Mountain Project Logo

11yr old climber falls at Smith Rocks

Brandon R · · CA · Joined Mar 2006 · Points: 223
Andy Shoemaker wrote:

I'm not sure how "I'm in direct" doesn't convey an action.  I personally prefer to use "BELAYER'S NAME, I am safe. Take me off belay" when that many words can be easily heard by my belayer. I never use the words SAFE or OFF BELAY in a climbing setting for anything other than this command.

Many would argue that this many words is a cluster f and if my partner and I know that "i'm in direct" and "i'm safe, take me off belay" are synonymous I see no issue with that approach.

It only conveys action if the belayer knows what you want them to do when you say "in direct" or "safe". "In direct" and "safe" are really only status updates and any action inferred are open to interpretation by the belayer. "Off belay", on the other hand, is a direct command to the belayer. There is little to confuse about that. Of course, what you prefer to use works just fine because it includes the actual action/command that you want your belayer to do. 

Some people do say "in direct" to mean "off belay", while others only say it because they want slack but still want to stay on belay. Those particular words should just never be said at an anchor. Way too much room for confusion. 

Colonel Mustard · · Sacramento, CA · Joined Sep 2005 · Points: 1,257

I hope I only ever imagine the anguish of this situation. My best to Cohen in his recovery. Cleaning anchors is generally simple but obviously not casual, we should not send a beginner up to do that task.

duncan... · · London, UK · Joined Dec 2014 · Points: 55
Yury wrote:

What can go wrong with government owned monopoly?

Just google for what's happening in Canada, UK, Australia etc.
Trust me, you do not want to deal with such system.

I don't need the doubtful benefits of a google search, though I can quote health economists if you like since I work with them. I've dealt with (worked in or been on the receiving end of) US, UK, and Australian systems.  Trust me, anyone preferring the US system has a financial interest in it or is bonkers. 

Best of luck to the lad and his family. 

Yury · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Oct 2014 · Points: 0
duncan... wrote:

Trust me, anyone preferring the US system has a financial interest in it or is bonkers. 

You must be progressive woke liberal.
Up here in Canada we can only dream about services you can get down there.
You already spend higher percent of GDP on government funded health care than in Canada.
You need just to fix a small gap - health coverage of independent contractors and small businesses.
I strongly believe that this can be done within already available budget.

Dhayan Roark · · Crowley Lake, CA · Joined Jan 2010 · Points: 10
Yury wrote:

You must be progressive woke liberal.
Up here in Canada we can only dream about services you can get down there.
You already spend higher percent of GDP on government funded health care than in Canada.
You need just to fix a small gap - health coverage of independent contractors and small businesses.
I strongly believe that this can be done within already available budget.

You think it’s so great because you don’t live here. Any system can be run poorly but clearly health care is going suffer when profits are involved. If you have the same people running it but their goal is to provide optimal health care and not milk the most profits possible then what do you think the outcome is? It’s really not that complex…

Dhayan Roark · · Crowley Lake, CA · Joined Jan 2010 · Points: 10

I wish Cohen the fastest and most complete recovery possible. 

slim · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Dec 2004 · Points: 1,083

do we know for sure that the adult(s) knew what they were doing?  we have been running into this more frequently, where the "adults" appear to have no idea what they are doing.  they have heard that climbing is "safe", so no need to worry...

Max Tepfer · · Bend, OR · Joined Oct 2007 · Points: 3,683

The rumor I heard is that he was prerigged and tethered, but unclipped the anchor instead of the tether when he began his rappel.  Leaving him tethered instead of solely prerigged is certainly a contributing mistake, but the bigger mistake is leaving a child unattended at the top of a cliff when they're learning something that consequential.

Russ Walling · · Flaky Foont, WI. Redacted… · Joined Oct 2004 · Points: 1,216
slim wrote:

do we know for sure that the adult(s) knew what they were doing?  we have been running into this more frequently, where the "adults" appear to have no idea what they are doing.  they have heard that climbing is "safe", so no need to worry...

