Mountain Project Logo

Ice Boot Help plez

Original Post
Conrad Wanker · · Boulder, CO · Joined Jan 2019 · Points: 50

Hey there! Seeking some help/guidance. I spent the better part of the day trying on as many boots as I could find locally and came away empty handed. I am fortunate to have fairly well stocked local shops nearby and tried on Phantom Techs, Phantom 6000, G Techs, and G Summits, in almost every size I could ask for. The closest thing to a decent fit I could find was a Phantom tech but it wasn't good enough for me to pull the trigger.

Here's my problem. My foot is 9 3/4 in long and 4 1/4 in wide. Just under a 40 on the brannock device and right in between a D/E on width. Combine that with a wide forefoot, narrow and shallow heel with an average/below average arch volume and I'm slipping and sliding in every boot or circumcising my toes to keep em in place. 

Heel lift was more than noticable in every boot I tried despite cutting circulation off to my foot cranking down the laces/boa depending on the boot. Sure cranking the boa helped but theres no way I could sustain that level of pressure for a long duration. 

The biggest takeaway from trying on 10+ pairs of boots today was that the top of my foot isn't making good contact with the inside of the boot when tightened and that allows my forefoot to slide and my heel to lift. The kind folks at the la sportiva store here in boulder pulled out some nepal cube tongue inserts and let me throw them in the g-techs, no dice. Stacked insoles, no dice. 

Boots I'm currently interested in looking at or buy/returning: 

  • AKU- Aurai/Hayatsuki
  • Asolo- Eiger XT 
  • Lowa - Alpine Ice gtx 

Maybe there is some mythical combination of foam insert, insole, heel sleeve that would improve this. If anyone has solutions or ideas I'm here to listen and learn. 

rocknice2 · · Montreal, QC · Joined Nov 2006 · Points: 3,847

Which ice climbing boot similar to the Phantom Tech has a narrow foot and heel?

Gemini replied:

For a technical ice-climbing boot similar in performance and intended use to the Scarpa Phantom Tech HD, but tailored for a narrower foot and heel volume, look at these top alternatives: 

La Sportiva G-Tech / La Sportiva G-Summit: La Sportiva's technical single boots are built on a narrower, lower-volume performance last compared to Scarpa's footwear, offering superior heel retention and a snug fit through the midfoot and heel. 

Salewa Ortles Couloir: On Mountain Project, users note that the Salewa Ortles Couloir runs exceptionally narrow across the board, making it a strong contender if the Phantom Tech feels too voluminous or causes heel slip. 

Asolo Eiger (or Asolo Mont Blanc): Asolo mountaineering boots are widely recognized for having a notoriously narrow heel pocket and lower-volume fit profile, though they should be tried on first as the narrow last can cause pressure points for some foot shapes.

Mike Larson · · Los Angeles, CA · Joined May 2006 · Points: 70

Neoprene ankle booties are going to be your best bet. They come in varying thicknesses so you can really chunk them up if needed. Order a selection off amazon and see what works. Scarpas and LS are pretty similar in the heel lock department these days, with Scarpa wider in the forefoot as I'm sure you found out. Then bring those booties into the shop and get fitting.

I have notoriously low volume ankles and perilously high arches which meant heel slip was a foregone conclusion out of the box. I climbed in Nepals for 15 years (with tongue inserts) because I couldn't get a similar heel lock in any of the Batura line. The ankle booties solved the problem for me with GTechs. And as you probably found out today, GSummits have slightly better heel lock and BOA lacing out of the box, so maybe start there.

You can give Asolos or Salewas or Mammuts a try, but personally I think it's just easier to go with Scarpas or LS and use the ankle booties to dial in the fit.

Bruno Schull · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Dec 2009 · Points: 0

I was going to post exactly what Mike Larson said.  Try neoprone ankle booties.  

Also...

Try wearing two pais of socks, the outer socks with the toes cut off.  

Try insoles with a higher arch or different thickness. 

Try very light ski mountaineering boot and mold the foam inner boot to your foot.  Very stiff, warm, and comfortable.  

Try the Phantom 6000 or the Las Sportiva Phantom 6000 with an aftermarket moldable foam liner from Intuition or Palau. They make light, thin, toungue or wrap liners.  

At the end of the day, the market makes what the market makes...and if you have weird feet you're going to need to get creative and compromise in some area.  

For me, what I can't compromise is warmth.  I'm happy to climb with some slop and lift if my toes are warm.  If your toes go numb, not only is climbing uncomfortable, it's far less precise and secure.  Or, to express it somewhat differently, I can climb steep, technical ice better in larger, heavier, sloppier boots with warm toes...than in smaller, lighter, tmore technical boots with cold toes. 

Good luck!

Mike V. · · Logan, UT · Joined May 2010 · Points: 75

Agree with Bruno and Mike.

I have a wide flat foot. Things which have helped me in the past:

1. Insoles - They eat up volume, and they give me some arch which helps with volume too - I know you said you tried "stacked insoles" but if they're the flat/flopping factory insoles that come with the boots, you might have better success with real supportive insoles.

