Dog rant
|
|
Bruno Schull wrote: I'm with you about the macho posturing BS but you seem to be stuck in your own little bubble about this issue. I'm a big doggie lover and it sounds like I'd love yours, my wife however was the victim of a very serious dog attack/mauling as a child she still bears both the mental and physical scars. She loves dogs she knows but is (I hope undersandably) very wary of strange dogs. So 'She may run over to you and put her paws on your legs and jump up' is a very frightning thing for her and plenty of others. She's isn't psycic so 'for kissed and cuddles' isn't much help nor is 'you can put out your hand and tell her to sit, and she will'. Maybe a bit of empathy for why some people have a fear or discomfort around dogs wouldn't go amiss. In 2007 (my quick google didn't find more recent) in Switzerland there were 4,291 dog attacks reported, of which 2,678 were on humans. |
|
|
That's reasonable, Neil. Despite my own posturing, I am drawing some some insight about my own behavior from this thread. Nonetheless, I do have trouble identifying with what seems to me like hype about aggresive dogs. Of course, I am aware that dogs bite humans. But I am 50 years old, and I've been a dog lover since I was old enough to remember anything. I saw hello to almost all/most dogs when appropriate, probably to the extent that I become a nuisance to dog owners that just want to go about their day without some weird guy showering love on their dog. In all that time, I've never been bitten, or come close to being bitten. You have to be carefull. Some dogs give a low, tight growl when approached, or they have that ears down silent tension, and then you just stay away. I've also never seen a dog attack a human. Yes, I know, I'm extrapolating from my own experience (N=1) to the world, and ignoring the obvious facts, but something doesn't add up in my mind. Where are all these vicious dogs? Here in Switzerland, all children go through a swim training program. It's fun--they learn how to swim in school. Then, when they are older, they practice with full clothes, shoes, boots, and so on, and you realize that it's a safety thing--they are trying to teach children to survive in water immersion accidents. They do something similar with dogs and dog safety--they teach children how to approach and interact with dogs. I think more of that is needed. Basically, as you can tel from my posts, I think dogs are a n atural part of life, and learningb how to deal with them reasonably and responsably should be part of growing up. In any interaction between dog and human there are two sides--and it's not always the fact that the dog is unlashed that is the problem. By the way, lest folks pass off my rambling as the naive views of a Swiss person, I'm American, grew up in NYC in the 1980's, lived in California for decades, and worked summers in the Rocky Mountains for many years. Once again...never saw a dog attack a human! |
|
|
Bruno Schull wrote: Swiss dogs don't dig? And you only have wildlife in a particular season? Domestic dogs are visitors to these landscapes, as are we. It isn't fair to expect dogs to not be dogs, so they need to be leashed. Besides, that's the best practice to keep land managers happy, anyway. Otherwise, it can then become an access issue. Your off leash dog could, at the very least, help lead to the easy course of action. Zero dogs allowed. Or closed areas. That's far less bother than hiring extra rangers to waste time telling 10,000 visitors to leash their dogs. The latter is, as a couple others mentioned, the case at City of Rocks. More dogs off leash than on, and, since it's climbers, that means all over the park, not just in campgrounds. Although dogs in campsites are another set of issues. Especially if they aren't your dogs. The former may sound unlikely, but think about bird closures. Here, our local stuff is adjacent to, or part of, Wildlife Management Areas, and definitely sensitive. Bringing dogs at all can be an issue, in some areas at least. Last, unless you are on private land, public land is public land. It's not your personal backyard dog park. Gone are the days when these lands were do anything you want, whenever you want, however you want. All that said, I often have dog treats along on my climbing trips, and have lots of doggo friends. They can be great fun, for sure! Best, Helen |
|
|
Adam Burch wrote: FTFY, TLDR My favorite is the dumb ass off leash labradoodles who approach my leashed trash hound. The usual result is the doodle running away quickly with missing hair. I usually will say the entitlement grows with the amount of money they pay for the dog. |
|
|
