Mountain Project Logo
To save paper & ink, use the [Hide] controls next to photos and comments so you only print what you need.

Moonlight

5.6, Trad, 230 ft (70 m), 2 pitches,  Avg: 3.3 from 323 votes
FA: Bill Ryan, Willie Crowther, 1960
New York > Gunks > Trapps > h. The Arrow Wall - CCK

Description

This is a delightful 5.6, almost as nice as Madame G's or High E. The crux is as exciting as any 5.6 in the Gunks.

The first pitch is easy to locate: Use the same access trail as for CCK, just past the Andrew boulder. At the top of the access trail you'll see an obvious crack/corner system leading straight up. This is about 35' left of the huge Erect Direction corner.

P1: Climb up the face just right of an overhang and head for an obvious anchor on some small trees. Then follow the corner up to a bolted belay at the GT Ledge. 5.5, 130'. Alternatively, you can start by climbing the crack behind the flake to the left, at 5.7+R, then continuing up the left-facing corner.

P2: Move right on the GT Ledge about 40' (this is the same as the start of the 2nd pitch of Erect Direction) and climb up, diagonaling left, towards a large roof. Once you reach the base of the overhang, look for a fixed pin to the left and place a nut or two to back it up. Now, the crux: cower left, down and around the corner to a stance. This is all balance - no big jugs to save your ass until it's over. Then up through a nice finger crack to the final corner (easier on the right-hand wall) and the top. 5.6, 100'.

If your second falls at the crux, lowering to the GT Ledge may be your only way to get back onto the rock.

Descent: there is a bolted rappel line fairly close to the south, starting from the chains over No Glow, which will get you to the ground with a single rope.

Protection

Standard Gunks rack

Photos [Hide ALL Photos]

Rich Gottlieb, just after the crux on P2.
[Hide Photo] Rich Gottlieb, just after the crux on P2.
Tom finishing the end of Moonlight.<br>
<br>
Photo cred Justin B.
[Hide Photo] Tom finishing the end of Moonlight. Photo cred Justin B.
Craig Plescia rounding the crux of Moonlight.
[Hide Photo] Craig Plescia rounding the crux of Moonlight.
Starting Moonlight
[Hide Photo] Starting Moonlight
Partway up P1.
[Hide Photo] Partway up P1.
Drifting out towards the difficult section of moonlight.  Climber: Gottlieb Duwan, Photo, John Ely
[Hide Photo] Drifting out towards the difficult section of moonlight. Climber: Gottlieb Duwan, Photo, John Ely
Nice view of Pitch 2
[Hide Photo] Nice view of Pitch 2
Tersh going up the Enduro Corner--.. erm... Moonlight
[Hide Photo] Tersh going up the Enduro Corner--.. erm... Moonlight
starting up 2nd pitch<br>
Looks like a weekend...
[Hide Photo] starting up 2nd pitch Looks like a weekend...
The (intended?) start to P1 of Moonlight.
[Hide Photo] The (intended?) start to P1 of Moonlight.
The white rock at the end of this route is the best.
[Hide Photo] The white rock at the end of this route is the best.
The P2 Crux
[Hide Photo] The P2 Crux

Comments [Hide ALL Comments]

Adam Catalano
Albany, New York
 
[Hide Comment] Absolutely a classic climb that tops High E in my opinion. Stay low through the crux. The crux arete move is a good distance from your last piece, so keep your head about you. Apr 30, 2006
Michel
Montreal, Quebec
[Hide Comment] This is such a thought-provoking climb. Thoughts that were provoked: man, how do I start off? Do I follow that arch? Where's the damned piton? Oh crap, I'm slipped, will that piton hold?
In other words, great climb. Mar 5, 2007
losbill
  5.6
[Hide Comment] Fabulous climb. The P2 business features beautiful rock, nice moves with outstanding exposure and position. I am just not very good at this star thing. In terms of exposure (and feeling exposed) and moves I think Moonlight has it over High E. However I guess it it the truly airy aspect (position) of High E's P3 that gets it the 4th star.

If High E is busy, don't hesitate to do Moonlight. I don't think you will be disappointed. May 30, 2007
doligo
  5.6
[Hide Comment] A must do 5.6 in the Gunks. If you think after you clear the traverse, the hardest part is over, you'd be up for some rude awakening. The climb keeps on giving for all 100' of it. Don't forget your pink tricams and stoppers. Exciting lead! Apr 26, 2010
Gail Blauer
Gardiner, NY
[Hide Comment] I find this a somewhat serious climb for a 5.6. If you blow the traverse on P2, you are looking at an ugly fall back into the corner. The crack is beautiful, though. Jun 20, 2012
Benjamin Brooke
San Pedro, CA
 
[Hide Comment] i havent found a spicier 5.6 at the gunks. Not sure how the first pitch is only 5.5. getting started isn't that easy is it??? and the traverse on the second pitch is a boxer checker for sure. i snuck a purple c4 low to back up the pin but it still felt like it was a while before i got something else in. this is a sleeper classic climb. get on it and get scared. Apr 4, 2013
And Wilk
Espanola, NM
  5.6
[Hide Comment] This is a great climb from the ground up. P1 is one of those long pitches that just keeps giving. Great holds, moves, and gear all the way to the GT ledge. Then P2 starts the real fun. Some easy climbing up to the roof. The incredible traverse to follow. And then when you think you are in the clear you get some more tricky moves all the way to the top. Jun 13, 2013
[Hide Comment] A really high quality climb. P1 start to the left of the flake is ~5.7/7+. Big gear useful. May be a better idea to start on the face to the right.

