Mountain Project Logo

Honnold on NatGeo Tonight

Pierre Proulx · · Montreal, Quebec, CA · Joined Mar 2019 · Points: 10
Mark A wrote:

Google Play:  Thats weird I actually looked on GP right before my post and it said the season wasn't available yet.  Now to decide if I want to spend the $2 ;-)

no, no you don't. 

The 2$ is nothing in itself, but the time it would take you to watch this joke is time that is lost and you can never get back, and that is priceless!! Because in terms of learning and entertainment I'd say you're better off reading the back of a cereal box for half an hour. 

Dustin B · · Steamboat · Joined Jan 2006 · Points: 1,335

God I wish I could sell out...

BrokenChairs 88 · · Denver, CO · Joined Feb 2015 · Points: 240
Karen Hammersmith wrote: To stoop to this level, Sanni must really want a bigger fridge

This might be one of my favorite comments that I've ever read. 

Robert Rowsam · · Grand Junction, CO · Joined Oct 2012 · Points: 230

Full episode:

  • Alex looks sketchy doing a skydive
  • They descend a via ferrata, Alex solos it
  • Bear eats some ants, then Alex does
  • Bear rigs a stupid simul rap off a cable bridge, Alex makes a face
  • A little awkward small talk about dead dad's 
  • Bear sprays about being in the SAS (maybe not true)
  • Alex solos a downed tree to scope out a dead bird
  • Bear explains that water runs downhill
  • Alex does a shallow water solo traverse
  • They destroy a nice parachute to build a hammock, Alex is not impressed
  • Bear and Alex hold hands and make a fire
  • Bear dresses the bird from earlier, Alex was not a fan
  • Bear perpetuates the half dome ledge freak out misconception while they cook the bird
  • Bear is impressed Alex has feelings
  • Alex is impressed that bear can do anything
  • Bear whispers to a sleeping Alex at midnight
  • They drink pine needles tea for breakfast
  • They seem to never take their harnesses off, bear carries the rope around his chest
  • Bear puts sap on his hands, Alex expresses preference to keep hands and rock clean
  • Alex leads a slab, in approach shoes, with a large stick coming out of his backpack, clipping bolts. Calls it a ladder
  • Bear follows, makes it look hard. Totally out of breath at the top.
  • They tandem paraglide off a hill, Alex wears a helmet

Andy Kirkpatrick has a podcast. His latest episode is about Bear

Chris Duca · · Dixfield, ME · Joined Dec 2006 · Points: 2,485

I’m partially surprised Terra Incognita didn’t publicly boycott the episode with their “patriarchal/toxic-masculinity/white supremacist/asshole” comments they’ve recently been throwing around the Instagram.  Christ on a crutch (cue massive eye roll)!! 

Michael Atlas · · Charlotte, NC · Joined Apr 2014 · Points: 85

When Alex did the hard part of that slab I think he must of been told to act concerned a d take more time.  I mean it looked a little run out but for Pete's sake he was on bolts and what looked like no more than a 5.7 slab

David Appelhans · · Broomfield, CO · Joined Nov 2007 · Points: 410
My Cal At Last wrote: When Alex did the hard part of that slab I think he must of been told to act concerned a d take more time.  I mean it looked a little run out but for Pete's sake he was on bolts and what looked like no more than a 5.7 slab

Yeah...but he was being belayed by Bear...so basically free soloing.

Mark A · · Golden, CO · Joined Jun 2016 · Points: 96
David Appelhans wrote:

Yeah...but he was being belayed by Bear...so basically free soloing.

Bear had improvised the belay device using the skull of a dead rat he found (and ate).

Doug Emmett · · Reno, NV · Joined Oct 2018 · Points: 0

I think this may be Honnold's version of "jumping the shark".

C Limenski · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Mar 2016 · Points: 15
Mark A wrote:

Bear had improvised the belay device using the skull of a dead rat he found (and ate).

Actually?

Mark Pilate · · MN · Joined Jun 2013 · Points: 25
C. limbnski wrote:

Actually?

F  yeah...true alpinists know that marmot skulls make a sweet Reverso.  Thread each half rope through the eye sockets. 

Noob tip: make darn sure they’re completely dispatched before attempting.  they get awful nasty if they ‘come to’ mid rappel...

