Mountain Project Logo

New and Experienced Climbers Over 50 #15

Carl Schneider · · Mount Torrens, South Australia · Joined Dec 2017 · Points: 0
Sam Cieply wrote:

He's never been to Joshua Tree.

How do you know?

Carl Schneider · · Mount Torrens, South Australia · Joined Dec 2017 · Points: 0
Lori Milas wrote:

Can someone tell me if Carl is right?  “I think 10d on toprope should be accessible for most people.”   

Yeah yeah alright it was a fucking stupid statement. What do you expect from me? SENSE???!!! 

Now watch my climbing video...

https://youtu.be/cwbVFMWWkAE

Nick Goldsmith · · NEK · Joined Aug 2009 · Points: 510

Because you apparently don't know that 10d is a lot harder than 11a  ;)   I also have never been to JT but have been to enough places in the states with old school ratings to understand this.  heck we have two FA's right next to each other in VT and the harder of the two is 9+. the easy one is 10a ;) 

Sam Cieply · · Venice, CA · Joined Jun 2016 · Points: 25
Carl Schneider wrote:

How do you know?

If you had been, you would be a little more sympathetic to Lori's journey towards EBGB's. It's an intimidating route with a mantle crux at the start. I know strong climbers who have had trouble with it.

Bob Gaines · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Dec 2001 · Points: 8,774

"heck we have two FA's right next to each other in VT and the harder of the two is 9+. the easy one is 10a ;)"

9+ means 10c, especially if it's a Leighton Kor or Pat Ament route in Colorado!

Carl Schneider · · Mount Torrens, South Australia · Joined Dec 2017 · Points: 0
Nick Goldsmith wrote:

Because you apparently don't know that 10d is a lot harder than 11a  ;)   I also have never been to JT but have been to enough places in the states with old school ratings to understand this.  heck we have two FA's right next to each other in VT and the harder of the two is 9+. the easy one is 10a ;) 

10d is a lot harder than 11a??? What kind of grading system do you people HAVE!!??

I was just using a grade guide. I saw that a 10d is a 21. I honestly feel that very very very generally, in my experience, for most outdoor routes I've climbed, 23 is where it starts to sort the men from the boys. It seems to me, that with work, most fit people could eventually get up many 21s clean on TR. I've only led up to grade 23 (my table tells me that's about 5.11b/5.11c) on sports and 21 trad, so I'm as weak as shit, but for me at least, 21s are very accessible. 

No, I haven't been to JT, and I'm sure JT doesn't want me there, so have no idea of the differences there in grades. Only climbed at my home crags in the Adelaide hills, at Moonarie in remote SA, in The Grampians and at Mount Arapiles, as well as down by our coast. 

The silly little statement was supposed to be encouraging... :-(

Jarrod Webb · · Prescott AZ · Joined Jun 2017 · Points: 5

Wow Carl that video is one of the wackier things I've ever seen. Love the sound effects and how you think they're over and then they start again. I'm excited to see the next one

Bob Gaines · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Dec 2001 · Points: 8,774

"One of my favorites is when I did midnight lightning. In the spring (maybe 1996?) had driven from SLC to yosemite on a friday after work to try that on saturday and then did snake dike the next day. I spent 3 hours just getting to the lightning hold and my skin and ego were shredded. I only had a BD spot pad and someone 25 lbs lighter than me spotting me. So I came back the following fall with one pad and John Cronin--who at the time was the #1 competitive sport climber in the US. He did it easily (2nd try). As soon as we started trying it about 30 people from camp 4 came out with their camp chairs and beers to watch and after he did it when he got back to the base two or three asian families asked him to pose for pictures with their arms around him in front of the chalk lightning. For me, again, by the time I got to the lightning hold I was depressed, tired and my skin hurt. The crowd dispersed. I went to the grocery store in the village bought a OE800 40 and drank it on the walk back to the columbia boulder basically to cry in my beer. John says,  "you should try it again."  I did it next try and when I grabbed the jug I almost cried. I was so excited, I started almost running to the top and went to into the moss on the right and almost fell. "

Great story Todd!

Here's a shot of Kurt Smith, circa 1993, with his right hand on the lightning bolt hold. He sent it too, sans crash pad and spotters. And with tube socks!

Kristian Solem · · Hulett, WY · Joined Apr 2004 · Points: 1,085

Joshua Tree grades in order of difficulty:

5.9 / 5.8 / 5.10b / 5.10a / 5.10c / 5.11a / 5.11b / 5.10d / 5.11c / 5.11b / 5.12a / 5.11d / etc...

Disclaimer: The first fifteen feet of any route in Josh is excluded from consideration in the route's grade. This practice is known, among locals, as the great equalizer. Some good examples include O'Kelly's Crack, Bendix Claws, and of course the dreaded Double Cross.

Mark Frumkin · · Bishop, CA · Joined Feb 2013 · Points: 52

Bob, I think that is before 93?

Bob Gaines · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Dec 2001 · Points: 8,774

Mark, you're correct. 1987 stamped on the old slide.

Here's one of John Bachar, 1979, at the lip...no crashpad, no spotters, and a silent crowd of onlookers. My memory, like the image, is a bit fuzzy, but I still remember the power and precision of Bachar's technique. 

