Anyone know what knot this is?
|
|
|
Rethreaded bowline. Telltale sign is the double-loop of rope through the tie-in points. |
|
Agree. Sort of a short tail though. |
|
Victor K wrote:Agree. Sort of a short tail though.Not an issue; the entire second half of the knot is effectively a "tail" (compare it to a regular bowline, which is absolutely sufficient on its own). |
|
Gunkiemike wrote: Not an issue; the entire second half of the knot is effectively a "tail" (compare it to a regular bowline, which is absolutely sufficient on its own).Indeed, I´ve never even seen it tied with a stopper knot and it´s the usual tie-in around here. |
|
Yep. My go to. We call it the paranoid bowline |
|
Anyone have step by step pics? |
|
Joe - no pictures, but hopefully this description will help. |
|
Joe Garibay wrote:Anyone have step by step pics?http://www.animatedknots.com/bowline/index.php?Categ=climbing#ScrollPoint Just retrace at the end should be simple enough to follow. So if you follow these pictures to get a normal bowline than just follow where it ends and follow back around until you get to the start than tie a stopper knot. |
|
Thanks. I'm familiar with a single bowline. Wasn't sure if the double was just retraced or almost looked like a step through, i.e. a girth on a bite. (Alpine girth)? I don't know, throwing darts. |
|
You can tie it as a "step-through" (called bowline on a bight ), but that's totally unnecessary as a tie-in knot. |
|
Joe Garibay wrote:Anyone have step by step pics?The knots appendix at mutipitchclimbing.com |
|
Joe Garibay wrote:Anyone have step by step pics?Yes, I've explained how to tie it with photos. It's somewhere on this forum under a topic relating to the bowline. I dont tie the double fishermans at the top, instead I take the tail and run it back through using the Yosemite finish which keeps the tail out of the way. Tied that way, it's basically the most secure version of the bowline used in climbing and it's in essentially three knots tied in series making it pretty bomber. |
|
David Coley wrote: The knots appendix at mutipitchclimbing.comDavid Coley's website is a great resource, except he apparently can't spell "multipitch". :) Here's the direct link to his knot page, the rethreaded bowline (retraced bowline) is about 1/3 way down. people.bath.ac.uk/dac33/hig… |
|
This has been my standard knot for everything except the gym where it's not allowed. It's about as quick to tie as a figure-8 and super easy to untie after falls. |
|
The DAV did tests a few years ago and rated the rethreaded bowline equal to the rethreaded 8 in security and strength but better than the 8 in terms of getting the knot untied after loading. |
|
rgold wrote:The DAV did tests a few years ago and rated the rethreaded bowline equal to the rethreaded 8 in security and strength but better than the 8 in terms of getting the knot untied after loading.Does that mean that, like the fig 8, the rethreaded bowline doesn't need a double overhand backup knot? It just feels wrong to me to use an iteration of the bowline without a backup knot. |
|
We commonly use the double loop bowline on bomber two-point anchors like two bolts seen here. Something to keep in mind when using as a tie-in is the integral part of your system checks - ABC (Anchor, Belay, Climber) and knot inspection. My 8 & 9 year old can look at your figure eight and see if it's right or wrong. If you were tied in with a double-loop bowline the vast percentage would be giving you the WTH is that look -- this is not to be understated accidents occur from incorrect tie-ins. |
|
eli poss wrote: Does that mean that, like the fig 8, the rethreaded bowline doesn't need a double overhand backup knot? It just feels wrong to me to use an iteration of the bowline without a backup knot.No it doesn´t. We don´t teach it that way in Germany and the backup knot is completely superflous as the "spare" end of the rope is trapped all the way through the knot.It´s the standard tie-in knot for sport climbers at least in the part of Germany I live in. Having two loops spreads the wear on the tie-in points aND the re-threaded bowline is immune to ring loading. Where it´s not a good knot is with two ropes where it all starts getting a bit bulky in the harness so for trad I change to a re-threaded 8 (without a stopper naturally!). |
|
eli poss wrote: Does that mean that, like the fig 8, the rethreaded bowline doesn't need a double overhand backup knot? It just feels wrong to me to use an iteration of the bowline without a backup knot.I don't know whether the DAV commented on backup knots for these knots, but a backup knot certainly never hurts anything. If not backed up and the end went entirely through the knot you'd still have a single bowline with a very long tail, so it is hard to think of a backup knot as absolutely essential. However, if you use this knot to anchor a fixed line to two anchors, one loop to each anchor, then you must use a backup knot, because one of those loops is a single bowline to one of the anchor points. I'd use something else for this purpose anyway. The rethreaded bowline (let's not call it a double bowline, that's something else) is pretty common in Europe, so it seems at least some climbers are capable of checking it. Personally, I'd use the rethreaded bowline as my regular knot but with half ropes, that's four strands through the tie-in points---gettin' a little crowded. |
|
Deja Vu |