Mountain Project Logo
To save paper & ink, use the [Hide] controls next to photos and comments so you only print what you need.

West Pillar

5.9, Trad, Alpine, 600 ft (182 m), 5 pitches,  Avg: 3.4 from 101 votes
FA: Gary Colliver and Mike Cohen, 1972
California > Yosemite NP > Tuolumne Meadows > Cathedral Range > Eichorn Pinnacle
Warning Access Issue: Latest updates on closures, permits, and regulations. DetailsDrop down

Description

The West Pillar route is a fun route and a great link-up with a route on Cathedral Peak. When linking these two routes, you effectively make a loop, hiking out on the John Muir trail, instead of the Cathedral Peak approach trail. The first pitch begins with a wide crack (5.9). There are two ways to go on the next section. The original route moves right and climbs 5.9 cracks to a horn in one pitch and climbs back left via 5.7 and 5.8 climbing in the next pitch. A direct route is also possible at 5.10 and is popular. This variation climbs directly above the first pitch belay for two pitches, both 5.10, and meets up with the original route where you can belay on the ridge. The 4th pitch is mostly 3rd class and ledgey with some 5th class terrain. It traverses underneath the ridge proper. The final pitch appeared to have some options but should stay left of the ridge, climbing one section of 5.8 and easier climbing before the summit.

Location

If climbing Eichorn's West Pillar after Cathedral, you will have to descend Cathedral to the ground and traverse around Cathedral to the west to reach the West Pillar route. If climbing the West Pillar route from the car, approach via the John Muir trail and Eichorn's West Pillar route is visible from the trail. The West Pillar route starts with an obvious, wide crack. Descent from Eichorn's is possible with one rope via a rappel from the summit.

Protection

Nuts, double set of cams to #1 Camalot and single set of cams to #4 Camalot. One rope.

Photos [Hide ALL Photos]

West Pillar on Eichorn's Pinnacle.
[Hide Photo] West Pillar on Eichorn's Pinnacle.
P5 rib pinching face variation
[Hide Photo] P5 rib pinching face variation
Eichorn's Pinnacle with the West Pillar route visible.
[Hide Photo] Eichorn's Pinnacle with the West Pillar route visible.
Following P1
[Hide Photo] Following P1
Emma Ely rappelling from the summit
[Hide Photo] Emma Ely rappelling from the summit
Looking up P3.
[Hide Photo] Looking up P3.
The climb!
[Hide Photo] The climb!
Start of P1.
[Hide Photo] Start of P1.
Start of P2, just before stepping around the corner and heading up.
[Hide Photo] Start of P2, just before stepping around the corner and heading up.
Mike in the wide crux of pitch 1
[Hide Photo] Mike in the wide crux of pitch 1
You pull over the boulder and the incredible view of the pinnacle is right ahead of you
[Hide Photo] You pull over the boulder and the incredible view of the pinnacle is right ahead of you
Cathedral Lakes from the summit ridge of Eichorn's. <br>
<br>
Photo: Corey Gargano
[Hide Photo] Cathedral Lakes from the summit ridge of Eichorn's. Photo: Corey Gargano

Comments [Hide ALL Comments]

stuart H
San Rafael
 
[Hide Comment] In the Reid & Falkenstein, 1983 guide book it says the original 5.8 route is by Colliver & Cohen in 1972 and the 5.9/10 variation was put up by Alan Bartlett and Don Reid in 1979. Interestingly, the original rating was at 5.9 and then it was upgraded to 5.10a in the 1992 edition. Apr 9, 2013
BruceB
Reno, NV
 
[Hide Comment] Highly recommend the direct variation.
Pitch #2 starts with some beautiful hand jams through a committing bulge (5.8) followed by a steep ramp with more great hand and fist jams (5.8+) to a sloping ledge.
Pitch #3 starts with a committing layback or finger jam up a steep corner. Good hands but thin feet, it only last for about 8 feet. IMO 510a/b. Then there's a good rest followed by another nice but easier layback. Then a bunch of easy 5th to a great belay. Jul 3, 2013
Mike McL
South Lake Tahoe
 