Lori Milas · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Apr 2017 · Points: 250
Carl Schneider wrote:

10d is a lot harder than 11a??? What kind of grading system do you people HAVE!!??

I was just using a grade guide. I saw that a 10d is a 21. I honestly feel that very very very generally, in my experience, for most outdoor routes I've climbed, 23 is where it starts to sort the men from the boys. It seems to me, that with work, most fit people could eventually get up many 21s clean on TR. I've only led up to grade 23 (my table tells me that's about 5.11b/5.11c) on sports and 21 trad, so I'm as weak as shit, but for me at least, 21s are very accessible. 

No, I haven't been to JT, and I'm sure JT doesn't want me there, so have no idea of the differences there in grades. Only climbed at my home crags in the Adelaide hills, at Moonarie in remote SA, in The Grampians and at Mount Arapiles, as well as down by our coast. 

The silly little statement was supposed to be encouraging... :-(

GRADE SHAMING!!!    

Carl, you unwittingly gave me a lesson in grading differences around the globe.  Don't take it to heart... you are loved.  And I'm proud of you, Carl...  you don't have a community here who has ever been to your climbing crags, or who knows how it goes Down Under.  Yet you keep checking in, and letting us know of your progress... and what ever happened to your withania?  

I'm still not sure what makes this all so important.  I've never been 'competitive' in a sport -- maybe in business, never with my body.  All I know is, having worked this hard to manage some very difficult climbs, if your average person-on-the-street could walk up and do a better job, then I'll take up bowling.  Heck, one of the 10d routes I really want to climb... I can't even get TO the route, let alone climb it.  

I don't know who these magical people are here on this thread... some kind of witchcraft gets them up these amazing routes, not mortal skills.  Maybe it's strong drink, psychedelic brew... but all I have is two feet and a faint heart as they breeze on by.    

And yet... here we fucking are, somehow mastering the impossible little by little.  (I found out why Tony left so abruptly the other day... he finally said he just couldn't bear to watch me climb.  So after all his macho strutting, this game is too much for him.    )  

--------------------

To a previous post upthread... good advice on the first 15 feet.  I was having such a good time on a route on King Otto's Castle... Tarawassi Wiggle... thinking, well, this is ok!  When I arrived at the first horizontal crack, Bob said "Now this is where the route gets fun!"  Deflated chuckwalla... 

Mark Frumkin · · Bishop, CA · Joined Feb 2013 · Points: 52

It isn't important. The witchcraft of the planet. Little by little moving forward building a foundation.

Carl, you might fit in better than you think.

GabeO · · Boston, MA · Joined May 2006 · Points: 302
Kristian Solem wrote:

The first fifteen feet of any route in Josh is excluded from consideration in the route's grade.

Much the same is true in the Gunks.  Laurel is the classic example.  It starts with a 5.8 move to get off the ground, yet gets the overall grade of 5.6.

GO

Lori Milas · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Apr 2017 · Points: 250

What's everyone listening to?  Care to share your favorite (or current) playlist?



Frank Stein · · Picayune, MS · Joined Feb 2012 · Points: 305
Russ Walling wrote:

If you think 10d is sandbagged, wait till you hit 11d. All of those are 12c.

A .11d is just an angry .12a. 

Jan Mc · · CA · Joined Aug 2013 · Points: 0

Lori, also realize that slab in particular is more often mental than physical and more so the harder it gets.  When you get to the really hard routes it often becomes a matter of 'make believe' and how well you can convince yourself that by some magical thought your foot will stay on that almost non-existant hold that you put it on.  If you can't convince your brain, your feet won't believe either and will fall off every time.  This is where 'practice makes perfect' really comes into play.  Either climb slab a LOT or don't climb slab well.

PTR · · NEPA · Joined Aug 2009 · Points: 5
GabeO wrote:

Much the same is true in the Gunks.  Laurel is the classic example.  It starts with a 5.8 move to get off the ground, yet gets the overall grade of 5.6.

GO

I've seen people similarly baffled by the start of Easy Overhang [5.2].

Lori Milas · · Joshua Tree, CA · Joined Apr 2017 · Points: 250
Jan Mc wrote:

Lori, also realize that slab in particular is more often mental than physical and more so the harder it gets.  When you get to the really hard routes it often becomes a matter of 'make believe' and how well you can convince yourself that by some magical thought your foot will stay on that almost non-existant hold that you put it on.  If you can't convince your brain, your feet won't believe either and will fall off every time.  This is where 'practice makes perfect' really comes into play.  Either climb slab a LOT or don't climb slab well.

Jan, this means a lot coming from you—and I’m listening.  I got shut out by this route again today. My toes hurt, my calves hurt, and my feelings are hurt.  I’m just...baffled.  

Nevertheless, when I got in my car to drive home today I was just simply happy.  Happy to have been outside today, blue sky, wonderful company and to know I’m trying to work on something really hard.  

Carl Schneider · · Mount Torrens, South Australia · Joined Dec 2017 · Points: 0
Lori Milas wrote:

What's everyone listening to?  Care to share your favorite (or current) playlist?



https://music.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLKe4QEir9bLvKenNt43uy-9S5PjO5Ecmc

Here's one of my, named "chill" 

This topic is locked and closed to new replies.

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.