Continue with onX Maps
Sign in with Facebook
Draws for trad and sport
|
I’ve been accumulating gear to begin sport and trad climbing in the Southeast (but haven’t had a chance to climb up there as I’m coming from Florida), and I have most of the trad pro I think will be necessary. The main thing I am missing for both disciplines are draws, and I’ve been looking to find a middle ground that would allow me to begin climbing both sport and trad, but I am more interested in trad at this time. I’m currently under the impression that 12 QuickDraws and 4 alpine draws would be a good place to start, but I am concerned that 4 would not be enough alpine draws if routes were meandering, but I don’t really know what climbing in the Southeast tends to be like. I’ve been looking at budget wiregate draws like the BD Hotwire or CAMP Orbit Wire, but am unsure if the dog ones would be long and flexible enough to be decent for trad. A lot I’ve seen for trad says to just go for all alpine draws, but that seems like that would be a large sacrifice for sport climbing. Sorry if there has been a thread like this, I tried looking around but couldn’t find anything that really came to a conclusion. |
|
Sport climbing on alpine draws isn't terrible. The main issue with quick draws for trad on not super wandery routes is weight, so those skinny dyneema draws can double on both a sport and trad racks. Plus if the dogbone is sufficiently long and skinny it doesn't let you backflip as it'll twist itself to oppose the direction of motion. How many you need really just depends on how long the pitches are. |
|
It's just two carabineers connected with some webbing. Don't overthink it. It's always a tradeoff between ease of use, like bigger crabs for easier clipping, beefier dog bones that are easy to pull up on and last longer, and weight. I would say that sport climbing on alpine draws actually sucks more than using "sport" quick draws for trad climbing. They are a pain to clip, the carabineers flip over, they can get tangled on your harness when you have too many of them. Half the time I see people sport climbing on them they are an absolute gong show. The southeast has so much great sport climbing so don't discount actually sport climbing. What I would do is buy 12 cheap wire gate draws (honestle the BD hotwires are actually pretty nice) and the 4 alpines, and if you find you need more alpines just buy 4 more slings and swap the carabineers out from the quick draws when you go sport climbing. I have sport climbing draws (DMM alpha sport) and trad climbing draws (DMM alpha trad) among about 60 other draws that my wife and I have accumulated over the years and while it's nice to have bougie 30$ draws for specific endeavors, it is wholly unnecessary and me just being a gear whore. |
Alexandre Passoswrote: What would be a generally good dogbone length to look for in a skinny dyneema quickdraw like to mentioned? |
|
For trad climbing, I’d recommend having at least 6 alpine draws. For regular draws, I’d suggest a dogbone that is somewhat substantial for sport routes but also relatively light for trad routes coupled with a carabiner that is light and clips easily. The quickdraw that ticks these boxes for me is the Petzl Finesse dogbone coupled w/ Petzl Spirit carabiners. If you don’t want to buy dogbones and carabiners separately or want to save more weight, the Petzl Ange Finesse quickdraws are good, but I prefer the action of the Spirit carabiners, which are almost as light as the Ange L. https://hownot2.com/products/spirit?srsltid=AfmBOooafsk-PA9VJSENACa9r__xOOJstWjqYN9Rl1PDvUOAxiH0BCcr |
Connor Dobsonwrote: Thanks for pointing out the idea of switching dog bones for slings, I hadn’t thought about that. I’ll get the hotwires in that case. |
|
Connor's comment is on point. As someone that really just got into everything in the past year or two - I use a mix of quickdraws and alpine draws on trad routes and don't sweat the weight too much (it's very minor for single pitch or low multis). For carabiners - buy a few different types and just try to exercise them building anchors/clipping practice etc. - I ended up switching out a bunch of mine for Dyons as I liked the action better. There's a lot of good 'biners out there, but find the one you like before building up your rack. Also for me, I went full size on most things as it just makes everything easier as I sort through how I actually want to do my gear. The biggest thing to remember is that the right draws/'biners won't make you climb harder, it will just reduce annoyance, rope drag and logistical difficulties. |
|
I climb primarily trad multi pitch and alpine, and 4 alpine draws wouldn't be nearly enough. I tend to carry 12+ alpines for what I do and a couple 120cm draws too but that's more niche. If you're doing single pitch trad, you can get away with closer to 6 alpines and supplement the rest with sport draws. For hard single pitch trad (Jtree) I usually carry some mix of sport draws, 30cm draws, and alpine draws, leaning most heavy towards the sport draws unless the route wanders a bunch. A decent middle ground is to use long dogbones (I have 6x 30cm Cypher brand dyneema dogbones that are a nice balance between sport and alpine length. I think it was Fritz maybe who posted that he does this and I borrowed his idea. Just to give you more options. Really it comes down to what you're climbing most often and what you find your most frequent needs are. It's hard for us to tell you what you should do because it's your needs that will dictate it, and those needs will likely evolve over time. |
|
I would advise against using stiff draws on trad routes until you have a good bit of experience. Also: even super-floppy “trad” draws are still less floppy than an alpine draw and frequently shorter than ideal. The only routes that don’t wander are continuous vertical cracks. And even on a continuous vertical crack your belay loop frequently winds up 18” or more on one side or the other of the gear. Once you have more experience you will be able to ration your alpine draws over a full pitch but when you are just starting out you’ll save mental bandwidth by having all alpine draws. |
|
If having a stiffer dogbone is making your gear walk or pop out it was either: A. Not enough extension B. You suck at placing gear It's usually B |
|
I think you will be happier with a few more alpines (6-8 total). One or two should be double length. Not really that relevant here, but it’s a pet peeve of mine when people over-use draws on trad gear. Cams have their own sling and it’s often plenty! Also, most partners will have some draws to contribute. Don’t worry if your rack isn’t fat. |
Connor Dobsonwrote: Exactly. :-) |
|
I generally use 10 floppy longish spectra quckdraws and 5 alpine draws for trad climbing. I rarely sport climb but the quick draws work ok for sport climbing. If my mix of climbing included more sport climbing I would shorten and stiffen the quickdraws some. The vast majority of climbers over extend their gear placements. Generally beginner and intermediate trad climbers extend every piece with an alpine draw which does little more than lengthen the distance of a fall. If you pay attention to the rope path and where the next piece of gear will likely go you will often need no extension or a quick draw will suffice especially with cams. Nuts require some extension but a quick draw will often suffice. It is enlightening to look back at a pitch and notice which pieces actually needed the extension. |
|
I have a bunch of the Mammut sender draws. They have either wire gate or solid gate. The 12cm ones are stiff enough for easy sport clipping, and the 17cm ones are floppy enough to not wiggle your placements around. The only bummer is the carabiners are kinda small so your clipping technique has to be dialed if you have big hands. |
|
Generally speaking, I have a couple of longer draws and shorter ones that are typically manufactured draws- think Petzl Ange and WC Helium carabiners with a strong, lightweight dogbone. I used these primarily for quick passive placements that don't need to be extended. I also carry 6-8 extendable dyneema runners for placements that need to be extended (depending on the pitch/objective, I may have more or less of these, but this is my go-to setup). My approach is entirely unnecessary; it's just what I've grown accustomed to. You could probably do all quickdraws, or all extendable runners. The longer you do it, the more you'll work out a system that is best for you- the key is knowing and trying different options to make that determination. |
