Mountain Project Logo
To save paper & ink, use the [Hide] controls next to photos and comments so you only print what you need.

Mystery Achievement

5.7, Sport, 110 ft (33 m),  Avg: 3.2 from 371 votes
FA: Jay Goodwin 1983
Idaho > S Idaho > City of Rocks > Breadloaves > Super Hits - Bloody F…
Warning Access Issue: (1) Weather Wall, Yellow Wall, & all the crags north of Twin Sisters are CLOSED. (2) There are no longer trash cans in the park. (3) Highlining ban in place for CIRO and CRSP DetailsDrop down

Description

Start up a right-trending ramp toward the first bolt. Make consistent and fun face moves on incredible holds up the face and finish by pulling a sweet bulge right before the anchors.

Route History: "Mystery Achievement" was originally put up in a traditional style by climbing ranger Jay Goodwin in 1983. Protection consisted of some small gear and less-than-inspiring slung horns. In 2014, Jay bolted the line in an effort to increase traffic and to add another well-protected moderate to the City.

Location

Follow a right diagonally going crack to a featured face that is located just to the right of "Twist & Crawl". 

Protection

11 bolts. Chain anchors. 

Photos [Hide ALL Photos]

Mystery Achievement. Awesome 5.7 bolted line with a steep VB finishing move you could find in a climbing gym
[Hide Photo] Mystery Achievement. Awesome 5.7 bolted line with a steep VB finishing move you could find in a climbing gym
Positive holds abound on Mystery Achievement
[Hide Photo] Positive holds abound on Mystery Achievement
Dad half way up Mystery Achievement on the right. Climbers at the top of the 5.6 Chimney in the middle and Bloody Fingers to the left.
[Hide Photo] Dad half way up Mystery Achievement on the right. Climbers at the top of the 5.6 Chimney in the middle and Bloody Fingers to the left.
Runout easy bottom, good bolting thereafter.
[Hide Photo] Runout easy bottom, good bolting thereafter.
cool roof feature on top of mystery achievment
[Hide Photo] cool roof feature on top of mystery achievment

Comments [Hide ALL Comments]

Vanessa Fabian
Jackson, WY
 
[Hide Comment] has since been retro bolted, and is a very fun climb. May 7, 2013
Rob Albert
  5.7
[Hide Comment] This route is very good, and should not be missed by 5.7 climbers. Fun, safe, a good intro to sport climbing. May 14, 2013
RKM
Alpine, Utah and Almo, ID
 
[Hide Comment] Mystery Achievement is no longer a Mystery or an Achievement. May 19, 2013
Michael Mahoney
Gillette, WY
  5.7
[Hide Comment] Bomber bolts have been recently added. THIS IS NOT AN "R" RATED CLIMB ANYMORE! Jugs the whole way up including over the roof (very fun move) that make this feel like a gym climb. Great Anchors at top. One of my favorites at the City! Jun 9, 2013
Rodger Raubach
Billings, MT
[Hide Comment] A 70 meter rope is needed for a single rope rappel, or lowering. Still...tie knots in the rope ends! Jun 25, 2013
Justin Streit
Las Vegas, NV
  5.7
[Hide Comment] Well protected (maybe too many) with bolts now make this climb a City of Rocks classic at its grade. A great route to learn to lead as well since the bolts are so close together. Sep 6, 2013
TNORM
  5.7
[Hide Comment] FUN!!!!! Morning Sun. Can use a 60m if you down climb the ramp. Sep 29, 2013
Dr. Long Arm
  5.7
[Hide Comment] As fun as it gets for 5.7! Great jugs and an awesome roof pull at the top. Apr 27, 2014
DavidCollins
Grand Junction, CO
  5.7
[Hide Comment] Long and fun! Well protected for a beginning leader once the first bolt is clipped. However, it does take a 5.6/5.7 move to get to the first bolt and this is about 25ft above the ground. Beginning leaders may think about this. Jul 26, 2014
Ben Mackall
Bozeman, MT
 
[Hide Comment] Decent variation that goes up the enticing fingercrack (gear) to the left of the first bolt, joining up with the bolt line above the prominent rail at 1/3 height. Nov 10, 2014
[Hide Comment] Climbed this 2015, with and without clipping bolts. Fun climb, but definitely memorable when you lead it on gear. bring extra cams or weighty gear to keep your slings from popping off the knobs. Jan 4, 2017
Jay Goodwin
OR-NV-CA-ID-WY
[Hide Comment] There is truth in both Bingham's and RKM's comments. This was a risky lead, though not technically difficult, because the pro was mostly slings on sloping horns - some pretty good, many kind of sketch. I had never seen anyone on it since I put it up - hence the decision to retrobolt it some thirty plus years later.