Well one can never really know without witnessing it.  But, that being said it saddens me to learn that people on this very thread, many that consider themselves to be actual climbers, are not operating under the safety umbrella that title should bring.  YET, they did not know you could high clip a biner or draw on a pre-threaded anchor to not only make it safe for a neophyte rapper, but also reduce wear on the anchor.  That is mind boggling.  

Speedy recovery to the boy.

amarius · · Nowhere, OK · Joined Feb 2012 · Points: 20
Max Tepfer wrote:

The rumor I heard is that he was prerigged and tethered, but unclipped the anchor instead of the tether when he began his rappel.  Leaving him tethered instead of solely prerigged is certainly a contributing mistake

Could explain this in greater detail? 

Andy Shoemaker · · Bremerton WA · Joined Jul 2014 · Points: 35
amarius wrote:

Could explain this in greater detail? 

Possibly the rope was never through the chains.  It was only through "a toprope anchor" (4 lockers and an equalized cord) that was clipped to both bolts.  Climber clips tether onto "toprope anchor" to rest at top of climb.  Then climber mistakenly unclips both lockers in the bolts and leans back and the whole system falls away from the chains never having been used.  

Just typing it out gives me the willies.

Alex Fletcher wrote:

If what Max Tepfer said the rumor was is what actually happened then there’s not that much than could have been done. 

I hadn't considered until your post that the route may be equipped with mussy hooks.  Man.  That's heart breaking to know even if all best practices were followed this young guy might have mistakenly dropped the rope right out of the mussy hooks and fallen.  And the only way it could have been avoided is like you state Alex- adult at the anchor waiting for the kid, additional belay, etc.  

I never even considered this possibility with open system anchors.

Screenshot from High Desert Climbers Alliance's website from Smith Rock:

CritConrad · · Bend, OR · Joined Aug 2010 · Points: 651
Andy Shoemaker wrote:

Presumably the rope was never through the chains.  It was only through "a toprope anchor" (4 lockers and an equalized cord) that was clipped to both bolts.  Climber clips tether onto "toprope anchor" to rest at top of climb.  Then climber mistakenly unclips both lockers in the bolts and leans back and the whole system falls away from the chains never having been used.  

Just typing it out gives me the willies.

A similar accident happened in Arkansas when I lived there in college.  Leader climbs a route and sets up a TR on two quickdraws.  The second person follows the route on top rope and cleans the draws as they climb up, he clipped into the draws themselves (he considered that his "anchor" because that's what they were top roping through), unclipped his rope from the quickdraws.  He then untied his knot, threaded the rope BACK THROUGH THE QUICKDRAWS (again which he thought was his "anchor") and tied back in.  He proceeds to unclip the quickdraws from the anchor and decks from the top of the route.  He was miraculously not seriously injured!

When someone is learning like this with a friend coaching them by yelling from the ground it is understandable that they don't comprehend the basics of what the actual anchor is or the fundamentals of transferring their weight while hanging on an anchor 60 ft off the ground. It all stemmed from simple communication errors and the fact that he was not being directly supervised by a more competent climber.

Tradiban · · 951-527-7959 · Joined Jul 2020 · Points: 212
CritConrad wrote:

A similar accident happened in Arkansas when I lived there in college.  Leader climbs a route and sets up a TR on two quickdraws.  The second person follows the route on top rope and cleans the draws as they climb up, he clipped into the draws themselves (he considered that his "anchor" because that's what they were top roping through), unclipped his rope from the quickdraws.  He then untied his knot, threaded the rope BACK THROUGH THE QUICKDRAWS (again which he thought was his "anchor") and tied back in.  He proceeds to unclip the quickdraws from the anchor and decks from the top of the route.  He was miraculously not seriously injured!

When someone is learning like this with a friend coaching them by yelling from the ground it is understandable that they don't comprehend the basics of what the actual anchor is or the fundamentals of transferring their weight while hanging on an anchor 60 ft off the ground. It all stemmed from simple communication errors and the fact that he was not being directly supervised by a more competent climber.

I would expect any adult to be able to assess their own situation (If I unclip this, what will happen???) but an 11 year old doesn’t have the wherewithal to know the consequences of their actions.

