Mountain Project Logo

Gear taken from Pistol Whipped

Insert name · · Harts Location · Joined Dec 2011 · Points: 61
Rob Dillon wrote:

In the hierarchy of cragging sins, gear theft is far worse than leaving ropes up, and it is dismaying to see people getting far more worked up about the latter.  

Pretty sure project draws are game Now according to half of MP... I had someone steal a fixed line that was up for bolt changing.


No one knows the back story (including me). But being a thief instead of taking the gear and calling or leaving it on the ground is shitty. (Edited: Just saw Andrews post) have all the discussion you want about poor form and if it was then hopefully it doesn’t happen again. I just don’t think someone deserves to have shit stolen which seemed a good possibility with how most people handle these things now.

Marc801 C · · Sandy, Utah · Joined Feb 2014 · Points: 65
Insert name wrote:

But being a thief instead of taking the gear and calling or leaving it on the ground is shitty.

https://www.mountainproject.com/forum/topic/120571181/gear-taken-from-pistol-whipped#ForumMessage-120579314

Rob Dillon · · Tamarisk Clearing · Joined Mar 2002 · Points: 727

Well, Nick and Andrew, you both have my # so if I can help in any way to facilitate this gear exchange, LMK

Frank Stein · · Picayune, MS · Joined Feb 2012 · Points: 305
Insert name wrote:

Pretty sure project draws are game Now according to half of MP... I had someone steal a fixed line that was up for bolt changing.


No one knows the back story (including me). But being a thief instead of taking the gear and calling or leaving it on the ground is shitty. (Edited: Just saw Andrews post) have all the discussion you want about poor form and if it was then hopefully it doesn’t happen again. I just don’t think someone deserves to have shit stolen which seemed a good possibility with how most people handle these things now.

Oh common, now you are just throwing an internet tantrum. Yes, gear theft is all bad in all instances, but how can you equivocate 8 cams and 350’ of fixed rope blocking a crack with project draws on a sport route?

Max Tepfer · · Bend, OR · Joined Oct 2007 · Points: 3,683
Insert name wrote:

Pretty sure project draws are game Now according to half of MP... I had someone steal a fixed line that was up for bolt changing.


No one knows the back story (including me). But being a thief instead of taking the gear and calling or leaving it on the ground is shitty. (Edited: Just saw Andrews post) have all the discussion you want about poor form and if it was then hopefully it doesn’t happen again. I just don’t think someone deserves to have shit stolen which seemed a good possibility with how most people handle these things now.

Yeah, no.  If you can't see the radical context shift in what you're saying, you need to either read the thread more carefully or think harder about what's being said.  Project draws don't really inconvenience anyone. (if they're left up for a season or less and are working, safe quickdraws-longer than that, they typically become trash) It's a bummer someone stole a rope you fixed for route maintenance.  That isn't cool.  It's also completely different from what's being discussed here.

Lastly, pretty much no one is saying stealing a fixed line is cool. (and it sounds like it wasn't stolen anyway.  No surprise there given the terrible cell reception and the fact that people tend to camp out there for days at a time) This thread shouldn't be or be taken as a personal attack on Nick as a person at all.  All we're trying to say is that it isn't cool to fix a rope on a route (let alone a mega classic) for any significant length of time.

Michael Rush · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Aug 2020 · Points: 0

Can anyone name another activity where it’s ok to leave gear in a public place after one leaves the area for a day? 

Allen Sanderson · · On the road to perdition · Joined Jul 2007 · Points: 1,100
Michael Rush wrote:

Can anyone name another activity where it’s ok to leave gear in a public place after one leaves the area for a day? 

Getting off topic, but hunters leave stands and blinds up. They can do so for two weeks* on most federal lands without any issue. After two weeks some lands require the blinds/stands to be moved to a new location a prescribed distance away. Other lands have specific reg in place where stands/blinds may be left up for all of the hunting season (installed a week  before and removed within a week at the end of the season).

*In general, on most federal lands one can occupy a "location" for at most two weeks. Camping, parking an RV, hunting blind, climbing route, draws, etc.  In my experience, many hunters do not know this regulation. Similarly many climbers and campers do not know it either.  In fact most do not.

If one finds gear in place, and is annoyed enough to remove it, not do keep it as that is theft (a friend learned the hard way when they took down a hunter stand). Turn it over law enforcement and if after 60-90 days no one claims it, legally it is yours. In the mean time, it is just no longer acceptable to leave any gear at the crags, regardless of past practices or land management regs. Too many people.

Insert name · · Harts Location · Joined Dec 2011 · Points: 61
Max Tepfer wrote:

Yeah, no.  If you can't see the radical context shift in what you're saying, you need to either read the thread more carefully or think harder about what's being said.  Project draws don't really inconvenience anyone. (if they're left up for a season or less and are working, safe quickdraws-longer than that, they typically become trash) It's a bummer someone stole a rope you fixed for route maintenance.  That isn't cool.  It's also completely different from what's being discussed here.

Lastly, pretty much no one is saying stealing a fixed line is cool. (and it sounds like it wasn't stolen anyway.  No surprise there given the terrible cell reception and the fact that people tend to camp out there for days at a time) This thread shouldn't be or be taken as a personal attack on Nick as a person at all.  All we're trying to say is that it isn't cool to fix a rope on a route (let alone a mega classic) for any significant length of time.

I didn’t say it was cool to steal project draws. But plenty of people on MP think it’s ok and do it. There have been a lot of posts about this over the years.

I spoke with Andrew and we both agreed on the subject. We both agree it shouldn’t have been there and we both agree it is right to return the gear.

Max Tepfer · · Bend, OR · Joined Oct 2007 · Points: 3,683

Gotcha.  My bad for misunderstanding your post.  There are a lot of things that a lot of people on here believe that are totally laughable to me.  Glad to hear we're on the same page on this one!

Fuzz A · · Colorado · Joined Oct 2014 · Points: 85
Rob Dillon wrote:

Well, Nick and Andrew, you both have my # so if I can help in any way to facilitate this gear exchange, LMK

Rob, thanks for looking out. Nick has all of his gear back!  It was left with my partner in Moab so that it could be returned assuming that the owner was still in the Moab area.  All is well.

The takeaways that I see from this conversation are: Don't steal people's kit. If you are not the owner of the kit, you are not the owner of the kit. Assume positive intent and be a homie. 

highaltitudeflatulentexpulsion · · Colorado · Joined Oct 2012 · Points: 35

You don't work third pitch 12- in the creek. You climb lots of other 12-, build up a repertoire of skills and endurance, and go up there and onsight it.

Pnelson · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jan 2015 · Points: 635
highaltitudeflatulentexpulsion wrote:

You don't work third pitch 12- in the creek. You climb lots of other 12-, build up a repertoire of skills and endurance, and go up there and onsight it.

I seem to remember both of us onsighting PW back in like 2006. Had we found this kind of gear on the route we would have taken it and returned it with a fair amount of shit-talk and shaming as well. Super lame to leave fixed gear on a route like that.

alpinist 47 · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Mar 2017 · Points: 0

^^^^^^^climb lots of 5.11 then try 5.12;)

Russ Keane · · Salt Lake · Joined Feb 2013 · Points: 452

Best thread I've read in a while.  Good posts.

M M · · Maine · Joined Oct 2020 · Points: 3

It was for photos according to the note posted, seems weird that the note said one thing and the person who wrote it says different

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

Southern Utah Deserts
Post a Reply to "Gear taken from Pistol Whipped"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.