Mountain Project Logo

Routes in Hemingway Buttress (East Face Left)

Ant Farm T 5.8 5b 16 VI- 15 HVS 4c
Coyote Bait T 5.7+ 5a 15 V+ 13 MVS 4b
Dung Fu T 5.7 5a 15 V+ 13 MVS 4b
Feltonian Physics T 5.8 5b 16 VI- 15 HVS 4c
Funky Dung T 5.8 5b 16 VI- 15 HVS 4c
Golden Years T 5.9+ 5c 17 VI 17 E1 5a
Hernie, Hernie, Hernie T 5.8 5b 16 VI- 15 HVS 4c
Horn Dog T 5.10d 6b+ 21 VII+ 21 E3 5b
Man's Best Friend T 5.9 5c 17 VI 17 HVS 5a
Overseer T 5.9 5c 17 VI 17 HVS 5a
Pig in Heat T 5.10b 6a+ 19 VII- 19 E2 5b X
Poodles are People Too T 5.10b 6a+ 19 VII- 19 E2 5b
Poodlesby T 5.6 4c 14 V 12 S 4b
Prepackaged T 5.10a 6a 18 VI+ 18 E1 5a
Roadrunner, The T 5.11c/d 7a 24 VIII 25 E4 6a
Rock Wren T 5.10a 6a 18 VI+ 18 E1 5a
Sea Monkeys T 5.10 6b 20 VII- 19 E2 5b PG13
Smoke-a-Bowl T 5.9 5c 17 VI 17 HVS 5a
Such a Poodle T 5.8+ 5b 16 VI- 15 HVS 4c R
White Lightning T 5.7 5a 15 V+ 13 MVS 4b
Type: Trad, 120 ft
FA: Chris Wegener and Roy Naasz, March 1973
Page Views: 17,656 total, 94/month
Shared By: C Miller on Jul 8, 2002
Admins: C Miller, M. Morley, Adam Stackhouse, Salamanizer suchoski, Justin Johnsen, Vicki Schwantes

You & This Route


546 Opinions

Your To-Do List:

Add To-Do

Your Star Rating:


     Clear Rating

Your Difficulty Rating:


-none- Change

Your Ticks:

Add New Tick
    -none-

Description

Near the left side of the wall is this hand/fist crack, which lies 5' left of Poodles Are People Too (5.10b) a nice looking thin crack.

Climb the classic crack straight up, moving slightly left near the top. Rap from anchors 20' right of the finish with two ropes (120' rap) or walk right and rap from anchors atop The Importance Of Being Ernest with one rope (75').

This is a great climb at a wall with many fine crack routes. Everyone should do this climb at least once as it is a good introduction to crack climbing and Josh in general.

Protection

Pro to 3"
Billy B.  
 
Just led this again today, and I still think that it is harder than 5.7. I did the 5.9 variation at the top, and I believe that the lower crux was harder than the 5.9 part. However, I also believe that it is a fantastic route! Just make sure that you are a solid 5.8 leader before you try it. May 27, 2017
Nathan Collins
Portland, OR
 
Nathan Collins   Portland, OR
 
After seeing some comments about big gear I carried up a BD #3 and #4; biggest cam I placed was one #2 :P I was worried about saving the big gear for when I needed it -- I did end up using the #3 as part of the anchor -- but got by on nuts and hexes (I placed 5 of the 7 BD hexes I brought up). There are great passive placements in the smaller cracks on the sides of the big crack that is this climb.

Agree the crux about 20 feet up entering the wide crack in the small roof felt harder than other 5.7s at JTree. However, putting my arm into the wall up to shoulder found a great hand or fist jam (don't remember now). Feb 17, 2017
alex carey
  5.7+
alex carey  
  5.7+
While being lowered the pressure from my foot pushing off the rock kicked off a bowling ball sized rock on the left side of the climb, about 40 feet up. May 3, 2016
Cron
Barrington, NH
  5.7
Cron   Barrington, NH
  5.7
raps fine w/ a 60 m. Just tie your ends and do a chill 10' down climb (5.2). Jan 24, 2016
polloloco
Downey, CA
  5.7+
polloloco   Downey, CA
  5.7+
The guidebook my partner had (thinner one with yellow) called this 5.7 and had you going up the crack just to the right at the finish. Looking at everyone's comments, sounds like I did the 5.9 variation instead? It definitely felt pretty strenuous in the end and felt harder than the undercling crux area.

Anyways, great climb. Definitely kicked my butt as a new trad leader. Lower crux and definitely the finish (the way I did it) felt harder than Dappled Mare 5.8. The middle section was a nice rest. Like others have said, wish I had 2 #3 camalots, ended up making do with a hex and slinging a horn in the middle. Was pretty physical for me.

