Mountain Project Logo

How many of you regularly use 2 piece anchors?

Hson P · · Berkeley, CA · Joined Nov 2017 · Points: 54

If I’m low on gear, I’ll use two pieces to bring up my second, then add a third with gear they cleaned from the pitch once they arrive at the anchor.

Derek DeBruin · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Jul 2010 · Points: 1,129

Interesting to note in this thread the mentions of taking gear out of the anchor to give to the lesder. If anything, it's the leader fall that's more likely to rip the anchor, not the top roping by the follower. Sometimes it might make more sense to take a piece from the follower when they arrive to buttress the two piece top roping anchor and add some security for the lead.

Colby Wangler · · Reno · Joined Oct 2015 · Points: 392

I almost always use just two bolts as an anchor, figure it’s plenty safe. 

John Pitcairn · · Arapuni, Waikato · Joined Jan 2015 · Points: 1

Does one sketchy #4 cam and a sitting heel-brace count? My second fell off too.

Russ Bangert · · Yosemite · Joined Jun 2011 · Points: 57
Derek DeBruin wrote:

Interesting to note in this thread the mentions of taking gear out of the anchor to give to the lesder. If anything, it's the leader fall that's more likely to rip the anchor, not the top roping by the follower. Sometimes it might make more sense to take a piece from the follower when they arrive to buttress the two piece top roping anchor and add some security for the lead.

What's interesting is that some people feel the need to focus on the possibility of FF2 on an anchor when it's rare and easily avoidable in most situations. Most climbers go their whole career without doing it, and it's extremely obvious when you do and don't need to worry about it. Not every anchor needs to protect against it. 

JaredG · · Tucson, AZ · Joined Aug 2011 · Points: 17
John Pitcairn wrote:

Does one sketchy #4 cam and a sitting heel-brace count? My second fell off too.

Your butt counts as a piece, and a heel-brace counts as a piece, so that's actually a 3-piece anchor.

Fabien M · · Cannes · Joined Dec 2019 · Points: 5

As someone else mentionned I think the most important it to be adaptable. Depending of many variables the best/only option may be a 3 pieces anchor, a 2 pieces anchor or a 1 piece anchor. In any case, you need to be confortable with what you are setting up and be convinced (as much as possible) that its a solid anchor.

Rob D · · Queens, NY · Joined May 2011 · Points: 30
Ted Pinson wrote:

For a TR anchor yes (we just had an accident where someone was climbing on a single tree anchor that failed when the sling cut on an edge) for lead only if it’s on the small end.

dont' want to nitpick, but if you just use a piece of cord or long webolette and tie a knot you instantly have redundancy on the anchor without adding another piece of gear (unless the tree falls....)

rocknice2 · · Montreal, QC · Joined Nov 2006 · Points: 3,847
Rob D wrote:

dont' want to nitpick, but if you just use a piece of cord or long webolette and tie a knot you instantly have redundancy on the anchor without adding another piece of gear (unless the tree falls....)

Well it depends. If the anchor is a bombproof tree but the single sling is a girth hitched and draped over the edge. Then it not redundant, even with a knot.

I hear a lot of up voting the two piece anchor but with the caveat "if it's two SOLID pieces" is somehow lost in the message. While this statement can be true it's irresponsible.

The tried and true trad anchor is 3 pieces and for good reason. The OP is somewhat beginner trad leader asking what we REGULARLY do for an anchor. Almost everyone responded with a massive dick swinging reply of when they use 2 pieces anchors. I'm sorry but that's fucking bullshit. It's 3 solid pieces whenever you can get them. Are there exception?... of course there are but they are the exception not the rule. None of us are infallible so we need to take the appropriate steps to ensure that the anchor is always redundant. And while two redundant pieces are adequate the third is added to compensate for human error. There is an increased safety margin with 3 vs 2 pieces as someone eluded to up thread.

I can't count how many YouTube videos I've seen when the leader rips upto 3 pieces in a row and decks. Even more videos of placements that I was surprised could even hold the weight of the quickdraw. How many posts of exploding X4's. Everyone thought they were placing bomber gear.

I always use 3 pieces when I can, which is 99% of the time. I've made anchors by just digging into the snow with me ass and heels. That doesn't mean I'd say, to some new leader, it's OK to do it that way. The time to use these simplified anchors is when you don't need to ask on the internet. It's cause you know what you're doing.

"You're on belay just don't fall."

Ted Pinson · · Chicago, IL · Joined Jul 2014 · Points: 252
Rob D wrote:

dont' want to nitpick, but if you just use a piece of cord or long webolette and tie a knot you instantly have redundancy on the anchor without adding another piece of gear (unless the tree falls....)

For sure.  If I’m at a tree my preferred anchor for multipitch is to wrap it with a looped cord and tie a figure 8.  But if I’m setting something up at the top and leaving it unattended for multiple people to take laps on, I’m gonna look for a second arm.  There’s no reason not to improve your odds when setting from the top like this.

