Mountain Project Logo

Minimum Number of Pieces for a Trad Anchor?

Nick Goldsmith · · NEK · Joined Aug 2009 · Points: 510

Something out on  Brexies pillar.  

Billcoe · · Pacific Northwet · Joined Mar 2006 · Points: 941

The minimum amount of pieces for a safe belay is zero. Max is, many many. There are so may situational caveats that it would be better to just get a book or a guide.

Colonel Mustard · · Sacramento, CA · Joined Sep 2005 · Points: 1,257
Jaren Watson wrote:

One must work pretty hard to use fewer pieces than that.

I mean, I guess you could tie a big acme 500 lb iron shot putt to your end of the rope and drop it towards your follower, flinging them violently off the climb and to their imminent doom and call it an anti-anchor? Negative anchor? Nanchor? 

I’ve actually gone with zero pieces, it happens. In my case I was stanced in a bowl over the top of a climb and there’s no way I could have been hauled out and over so I saved time and had a chuckle.
Buck Rio · · MN · Joined Jul 2015 · Points: 16

Sometimes a simple hip belay is the safest and best belay you're going to get given the situation. Like during a thunderstorm, when the rope is really wet and doesn't feed through a belay device, and you are just trying to get some shelter.

Jack Servedio · · Raleigh, NC · Joined Feb 2016 · Points: 40
Jaren Watson wrote:

One must work pretty hard to use fewer pieces than that.

Nah - when I'm on routes with bolted anchors or trees for a belay, I always bring a wrench and drill or my chainsaw and bring the anchors home with me. Whenever I have the chainsaw, I find I'm bootying tons of gear too, must be lucky. I find that whenever I rack it, on the way back down there is a ton of abandoned gear and gear just sitting at the bottom, almost like the people climbing on it just ran for some reason. Strange.

Pavel Burov · · Russia · Joined May 2013 · Points: 50

Zero. Sling a good horn at the top.

Tim Opsahl · · South Lake Tahoe, CA · Joined Oct 2016 · Points: 20

How about this math problem, "minimum number of pieces for an anchor before an R runout?"

I was up on South crack of Stately Pleasure Dome in Tuolumne last weekend, and got to the top of the third pitch - let's assume a potential 60 foot runout afterwards.

I made an anchor with 2 .4's and a .75. They were pretty bomber, but I noticed right underneath a .4 and .75, were 2 bomber nut placements in the same slots. So I backed the cams up - a 5 piece anchor before a 60 foot runout.

Assuming the .4s and .75 were bomber, how would that fare a 60 foot fall of 145 lbs individual? Was I excessive?

Paul Hutton · · Nephi, UT · Joined Mar 2012 · Points: 740

Add the kNs of each piece together. 224 lbs/kN. That's how much your anchor will hold, if the rock doesn't break first.

YouTube: Arnaud Petite black bean

Harumpfster Boondoggle · · Between yesterday and today. · Joined Apr 2018 · Points: 148
Paul Hutton wrote: Add the kNs of each piece together. 224 lbs/kN. That's how much your anchor will hold, if the rock doesn't break first.

YouTube: Arnaud Petite black bean

That's not how it works.

At the beginning there may be some load sharing between two pieces or so, but after that the anchor fails sequentially meaning that it is only as strong as the next strongest piece still in the rock.

What multiple pieces add (besides some measure of load sharing at the beginning if there is some attempt at equalization) is redundancy if one of the pieces turns out to be bad (rock/placement etc). But they will never be perfectly equalized which is what would be required to sum their strengths.

Look up the vids of cordellette anchors failing. As the cord stretches there is some load sharing, but after that it fails sequentially.

Paul Hutton · · Nephi, UT · Joined Mar 2012 · Points: 740

What's your source of knowledge? I just took a PCGI course.

What is Arnaud intending with multiple trad pieces equalized together, and 80 ft. Run outs?

Harumpfster Boondoggle · · Between yesterday and today. · Joined Apr 2018 · Points: 148

"I stayed at a Holiday Inn last night" sounds like is worth about as much as your course   .

My source of knowledge is Reality.

Arnaud is attempting redundancy, primarily, and some (unquantifiable) measure of load sharing. Also multiple pieces directionally stabilize each other to some degree which is useful.

Don't get me wrong as there is nothing wrong with redundancy, but their load carrying does not simply sum. Particularly because the direction of load may not be perfectly anticipated leading to individual pieces taking most of all or the load when it comes.

curt86iroc · · Lakewood, CO · Joined Dec 2014 · Points: 274
Paul Hutton wrote: Add the kNs of each piece together. 224 lbs/kN. That's how much your anchor will hold, if the rock doesn't break first.

Please also understand that the load ratings given to artificial protection pieces are determined in a laboratory under ideal conditions based on specific loading scenarios usually defined by an international standard. there are too many variables to say, "because my #3 is rated to 14 kN by black diamond means it will always hold a fall that generates 14 kN."

Paul Hutton · · Nephi, UT · Joined Mar 2012 · Points: 740
curt86iroc wrote:

Please also understand that the load ratings given to artificial protection pieces are determined in a laboratory under ideal conditions based on specific loading scenarios usually defined by an international standard. there are too many variables to say, "because my #3 is rated to 14 kN by black diamond means it will always hold a fall that generates 14 kN."

