Mountain Project Logo

11yr old climber falls at Smith Rocks

amarius · · Nowhere, OK · Joined Feb 2012 · Points: 20

I realize each crag has preferred anchor cleaning ethic - what is used at Smith - lower or rappel?

Garrett Genereux · · Redmond · Joined Apr 2012 · Points: 35

LOWER. It is rare to come across a single pitch route at a popular crag that hasn't been equipped with SS mussy hooks thanks to the High Desert Climbers Alliance and dedicated individuals. 

Climb On · · Everywhere · Joined Jan 2016 · Points: 0
amarius wrote:

I realize each crag has preferred anchor cleaning ethic - what is used at Smith - lower or rappel?

I’m not a local but I’m visiting at the moment. I haven’t seen anyone rap a single pitch sport yet. 

Lane Mathis · · Denver, CO · Joined May 2017 · Points: 306
amarius wrote:

I realize each crag has preferred anchor cleaning ethic - what is used at Smith - lower or rappel?

When sport climbing, lower all the time unless it's impossible. 

Alex Fletcher · · Las Vegas · Joined May 2016 · Points: 252

@Marc801 C : these skills and techniques need to be continuously passed down for them to become common use.

@Amarius : lowering is the recommended technique for all single pitch climbs. Rappelling has more transitions and therefor more room for errors to occur. The simplest way down is the safest. I will lower. I will encourage others to lower. I will help pay for and replace the worn hardware caused by lowering. Worn hardware costs less to replace than medical bills.

Rappelling is obviously a necessary skill in climbing and should be practiced before it’s needed. But in general lowering or walking off is the safer option. 

Andy Shoemaker · · Bremerton WA · Joined Jul 2014 · Points: 35

Hopefully with the large uptick in new climbers heading outside we are able to work together as a community to encourage always lowering from bolted anchors.  Threads like this are helping to inform some percentage of those new climbers.  

This could have been far more tragic.  Mega thanks to the first responders that took good care of this young fellow.  Hopefully its a full recovery and he is out on the playground at school next fall.

Anyone know where folks who can afford it can donate directly to the first responding organizations in this case like alot of folks do for our local mountain rescue team following a rescue?

FrankPS wrote:

AV, 

What is your solution to solving the American health system? Free, nationalized healthcare?

Less "free" and more "no cost at time of service" since I'm sure many read this and shouted "nothing should be free!!!".  With an estimated $150 trillion in personal wealth in the US and somewhere between $30 and $50 trillion in the hands of the top 1% it seems pretty reasonable to expect the tax system to come up with the money to provide quality health care that the majority of Americans believe is a basic human right.

FrankPS · · Atascadero, CA · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 276

For being the wealthiest nation on earth, we are 33 trillion in debt. Maybe we are the brokest nation on earth!

Andy Shoemaker · · Bremerton WA · Joined Jul 2014 · Points: 35

Without the skilled personnel who responded to this tragedy it could have been even worse.  Anyone know who else was there for the rescue?

Support the staff and infrastructure of Smith Rock State Park:

https://store.oregonstateparks.org/index.cfm?do=v.dsp_donation

Support Deschutes County Search and Rescue: 

https://www.deschutessearchandrescue.org/donate/

Support the folks replacing worn out hardware in Smith Rock and elsewhere in eastern Oregon:

https://www.highdesert.rocks/donate

Waiting to hear back from Redmond Fire/Rescue on how to send donations.  Couldn't find any website or contact for Jefferson SAR or a way to donate directly to Oregon SP.

alpinist 47 · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Mar 2017 · Points: 0
FrankPS wrote:

For being the wealthiest nation on earth, we are 33 trillion in debt. Maybe we are the brokest nation on earth!

Or greediest!

Please stop

Bye

Garrett Genereux · · Redmond · Joined Apr 2012 · Points: 35
Andy Shoemaker wrote:

I just emailed Redmond Fire and Rescue (one of the responding organizations to this accident) to ask how folks can donate directly.  Will update this post when I hear back.

Couldn't find a way to donate to the Oregon State Police who also were reportedly on scene.

Anyone know who else was there for the rescue?

I was not there but would have to assume that Deschutes county SAR and perhaps Jefferson county came down as well since Smith is so close. 

Tradiban · · 951-527-7959 · Joined Jul 2020 · Points: 212

Not even I would dare turn this thread into a political debate. Y’all should be ashamed of yourselves.

Andy Shoemaker · · Bremerton WA · Joined Jul 2014 · Points: 35
Tradiban wrote:

Not even I would dare turn this thread into a political debate. Y’all should be ashamed of yourselves.

You right. Thanks for the wake up call. 

Climb On · · Everywhere · Joined Jan 2016 · Points: 0
Andy Shoemaker wrote:

I just emailed Redmond Fire and Rescue (one of the responding organizations to this accident) to ask how folks can donate directly.  Will update this post when I hear back.

