What's up with Victory Whippers?
|
|
I'm a big ol' gumby (as evidenced by my MP ticks list) and I'm a bit confused by the "ethics" surrounding victory whippers. Not the ethics regarding bolt wear, as others have passionately discussed in another thread, but the ethics of "did you get truly send or not". My understanding of a victory whipper is a fall taken right at the anchors to celebrate finishing a route, meaning the climber obviously hasn't clipped the anchors. I also understand that the definition of redpointing a route means you clip the anchors/last bolt. I think victory whippers are rad and am working up the balls to try them soon, but these definitions don’t seem to line up. Are people who take victory whippers not claiming a redpoint? Are they doing something to prove they could have clipped the anchors and didn’t just blow the last move? I’ve asked some of my more experienced partners and they didn’t have much of an answer. Personally, I feel that people should choose their own definitions of a “send” (within reason) so I see this discrepancy as fine, but I know other people interpret things a little more rigidly. Please let me know if I’m understanding things wrong, or if this discrepancy is just something people live with. |
|
|
I think you are looking for a hard definition of redpoint that most climbers just don't care about. For most people, if you get to the end of a route and slap the chains or hang from the clipping hold, and then jump - that is a send. I would assume for most people that if you are in control at the end of the route and purposefully whip, then your send "counts" for whatever that is worth. |
|
|
So you really think that people are taking victory whippers because they were too pumped to clip the anchors? If you want to have a discussion about whether being able to clip the anchors and choosing not to, is somehow different from being able to clip the anchors and clipping them, and that such a distinction matters to anyone, more power to you I guess. |
|
|
I would prefer if we kept climbing anchors for top rope only. Keeps it clear for people trying to dial in the route. |
|
|
I’ll give anyone the “send” if they choose to take a victory whip over clipping and lowering. Slap the anchor, jump and scream. Holla. |
|
|
A victory whip is my strategy when I fail to bring enough draws but still want that sweet send. |
|
|
Seriously? This is what ya’ll mad about today? |
|
|
Ive always clipped the anchors, cheered or whatever, then unclipped the anchor and then.... tally ho! Again, Im sure if someone is in control at the anchor and not sketch festing, it counts |
|
|
Scenario 1: I got to the anchors, pumped out of my mind, attempted to clip the anchors, couldn’t do it, let go of the rope, and taken a fall—no send. And no victory whip, in my book. Just a fall, at the end of almost-redpointing the route. Scenario 2: I got to the anchors, slapped the biners, and yelled, “woohoo! I’m going to victory-whip!” And then taken a fall—redpoint, and victory whip. The only time it would matter in the slightest would be a situation where the clipping of the anchors is the actual crux of the route. There ARE routes like that. But very few. And even on those routes, you and your belayer would know the difference between getting to the top with gas to spare for anchor clipping, and falling from the last hold because you had nothing left. |
|
|
Choss Cowboy wrote: Shit there's some 30m routes with one bolt mid way near me. That would be one heel of cheese grater slide! |
|
|
Victory whips are so much sweeter when you clip your own draws to the wall and just throw yourself off the top of a overhang |
|
|
The real purpose of victory whip is to deny the top rope to your lazy pals. |
|
|
Thanks for the helpful replies everyone! I guess people take the specifics less seriously than I'd come come to believe. |
|
|
Choss Cowboy wrote: I'm a bit confused. Are you saying you want to keep the anchors clean so one person can top rope a route at the same time someone else works it on lead? And then the leader victory whips instead of lowering off the anchor? |
|
|
High Plains Drifter wrote: Nah, he's just making a poor attempt at trolling. |
|
|
High Plains Drifter wrote: This is where you’re wrong. Unless you’re an 18-year-old male, every fall is potentially dangerous. Weird shit happens. I’m not trying to take giant wingers unnecessarily. |
|
|
Porch Henry wrote: Because they’re indestructible! ;) |
|
|
I once had this happen on a project: I clipped the 6th bolt off the final kneebar, did the crux, pumped out of my mind and holding the clipping hold for the anchor (a sloper I could barely hold on to). I couldn't let go with either hand to clip. I could have just slapped the chains and fell (bolt at my feet... no biggie) or even grabbed the chains. But there was no way I could have pulled up rope and clipped when I was that pumped. According to folks here I could have just taken the send? Just claim you could have clipped the chains but chose not to? In my book you need to clip the chains for the redpoint. Or at least one chain. If you really want to whip, just pull up the rope, flick the gate of the last biner (without clipping the rope) then let go. You get the bonus whip with all that rope out too! |
|
|
John RB wrote: Nope. No one here is saying that. If you reach the anchors but you can't clip the anchors and you fall, no one would call that a victory whipper. Well, no one with self-respect. |
|
|
|
|
|
“Victory whippers” count as sends only on friction slab. Thems the rules. Deal with it. |