Alex Fletcher · · Las Vegas · Joined May 2016 · Points: 252

If what Max Tepfer said the rumor was is what actually happened then there’s not that much than could have been done. A pre-rigged rappel is the industry standard in descending with inexperienced followers. Leaving a tether attached could create confusion and if “The Anchor” was a temporary personal gear anchor rather than permanent chain anchor then that could create more confusion.

A belayed (from above) rappel could work here but how many recreational parties even know how to do that procedure?

Another possible choice would be to have an adult below (fire fighters belay) and an adult above (close supervision of what’s clipped and not clipped). Of course that may be ideal, but realistic?

Like it was mentioned, if this was a pre-rigged rappel gone wrong then that is extremely sad as that’s considered one of the best options for inexperienced followers. It goes to show there’s more that can go wrong even when you’ve done your best. 

I wouldn’t place blame on others for this accident. It’s just unfortunate for all involved. Climbing is dangerous and we engage in it willingly just like so many other activities. 

Alex Fletcher · · Las Vegas · Joined May 2016 · Points: 252

I agree that pre-rigging rappels and removing everyone’s tether prior to anyone beginning to descend makes for the least moving parts later on, but there are still errors that can be made.

If the first rappeller unweights the rope the follower will fall if their hands are not holding the rope. A proper and well executed transition from weighting the rope into firefighter belay is a requirement.

I’ve known people to fall 40 feet before (thankfully) being caught because of this error. 

I have personally had a follower that didn’t realize they needed to use their hands on the rope at all to control their rappel. Another catch with the firefighter belay in that instance. 

John RB · · Boulder, CO · Joined Oct 2016 · Points: 194

I know this is maybe not the best place to say this but...

Mussy hooks save lives.  Maybe not in this situation, but generally for single pitch routes that are often led.

Please consider donating to ASCA (and maybe your local climber's coalition if they're doing similar work).  safeclimbing.org 

(I'm not affiliated with them, just another supporter.)

amarius · · Nowhere, OK · Joined Feb 2012 · Points: 20
rock climbing wrote:

I have friends that would not top rope through mussy hooks even after I told them it is ok.

Good on them - mussy hooks are for lowering, not top-roping. 

Mr Rogers · · Pollock Pines and Bay area CA · Joined Aug 2010 · Points: 92
amarius wrote:

Good on them - mussy hooks are for lowering, not top-roping. 

Unless people who put the fixed gear in give the okay.... Like I and My friend have done at Cosumnes and several other crags. We happily replace them as they become worn.
However I completely agree, the default is be to use your own gear until you know otherwise. Our stance is not the norm, and I tell folks that its not be expected at other crags, but sure saves time and people doing stupid shit at the anchor. CRG sees lots of beginners and I have seen many bad/dangerous anchors by newbs that I or others have to take the time to call out because we don't want to see any meat sacks falling.

amarius · · Nowhere, OK · Joined Feb 2012 · Points: 20
Mr Rogers wrote:

Unless people who put the fixed gear in give the okay.... 

I applaud you, very nice gesture. Unfortunately, it is not going to serve the climbing community - even though what you did, i.e. allowing top roping off fixed gear, is extremely convenient, it is an exception to the rule. Climbers used to this convenience are extremely likely to attempt something similar at crags that do not allow top roping off fixed gear, with numerous gumby-bashing threads on mountain project to follow.

Edit - I almost felt like posting a flaming post about some clueless climbers top-roping through HANGERS, but I thought nobody would believe it.

Brandon R · · CA · Joined Mar 2006 · Points: 223

Outdoor climbing accidents won't be decreased by turning it into a padded romper room, that's what the gym is for. It'll likely just foster a culture of dependence, where one doesn't need to learn necessary skills at smaller/easier crags, then move on to other crags to have their accident there instead. The only thing that is going to improve accident stats is fostering a culture where people that choose to do something so obviously dangerous such as rock climbing understand and take it upon themselves to carefully learn how to do so in a safe(r) manner. More learning > more hardware (but I do love some mussys on single pitch cragging). Invest in that if you want to make a difference. Also, see Snake Dike thread.

This topic is locked and closed to new replies.

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.