2. Heel cups - I haven't had a chance to try neoprene cups over the socks (great suggestion), but I've used these inside the socks - https://www.target.com/p/unique-bargains-silicone-non-perforated-heel-protectors-nude-1-pair/-/A-1001552938#lnk=sametab - They eat up a little bit of volume, but most importantly for me, they prevent my heel blisters

3. Lacing - I opt for larger boot so my forefoot isn't in pain, which means heal slop and toe bang - One trick I learned was creating "zones" of tension in the boot. Basically I keep the forefoot loose, and then right around the instep, I do 2-3 twists of the laces (think the starting point of a surgeons knot) before lacing above the instep and ankle. That way I can cinch down my instep/ankle without tightening my forefoot

4. Heel Ramps and Boot Boards - I do this in my skimo boots (Dynafit TLT series) - https://skimo.co/boot-hardware

Aaron Liebling · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jun 2010 · Points: 957

Similar feet similar solution: insoles

Echo Echo · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Apr 2020 · Points: 0

The Aurai is very Low volume, the new Aurai Evo fits differently, as the toe box is wider but the rest of the boot remains low volume including low vertical height inside the boot. They are oddly kind big externally though. The new Evo I find the boot touches my foot everywhere inside though so ended up returning as my toes were always touching the end even in really big sizes.

The Asolo is really nice, again less vertical height than the phantom. It is a very flexible boot however, more so than my b2 boots. I liked it a lot but the heel cup put a lot of pressure on my heel 


also, try an insole in the phantom

Grant Watson · · Red Deer, AB · Joined Feb 2023 · Points: 13

Remember that the big feature of the G-Summit is the ability to loosen off the Boas at the belay and crank 'em down again when climbing, so the "long duration" pressure might last a much shorter time than you're thinking.  No, I don't work for La Sportiva, but man, do I love that feature!

poop mcfart · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Nov 2024 · Points: 0

I have very narrow feet and ultimately live with a little bit of heel lift with the LS boots. It hasn't really hindered me yet. i think the tongue inserts can help. another thing is ankle wraps or j bars for ski boots.

supposedly the North face ones have a narrow heel and still feature the BOA, i can't seem to find anywhere near me that stocks them, maybe they do in Boulder though.

I would also like to add in one other possibility, many first time ice boot buyers maybe take the dont let your toe touch the front when you kick a little too literally, I do wonder if one of the problems here is that you are going a little too big on your boots? i have met many people who have told me they went too big on their first pair of boots and had to go smaller later. my boots are on the smaller side of acceptable and I have not lost  toenail yet.

NateC · · Utah · Joined Feb 2013 · Points: 1

I have the Asolo Eiger XT. It’s been a phenomenally good boot.

The Phantom Tech is the closest fit for me before I got the Eiger. I had to lace it super tight and put thick insoles in it and barely had a heel lock. I had foot and calf pump like crazy and my feet were always cold.

The Eiger fits my lower volume foot, and skinny ankles well. My forefoot is wide and flat and my heels are narrow. I hope this helps.

FWIW, I wear a 42 in both boots. 

Adam Stone · · New Franklin, OH · Joined Sep 2020 · Points: 10

You might consider the boot that fits you the best, and try the tongue inserts from a set of LS Nepals.  It may help with the heel lift , and alleviate some of the lace pressure. A good boot shop should have the tongues in stock, or at least a set you can try.  I believe you can buy them separately direct from LS.

Larry Morgan · · Longmont, CO · Joined Mar 2024 · Points: 0

Wildcat Mountaineering in Lyons carries Zamberlain if you want another potential option to try. 

I wish I could find Asolo Eigers in person. They seem like exactly what I want when I decide to upgrade.

Evan Gerry · · Redding, CA · Joined Nov 2016 · Points: 15

I have an average heel, E/EE width and low arches, sportiva and scarpa are too narrow for me, Lowa Alpine Ice fit perfectly.

Conrad Wanker · · Boulder, CO · Joined Jan 2019 · Points: 50
Mike Larson wrote:

Neoprene ankle booties are going to be your best bet. They come in varying thicknesses so you can really chunk them up if needed. Order a selection off amazon and see what works. Scarpas and LS are pretty similar in the heel lock department these days, with Scarpa wider in the forefoot as I'm sure you found out. Then bring those booties into the shop and get fitting.

I have notoriously low volume ankles and perilously high arches which meant heel slip was a foregone conclusion out of the box. I climbed in Nepals for 15 years (with tongue inserts) because I couldn't get a similar heel lock in any of the Batura line. The ankle booties solved the problem for me with GTechs. And as you probably found out today, GSummits have slightly better heel lock and BOA lacing out of the box, so maybe start there.

You can give Asolos or Salewas or Mammuts a try, but personally I think it's just easier to go with Scarpas or LS and use the ankle booties to dial in the fit.

Is there a specific link you can point me to? or ones youve had success with? looking at a variety atm 

Mike Larson · · Los Angeles, CA · Joined May 2006 · Points: 70

These are definitely my favorite. You can find them in different thicknesses.

Alyssa K · · South Lake Tahoe · Joined Mar 2014 · Points: 46

+1 for EZeeFit, I use the ultrathin. I tried on every boot on the market, insoles, tongue inserts, boot fitting foam, and nothing else worked as well. 

Rock O'Clock · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Dec 2025 · Points: 0

Also +1 on the ezeefit. I had to use them with my LS g5 evos, now with my g summits they are optional, but they are comfy and any improvement in fit is an improvement. I also wear them in my 3 season boots and ski touring boots to keep my heel/Achilles tendon comfier and make my socks last longer. 

Guideline #1: Don't be a jerk.

Ice Climbing
Post a Reply to "Ice Boot Help plez"

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.