Mountain Project Logo

Heuristic traps and situational awareness

Bill Kirby · · Keene New York · Joined Jul 2012 · Points: 480

Assume ass you me etcetera etcetera

 What's the other one.. Experience is making poor decisions or something something..

Sounds like adventure and learning the hard way resulting in some good stories.

Keith Wood · · Elko, NV · Joined May 2019 · Points: 480
Josh Rappoport wrote: 

Again, at the time I felt I was making the correct decisions given the information available, but like a lobster going into a trap, ended up at a bad end anyway.

Nobody boiled you and ate you. At least there's that.

More seriously, The distinction between bolted trad routes and sport routes is a real one.

Trad climbers that establish routes that include bolts tend to think about bolt positioning in terms of the maximum risk they are willing to take or expose someone else to. Smart bolt placements usually protect the most dangerous moves or settings, but it is not always certain that FA's placed bolts in the most thoughtful ways. But generally, bolt spacing is wider on bolted trad lines.

Sport routes tend to mimic the gym experience where bolts are regularly spaced to make for short falls. If you approached the route with a sport climbing idea in mind, but it was really a bolted trad route, you were probably in over your head just because you were thinking about it wrong. Climbing on wet didn't help that situation and made the consequence more likely.

coppolillo · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2009 · Points: 70

Some good stuff shared above. I'm working on a piece with a buddy and we just wrote the paper vs. digital map portion of it...I'll paste below. Related to your experiences above.

"Paul Hurst (Royal School of Military Survey, Newbury, UK) and Paul Clough (Information School, University of Sheffield) conducted studies comparing orienteers’ preferences and competence in mapping exercises with both paper and digital maps. They published their results in The Journal of Information Science. In the study’s abstract they write, “As geographic skill increases, there is a greater preference for paper maps; non-experts prefer online/digital maps. Also, paper is the preferred medium for planning and executing navigation on foot across all groups. Overall, results suggest that paper maps are here to stay for the foreseeable future and remain the preferred choice for some in the digital age.”

Strangely enough, some of the cutting-edge research on this topic comes from direct-mail marketers. Looking at how consumers digest paper mail versus digital, researchers at Bangor University’s Centre for Experimental Consumer Psychology discovered (via fMRI) that information presented on a physical card (rather than a screen) activated areas of the brain associated with spatial awareness and spatial memory networks, while digital information failed to do the same."

As soon as our nose is down in the phone, we are missing things around us. One really good skill that Michael Mauboussin talks about is being able to go from minutiae to bird's eye and back. I use the phone plenty, but mostly to verify location/etc occasionally, while using a paper map and eyeballs-on-terrain, too.

You're smart to be asking questions and debriefing experiences. It's the fastest way to learn. Good job.

Bill Lawry · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Apr 2006 · Points: 1,914

An uneventful personal story ...

I am lucky enough to have near my home a largely brush free scramble loop in the foothills that takes about an hour when solo, 90 minutes porch to porch. It has many relatively easy boulder problems, one 30m slab (5.4 to 5.7), and two 25 foot problems that are towards vertical (one 5.7 and the other 3rd or 4th class).

I make the circuit year round and so in all kinds of weather, spanning from high desert summer heat to a few inches of wet snow.  And I do it in the same type of trail shoes that I’ve worn on it for over 15 years:  Brooks Cascadia not that this matters.

I’ve only turned around once due to snow. But uncountable times I have adjusted here and there due to wetness or dirt scum dried on after raining in a way which my wife calls a “gully washer.” So, maybe just the 5.4 way up the wet slab this day.  Or skip the 5.7 highball due to snow that day.

It’s not so much that I ignore a weather-related hazard. Rather, it is a game about judging whether I can work through the hazard ... based on gradually earned experience I assume.  Hopefully no one here hears about it when I finally take that fall that is hard enough to break something.  ;)

And, for one of my out of town sisters - also a climber, the loop has become a yardstick of sorts, having first done it in good personal physical condition, then a couple times later after foot and then knee surgeries, and probably in the next few months after recovered to whatever degree from a knee replacement.  In all those, she has explored and adjusted due to new and hopefully temporary-ish physical limitations ... a different kind of “hazard” to work through.

Bret: I am going to have to read “Deep Survival”.
Suburban Roadside · · Abovetraffic on Hudson · Joined Apr 2014 · Points: 2,419

Buck Rio wrote:
There is no "Grace" to growing old...it sucks. There is nothing you can do about it.

rob.calm wrote ·                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         23 hours ago · Loveland, CO · (Joined May 2002)

Three weeks ago, I was at Vedauwoo climbing easy slab pitches up to 5.7.
 The climbing went fine, but I was gasping for air on the short approaches.

 I saw my internist the next day, followed by the cardiologist the following day and

surgery that night to implant a pacemaker to correct a pathologically slow pulse.

 Recovery is going along OK,
 but I’m not allowed to raise my L arm above my shoulder for the next 6 weeks.

I’m walking a lot including some easy hikes in the foothills.
 I plan on getting back to weight training at home in about 2 months.

When I can do 12 chin-ups and 6 somersaults, I’ll consider climbing again.

At 89, I feel fortunate and appreciative of modern hi-tech medicine and that I can climb easy routes.  

I don’t give a damn whether this is happening “in Grace” or not.  
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Thank You, Bill
 I'd forgotten

Far away & Long ago

Bill Lawry wrote: Suburban,

You’ve probably read it already. But if not, this is a great read from Dingus Milktoast ...
Old Man By The Fire story (link is to the old Rockclimbing.com site)
Bill Lawry · · Albuquerque, NM · Joined Apr 2006 · Points: 1,914

Suburban,

You’ve probably read it already. But if not, this is a great read from Dingus Milktoast ...

Old man by the fire story (link is to the old rock climbing.com site)

3AxisCtrl · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Sep 2015 · Points: 0
Guy Keesee wrote: Don’t believe everything Google feeds you.

More generally: Don't believe everything that anyone (including your own brain) feeds you.


Enough experience of things going wrong should lead to a belief that they can do so again, and open your mind to the idea that you always need Plan B.

Ross D · · Bozeman, MT · Joined Dec 2010 · Points: 0

Read "Deep Survival" by Laurence Gonzales.

It covers case studies of many scenarios, mountaineering, whitewater, aircraft accidents and the decision process/events leading up to them. Its way more exciting than it sounds.

Jason4Too · · Bellingham, Washington · Joined Apr 2014 · Points: 0

Good discussion.  Usually when heuristic traps come up for me it's in the context of avalanche education.  AIARE likes to teach the FACETS acronym but I feel like that overcomplicates things.  A lot of the heuristic traps that we fall into come down to scarcity, complacency, or social acceptance.  
In the case of the road I would say that there was some complacency due to the fact that the road seemed to be a known road on google maps so it must be ok, right?  Did it turn out to be the right road or was there another way to the trailhead that you had missed?
In the case of the slippery slab I'd suggest the scarcity of engaging climbs led you to take more risk than you would have normally taken.  I don't know what the group dynamic was, maybe there was also some social pressure to show that you're a good lead climber and you were seeking acceptance from the group.

Tradiban · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Apr 2004 · Points: 11,610
oldfattradguuy kk · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Aug 2006 · Points: 172

This is currently a big part of avalanche education 

Josh Rappoport · · Natick, MA · Joined Sep 2017 · Points: 31
Tradiban wrote: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/31/magazine/avalanche-school-heidi-julavits.html

"...every moment you don’t turn around for home, it becomes harder to do so..."

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

General Climbing
Post a Reply to "Heuristic traps and situational awareness"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.