditions, the ability to say something like "the stopper with red tape is fixed; don't bother trying to get it out" can be a time-saver. And once the conditions are no longer pleasant, radios make an enormous difference in supporting a safe and efficient outcome. This can be true on the approach and descent as well, when the party sometimes gets separated. That said, you'd better have your no-radio game on too, because the things might fail when you need them most.

Of course, once you put a tool in people's hands, there will always be folks who make you wish the tool had never been invented. Climbing in many areas is now a crowded activity, partially frequented by an urban demographic that arrives with a sporting-arena mentality.  It would be nice if people were thoughtful about how their behavior intrudes on others' experience, but that just doesn't seem to be the way humans are built, otherwise we wouldn't have dog poop bags left all over the trails. In any case, those who are hoping, increasingly in vain, for peace, quiet, and solitude are probably a dwindling minority, subject to "oid guys shaking their hands at clouds" derision while the party rages on.

Mark D · · Lakewood, CO · Joined Apr 2012 · Points: 45

I love it when rgold chimes in on threads with his wisdom. Walkie Talkies are great, and I can't be convinced otherwise.

Salamanizer Ski · · Off the Grid… · Joined Sep 2005 · Points: 24,464

I have solved the annoying radio problem by;

1. Climbing where other people “don’t”.

And I have been able to successfully mitigate all the other problems you encounter in climbing by;

2. Climbing where other people “won’t”! 

Eric Craig · · Santa Cruz · Joined Sep 2024 · Points: 5
Salamanizer Ski wrote:

I have solved the annoying radio problem by;

1. Climbing where other people “don’t”.

And I have been able to successfully mitigate all the other problems you encounter in climbing by;

2. Climbing where other people “won’t”! 

👍👍

I haven't experienced any annoyance from other people's use of walkie talkies. Maybe when/if my hearing deteriorates I will adopt them. Until then it's just another thing to interfere with the climbing experience. 

Edit added: I only have very vague recollections of not having radios being an issue, so it would seem the issues were solved with out that much difficulty. I actually can't remember any specifics whatsoever about any such event. It isn't that hard. Lucky? No doubt that's part of it, but your luck improves drastically when you stack the odds in your favor. But I get it. I get why.

Daniel Joder · · Barcelona, ES · Joined Nov 2015 · Points: 0

I identify with pretty much everything rgold said above, in both his before WT (walkie talkie) experience and the after WT. It might have been mentioned above, but you can turn off the annoying beep and also set the volume at an appropriate level—two things that will make you slightly more stealth and less annoying to anyone around you.

WTs sure would have saved us some time one day with my 80-year-young climbing partner. It was cold and windy and I was belaying him from above. He was moving awfully slowly up a short bolted aid section so I assumed he needed a physical boost… I then proudly rigged up a 3:1 and was pulling hard. However, I was actually severely hindering his progress since it made it super difficult to unclip the draws from the bolts with the rope so tight against the rock (and his somewhat arthritic fingers)… a radio call would have solved the issue in a second. 

rgold · · Poughkeepsie, NY · Joined Feb 2008 · Points: 526

I've been in a host of situations before radios that were unpleasant, very time-consuming, and in some cases, dangerous, where radios would have completely solved the problem. Did we manage without radios? You bet.  Would have been better off with radios? Roger that.

Collin H · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jun 2020 · Points: 141

Here’s another example. I was following the East Buttress of Whitney, and my partner asked if I was at a good stance and could stop for a minute. I let him know that I was. Apparently, the belayer for the party above us (who he was sharing a ledge with) suddenly began feeling the altitude, got pale, said “I feel like I’m going to pass out”, sat down, and let got of the brake. So after checking with me, my partner tied off my belay and took over theirs. The leader for the other party was out of earshot and no one had radios, so they had no idea what was happening.

We got by just fine without radios, but it was by luck that I happened to be within easy earshot on a windless day, and radios still would have reduced the volume of our exchange. And if the other party had radios, the belayer could have told their leader to get to a stance and/or go direct to a piece and tied off the belay when she began feeling unwell, or my partner could have radioed that for her (of course she still should have tied him off before sitting down, but I think she tried to power through it until she no longer had the mental presence to respond appropriately).

I’m not sure how rope tugs could have been used to communicate that situation for either of our two parties. Of course I wouldn’t have kept climbing if slack wasn’t being taken in, but I’m guessing my partner wouldn’t have wanted to tie me off and take over for the other party without being able to make sure I was at least aware of that. His ability to communicate allowed him to respond quickly and confidently. I still feel fine climbing without radios, but unusual situations do sometimes arise, and radios are great when they do.

Also, if the OP’s premise is that radios are ruining climbing, that would indicate they don’t use radios, so they shouldn’t be bothered by radio traffic using up channels, only by the sounds of other people using radios. I don’t think I’ve heard a radio unless I’m within a pitch of someone, and when I have, it’s been pretty unobtrusive. I have frequently heard yelling by parties who are struggling to communicate about stuck rope/pieces or other things that fall outside what is easily communicated by rope tugs and not as simple as on/off belay.

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

General Climbing
Post a Reply to "Walkie Talkies Have Ruined Climbing for Me"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.