Camp Nano 22’s - sticking wire gates on some
|
|
I replaced most of my larger wire gates with Camp nano 22 mini wire gate carabiners last year, mostly to save weight and bulk on my harness. Last week while leading a mixed bolt/trad route, I clipped a bolt and the wire gate stayed open. I manually closed it and kept climbing. My partner let me know when he cleaned that he noticed it sticking open also. Since then I went thru all my carabiners opening them to make sure they snap shut and I found one other Camp nano 22 that felt sticky, didn’t get stuck in the wide open position like the other one but it didn’t close all the way. I cleaned with warm soap and water thinking they got some dirt in there but it didn’t help. I retired two out of about 30 of these carabiners. Considering these were a year old at most and visibly looked fine, I’m not going to buy these again. I may actually go back to the larger sized Camp photons I was using previously because clipping the rope into the larger carabiners is so much smoother and easier than the small ones (sometimes get my fingers stuck while clipping the rope). Just wanted to let yall know to check your Nano 22’s for sticky wire gates if you use these carabiners…. |
|
|
My nanos do this from time to time, but I think the photons are actually worse. When I notice it, I give then a quick spray of silicone lube and they stay good for quite a while. |
|
|
I put cam lube on the gate attachment point and they’re usually good for years. Give it a try. |
|
|
I've used many makes and models of carabiners. I've noticed a significantly high malfunction rate with CAMP wire gates carabiners in general, not just the CAMP nano 22. During the same conditions and maintenance schedule (zero), no other wire gates ime get sticky as eagerly as CAMP wire gates. They're certainly cheap and light; I avoid them. |
|
|
Yep, my old photons all have eventually stuck but as others have said, cam lube/silicone spray seem make em good as new. It is a bummer because they're great 'biners otherwise but I'm not sure its something to be worried about from a larger safety perspective, i.e. a gate getting stuck is a safety issue but maybe not indicative of a greater structural safety issue. |
|
|
My CAMP photon after a couple years. 3 photons of 8 draws were sticky, stiff, and staying open. A drop of bike chain dry lube in hinge made them all crisp and feel like new again. |
|
|
Jeez people clean your 'biners! Yes, Camp's biners get sticky if you don't take care of them. Take care of your gear and it will take care of you. Warm soapy water and some lube will have them back to normal in no time. White Lightning bike chain lube is a great option. |
|
|
Dirt is a thing at play here for sure, which can be mediated with washing and lubing. There is also sometimes a torsional component where just kind of tweaking the gate side to side will take care of it. This happens with Nanos, Photons, and Dyons. I’ve kind of moved away from using CAMP wire gates, at least partly because of this phenomenon. It’s an easy enough fix, but the fact that it happens so frequently is a turn off. |
|
|
I recently moved to dmm alpha and aethers after getting some sticking gates on my photons |
|
|
Drop of chain lube, good as new. Ta-da |
|
|
Camp wire gate Biner‘s sticking open is not a phenomenon, It is normal. These are the only biners I’ve ever encountered that stick open on a routine basis. They are fucking junk. It is a very simple fix. They simply need to redesign the way the gate works. My buddy got all of his biners replaced by Camp, unfortunately, rather than giving them his money back, which is what they should’ve done, they gave him a gift certificate so he bought all solid gates from Camp, these seem to be fine, but generally, I would not buy them or even take them for free. I really hate this Biner, mostly because I climb with people who own them and literally every single time, there’s biners that stick open. Unfortunately, somebody will die or get seriously injured from falling and having the camp Biner stay open. In fact, I’m surprised they haven’t been sued out of existence yet. It seems ridiculous because I guarantee the fix is very easy, having used multiple other Wiergate carabiners that do not do this and never need to be cleaned and have never been lubed. This is not user error. This is an engineering flaw that camp has refused to fix. They know about the problem, but haven’t done nothing about it, this is embarrassing and, will likely lead to a lawsuit and then they will be forced to redesign it if they can stay afloat. |
|
|
This is my buddies rack of photons that he returned to camp and got a gift certificate for 300 and something dollars and bought solid gate biners because of the poor design of the photons, he did not want to buy any more Photons or nanos because it’s an obvious flaw in the gate design of the biner. PS he washed and lubed these biners multiple different times . |
|
|
Yeah CAMP biners are the only ones that have ever stuck open for me. I've bootied a fair few that I would never climb on because they stick open so bad. Nanos were generally ok for me, but man even new photons sometimes stick open. Also personally not a fan of how the tension of the gate feels (hard to start and tension eases off). I've found Trango Phases to be a good enough equivalent for nanos, and WC Heliums to be good replacements for photons (albiet more expensive). |
|
|
CAMP has been having these biner issues for all 20 years I've been climbing. I really doubt they're ever going to change. I limit my half dozen Nanos to racking biners for big alpine missions because that's the one role they can't seriously screw shit up in. Dyons are my favorite biner (along with Ange) and I've never had any issues with them, but part of me worries it's just a matter of time. The fact that CAMP's advertised weights are always wildly exaggerated I think speaks to their general quality control (I've never had a Dyon weight under 35g, despite a catalog weight of 33g). Anytime a partner has a rack of all nanos or photons, I insist we use my gear. |
|
|
I have literally never had this issue and i've owned/own a couple hundred CAMP carabiners I've also weighed my nanos and photons and not had more than 1g variance ever. Maybe I'm just lucky. Never had anything but a good experience with CAMP stuff. |
|
|
I've had this issue as well. |
|
|
Cosmic Hotdog wrote: Yup - throw a few drops of cam lube in there. This has always worked for me. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Little splash of silicone spray |
|
|
I ditched all my nanos and photons for this reason. Switched to bd litewires. |