Ackley The Improved · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Mar 2020 · Points: 0

One must take into account any upward pull.

It might take one plus placements just for that.

Ackley The Improved · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Mar 2020 · Points: 0
Buck Rio wrote:

If there are two perfect pieces, a third isn't really going to add much. This is two nuts. Sorry for the bad pic, but that top nut is in a slot, and could never come out on its own. The bottom nut is also bomber. I just used a 120 cm runner to connect them. My static line is tied off there as a back up. we rapped the static line that is cloved to the master point. 

If a belayer was pulled upward against the bottom nut?

Edit- looks like upward pull placements available too.

Jim Titt · · Germany · Joined Nov 2009 · Points: 490

It means the top piece is now the belay.

climber pat · · Las Cruces NM · Joined Feb 2006 · Points: 301
Ackley The Improved wrote:

If a belayer was pulled upward against the bottom nut?

Whatever piece that pulled the belayer up is still in the system and apparently adequate.

David Gibbs · · Ottawa, ON · Joined Aug 2010 · Points: 2

I consider a 3-piece gear anchor to be my standard.  Do I ever make exceptions?  Yes, sometimes, but they are the exception.  

(Two bolts is fine.  A single solid tree is fine -- but I'll make sure that I've got that tree wrapped with a redundant sling.)

Ackley The Improved · · Unknown Hometown · Joined Mar 2020 · Points: 0

Gifts from the mountain —horns, pinches, trees, i never pass up if quick and on route.

I F · · Curled up under damp leaves… · Joined Mar 2017 · Points: 4,386
rocknice2 wrote:

Well it depends. If the anchor is a bombproof tree but the single sling is a girth hitched and draped over the edge. Then it not redundant, even with a knot.

I hear a lot of up voting the two piece anchor but with the caveat "if it's two SOLID pieces" is somehow lost in the message. While this statement can be true it's irresponsible.

The tried and true trad anchor is 3 pieces and for good reason. The OP is somewhat beginner trad leader asking what we REGULARLY do for an anchor. Almost everyone responded with a massive dick swinging reply of when they use 2 pieces anchors. I'm sorry but that's fucking bullshit. It's 3 solid pieces whenever you can get them. Are there exception?... of course there are but they are the exception not the rule. None of us are infallible so we need to take the appropriate steps to ensure that the anchor is always redundant. And while two redundant pieces are adequate the third is added to compensate for human error. There is an increased safety margin with 3 vs 2 pieces as someone eluded to up thread.

I can't count how many YouTube videos I've seen when the leader rips upto 3 pieces in a row and decks. Even more videos of placements that I was surprised could even hold the weight of the quickdraw. How many posts of exploding X4's. Everyone thought they were placing bomber gear.

I always use 3 pieces when I can, which is 99% of the time. I've made anchors by just digging into the snow with me ass and heels. That doesn't mean I'd say, to some new leader, it's OK to do it that way. The time to use these simplified anchors is when you don't need to ask on the internet. It's cause you know what you're doing.

"You're on belay just don't fall."

At first I wanted to take issue with "somewhat beginner" but that's probably fair. I consider myself competent but that doesn't make up for time and mileage I guess. Anyways, this has been pretty enlightening. Dick-swinging or not I'm actually super surprised this many people do regularly use 2 pieces and call it solid, but that's why I was asking. To those remarking on trees, 2 bolt anchors, and the such I guess I should have been more specific as yes I understand how those things work. I wasn't really asking for advice, but I guess thanks to those that gave it even though I understand the principles of anchor building. I really was just curious about 2 piece gear anchors, and I got a lot of input back and I appreciate it! Keep on doing your thing, I'm not getting down on you choosing to place less pieces and wasn't trying to imply such, just asking a question. 

Buck Rio · · MN · Joined Jul 2015 · Points: 16
Ackley The Improved wrote:

If a belayer was pulled upward against the bottom nut?

Edit- looks like upward pull placements available too.

Rap line, we are at the top of a cliff. You either TR or rap in and lead out, so no need for an upward, but for sure available.

Dave Olsen · · Channeled Scablands · Joined Dec 2019 · Points: 10
climber pat wrote:

Whatever piece that pulled the belayer up is still in the system and apparently adequate.

Adequate for?

Getting pulled off the belay stance and having the anchor fail can lead to bad things.

climber pat · · Las Cruces NM · Joined Feb 2006 · Points: 301
Dave Olsen wrote:

Adequate for?

Getting pulled off the belay stance and having the anchor fail can lead to bad things.

Adequate for holding a fall and the weight of both climbers.  Seems like all you really need.

This topic is locked and closed to new replies.

Log In to Reply
Welcome

Join the Community! It's FREE

Already have an account? Login to close this notice.