Couldn't find a way to donate to the Oregon State Police who also were reportedly on scene.

Anyone know who else was there for the rescue?

The park rangers were there as well.

Brandon R · · CA · Joined Mar 2006 · Points: 223

I actually prefer to rappel on single pitch if there are no mussy hooks, and feel it's (marginally) safer. Most accidents (I think) aren't due to the rappelling or the transition itself, but due to miscommunication between climber and belayer. There's just too many people who aren't crystal clear with their commands. As the climber, if I choose to rappel, I take the worst consequence of miscommunication out of the equation and regain full control of my safety. It's easier to control my own speed of descent, can't be lowered off the end by a belayer looking up at me (vs a rappeller looking down), causes less wear to hardware and ropes, and frees up a member of the party to do whatever. Mussies are a different story though... I can't deny their convenience. 

I don't know if lowering instead of rapping would have made any difference in this accident though. In either case, if you remove your connection to the anchor before you're connected to the rope (either on rappel or tied in and ready to lower), you're in for a bad ride. The quote below is a little confusing and might just be the frantic ramblings of a very worried grandfather though, so who knows what really happened. 

Cam Brown wrote:

I was in the area when the boy was being loaded into the EMS vehicle with the medics. The grandfather was walking behind the vehicle and told me that his “grandson was preparing to rappel and instead of removing his PAS, he disconnected or removed the anchor completely”.

From what I was told by the grandfather, the boy was inexperienced and was rappelling without direct supervision at the anchor. I was very upset  to hear the response as there are so many ways to have someone rappel safely if they are learning to rappel. That being said, simply lowering is the recommend choice at a single pitch crag.

FrankPS · · Atascadero, CA · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 276

Sounds like this is not a rappel vs. lowering accident as much as it is a result of inadequate adult supervision.

Sad.

Alex Fletcher · · Las Vegas · Joined May 2016 · Points: 252

@Brandon R 


A lot of the communication issues stem from using the phrase “in direct.” I cringe every time I hear it.

When climbers communicate, our calls are followed by actions. Calling “in direct” does not convey an action to be done so shouldn’t be used.

Calling for “Slack” “Tension/Take” or “Lower” all convey an action.

The unclear communication that occurs is when a belayer hear’s “in direct” and chooses to interpret that as “off belay” when that was not the command given. Then the climber, who may be expecting to be lowered, is no longer on belay.

Instead of using “in direct” please just say “slack” if that’s what you want! 

@FrankPS

Unfortunately you may be right. It is my recommendation that inexperienced followers should have their mentor at the anchor with them to clean together for their first few times. I belay up a follower to clean the anchor frequently. Sometimes lowering or sometimes rappelling. 

highaltitudeflatulentexpulsion · · Colorado · Joined Oct 2012 · Points: 35
Cam Brown wrote:

From what I was told by the grandfather, the boy was inexperienced and was rappelling without direct supervision at the anchor. 

If this is accurate, that’s practically criminal.

Tradiban · · 951-527-7959 · Joined Jul 2020 · Points: 212
FrankPS wrote:

Sounds like this is not a rappel vs. lowering accident as much as it is a result of inadequate adult supervision.

Sad.

Please, is anyone out there is considering a new operation or just isn’t 100, call the Tradiban Hotline ^^^ and I will talk you through it. Call from the anchor if you have to, we can F Time if need be. And please always be Tech safe and have your phone on a lanyard. 

Namaste

Andy Shoemaker · · Bremerton WA · Joined Jul 2014 · Points: 35
Alex Fletcher wrote:

When climbers communicate, our calls are followed by actions. Calling “in direct” does not convey an action to be done so shouldn’t be used.

I'm not sure how "I'm in direct" doesn't convey an action.  I personally prefer to use "BELAYER'S NAME, I am safe. Take me off belay" when that many words can be easily heard by my belayer. I never use the words SAFE or OFF BELAY in a climbing setting for anything other than this command.

Many would argue that this many words is a cluster f and if my partner and I know that "i'm in direct" and "i'm safe, take me off belay" are synonymous I see no issue with that approach.

Based on reports, it seems miscommunication was NOT the cause of this accident.  A lapse in judgement by the one(s) with the expertise, climbing with an inexperienced climber without expertise seems to be the root cause.

Yury · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Oct 2014 · Points: 0
Dan Schmidt wrote:

Posted this earlier to IG: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/1468-0009.12647

The third bullet point in the summary pretty much nails it:

  • US health care is, increasingly, publicly financed yet investor owned, a trend that has been accompanied by rising medical costs and, in recent years, stagnating or even worsening population health. A reconsideration of US health care financing and ownership appears warranted.

What can go wrong with government owned monopoly?

Just google for what's happening in Canada, UK, Australia etc.
Trust me, you do not want to deal with such system.

This topic is locked and closed to new replies.

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.