HughC · · Fort Collins, CO · Joined Jul 2015 · Points: 60

Looks like after AH made that, "Hmmmm, seems sketchy" face,  that simul-rap without knots turned into them putting figure eights with a bight, clipped into lockers. AH may take risks, but he ain't crazy!

John Penca · · North Little Rock · Joined Sep 2018 · Points: 0
Marc801 C wrote:

Watched it last night. Alex seemed like he enjoyed it, and took a number of opportunities to slag on Bear.

Yeah, he got a few good ones in along with some good  WTF? looks.  It seemed like good fun for both of them.

Those shoots prolly take a week or so to set up and film.  Alex was probably put up in first class accommodations in the Alps.  Not bad for a valley rat.

Paul-B · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Mar 2011 · Points: 115
Doug Emmett wrote: I think this may be Honnold's version of "jumping the shark".


So many things I don't understand here.  

1.  They're supposedly doing a "counter-balance rappel" but they tie figure 8's on bites attached to anchor with locker.  This is not a counter balance rappel.  They're each individually on the anchor.

2.  They're simultaneously rappelling, but both on double strand ropes.... this defeats the purpose of simul-rapping.  Why not just go 1 at a time and bring 1/2 the rope.

3. The other obvious problem with this is they can't pull their rope....

4. Supposedly a 300 foot rappel and they both do it on double strands, that's 1200 feet of rope or 365 meters of rope..... there's no way bear was carrying that in those bags.  They clearly brought in more rope between the sequences (I just watched the clip).  This is very misleading and unrealistic (no surprise given the show).  

5. Bear says they're gonna need both ropes and the emergency rope to make that far of a rap.... it sounds like they're joining 3 ropes together... so is somebody passing a knot?!

splitclimber · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jan 2007 · Points: 29

Oh Paul

Eric Roe · · Spokane · Joined Jan 2016 · Points: 16

I don't understand why they need to outright lie about so much.  The ropes, not actually simul rapping, rapping off of a cable bridge (WTF?).  Like, climbing and rappelling are already cool enough to the average person.  Why add the fake drama?  It's fulfilling every stereotype of crappy american TV.  I feel like Nat Geo is capable of a lot better.

plantmandan · · Rice Lake, WI · Joined Sep 2010 · Points: 96

People, just enjoy the episode! If you are nitpicking the details, you are missing the point. Of course its all staged, like any other 'reality TV', who cares? If you live in Colorado, just look at the episode he filmed in Eldo for context. It's still entertaining, if not genuine.  

This show is all about the campfire chats at the end of the day. They provide the best info that celebrities usually won't reveal in other settings. The part about his dad should be interesting. It was barely covered in Free Solo from Alex's perspective.

Layne Zuelke · · Baton Rouge, LA · Joined Mar 2019 · Points: 30

I wonder which hotel they stayed in after breaking down the camping scene for the night? And I’m betting the dinner was a lot more satisfying after Alex went back to his room  and puked up the well done pigeon that the crew had cleverly planted on the ledge. Carrion my ass. 
I’d love to have watched the filming of the climbing scene. I’m  sure it went something like “Hey Alex, can you down climb that last 20 feet and make it look a bit harder? A little more grunting and emotion if you can?”  
I wonder how many takes that bridge scene took. “Alright Bear and Alex, can you step off the bridge so the riggers can come over and make the Simul Rap a safe fixed rappel....?” “Hey wardrobe,  can you grab a fresh pair of undies for Bear, his are all wet. And bring some ice packs for the dead bird while you’re at it....

GDodds dodds · · Portland Maine · Joined Apr 2013 · Points: 0

I think the socks add some nice padding.

avian tom · · Anderson, S.C. · Joined Feb 2020 · Points: 0

What a great episode. This should be a highlight reel for the scouting movement! Scouting often uses techniques from mountaineering, rock climbing & rappelling as a tool to overcome fear. This is truly, what a mature eagle scout should be able to spread his wings & aspire to be...at least half or a quarter of Mr. Honnold's ability (b/c scouting uses climbing as a teaching tool so much). For icing on the cake, they exfilled via paraglider; & I would even go as far as to say that paragliding/paramotoring is also within the grasp of a mature eagle, or a product or denizen of the scouting movement. Mr. Honnold has summited the apex of climbing & now the question is, will he enter the world of paragliding/paramotoring? His methods are effective with heights, right...!

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

General Climbing
Post a Reply to "Honnold on NatGeo Tonight"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.