Original line did follow the crack at the bottom since that offered a place to get some pro. Thought about leaving off the first bolts because of this, but in the age of sport climbing, many carry only draws and very few carry the slings you would need to protect this climb as it was originally protected.

Intent with the retrobolting was to make the climb safe for grade level. Too many bolts now? Sort of agree with this, but suggest you skip the clip if you don't need the bolt. It was too good a route to have no one climb it due to fears about the pro. Oct 2, 2017
Mark Webster
Tacoma
[Hide Comment] Holy Mackerel!!! This is my new favorite route at the city. And I don't even like sport climbs. This route is absolutely, positively awesome. The wacos remind me of the super positive holds on a 5.8 at the climbing gym. You know when they get a brand new box of super sticky textured holds and build and entire route from them? Every hold has an incut edge, like grabbing a dinner plate that is standing on edge. If you like sport climbs, I think this is better than Too Much Fun. I did place a cam before the first bolt, and another before the last bolt...but only because I'm an old chicken. The last move to the anchor was challenging for my niece, who is short. I'd recommend bringing a long sling or two in case you are a short leader and have to aid the bulge. Freaking awesome route! Jul 6, 2018
Ty Gittins
Bozeman
 
[Hide Comment] Crazy patina plates define this route. Amazing! Maybe not quite as good as Too Much Fun, but certainly one of the best single pitch 5.7s around May 18, 2020
Brandon Marshal
Victor, ID
  5.7
[Hide Comment] PHENOMENAL CLIMB, favorite 7 at the City and solid for the grade. Healthily spaced bolts - great for leaders used to "bolted to death" climbs. Crux is bulge up high.

Even though the first bolt is pretty easy to reach, it is very high. I placed two small finger sized cams (#0.2 - 0.5ish) in the obvious crack left of the first bolt, on top of the starting slab. Otherwise, blow the first move and risk a 30ft grounder! Nov 16, 2021
Old lady H
Boise, ID
 
[Hide Comment] A 70m will let you lower, or double strand rappel....but just barely. I've seen 70s reaching the ground with a bit to spare, and 70s that were a foot or so short, so close the system! Also, at just under 5', it wasn't pretty, and was a multistage project, but I did get over the top bit. It's there, if you hunt for it. I was on top rope though, I'd not try it on lead, myself, at the grade. And thanks, Jay. RKM, I get it, you know I do, but it was Jay's call, and it's a well loved route now. As great as COR is, there's not an overabundance for us lesser beings. Sorry the park has changed for you, but it's still got a lot of climbing to be had. And, ironically, I also support leaving it mostly as is. Keep the old school heads up pay attention adventure! Nov 19, 2022
Brandon Marshal
Victor, ID
  5.7
[Hide Comment] This is a great, well-bolted 5.7 climb. Though, new leaders might find the first bolt a little high off the ground. After climbing around in the fourth class trough to the left, the bolt is reached via an easy one move 5.7 mantle. The final roof is harder than 5.7 but is over quickly and well-protected on big holds. Aug 9, 2023
Alex Headley
Rexburg, ID
[Hide Comment] A .75 camalot in the vertical crack right off of the ramp protects some of those first moves before that first bolt! Oct 10, 2023
Benton Hodges
Jackson, WY
 
[Hide Comment] Knot the ends of your ropes on this one! 60m wouldn’t do it. 70m just makes it. 80m is comfortable. Be very picky where you belay if you are on a 70m. The comment above is spot on. Plug a 0.75 or two in a nice vertical crack before making the mantle move to the first bolt. A good spot for a newer trad leader to plug a piece of a gear before clipping bolts to the top. Oct 28, 2023
Jeff Johnson
Missoula, MT
 
[Hide Comment] 70m and knot the ends. Placed a #1 tricam in the crack before making the mantel below 1st bolt. Possible to reach a bolt and then retrieve the one below if needed on a couple. The bolder roof/mantel at the top is a great finish! Note: it can get windy on the top of this! Apr 12, 2026