Mountain Project Logo
A good first lead.
ID 107200921 ·

Rate Photo
     Clear Rating
  5.0 from 1 vote

Adam Shaleen
Jul 5, 2011
A good first lead.  
john laing
john laing   Albuquerque,NM
"A good first lead" ... with a sub-optimal belay stance.

I routinely observe that, especially, early leaders (top-rope habits) seem to be okay with their belayer standing a significant distance from the base of the route, rather than reasonably & essentially directly below the first protection placement.

This introduces implicit slack in the rope from the "hypotenuse" lengthening of the rope to the climber with consequences of: increased lead-fall distance; the rope becomes a target for the leader to impact; and will produce outward & even upward, rather than a downward pull on the protection.

It takes a very low force to pull the belayer laterally, while full-body-weight force is required to lift (an unanchored) belayer off the ground. And it's almost assured that when the climber is heavier than the belayer, the belayer will be yanked-forward and often plucked-off the ground towards a collision with the falling leader.

'Best practice' belay stance isn't about 'how likely/unlikely that the leader falls' it's about 'what will happen if the leader falls:' where will the belayer go, where will the leader end-up? Mar 13, 2012

Nearby Photos

In This Photo

Adam Shaleen
Minneapolis, MN