Last Exit
|
|
Over the past three decades, a “hyper development” model of new routing has become prevalent in Washington. From its inception this has been a detrimental model to follow and unless we change course our ability to explore and climb new crags in the future will be needlessly constrained. Once Index stood apart from this style of development; however, the Town Walls are no longer an exception. Climbing is harmed by creating a new route by squeezing in a line of bolts. It is often best to leave some routes as top ropes. This is true on short crags with easily accessed tops but it is especially true on crags with a top roping tradition; however, many routes without walk up accessible anchors are also best left unbolted. We don’t lose much personally when we climb with a little restraint and doing so will help keep the future of WA climbing alive. |
|
|
You should probably elucidate these points if you want anyone to take them seriously. Right now this kinda just comes across as a curmudgeonly rant. I'm not seeing any real arguments to work with. First, how are you defining hyperdevelopment? Links to especially egregious examples would be very helpful in understanding what you mean. How does hyperdevelopment constrain future development? Are you saying we should wait to develop routes so that future climbers can develop the same routes, only later? Or are you saying if we develop too much too quickly it will lead to access issues? If it's the latter, give examples. How is climbing harmed by squeezing in a line of bolts and what are some clear examples? Again, links would be helpful. When and why are routes best left unbolted when there is no other way to access them? Give examples. What do you mean by "climb with a little restraint"? To me, that sounds like knocking on holds and double checking my gear. |
|
|
I agree that there are some recent squeeze jobs that have gone up in Index and it sort of feels like every square inch of climbable rock will be tapped out in the not too distant future, but I'm also curious if you have any examples that spurred this discussion? |
|
|
I am for new routing and I don’t think Index is close to being climbed out. It’s not a matter of specific routes that have inspired a "curmudgeonly rant." I hope people will be able to explore and develop new routes there and other places for years; however, the hyper-development model will bite climbers in the rear if it continues to be followed. It’s just not sustainable especially when publicized by sites like MP. Land managers will crack down. I just happen to be fond of Index so I thought I’d comment about Index. |
|
|
Darryl, I'm pretty sure we agree on this issue. The problem I'm having is that I don't really know what you are trying to get at or who you are trying to reach here. You are saying it's a problem at Index, but you don't know of any specific examples. If we can't point to routes or walls as examples of squeeze jobs or hyperdevelopment then there isn't anything we can learn from. Also, if we want to say the land managers will crack down, then we need to justify that claim with examples. I worry about this, but I'm not aware of any good examples (maybe hueco? But that's mostly bouldering so kind of different). The most hyperdeveloped, squeeze-jobbed, unnecessarily bolted area I know of is horseshoe canyon ranch, but that was all actively encouraged/forced by the (private) land managers. I also don't really know what you mean by hyperdevelopment without examples since that term seems entirely subjective. I'm just trying to help get us all on the same page so that a conversation is possible. I do think it's a good conversation to have. |
|
|
I honestly don’t understand how adding 20 bolts to a wall with 100 has any threat of access. Also I wish people developed more it’s pretty feasible to climb every route at your ability level in a year or two in western Washington. I simply do not understand why fewer routes are better or how any land managers actually care. The ones I have talked to seem to mostly prefer no one die beyond that they don’t seem to care if a wall has 200 bolts or 10. Also if anything there is more restraint in climbing development there are significantly more climbers now and far far fewer develop. This post really needs specific examples of how these things are problems and not the theoretical abstract. |
|
|
Trevor Taylor wrote: Totally agree with this perspective. I'm anti squeeze job as much as anyone but don't see the harm in new routes going up at established areas that don't contradict the existing ethic the crag was developed under. Caveat: I know route quality is subjective, but I've been guilty of visualizing a potential line as better than it is solely because I wanted to establish it. Lesson learned. Developers should toprope the shit out of a potential route and get other people on it before sinking in bolts or doing a substantial amount of cleaning, especially if you'll need to remove lots of moss/lichen/habitat. i.e. does the wall really need a wandering and ledge-y route that was dug out of dirt and moss and choss? Probably not. Consider how many developers have stared at the wall and chose not to develop that line. That should say something.... |
|
|
Trevor Taylor wrote: Funny you should say that. I might be wrong I seem to recall we discussed something those lines, and I seem to recall you mentioning severe accidents/deaths wasn't such a big deal.... |