The rappel to the right of it just made it with a 70m rope. Make sure you tie your ends! Jul 12, 2015
Tony Whitney
Las Vegas, NV
Tony Whitney   Las Vegas, NV
Climbed this route last weekend. I thought it was a great climb and an excellent example of JT crack climbing (one foot in and one foot out). I am used to climbing Red Rock NV, so I might not have the comparisons down completely. This felt way harder than any 5.7 I have ever done. I guess what my partner told me is true..."In JT, the first 20 feet don't count". Apr 6, 2015
AndrewB
Davis, CA
 
AndrewB   Davis, CA
 
I thought going right at the alcove was the standard route, based on watching the group ahead of us. That crack seemed tough, so I traversed back left on some face holds. Fun top out! Mar 9, 2015
David S.
San Francisco, CA
  5.7+
David S.   San Francisco, CA
  5.7+
Very slippery climb in places. Chris D's advice about placing a #3 Camalot in the crack above the crux undercling was spot on, but ended up blocking some of the more solid jams needed to squeeze through that crux. I don't know how I ended up getting through that greasy part of the climb, but it wasn't pretty. Crux is definitely the first 20 feet.

I was a little bit disappointed by the sudden change in character of the climb about half way up. It turned into a blocky chimney with pro being placed more sporadically. Despite this, and though the line is not as pure a crack line as something like Double Cross, it still gets three stars in my book because of the length. The final crack that heads left at the end has the most beautiful jams on the climb, in my opinion.

Recommend bringing two #3s and a #4 Camalot; the crack gets a little wide in the middle and has an awkward (for placing pro) break in the width towards the back of the crack. I didn't bring a #4 and ended up placing a #9 BD hex, which I wasn't too sure of.

As others have said, this is a 5.8 anywhere else. It's Joshua Tree. So I'll call it a 5.7 (though, to be fair, this climb is significantly harder than other 5.7s I've done in the park- e.g. Lazy Day or Double Dogleg, which I thought were quite a bit easier than this). May 25, 2014
henrysunset  
 
Easy enough (felt 8+ based on routes in WA) but the crack was hard on the hands, and especially the inside of my left forearm as I was laying back on the crack on the inside of the left side of the crack. 10ft up there is a tough part that you have to push through to get onto the main crack. I was asking for a tight belay as the rock is super rough, and the idea of taking a fall sounded - unpleasant.

Ed did a great job leading it, so I got lots of breaks to clean gear. I was a bit sketched out due to exposure by the end but did well.

It was definitely more fun than nearby Dung Fu. Mar 29, 2013
Canon
  5.7
Canon  
  5.7
Only had one #3 camalot - wish I had at least two. Walked it up several times in the lower section. There's a hidden rail on the left side of the crack in back that must go up at least half the climb. Heck of a lot easier with that. Really cool climb, but the fact that the whole area is always mobbed takes away some of the experience. Nov 17, 2012
Ryan N
Bellingham, WA
Ryan N   Bellingham, WA
A sandbag at that grade. Very strenuous moves and fairly long climb. Get it while it's in the afternoon shade. All sorts of gear will work big or small nuts or cams. Oct 13, 2012
Jan Tarculas
Riverside, Ca
  5.7
Jan Tarculas   Riverside, Ca
  5.7
I did dung fu "5.7", the flue "5.8", double cross "5.7+ - 5.8", and hands off "5.8" and I thought this was the hardest one of the bunch with the flue being the easiest. First 15ft was the crux for me and very greasy. We jokingly called it grease lightening after doing the climb. Mar 17, 2012
Chris D
the couch
 
Chris D   the couch
 
Greasy at the crux.

Get pro before starting into the fist crack about twenty feet up to avoid hitting the block that the climb starts off of if you blow it. A #3 Camalot is perfect.

The hardest moves on this route are every bit as hard as the moves on 5.8 cracks in other areas. Whatever. Joshua Tree. Jan 3, 2012
Zachary Wilson
Tucson, AZ
  5.7
Zachary Wilson   Tucson, AZ
  5.7
Love this route, no matter what anyone else says. Straight-ahead crack climb, good pro, and strong for the grade. Nov 25, 2011
Brandt Allen
Joshua Tree, Cal
Brandt Allen   Joshua Tree, Cal
They must be back again from last summer. I was stung four times at the rap anchor while helping with some bolt maintenence. The bites itched more than hurt, but it was still scary! Jul 1, 2011
Cho
Cho  
As of 6/25/11 there is a hive of very aggressive (africanized?) bees 15-20 feet back from the top of the climb. When I topped out and saw them, I set a directional and belayed from in front of the big boulder, figuring it would offer sufficient protection. After a few minutes of belaying, they found me and started swarming. I did my best not to provoke them....that is, until the first sting. After that, I unleashed a furry of obscenities and swinging rope. Unfortunately, my highly tactical defenses were ineffective and I got stung twice more. After continuous cries of "are you ok" and "up rope" my partner finally topped out. The bees left her alone, so maybe they only like dark skin?? A couple of them were agro enough to follow me all the way down the rap back to the base....where they met sweet death. Jun 27, 2011
T.J. Esposito
San Diego, CA
 
T.J. Esposito   San Diego, CA
 
Wasn't a bad climb but in a number of sections the feet are a little slippery from so many people climbing this route. Jun 8, 2011
Brandontru
Nevada
  5.7
Brandontru   Nevada
  5.7
A great route for anyone who wants to go passive keep it real.