[Hide Comment] I found doubles of hand sized cams (green-blue camalots) useful for the standard route. 2 #4s are helpful as well if you want to sew it up. Of course, YMMV. Jul 24, 2013
David Knowles
Princeton, NJ
[Hide Comment] We did the direct variation which I would recommend. The direct approach from JMT however... sucks. With no defined trail it is a) unpleasant and b) causing a lot of erosion. Do cathedral first and then go down the 3rd class slabs to the base - there's actually a trail(ish) doing that. Jul 2, 2018
Peter J
Bishop
 
[Hide Comment] Amazing climb. But there is some sort of piss all over all the jugs/in the cracks? Especially on P2. Aug 20, 2018
Peter J
Bishop
 
[Hide Comment] Also, there is a large loose block in the crack about 20 feet up the third pitch--directly above the belay/rappel station! I was nervous to trundle it so I just pushed it into a slightly more stable position. Beware! Aug 20, 2018
[Hide Comment] Peter, that is indeed marmot piss. I would highly recommend to anyone else that climbs this to be wary of hantavirus from contact. Just make sure to keep the wrappers on your cliffbars when you eat em and you should be fine. Oct 19, 2018
Steven Thaw
Moraga, CA
[Hide Comment] Eichorn Pinnacle is the correct name despite this website! Refer to David Eichorn Jules son! Aug 15, 2020
Sy L
Cupertino, CA
[Hide Comment] Approach: +1 to the direct approach in guidebook sucks (JMT to Cathedral lake then leave the trail to the left towards the base of Eichorn after the long gradual uphill trail starts to go down hill). If you really want to use this approach, do not cut to the left until West Pillar is directly to your left, this would make cross country walk more direct and cause less erosion. Would recommend to start with JMT towards Cathedral Lake then take the trail to Cathedral Peak (they added a new climbers trail sign: a biner, it’s hard to miss the turn). There’s a trail to the base of West Pillar (lead you directly to the start of the climb above the trees) from Cathedral Peak.
Descent: take the descent of Cathedral Peak. The “direct” 3rd class descent again is not defined, dirty, and you’ll have to do some cross country erosion hike back to JMT again. Sep 7, 2020
[Hide Comment] Climbed the finishing crack on P5 yesterday on accident that is in between the 5.8 rib wrestling variation and the 5.9 OW variation. Does anyone know what this goes? Seemed to be maybe 5.10 layback moves on flakes? Jul 12, 2021
Mike Toffey
Yosemite/Lone Pine, CA
  5.9+
[Hide Comment] Toughest 5.9 around! Heard this original ‘5.9’ variation is actually much harder than the newer direct ‘5.10b’ variation. Gotta try that one next time. Sep 15, 2021
J J
CA
  5.9
[Hide Comment] Cool Route. BD#5 & #4 came in handy. Sep 20, 2021
Harris Kashtan
  5.10a/b
[Hide Comment] Climbed this after doing the direct variation and very much enjoyed it, though found it a little more burly. When starting the route, remember to belay at the top of the 5.0 ramp right before the crack steepens. We tried from the bottom with a 60m, came up short and had to have my belayer move up the ramp to finish the first pitch.

1st pitch - Awesome, steep climbing with a series of bulges that you can mostly stem through. Belay at the top of the last bulge when you see the route split into two options, there will be a piton with a quick link here.

2nd pitch - From the belay, you climb slightly down and climber's right along the edge of the ramp in order to make turning the corner as easy as possible. From here, you head up the right facing corner toward a daunting headwall/crack. I found the moves to get past this to be closer to 10a/b but protected well. Above this is the 5.9 squeeze/stem/flare that will feel hard if you aren't good at wide/OW technique. Protected well with a #4 and #2. At the top of this is a nice ledge that I ended up belaying at because my rope drag was heinous.

3rd pitch - Looking up, you see a very steep crack system that initially looks good but as you climb, the quality gets worse and the rock gets fragile. Before you hit the committing left facing flake/lieback, go right to the slung rock and then head up, good quality rock. This meets up with the 3rd pitch from the direct variation.

4th/5th pitch - continue as described for direct version. Of note, the 5th pitch can be a rope stretcher for a 60m, finish the 4th pitch as far as comfortable. Additionally, my partner and I have had communication issues on the 5th pitch with wind/distance. Plan this out before or carry comms. Jul 6, 2025