|
|
Franck Vee wrote: Haha well they honestly seem to care about the non climbers more. Like someone going up a 4th class scramble thinking it’s a hike, rockfall, scared children. And maybe people actually climbing and dieing en masse one or two deaths isn’t anymore dramatic than fishers having strokes out in the water. Also I don’t know if the vantage tower being tipped over with a truck jack story is true but if that isn’t heavy handed behavior I don’t know how anything these days could be worse. Also just vantage in general has so much history of heavy handed behavior I don’t know how scrubing moss in index is even close. |
|
|
I think developing is fine as long as it’s done properly and in good rock. Seriously a top rope route, is not any different of an eyesore with all the chalk. You really have to look for bolts, plus there would be extra impact from people constantly walking around to set up tr’s and probably abuse to trees as anchors. But…Trevor claiming you can climb every route in western Washington within your ability in a couple years is rediculous. I would place any amount of money that you couldn’t climb every route 11d and under in just index in 2 years, to be honest probably not a chance in 5 |
|
|
saign charlestein wrote:I think developing is fine as long as it’s done properly and in good rock. Seriously a top rope route, is not any different of an eyesore with all the chalk. You really have to look for bolts, plus there would be extra impact from people constantly walking around to set up tr’s and probably abuse to trees as anchors. Yeah^ honestly bad rock is way way too much effort.
I was a bit hyperbolic but for me in 2.5 years in Washington I only have 15 5.11s left in the exits and 15 in vantage most of which either seep or are gross or long hikes or alone amongst other climbs. It definitely depends on how much you climb but if someone is a 5.11 trad climber and lives in Everett I would imagine they would get through index pretty fast at least fast enough that more routes would be preferable. The main point I was making was that in most places with rock there is actually way more climbing Lander, Boulder, Bend, or New Hampshire there are a lot more routes across all climbing disciplines and Washington has enough rock but nowhere near the density. I would love more 5.11 to low 5.12 to onsight for after work cragging (which index is a pain for). |
|
|
i don't think it will be the bolts that get things shut down. it will be the mass scrubbing of all of the lichen and moss. once they find some rare/endangered/remotelyinteresting flora you guys are toast. that being said, without weekly scrubbing the routes are going to vanish within a year or so, so i don't really know what can be done about it (other than get used to climbing on moss and choss). |
|
|
saign charlestein wrote:I think developing is fine as long as it’s done properly and in good rock. Seriously a top rope route, is not any different of an eyesore with all the chalk. You really have to look for bolts, plus there would be extra impact from people constantly walking around to set up tr’s and probably abuse to trees as anchors. I guess "done properly" is the entire issue. When you write "You really have to look for bolts, " I realize how diverse people really are - I would have thought someone walking up to the "Garden Wall" or "Fun Forest" would have noticed the bolts without effort. The erosion issue is very real but also a special case and not generally applicable. Good climbing, I am off to Mt Rainier for a week.. |
|
|
Good for Daryl calling out the ugly fully industrialized nature of route development particular at Index these days The installation of via ferratas at crags strikes me as "egregious example of hyperdevelopment". They're an eyesore, a potential safety hazard and are going to be an absolute disaster to maintain when whatever cheap rebar was used inevitably rusts out. And honestly they seem to be the product of someone who likes to construct rebar ladders for the sake of constructing rebar ladders more so than for any actual utility. Consider what value the northern slabs ladder adds over just walking by K-cliff. Or the couple steps added in the gully headed to the Diamond. I'm of the impression that developers at Index sort of led the way here and that style of development has now extended elsewhere. In the case of the Space Wall near Newhalem via ferratas we installed during a ban on further route development in an area managed by a national park. NOCA is now actively deciding what to do there Planning Document. Long term I really doubt this particular action is going to improve the climber/ land management relationship. Establishing new lines anywhere requires removing loose rock and in the northwest a substantial amount scrubbing. But where's the line? Consider the full scale unearthing/deforestry that's occurring on the Lookout Wall. I mean the effort expended there is absolutely mindboggling for I'm not sure what kind of end result. Like the via ferratas it flies under an land manager radar but again export this elsewhere and the outcomes could be very different. Finally throw in the 1-*, bound to moss over, squeeze jobs everywhere, ugly and unnecessary fixed draws on the UTW and a couple hundred fixed lines on everything from classics to moss caked gullies and you've created a genuinely unaesthetic experience.