Stoppers Mar 4, 2010
Aerili
Los Alamos, NM
 
Aerili   Los Alamos, NM
 
First climbed this almost 3 years ago; still somewhat physical moves on the first third despite my much increased teckneek now (ahem). Still had a foot slip off during the crux move but pulled right through (don't remember how, it's a blur you know).

The 5.9 exit variation is thin and steep, so make sure to bring some small nuts and super small cams. Beware of Z-clipping here if you put a couple pieces close together. Jan 10, 2010
Chris M
Seattle, WA
  5.7
Chris M   Seattle, WA
  5.7
Great line! The bottom crux is awkward and probably will be tough for begining leaders Oct 26, 2009
Russ Walling
www.FishProducts.com
Russ Walling   www.FishProducts.com
From the rap anchors described, a 70m will get you all the way back down to the deck, or real close to it. Aug 26, 2007
caughtinside
Oakland CA
  5.8
caughtinside   Oakland CA
  5.8
hate to uprate a classic, but this is one of the more physical 5.7s you'll ever do! the crux is short, but takes some power. If double cross is .7+, this is an .8. Fun climb, but Overseer is a better warmup than this thing! Mar 30, 2007
Adam Stackhouse    
  5.7
This a 3 out of 5 star route, that is easily accessed, accepts copious amounts of pro and lays at the lower end of the 5-scale. Highly recommended for the novice leader, or someone looking for a casual rope length climb. Apr 12, 2006
Scott Edlin
boulder, co
  5.7+
Scott Edlin   boulder, co
  5.7+
this route was the climax of my jtree trip. beautiful line, bomber jams, excellent pro, long, and sustained qualities all combined to make this more fun to me than bastille crack in eldorado canyon. if you liked double dogleg and thought it was a little easy, step up to this. Apr 12, 2006
Good route. There are rap anchors off to the right. You can rap with one 60 meter rope but YOU NEED TO DO SOME DOWNCLIMBING. Do not rappel off the ends of your rope. Oct 10, 2004
Hell yeah! Classic beyond words, believe the hype. Great straight forward jamming crack with excellent gear placements throughout the pitch, nice upper moves with excellent exposure. Simply and awesome climb anywhere.Don't forget to tape your hands or risk the cheese grater. Oct 1, 2004
Locker
Yucca Valley, CA
 
Locker   Yucca Valley, CA
 
up top taking a right instead of a left, a little pulling and then an 5.8/9. The left side, 5.7 fits. Whatever... Apr 27, 2004
Sirius
Oakland, CA
 
Sirius   Oakland, CA
 
If this route were anywhere else besides Joshua Tree, say for example Colorado, more people would agree on it being a three star line. If I were on a desert island and could have only one climb, would this be the one I'd take with me? No. But, thinking of all the other areas where I've climbed I'm going to call this spade a spade: three stars.

And shaded. Apr 6, 2004
Woody Stark  
5.8
I've led it many times and always felt it was an eight. Feb 21, 2004
Steven Powers
  5.7
Steven Powers  
  5.7
its good, but not that good Oct 2, 2003
Dynomight510
  5.7
Dynomight510  
  5.7
The crux is a few moves after the start and the crack takes pro very well. The climb eases after that until you reach the last 20' where you can choose a 5.7 finish to the left or a 5.9 finish slightly to the right. You are at a soolid stance to place pro before you start either finish. However, the 5.9 finish involves a short sequence of 5.9 moves, so be strong enough to stop and place gear or power through the section w/o falling. The rock below you here is low angled. The 5.7 finish involves a hand crack. Oct 1, 2003
Tony B
Around Boulder, CO
  5.7
Tony B   Around Boulder, CO
  5.7
The route was pretty good, but I've done better climbs at the grade.

You need two ropes to rapp off of the anchors just right of this, but you can walk well to the North out under a bridge and to a point of rock and find a set of bolt-anchors that allows for one rap on a single 50M rope. Apr 15, 2003
Great Route, must do for the grade! I thought the crux was near the start,about 10-15 ft up, when you have to enter the crack past the little slabby part.Just throw in some pro, and go! The variation to the left near the top is veryfun (6). Enjoy! Jul 9, 2002