P2 is fantastic. Thoughtful, delicate moves combined with gunks big air. The only reason to not do this climb would be having an inexperienced or easily spooked follower.

Gear beta for P2: Many good nut placements of all sizes. I found offsets particularly useful. Cams up to #1 C4. Oct 5, 2015
Optimistic
New Paltz
[Hide Comment] I think it's pretty reasonable to call the traverse on p2 R-rated. You're probably 12 feet from your last piece by the time you finish stepping around the corner, and the rock all along the traverse (ie the rock keeping your small to medium wires in place) is pretty fragile looking. Great route though!

One thought,if you think your second is going to have trouble or need coaching, various belays can be set just beyond the traverse. Just be sure that the second has a good directional after the traverse if you belay over in the corner (which is the base of the Gottlieb finish to Keep on Struttin and is a great pitch too, but 5.9). Belaying here is a nice way to enjoy all the exposure up there too. Apr 29, 2017
David K
The Road, Sometimes Chattan…
  5.7 PG13
[Hide Comment] Unlike other Gunks classics at the grade such as Madame G or Shockley's where sub-par climbing on the first pitches guards the money pitch, the first pitch of this is pretty fun, gaining exposure as you ascend the dihedral. It would be 2-3 stars, very worthwhile climbing by itself. And of course the money pitch is incredible, absolutely 4 stars. The crux traverse is obviously the most memorable, but there's another crux-y sequence near the top which is strenuous and lieback-y, and all on beautiful, solid rock.

After the traverse, I had good luck with a strategy of placing a piece, moving up, placing another piece, and backcleaning the previous piece for a few moves, until I was above the crux. This gave me some protection while saving my follower from a crazy swing, and reduced rope drag too. I was glad to have done this, because my follower got stung by a yellow jacket and fell at the crux.

I think the crux to this is hard to grade. It isn't strenuous at all--it's balance-y, so if you're looking only at strength required, it's arguably 5.5 or even lower. But I think most 5.6 leaders are going to find the balance and body positioning of this crux challenging. Additionally, this isn't the place to sandbag--I don't mind sandbags if the protection is good and falls are safe, but that's not how this is. The original person who added this didn't see fit to give it an appropriate safety rating, so I'd rather see this get a soft rating so nobody gets in over their head and gets hurt. So until I see a PG13 or R on this I'm rating it 5.7. Aug 10, 2018
J B
Cambridge, MA
[Hide Comment] Climbed this yesterday. I've ticked most of the classic 5.6s at the gunks and this one felt notably harder and scarier than any of the others.

We did the direct start protected by a number 4, which was probably the most enjoyable single move of the route. The big cam made the start fun and safe. If you place that big cam then you either need to back clean that piece to lessen the rope drag or split P1 into two by belaying at the tree, which is what we opted to do.

P2 scared me. The gear is a little bit sparse around the crux traverse. I found some good nut placements and a low purple c4 but I didn't extend everything enough and the drag was so bad that I had to build a belay on the slab and split that pitch up too. The slab provides a couple of good opportunities to belay, so it's no big deal if you choose to stop here like I did.

Take all of this with a grain of salt of course, this was only my fourth day leading trad. Overall it was a memorable adventure. Jun 24, 2019
[Hide Comment] Similar thoughts to most of the comments above but since it took me a moment to find the second pitch and relative to other .6's the traverse is a bit airy/committing, in lieu of suggesting a higher grade /protection rating, I think a little extra details would help for anyone a little unsure of this climb.

P1: Start to the right or underneath of the flake. Inconsequential either way, both seem very approachable relative to the rest of the route. A #3 or 4 C4 might make protecting the flake directly more comfortable ... eventually progress to the face. Belay off the tree

P2: 30' or so to the right of the tree (passing a second tree) the second pitch begins. If you have a #3 or 4 with you, you can protect the start in a huge horizontal ~ 2 steps off the GT ledge. As you aim for the crux traverse, there will be a piton middway on very easy climbing up until the piton protecting the crux as you move up and left. As other have said it is good to back this up - you do not get another obvious piece of gear for another 10-15'. However, I'd say that the first half of the traverse is more difficult (made easier by downclimbing a step or two) than the second half -- so a little extra distance between you and your last piece is more of a mental crux for the newer leader. After pulling this, you are greeted with some very enjoyable face climbing / crack moves -- outside of the traverse, this was the most fun / thoughtful part of the route. Mar 10, 2020
The Weavers
High Falls NY
[Hide Comment] Exciting exposed traverse with great climbing after. The first pitch is easy and excellent as well. Aug 23, 2021