|
|
nathanael
·
Apr 27, 2019
·
San Diego
· Joined May 2011
· Points: 528
Apparently it was a microscender. (Rope solo fb page)
|
|
|
rockhard
·
Apr 27, 2019
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined Jul 2010
· Points: 75
I don't understand why this is even a story...he had a backup knot that eventually stopped him from hitting the ground. just should have tied them more often so he wouldn't scared himself so silly. Then as a previous person mentioned, he should have known how to use a kleimheist. Story is more spray than anything else
|
|
|
Mark Pilate
·
Apr 28, 2019
·
MN
· Joined Jun 2013
· Points: 25
Exactly. Instead of writing an article to Climbing posing as a hardman enlightening us to hidden psychological dangers , he should’ve simply posted to MP first asking how to use his gear and tie a klemheist.
|
|
|
Pete Spri
·
Apr 28, 2019
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined Jun 2009
· Points: 342
Carolina wrote: Seems like a reasonable request to ask what device this guy was using.
glad hes ok I disagree. Likely people would skim the article, blame it on the X device, and not pick up the real info that caused the problem. By ommiting the device, he is literally saying that the device wasn't at fault.
The people that are asking for the device are the very reason that he didn't tell it in the first place: Wrong conclusions.
|
|
|
Mort
·
Apr 28, 2019
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined May 2004
· Points: 21
Fascinating comments. Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk. I have to say writing this article was less than rewarding. The editor took some large liberties, including the take away message about obsession with climbing. That wasn't my title. I originally wrote this for friends and family who read about the fall and saw pictures of my hands on my fiance's facebook page. The original title was "Interesting Day." I tried to incorporate as much humor and understatement as possible, my usual style. Naming routes and grades was for the people who know me or know the area. A friend said "I know exactly where you stopped to tie your backup knot" because there's only one reasonable place to do this on the whole cliff, something I mentioned in the original. I certainly wasn't implying I never fall off 12a's. However, it was very unusual for me to fall from one I'd done many times and really suits my style. Plus, there are only about 50,000 climbers in the world who never fall off 12a's. If that's bragging, then I should mention I once ran a 9-minute mile too.
Someone told me about the intriguing discussion here and I had planned to mention the device, but someone else already did. I was misusing it, so it would be stupid to hold the manufacturer responsible. Climbing Mag had nothing to do with that decision. I thought it was the responsible choice. Misusing it and taking shortcuts was one of the big messages, especially in the original story. I loaded it properly and hung from it many times as I worked my way back up to the anchor.
Someone said the article is all over the place. Probably too many cooks. Climbing had me cut a lot and changed the emphasis of other things. I had mentioned that as a psych prof, "the next several seconds were interesting" and then described the amazing number of thoughts I had in that short time. The strengths/weaknesses interview reference was a JOKE. In the original, I focused on obsessing over plans and being unwilling or hesitant to change them as the real problem. Thus, injuries. I'm sure no one on MP has ever overtrained due to sticking to a goal, or gone for the summit when conditions suggested retreat.
Sheesh! Bitch on and maybe I'll check back in a month to catch up. Jeff Elison
|
|
|
Mort
·
Apr 28, 2019
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined May 2004
· Points: 21
Thanks Pete Spri, you hit the nail on the head.
|
|
|
Mark Pilate
·
Apr 28, 2019
·
MN
· Joined Jun 2013
· Points: 25
Hey Jeff, thanks for chiming in to add perspective to the discussion being had at your expense to some degree. Definitely glad you are Ok and it turned out all right.
That said, I still don’t quite get your point. I re-read the article to refresh my own perspective which may have come across harshly.
Didn’t get the idea of not clipping bolts so as to not ruin the workout, yet tying knots was too much of a workout....
On my first read, it seemed to me like you laid the blame on soloing and now you’ll be fine if you stick to straight sport climbing with a partner. I don’t see the connection. Same shit can happen in ANY type of climbing if you cut corners and don’t have your shit wired.
Maybe that was your point? Focus on what you are doing, instead of what you want to achieve.
Anyway, good luck out there and enjoy. Soloing or not.
|
|
|
Try Cam
·
Apr 28, 2019
·
Ft. Wayne, IN
· Joined Nov 2017
· Points: 0
I enjoyed the article, Jeff, and I empathize with you about editors, whether they are of the professional or armchair variety. I would have liked to read the original.
|
|
|
John W
·
Apr 28, 2019
·
Denver, CO
· Joined May 2018
· Points: 0
I dont get why so many people are caught up on what system he was using, that was not the point of the article. The purpose was self exploration and learning something from his own overconfidence and lack of safety margins.
If you want to know what gear/systems to use for rope soloing, there are plenty of articles dedicated to that already.
Have some humility and enjoy a story, my goodness.
|