Yep. Minimum breaking strength (MBS; sometimes stamped onto the gear, right next to the kN amount). Ideal outdoor conditions are clean, stable rock. 

climber pat · · Las Cruces NM · Joined Feb 2006 · Points: 301
Tim Opsahl wrote: How about this math problem, "minimum number of pieces for an anchor before an R runout?"

I was up on South crack of Stately Pleasure Dome in Tuolumne last weekend, and got to the top of the third pitch - let's assume a potential 60 foot runout afterwards.

I made an anchor with 2 .4's and a .75. They were pretty bomber, but I noticed right underneath a .4 and .75, were 2 bomber nut placements in the same slots. So I backed the cams up - a 5 piece anchor before a 60 foot runout.

Assuming the .4s and .75 were bomber, how would that fare a 60 foot fall of 145 lbs individual? Was I excessive?

You were fine either way.  Falling on run-out slab will not generate FF2 forces.

Since the pitch is run-out you might as well u use the extra pieces in the anchor.

Colonel Mustard · · Sacramento, CA · Joined Sep 2005 · Points: 1,257

Making a nest of pro and is always right. That cotton mouthed moment of blind, illogical fear that causes you to frantically shove piece after piece into the rock before you finally summon the requisite resolve to soldier on? Priceless.

No pro. Too much. As long as you’re talking about it afterward, it all worked out.

Scott Powers · · Concord NH · Joined Nov 2014 · Points: 0

Three pieces is the general go to tool for anchors, possibly four pieces if some are smaller.  Even if you think they are bomber.  As others have pointed out there are plenty of cases where two is appropriate.  But I would suggest you consider the 3 piece as your general purpose tool, and any time you use fewer you should be able to very clearly articulate the reasons that that is more appropriate in the situation.  Maybe it is a big alpine climb where you are belaying from a huge ledge and you have a super light rack, or maybe that is all that is available.  Either case you have a clear reason.

Also you should consider your partner and their level of knowledge if you were to decide on using a two piece anchor in general.  They need to have enough knowledge to really understand the risks as well, and as a team you both accept the level of risk.  Also you might want to consider reading some anchor books, or the fall protection section of the Mountain Guide Manual.  

TREEfool · · Hartford, SD · Joined May 2012 · Points: 35
Ryan Pfleger wrote: A three piece trad anchor is my default. If I use more or less than there were extenuating circumstances.

x2

Building anchors is an art and part of the fun for me. Even if I have 2 bomber pieces which I am comfortable with I usually place a 3rd just for fun.

Erroneous Publicus · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jun 2010 · Points: 60
Scott Powers wrote: Three pieces is the general go to tool for anchors, possibly four pieces if some are smaller.  Even if you think they are bomber.  As others have pointed out there are plenty of cases where two is appropriate.  But I would suggest you consider the 3 piece as your general purpose tool, and any time you use fewer you should be able to very clearly articulate the reasons that that is more appropriate in the situation.  Maybe it is a big alpine climb where you are belaying from a huge ledge and you have a super light rack, or maybe that is all that is available.  Either case you have a clear reason.

Also you should consider your partner and their level of knowledge if you were to decide on using a two piece anchor in general.  They need to have enough knowledge to really understand the risks as well, and as a team you both accept the level of risk.  Also you might want to consider reading some anchor books, or the fall protection section of the Mountain Guide Manual.  

And I would suggest you reconsider your dogma.  The premise of this thread is that you have already determined that you have two BOMBER pieces, i.e., there is no reason to doubt either of them (not too small, not shitty rock, not likely to be directly loaded by a hundred foot leader fall, etc.).  The third piece is your tinfoil hat under that scenario.  If you must have 3 pieces to avoid an anxiety attack, clip the third piece to your master point (i.e., use it as a backup), so that the leader can take it with them on the next pitch, if they think they'll need it.  

proto G · · Falmouth (MA) · Joined Jan 2009 · Points: 219
Scott Powers wrote:  But I would suggest you consider the 3 piece as your general purpose tool, and any time you use fewer you should be able to very clearly articulate the reasons that that is more appropriate in the situation.  

Two clear reasons to use 2 bomber pieces (instead of 3) is that it's faster and saves one piece of pro for the next pitch. Provided you can indeed place 2 bomber pieces then these reasons always apply.

Stan Hampton · · St. Charles, MO · Joined Feb 2008 · Points: 0

I think the reason you use 3 pieces of gear is to decrease the probability of the anchor failing.  It's the same reason that we use 2 bolts at a belay when one is definitely capable of holding any force you could generate while climbing.

Ex:

Assume that you are capable of placing good protection in good rock.
Assume that the probability of a placement of protection failing is 0.02.

The probability of failure of a 1 piece anchor is then 0.02.  That's 2 out of 100.

The probability of failure of a 2 piece anchor is then 0.02  x 0.02 = 0.0004.  That's 4 out of 10,000 or 1 out of 2,500

The probability of failure of a 3 piece anchor is then 0.02 x 0.02 x 0.02 = 0.0000008.  That's 8 out of 1,000,000 or 1 out of 125,000.

Which one are you and your partner comfortable with?

PS.  I know of an instance where a 2 piece anchor failed when the leader took a fall at Suicide Rocks several years back.  Apparently the leader built a 3 piece anchor to belay the second up and then took one of those pieces out so that they could use it on the next pitch.  Despite a 100+ft fall and a broken neck he apparently survived.

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

General Climbing
Post a Reply to "Minimum Number of Pieces for a Trad Anchor?"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.