Half Dome's Snake Dike is being retrobolted - get involved!
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: I can totally see someone who has no appreciation of climbing history and what a classic route like this's value is, being willing to throw a load of bolts in and devalue the whole thing. Edit. Not a boomer myself. I can still understand why routes like this should be left well alone. Bolt this and you've just got another scramble with a good view. No sense of achievement in that 2nd edit for shitty typing |
|
|
Someone who wants that adventure can skip the bolts (it’s possible, I’ve seen the Alex handhold movie) and have that adventure. Someone who doesn’t want to skip the bolts can also have a fun time and admire the people who had to do without back in the day. This anti bolt boomer religion doesn’t make sense in 2026. Chopping bolts is more exclusionary and disrespectful than allowing people to choose the type of experience they want to have. National parks are for everyone (it’s not called boomer national park for a reason). |
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: Someone who doesn't want the adventure could conceivably climb one of the other countless low grade sport routes that exist, no? Can't remember for sure but I don't *think* Honnold was wearing a harness and trailng a rope on his solo. That'd probably make him clipping something to bail if he was kacking his pants slightly hard.
|
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: This age shit is just bigotry. Age is not relevant to the issue. You should keep your bigoted "thoughts" to yourself. |
|
|
Adam is just fishing for a reaction, probably trolling. Just ignore him and hopefully he'll get bored and find someone else to bother. Focus on the people engaging in good faith and don't waste more pages on him. |
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: You're either trolling or are an obtuse, willfully and aggressively ignorant idiot. Folks, don't be like Adam. |
|
|
Yosemite is a traditional climbing area, steeped in the foundational history of our sport. Routes like SD (in its previous state) are imperative, transformational stepping stones for bigger objectives. Being able to climb very runout 5.4 is an essential skill for the mountains. And fuck just because it’s on HD should have no bearing of why that needs to be changed. Just like countless others have said, just go climb the cables route if you aren’t ready for the commitment SD takes. If you want modern bolted actual sport routes, not a traditional route with bolts, then there are plenty out there- JFC Adam, your comments make me want to go chop bolts and have more R rated routes. But clearly I need to go touch grass, read some Twight, and stop worrying about self righteous sanitizers all while trusting that the guardians will restore things to the way they should be. BTW I’m a millennial. |
|
|
Keeping the drift alive: I'm a Gen Xer and I don't think anyone not using their full name is arguing in good faith. Sorry, not trying to be a dick, but if one can't stand behind their name, then their position is lacking from the onset. There are a few good reasons but a lot of bad excuses for not using full names. I also recognize as a white male I'm granted a ton more leeway in society than others. |
|
|
Byra is winning the troll contest bigly, I didn't expect it |
|
|
M M wrote: I think Byra is a bot. |
|
|
Daniel Shively wrote: OMG! I think that’s it!! |
|
|
Adam Byra wrote: Instructions unclear....I took my motocross bike up the falls trails, I shot guns at peregrines while on el cap cause they probably taste good, caught fish by using huge nets across the merced cause I suck at fly fishing, brought a jack hammer to make good stairs to the top of mt watkins cause climbing it would be way harder, reinstated the REAL fire fall cause that shit seemed dope AF..... |
|
|
Todd Berlier wrote: Many of the most experienced and thoughtful people here don't post under their full name. You don't think phylp phylp, Glowering, rgold, or Tal M are posting in good faith? Just because someone doesn't want random climbing memes and debates about Snake Dike to be on the first page of search results for their name by potential employers doesn't mean they are insincere or have something to hide. I just don't think my memes could compete on the current job market. |
|
|
Collin H wrote: They are, but not as good of faith as using one's full name. Good faith isn't black and white. It's on a continuum, imo. I'm also thankful for all the above's input on this thread (and yours) and MP in general. Always thoughtful and thoughtful provoking. I'm not trying to slander them.
To me this falls into the bad excuse category.
I don't understand this. |
|
|
Sorry, that last bit about memes on the job market was supposed to be a joke haha. The joke being that other applicants have better memes than I do and that in reality employers almost certainly don't care what I post here. My basic point is that one might not have a great reason for their decision to remain partially anonymous, but that's independent of whether or not they are being sincere about their own beliefs and their efforts to understand those of others (which is my definition of good faith). My bad for the confusion and further thread derailment! |
|
|
It took me over a year to figure out who rgold was, boy was I slow. Not that I ever knew him. There are several people I suspect I have met, BITD, but don’t have any real idea about who they are. |
|
|
Todd Berlier wrote: Todd didn’t you just say “I don't think anyone not using their full name is arguing in good faith”? Doesn’t sound like a continuum to me! Just messing with ya. Not that I need an excuse, but my profile on here used to use my last name, I only changed it once my brother started making a career in climbing because I did not want my MP shitposting to potentially affect him. I’ve never aimed to keep my identity private, even my Reddit account is very clearly linked to me as an individual. The lack of SEO results is indeed pretty nice though. Bit of a generational difference, as mentioned - I’ve now been on multiple podcasts saying all of the same dumb stuff I say on here, so certainly not a fear of standing behind my positions. Also, I know half you mf pronounce my last name wrong (and probably my first) when you read it in your heads and that bothers me so I’d rather just have you botch my first name when you’re talking trash about me |
|
|
Tal M wrote: Lol! Y'all are right, sorry for the drift and misplaced criticism! |
|
|
Mr Rogers wrote: FREEDUMB! |
|
|
I bet Sloan rides an e bike |




