Mountain Project Logo

Dog rant

Cherokee Nunes · · Unknown Hometown · Joined May 2015 · Points: 0

Anything that would be sufficient to put a city dwelling Californian at ease between March ‘20 and say October ‘21.

City? Lol. Nice try.

csproul · · Pittsboro...sort of, NC · Joined Dec 2009 · Points: 330
grug g wrote:

No dogs no dogs no dogs. They are hated, they are not welcome. They may be your emotional crutch because you suck at human interactions but the rest of us don't find them amusing!

Uh here?

Aaron Kolb · · Western Slope CO · Joined Jun 2022 · Points: 514

I'm still confused to how the dog debate got turned into a culture war. Last time I checked dog ownership among the stereotypical gen-Z/millennial Boulderite is nearing the 100% level.

Jake Jones · · Richmond, VA · Joined Jun 2021 · Points: 170
Aaron Kolb wrote:

I'm still confused to how the dog debate got turned into a culture war. Last time I checked dog ownership among the stereotypical gen-Z/millennial Boulderite is nearing the 100% level.

Because people like to politicize things when their point is full of holes.  It's the most prevalent form of ad hominem fallacy in social interactions online.  

"Oh, don't like what I'm saying?  Well, who'd YOU vote for??"  See?

tom donnelly · · san diego · Joined Aug 2002 · Points: 426
Shaun Johnson wrote:

This has been the highest percentage of people agreeing that dogs are not welcomed at the crag in history or this conversation. 

Now I live in SE Idaho and climb at City Of Rocks a lot. I would say that 9 out of 10 dogs are off leash and out of those 9 dog owners I would assume at least 7 if them know they are supposed to have their dog on a leash. The rangers basically walk around every day asking people to put there dogs on a leash. This selfishness takes up park resources and is actively destroying the fragile desert environment. Don't be selfish. YOUR dog is no different then everyone else's dog. The rules also apply to you.

Why aren't the violators fined?  In Joshua tree, also run by the NPS, violators are often fined.

Will C wrote:  Clearly, you have never been to Joshua Tree. Take a gander and lemme know how many dog owners you see actually following park regulations regarding their fur babies.

Ftr, I own a dog and love it; but it's never coming to the crag with me.

Lee Chandler wrote:  Dogs running around in JT, is a parks management problem, they need to enforce their rules, write tickets and etc. The same goes for all the other rules being broken that they choose to do nothing about as well.

I guess the fine amount needs to be increased and enforced even more.

Shaun Johnson · · Pocatello, ID · Joined May 2012 · Points: 1,655
tom donnelly wrote:

Why aren't the violators fined?  In Joshua tree, also run by the NPS, violators are fined.

I can not answer that question because I have not personally asked them, but it seems that the few rangers out there are very chill people. I would not be surprised if fines start getting issued as the problem increases. They however have started fining people for sleeping in camper vans staying in campsites designated for tents BTW. (unrelated to the dog rant, but worth mentioning.)

Jordan Wilson · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Dec 2017 · Points: 65
csproul wrote:

Uh here?

Grug Grug is reacting poorly but seems to be an outlier. However his name is Grug Grug might be just in his nature. 

Webfoot · · Oregon · Joined Jul 2018 · Points: 0
saign charlestein wrote:

I wanted that beef jerky…

End of rant.

My God, this is an outrage!

Ignatius Pi · · Europe · Joined Jun 2020 · Points: 14

I don't think that anybody has linked to this yet: https://www.trainingbeta.com/media/dog-training/?portfolioCats=72

Seems both relevant and helpful - and simply interesting for trying to understand what's going on in the brains of a familiar and mostly friendly species with whom we share this planet [ie dogs - ladies are a whole different level!].

David K · · The Road, Sometimes Chattan… · Joined Jan 2017 · Points: 434
Old lady H wrote:

I know of a dog getting butted off a cliff by a mountain goat when a friend was out on a group hike. He got to carry a big dog out on his shoulders, instead of having the weekend he planned. A dog was killed by a coyote (had a den nearby) on a popular, almost in town trail. Dogs almost killed by a random shooter (I narrowly missed that one, myself). Dogs who cooked themselves getting excited at the sight of water....that happened to be very hot hot springs (again, in the city limits near a park).

Jesus Helen, I wasn't ready to have my heart broken on a Friday night.

Including the devious camp mate of mine who swiped my muffin out of the side pocket of my pack, the brief instant it was on the ground when we arrived in the parking lot for our climbing!

To add indignity to injustice, this same furball friend once turned a boulder problem his mom and I were sussing out into a 2 move wonder. Jumped entirely over both of us, and one huge single scrabble saw him top out.

FCA = First Canine Ascent

Bruno Schull · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Dec 2009 · Points: 0

Thanks for all the positive replies folks!

