Tooth Fairy 

The Dennis Jackson guide gives the third pitch a 5.10 rating, so perhaps I am sand-bagging the rating on this a bit. However, I didn't think that pitch was much more difficult than many other parts of the climb, so I tended to agree with what can be found in the old Rosul-Dunning topos. One other note: the final finger crack isn't obvious from underneath the sotol buch. There are two grass filled cracks just to the right of it that don't look inviting. an alternate finish shown in the Rosul-Dunning is to meander right and then take a left-slanting crack to the left (5.8). We did this finish and would not recommend it. The face climbing to the the right is delicate and not all that well protected. The diagonal crack is filled with grasses and felt awkward, having occasional hand/fist jams interspersed with balancy lay-back type moves. We only went this way because I couldn't see the clean finger-crack above the sotol but I could see the two grass-filled seems next to it and there was no way I was going to throw myself at those seems.

FFA by Paul Horak and Glen Banks ca 1976.

Finally climbed the "real" last pitch. There are three old pitons in the grass filled crack leading up to the Sotol Yucca. A 1/4" bolt is hidden behind the Yucca. Climbing past the yucca without grabbing onto it looks very difficult. I recommend long pants and shirt, and simply heaving yourself up onto the plant. Probably not too good for the plant, but unless this area becomes high-traffic, I don't imagine much damage occurring. The finger crack above the Sotol is quality.

A few Notes:

P.1 creates a lot of drag if trying to link P1 & P2

p.4 Ditto on the shirt and pants for the cactus. It's yuc(ca) climbing through the green poky thing. The beached whale move worked for me and I don't consider it cheating. Above that the crack is a little dirty. Smiling will get you grit in your teeth but it's unavoidable since the crack is great leading up to the OW finish.

Definitely 2 rope raps. Tried it and barely managed with a single 70m but it meant rapping off single bolts (thankfully new)

Some info on P2 and the "hand crack". You leave the P1 belay by turning the corner to your right, and following an easy ramp/crack up and right to the base of a 22' left-facing corner. There is indeed a crack along the corner that gradates from about .25 to 2 inches. This short section, in my opinion, is quite technical but well-protected. I suggest really jamming your right toe in the crack and relying primarily on that point of contact. The left face is essentially featureless and good only for smears.

On the approach, you hang a left when the road peters out on the second ridge. We went up the first ridge, passed by a mine shaft and quickly realized we were beginning an approach out of Lord of the Rings. If you are not a well worn trail with cairns you are screwing up.

Stellar climb. I think the Rosul-Dunning topo is a very accurate representation of the route, although I got off-route in the 5.9 alt face climb below the sotol and ended up on Tooth or Consequences ... not recommended. By the time I fixed the mistake, I was sufficiently frustrated to body hump all over that sotol, totally violating its personal dignity. That'll teach it to poke me.

Also, the 5.10 alt start is definitely stout. I couldn't quite reach the second bolt. Inspecting it on rappel, it's definitely a little sketchy - an old buttonhead that is partially worked out of the hole, the hanger spinning 360 degrees. The good news is that, once you get far enough to clip it, the positive features are also beginning to resurface. The bad news ... if you fell and that relic pulled, the ledge-out potential is high. Sweet. Needless to say, I ended up backing off and taking the traditional 5.8 start to the left.

Finally, ditto on Bill's post. When the road stops at the top of a hill, you will also see a trampled down dirt area where people have camped ... it's very evident. Turn 90 degrees left (east, towards the Organ ridgeline), and you'll see that sizeable cairn that marks the trail. The trail is well worn and easy to follow.

out of all the climbs in the organs this one is a must do

Great climbing and rock. Definitely do the 5.9 friction on the last pitch. It's only hard for a few moves past the second bolt. No harder than the climbing getting into the p3 splitter. Very good and way better looking than that dirty crack with a big bush in it. You can see both bolts and where you want to go so I'm not sure how you could get off route, but who knows. I definitely cranked off the bolt to get past the sotol bush higher up this ptich.

The trail ends under some big trees at the base of the rock. go left and scramble up some blocks to get to the base of the route. The approach is pretty long but straightforward. Stop at the first good pullouts. It's not worth driving any further.

Really good route but It kind of sucks that the tooth isn't a worthy summit. Used the description here and it was spot on. Thanks.