|
|
|
Darryl Cramer wrote: Fun Forest is one thing but I don't think anything is wrong with Garden Wall. There used to be 2ish routes there including the ltr crack and the 5.8 plus Knob Job, and if I have my info right no one ever climbed them except knob job. I'm guessing because they were sooo dirty. The three new bolted routes are high quality, especially the .11+, and since the whole wall got cleaned so many more people will climb there now and be spread out from the LTW. I get that you didn't like bolts at the top of the crack but IIRC the gear is not good there so it wouldn't make sense to leave the bolts off of the sport routes. It may be 'preserving' the routes to leave them as they were but as a developer I think you should embrace people climbing your routes and if bolted routes next to them increase traffic from 0 to 2 people a day, that is a good thing. Tldr, the new garden wall routes are good. |
|
|
But yeah the via ferratas are dumb and I don't see the point. The one in the quarry is extremely ugly even tho no one goes over there, I think. Choss is classic and one star routes are often choss so... |
|
|
Darin Berdinka wrote: Yeah I know nothing about the via ferrata and would be fine if it disappeared.
I don’t really think the index via ferrata and the space wall via ferrata are the end of the world.
I think we can point to a lot of crags where this level of development has occurred… lookout point is not some exception. World wall 2, world wall, mazama, most vantage climbs and Tieton. It’s some major recent bias to think removing moss and some choss at lookout point is even close to as egregious as judgment day at world wall.
Has any development experience been aesthetic? Also who cares if it is aestic? Like I want climbs, the cost of new climbs is those things, they aren’t that bad, I’ll live with it. More importantly how do you think it should be done. Should there be some pre approval process? Or should a group of people come to an agreement about what there gonna do and if they break a few eggs they live with that. I want more routes, I hiked 45 min for a forgotten 5.13 today and there was 2 strangers on it, maybe new routes are good…and maybe we can live with the minimal cost. |
|
|
Daniel Chode Rider wrote: An interesting story about that very crack that involves the OP. Note that the story was recently told to me by the belayer. I was not there. Darryl can probably correct the story, but anyway- On an early attempt of A Touch Too Much (that crack), perhaps just before the FA, Darryl leads past the flaring-crack crux section, cruising through the easier finish, gets right up to the top, and somehow peels off. The fall nearly puts him on the ground. I may have heard about this back in the 80s, and it might be why I never tried to lead it. (Besides, TRing routes is perfectly satisfactory for me.) But coincidentally, Steve S- recently called me to remind me of the story, suggesting that I post it on the route's page. Nowadays, I suppose that event couldn't happen as there is a bolt to clip. Of course, leaders are welcome to refrain from clipping. And the TR person can ask their belayer to give them a huge loop of slack to replicate the grip factor. Edit to add a note about the 'hyperdevelopment'. If you don't like what you see at a specific crag or route, please try to directly contact the people who might know more about that specific route or crag. I think this leads to more constructive dialog without airing 'dirty laundry'. Just a request... On this note, I recall getting a phone call in the early 80s after someone cut down a dozen or so trees at the base of the Lower Town Wall. He wanted to know who did it and why. Well, it wasn't me, but I did know who did it and why, so I simply told him. And that was that. A few years later, a company leases some land next to the Country cliff, cuts far more trees down and drills a huge hole in the rock, using the rock dust to effectively make a parking lot area (though not used as such now). |
|
|
i'm glad to see other folks questioning the whole via ferrata rebar rungs thing. when shawn snyder started his rebar rung shit at smith i asked several times how that was any different than those at index, and just heard crickets chirping. |
|
|
The real tragedy of the new routes at Garden Wall is all the COVID themed names. If I had a nickel for every route called "social distancing" put up in the last year... |
|
|
You'd have $50 and 80 cents |