Here's a picture of my daughter and our dog at the crag--spending a day at the crag with family (two-legged and four-legged) is great!

caesar.salad · · earth · Joined Dec 2012 · Points: 75
Bruno Schull wrote:

This goes out to all the dog haters on this thread--God, there a lot of you.  How repugnant!

I think about people who don't love and embrace dogs the same way I think about people who don't love and embrace children--they're entitlted to their opinions, of course, but they will forever remain in my mind as somewhat selfish, fearful, closed-minded, anal-retentive, limited, lonely, and with a fundamental lack of empathy, kindness, generosity, and tolerance.  

I bring my dog to the crag.  Sometimes she's on a leash, and sometimes not.  She's absolutely sweet and loveable--would not bite or hurt a fly (cats, that's another story). You can put food between her paws and she'll wait for you to give her the sign before she eats it, she would never steal food or pee on ropes...but she is a gaurd dog, and protective of her pack.  When people arrive, especially men wearing hats or helmets, she will bark loudly, and look quite aggresive, before going up to them to lick their hands and beg for kisses and lie on her back in submission for belly rubs.   That can scare people initially, but, because I know she is so good-hearted, I feel like it's as much about the other people as the dog--it's like people being scared of a human with tattoos and a studded leather jacket--I can't control their reaction.  And I can't control her instinct to bark and defend (before asking for affection) on leash or off.  I feel like it's up top others to just deal, the way that I deal with other's people's shit, loud music, loud talk, cigarette smoke, litter, beer bottles, gun shots, political views, macho posturing, sexism, shouted beta, whatever.  Part of life.  Want to climb outside in public places?  Cool.  Learn to adapt and be tolerant.  That's what growing up in NYC taught me.

How about accepting dogs are part of human life?  We've been evolving with them for thousands of years, and they'll never go away.  Get to know dogs, learn to read them, learn to interact with them, which ones to pet and which ones to stay away from, and so on.  Who knows, perhaps you'll find dog love at the crag. It could happen.  

Picture of my pooch at a crag to troll the dog haters:

No.

Bryan · · Minneapolis, MN · Joined Apr 2015 · Points: 482

Now that we’ve all been heard on this issue where do we stand on crag dogs? 

SenorDB · · Old Pueblo · Joined Apr 2012 · Points: 9,429

I think it's safe to say that crag dogs, leashed or unleashed, are a great addition and ambiance. ....So long as they're well behaved and mind their manners. You know, kind of like what we would expect of crag people at the crags :)

David K · · The Road, Sometimes Chattan… · Joined Jan 2017 · Points: 434
Bryan wrote:

Now that we’ve all been heard on this issue where do we stand on crag dogs? 

Dude, poor dogs! Don't stand on them!

Marc801 C · · Sandy, Utah · Joined Feb 2014 · Points: 65
Princess Puppy Lovr wrote:

I think it depends on what counts as undeveloped but Olympic and Acadia come to mind as national parks as places with dog anarchy. 

Maybe do some fact checking before spouting nonsense like "...but Olympic and Acadia come to mind as national parks as places with dog anarchy."?

Here's Acadia, while basically dog friendly, is far from dog anarchy:

https://www.nps.gov/acad/planyourvisit/pets.htm

Olympic NP - https://www.nps.gov/olym/planyourvisit/pets.htm

Guidelines for dog owners visiting Olympic National Park. Please follow the rules of BARK!

Bag your pet's poop
Pet owners are responsible for removing pet waste from all areas in the park including campgrounds, picnic areas, parking lots, roads, pet-friendly trails, and other developed areas.

Always wear a leash
Pets must be restrained on a leash no longer than 6 feet.

Respect wildlife
Pets can harass or harm wildlife by making noise or scaring wildlife away.

Know where you can go
Pets are allowed on the following trails:

  •  Peabody Creek Trail (Olympic National Park Visitor Center in Port Angeles)
  •  Rialto Beach parking lot to Ellen Creek (1/2 mile)
  •  The beaches between the Hoh and Quinault Reservations (Kalaloch area)   
  •  Madison Falls Trail (Elwha)
  •  Spruce Railroad Trail (North shore of Lake Crescent)
  •  July Creek Loop Trail (North shore of Lake Quinault)

Pets are not permitted - on any trails not listed above, in public buildings, on interpretive walks, or in the wilderness.

Mark Starr · · Wandering · Joined Jun 2017 · Points: 305
Marc801 C wrote:

Maybe do some fact checking before spouting nonsense like "...but Olympic and Acadia come to mind as national parks as places with dog anarchy."?

Here's Acadia, while basically dog friendly, is far from dog anarchy:

https://www.nps.gov/acad/planyourvisit/pets.htm

Olympic NP - https://www.nps.gov/olym/planyourvisit/pets.htm

Written rules rarely align with what people do. I think everyone understands this, right? That's like saying speeding doesn't happen because we have speed limit signs posted. Or saying that dog poop bags on trails aren't a problem because there are signs telling people to pack them out.

