How many of you regularly use 2 piece anchors?
|
|
Howdy y'all. Scrolling through my Instagram feed (biased I know) and based on a couple comments I've seen on here, it seems that 2 piece trad anchors are popular amongst some people. I understand that an anchor with two bomber pieces is, well, bomber but I'm just curious how many people regularly use this setup? My guess is its mostly for the pics/flaunting the light, efficient, and fast style but I've been wrong before. |
|
|
If two bomber pieces do the job, why not? I don’t think there is any specific magic that happens with 3 pieces. In fact, I would be willing to bet an anchor with two good pieces and one shitty piece is more likely to fail than just the one with two good pieces, based on my understanding of how anchors are shocked when pieces rip. |
|
|
Sometimes two bomber pieces are all you can get. Not a huge problem. |
|
|
Not infrequently if at the end of a simuling block. Sometimes i’ll do two with a loose third that my partner takes out when they start leading the next pitch and there is a low chance of them falling before their first piece. |
|
|
Sometimes even just a single anchor is fine. |
|
|
I use whatever’s “ good enough”. |
|
|
Probably 35-40% of the time, as all you get get in my main climbing areas if two pieces. |
|
|
If there are two perfect pieces, a third isn't really going to add much. This is two nuts. Sorry for the bad pic, but that top nut is in a slot, and could never come out on its own. The bottom nut is also bomber. I just used a 120 cm runner to connect them. My static line is tied off there as a back up. we rapped the static line that is cloved to the master point. |
|
|
Salamanizer Ski wrote: This. Knowing how to make a bunch of safe enough decisions is key to moving quickly. If I'm on lower angle terrain where I know my partner can get in a couple pieces before there's an intolerable risk of them falling, I can find two bomber pieces, and we're trying to not decend in the dark or in storms, I do it a lot. As someone else also said, there's times when I'll pair a cam and a nut, then remove the cam so they leader has it, and sometimes, I even don't build an anchor at all and belay with the rope around a horn or boulder. The route, where you choose to belay, your rack, all dictate when this is stupid and when it makes sense. |
|
|
If one of them is a tree... |
|
|
If my partner is mature enough to understand 2 or even 1 piece is adequate i will use 1 or 2 or whatever is appropriate for a good anchor. If my partner is rule bound, dogmatic and inflexible i will use 3. |
|
|
i've i'm belaying off my harness and am sitting at a strong stance and want to be fast? often. piece in, clove, off belay. second piece, clove, start pulling rope. quick and ez. in my mind, a strong sitting stance is equal to one "backup" |
|
|
Ted Pinson wrote: you back up a tree? |
|
|
yes, I use two piece anchor a lot. |
|
|
Two totally bomber pieces...sure thing send it. I’ve got some partners though that would loose it if they arrived at a 2 piece so with them I toss I’m a third. |
|
|
chris b wrote: For a TR anchor yes (we just had an accident where someone was climbing on a single tree anchor that failed when the sling cut on an edge) for lead only if it’s on the small end. |
|
|
I used to use one- or two- piece anchors (when I first started climbing), then I read John Long's book on climbing anchors (abut a month later) in which he describes multiple fatal falls from failed multi-piece anchors and then all the AAC accident reports of similar accounts. The vivid imagery has stuck with me for 8 years. A two piece anchor is not necessary and sufficient to warrant "YGD", but it is associated with increased risk... mitigate risk properly and you're fine, but always leave sufficient room for unknown uncertainty. |
|
|
chris b wrote: I bring my own tree for redundancy |
|
|
Marc801 C wrote: Yup. |
|
|
Detrick S wrote: False. A two point anchor is always sufficient if the placement and rock are sound. If in doubt, add a piece (should be rare, especially on trade routes). If not, two is not riskier than 3 or 100. |
|
|
Regularly. Regarding that anchor book, those incidents have a root cause other than using two well placed pieces in good rock. |