@ Adam--thanks for the detailed response. That all makes sense to me, especially the part about big cats. Mountain lions are scary!!! I haven't lived in the US for maybe 25 years? It's hard for me to believe that places are worse than NYC was in the 1980's but the stories of dog bites and homeless baby snatching make me wonder! Often, I feel incredibly lucky to have built a life outside the US, but I do miss the open space and wilderness areas...there's nothing really like that in Europe. One point: You wrote: "If you and your dog were someplace where a leash was legally required, and it approach my kids without my permission, it would be pepper sprayed." OK, I can understand that. As I wrote above, when and where there are leash laws, my dog is leashed; it's simple! But where I live, in the city, in the forest, in the fields, in the mountains, and at the crags, there is no law that dogs must be on a leash, except for a period in the spring to early season when there are smaller breeding animals with young. So, not to be confrontational, and just as a matter of abstract internet debate, I wonder how you would react here: You're walking with your wife and kids on a forest path frequented by hikers, joggers, bikers, horseback riders, and so on. A young and energetic black lab comes bounding up to your kids, wanting to play. There are no leash laws--the owner is not obliged to put their dog on a leash, and when you go outside you assume the risk that a dog may approach you and your family. Would you mace a dog in that situation? I'm going to guess the answer is no. Here in Switzerland, unless you could prove that the dog was a threat, you would be breaking the law, and you would receive a steep fine. To be clear, if a dog does bite a human, the owner is resonsable, unless it can be proven that the dog was antagonized. So that makes it all more complicated. Despite my larger-than-life pro-dog stance, I hope it's clear that I would and do follow the law--if the law is that dogs shopuld be leashed, then my dog is on a leash. I think the more interesting debate begins when there are no laws...just a bunch of people with different ideras about right and wrong trying to figure out how to behave in an open society. All best, and post up some more pics of knife work: I'm particulalry interested in the interface between steel and wood--how can you make that durable and long lasting? Is it a question of tolerances? Good adhesives? Fixtures like rivets? I've always wondered. |
|
|
Bruno Schull wrote: Dude this ain't swizzy. This is murrica. You barely have to explain lethal self defense against a human let alone a dog. If a dog gets into your personal space you can treat it exactly you would a human that gets that close to you. Edit: not saying I agree with the state of affairs, just pointing out differences |
|
|
Bruno Schull wrote: Oh obviously he's not a knife-brandishing maniac. People who pretend to be knife-brandishing maniacs on the internet because they think it makes them seem cool, are way more common than actual knife-brandishing maniacs. That's what I meant when I called him an "internet tough guy". Case in point:
The posturing continues. If you actually were starting fights in front of your kids that would make you a terrible parent. But of course the likely reality is that you haven't done this and never will. Real men de-escalate. |
|
|
I think the anti dog view of the average mountain project user has been well established by the amount of dog rants and PSA posted. But based on the amount of dogs I still see out and about in forests and crags, I don’t think the heavily thumbed up agreements of a forum rant are swaying the public very far. Other than the national parks it seems like team dog has won, and there’s nothing dog dislikers can do about it. I vote if you hate dogs then stay in the gym (or national parks). The outdoors has to many wildcards around and you don’t want to be caught out of your comfort zone. |
|
|
Bruno Schull wrote: You are unwilling to control your animal despite the apparent and justified fear of others. And your reaction to their reasonable request to control your animal is basically "go fuck yourself." And if they were to take measures to defend themselves from your uncontrolled animal you would "defend her absolutely." Here is the States that is either going to get you shot or a murder charge depending on how it plays out. Switzerland has a gun culture of its own so I wonder if this is really how you roll. |
|
|
Locker wrote: If you don't stab a dog in front of your children are you even a parent!!? |
|
|
Todd Berlier wrote:
|
|
|
Todd Berlier wrote: He puts it more eloquently than me |
|
|
Merl Berry wrote: MP represents only a small fraction of climbers and a minuscule fraction of "the public". IOW, it's really hard to draw any conclusions from these repetitive threads.