I guess you could argue that the existence of rules disproves the existence of anarchy. But I would argue that if rules aren't strictly enforced then we trend towards anarchy. Park rangers can't possibly enforce dog rules in National Parks. There just aren't enough resources for that. Thus, functional dog anarchy.

But maybe I'm wrong. ::shrug::

Old lady H · · Boise, ID · Joined Aug 2015 · Points: 1,375
Locker wrote:

All my friends very much appreciate when I bring my dog...

Hmmm. Yes...could be about to rip your face off.

Maybe.

But?

With that back leg back, looking like they're on their belly?

That could also just be a happy pitty grin, especially if there's a tail wagging happily.

After all, that's kinda how I look in camp, pre coffee, on climbing/camping trips. And I rarely bite.

Rarely.

Best, H.

David K · · The Road, Sometimes Chattan… · Joined Jan 2017 · Points: 434
Adam Burch wrote:

When we go out on walks I've got these two typically to deal with leashless dogs.  When owners refuse to toss the leash on I show them what I have and explain the next steps.  That usually does the trick.  The entitlement and delusional behavior is unreal.

https://www.amazon.com/SABRE-Trigger-Deployment-15-Foot-4-5-Meter/dp/B088JWPH6Y/ref=sr_1_2_mod_primary_new?crid=25AVBH1D1TGQT&keywords=pepper+gel+gun&qid=1661649351&s=sporting-goods&sbo=RZvfv%2F%2FHxDF%2BO5021pAnSA%3D%3D&sprefix=pepper+gel+gu%2Csporting%2C154&sr=1-2

"When dog owners refuse to leash their dogs I threaten them with a knife."

Alrght internet tough guy, simmer down.  

The problem with most dog owners isn't that they refuse to leash their dogs when asked, it's that they should have their dogs leashed in the first place. Most will leash their dogs when asked, so I just don't believe this is a regular occurrence for you. And if you ever did follow through on this fantasy, brandishing a knife and spouting threats is a crime and doing it regularly would end you up in jail right quickly.

And more importantly than the law, it's just not right. You're escalating from someone refusing to leash their dog to credible threats of violence. That changes a situation where they are in the wrong, to a situation where you are MUCH MORE in the wrong.

This didn't make you sound cool, if that was your goal.

Bruno Schull · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Dec 2009 · Points: 0

@ David, It's my understanding that Adam Burch, regular and appreciated contributor, who often goes by "Burchy" (I think) would no more brandish a knife in a dog-leash-fight than you or I.  if I'm correct, he's a knife maker, and showing pictuyres of his craft is sort of his calling card on this site, especially when debates get heated, like Fritz and his goats (god bless them, Fritz and the goats one and all).  Maybe I'm wrong--maybe Burchy is a knife-brandishing, knife-wieding maniac--who knows?   But I don't think so. I just think he likes to show pictures of those beautiful blades (I'm not into knives myself, but I appreciate the craft). 

That said--Good Lord--Burchy, do you really load up with peper spray gun thing wver time you go for a dog walk?  That level of prepardness/defensiveness/paranoia (?) is utterly foreign to me.  I'd be scared to carry that because I feel like it would so greatly raise the chances of me getting shot by the police.  Honest question, are you trolling, or is that you regular practice?  Have you really had such bad experiences with dogs to warrant this?  If so, I feel bad.  Dogs are so much better than people.  I wish you the best on your quest to come to own that beautiful sheapard/maloinos mix...looks like a great dog.  

Further, all the macho posturing about picking up sticks and threatening owners without leashed dogs and so forth is ridiculous.  In this sense, I think David has it right: you are escalating a situation WAY further than it needs, and thus committing the greater sin.  I argue that the chances where you or your loved ones are actually in danger from  a dog are very, very slim, and those can be dealth with on a case-by-case basis, without treating all unleashed dogs and unhinged dog owners with aggresion and confrontation. 

Where I live (Switzerland) there are times of the year when dogs need to be on leash to protect wildlife.  During those times, my dog is on a leash.  For the rest of the year, she is off leash.  She may run over to you and put her paws on your legs and jump up for kissed and cuddles, and if you are drunk, or shouting, or angry, she may bark quite arresively, but her tail will be wagging all the time, and she just wants to warn her pack of possible danger, and solicit afffection from everybody. If she bothers you, you can put out your hand and tell her to sit, and she will.  Considering all that, I do sometimes put her on a leash when I see other dog owners struggling with a difficult dog, or when there is a kindergarten or school group, or an elderely person, and so on, but I react badly when other people demand that I put her on a leash for no other reason than their own fear and disgust and discomfort.  In those situations, when there's no legal or reasonable basis for my dog to be on a leash, and somebody shouts, "Put your dog on a leash!" I basically say, "Go fuck youself."    And if they kicked or maced or atacked my dog, I would defend her absolutely.  That's not macho posturing, that's just emotional reality.  I love her more than most people.  She is part of my family.  

This topic is locked and closed to new replies.

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.