I'd rather pay for fee based climbing permits than taxing gear sales. These sorts of things make me feel like the word 'conservation' is just a buzz word with no meaning.
So how much is a crag worth, no more than the fee to file a mining claim.
A potentially silly solution would be for the federal government to start a fund that is allocated to the top x government organizations with the cleanest "audit scores". This would be funded from the governmental organizations with the bottom x "audit scores" receiving a penalty that reduces their annual budget by a % meaningful enough to hurt.
The defense department has failed every single audit it's undergone, indicating that there is mass wastage of money. This structure would incentivize the military to crack down on fraud and waste, all the while paying penalties into this fund that could help fund the NPS (assuming they can swing a clean audit).
How about we spend a littttttle less on the military instead? The BLM has a budget of $1.6 billion, the NPS $2.76 billion. The military? $800 billion. Take even 1% of that and you free up $8 billion dollars for public lands, and we’d still have an outrageously overfunded military. Stop voting for the military industrial complex.
Agree 100% too bad we'll never have a political option that would actively make the changes. (Insert George Carlin quote)