Have you missed the point that it's not dislike of or hating dogs? It's the owners who have let them behave inappropriately or don't recognize where they shouldn't take their specific dog that is the issue. |
|
|
Bruno Schull wrote: He does, erry day, thanks to certain generous MPers who ship me surprise gifts like these from across the Atlantic! |
|
|
Adam Burch wrote: I'm not objecting to your use of violence to defend your children when they're attacked. If anything, I'd be fine with MORE violence IN THE CASE OF AN ACTUAL ATTACK. If a dog is attacking a child, shooting the dog with a gun is entirely justified, and probably more effective than anything you've described. But in no post have you actually described a dog attack, you've just described yourself using weapons inappropriately in situations where they are completely unwarranted. You're changing your story to be about defending children, when it has never been about that. It has always been about you pretending to be tough to impress strangers on the internet. In your first post, you said,
And then you made it clear with pictorial evidence that "these two" refers to pepper spray and a knife. In this context, I don't think it's unreasonable to assume that "show them what I have" means... you brandish a knife and pepper spray at the person. In that post you did not describe a dog attacking your child. You literally just described yourself "typically" brandishing a knife at someone. Keeping in mind that no dog attack has occurred, you don't have to show a knife, or have a conversation with the dog owner. If you believe your children are in danger, YOU CAN JUST LEAVE. You know, like a person who is trying to protect their kids, instead of show how tough they are. You tried to clarify in another post:
But then you said:
You realize that IS threatening dog owners with weapons? Again, no dog attack has occurred yet. You can just leave, which is a lot safer for your children. You're escalating the situation. This is putting your children in more danger, not less. Don't pretend this is about keeping your kids safe: this is about you feeling like a big boy. I don't think you know the law very well, either. You said:
The law on brandishing says, "draws or exhibits any deadly weapon", meaning that a knife on the hip can be considered brandished if it's shown to the other person. Source. Your words were "show them what I have" which certainly seems like you're "exhibiting" the weapon.
There isn't a tone of voice that makes "Look at this knife, I'm gonna stab your dog with it" appropriate. Again, if you feel your children are in danger, you don't need to talk to anyone. You can just take your children and leave. Starting a fight with a dog owner doesn't make them safer.
Oh. My. God. You're literally trying to pretend you have special forces skills right now because you climbed with some special forces guys? Internet tough guy gold right here. |
|
|
Does anybody remember the story about the birder in NYC and the "Melania" who called the police to say that she felt threatened by him when he asked her to put her dog on a leash? (I'm changing the convention of "Karen" to "Melania" for the reasons mentioned up-thread). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_Park_birdwatching_incident That story is crazy, not only because the accuser/victim share the same last name, but because of the intersecting narratives of race, class, sexuality, privalege, and so forth. The white, affluent women faced very serious consequences for her behavior; the black, gay male birder became something of a celebrity. I want to say he has a netflix show or a documentary or something? I like his tactics to deal with off-leash dogs in places where leashes are mandated by law: he doesn't carry a "big stick" so to speak, he just carrys a big bag of doggie treats. Most dog owners don't like the idea of strangers feeding their dogs, and so his tactic is to explain to irresponsable dog owners that, if they don't leash their dogs, he wil feed them treats. The dog owners get frustrated and angry, and the dogs get treats. It's a win win!
|
|
|
Bruno Schull wrote: Haha I remember that story. I didn’t realize they have the same last name. Not sure that tactic would work on more sane people. Sorry, it’s Karen forever and always. If I felt like I had to bring my dogs climbing, it’d be far away from people. And they’d probably still annoy the shit out of me. But I don’t feel like that. So I don’t bring my dogs. |
|
|
awesome sight yesterday. Guide brings his dog to the crag while working. (sop for this guide) She is super gentle but also really smart and completely bored with dad working. Naturally she wanders off and gets in other peoples business. Eventually a bunch of hikers get all bent out of shape over what they perceive as a lost dog at a dangerous overlook. meanwhile the guide is 100% clueless that he is teaching his clients to bring unleashed dogs climbing.... |
|
|
Adam Burch wrote: I wasn't trained by special forces to threaten people with knives like you. So I have to use my words. |
|
|
Most of this thread: https://youtu.be/LQCU36pkH7c |





