By alleyehave May 1, 2012
| Maureen Aldridge wrote: I always assumed I was too much of a newbie to contribute anything of value to these cool forums, but this thread motivated me to post... I thought, 'hey, there talking about newbies... maybe a newbie should weigh-in?' After my girlfriend spent two months leading in Yosemite, she convinced me we were competent enough to tackle some of Tahquitz's classics, swing-leading Open Book, Whoodonit, and the Wong Long. Were we slow? Probably. Did we let other fast parties pass or climb before us? Of course! If some amazing team of buff testosterone charged hulks begged to avoid a spectacular perspective of our butts for the next 4-8 hours, we obliged. Did we ever drop gear? Uuhhh.... not yet! But I don't want to jinx us. Was the initial forum poster in Tahquitz over this last weekend? If so, I believe I may have a little insight to his frustration. There were more relative 'newbies' waiting in line at 5.8 and under routes then possibly ever before in Tahquitz history! At least 3x parties I knew from Mesa Rim. Most I thought of as 'sport leaders,' boasting of 12a+ or harder from what I'd seen at the gym. Maybe they are closeted trad climbers? Who am I to judge? But, as one poster keenly pointed out, there wasn't a single party in line for Open Book, 5.9. So for those ready for a 5.6 R rated traverse (which friends who climbed the route on Sat. mentioned was wet and slippery, yikes!), more power to you! For the rest of us, on a perfect, balmy Saturday, if all your hearts desire is to lead your fav., semi-easy but still Tahquitz-serious 5.7-5.8, you either have to be creative or wait in line. In the end, we decided to go find another route, and avoid dealing with disneyline joy. That must have been all of the ruckus we heard across the valley at Suicide when the sun started to set :) "HOW MUCH ROPE DO I HAVE??" "OFF BELAY??? BELAY OFF!!" "NOOOO HOW MUCH!! WhAT! NO ON BELAY PUT ME ON BELAY!!" lol |  FLAG |
By Jake Jones From The Eastern Flatlands May 1, 2012
| If you get up early enough, you never have to wait in line or worry about an ATC hitting you on your noggin or scree dust getting in your eyeballs. Sometimes the first pitch can be slippery from condensation though. Take the good with the bad. To the OP- Every place is for inexperienced climbers. For example, newcomers to outdoor sport climbing that "crush gym .11s" will often come to NRG asking for a "good .9 or low .10 (at a crag where these routes are the vast minority) to warm up on". Most of these folks get humbled and find that outside the first time they are at their limit at around 9+. Most of us learn by making mistakes. Especially when making the mistake involves a healthy element of risk and fear. You've probably learned a thing or two yourself that way too. Now, as a more experienced climber and a "local", you have a few options. Option A, which you have chosen, is to feign wisdom and profess to everyone else that you know best and that you know who should be climbing which routes at which crags without ever having gotten to know the climbers you're referring to or making an attempt to discern more than a guess about their actual abilities. I've seen a guy that has been climbing for 10 yrs and onsights .11- drop his ATC. It happens. Option B- As a local and someone that frequents the crag and knows the routes pretty well, get to know these people that might become regular faces. If they are unsafe, try to get them to see why they are unsafe, and maybe point them in the right direction to being safer. You almost never see a forum post that starts with "totally helped some n00bs try to not be so n00bish today and I'm feeling all 'Mr. Rogers' on the inside with a positive glow." Option C- Most people choose this one. Do nothing. At all. Don't say anything to them at the crag, good or bad. Don't come home and spray about n00bs on the interweb. You do your own thing, be cautious of others' actions and let them find their own way. Everyone starts somewhere. Nothing you say or do is going to prevent people from being bumbling beginners at your crag, getting in over their heads, and annoying the veterans. There are very few climbers that haven't found themselves at that very same place early in their climbing. Actually, I kind of pity those that haven't. |  FLAG |
By agd May 1, 2012
| OP still hasn't responded. Obviously cowering now that he has released the wrath of MP. |  FLAG |
By x15x15 May 1, 2012
| alexdavis wrote: OP still hasn't responded. Obviously cowering now that he has released the wrath of MP. i'd say the OP got exactly what he asked for! first post is his first troll. once the bait is taken, its fish on, and all you have to do is watch the frenzy. |  FLAG |
By Scott McMahon From Boulder, CO May 1, 2012
| x15x15 wrote: i'd say the OP got exactly what he asked for! first post is his first troll. once the bait is taken, its fish on, and all you have to do is watch the frenzy. Watch out calling someone a troll! The admins deleted my post for saying that on the "chains on top of a sport route" thread. Big no no!! |  FLAG |
By Maureen Aldridge May 1, 2012
| alleyehave wrote: That must have been all of the ruckus we heard across the valley at Suicide when the sun started to set :) "HOW MUCH ROPE DO I HAVE??" "OFF BELAY??? BELAY OFF!!" "NOOOO HOW MUCH!! WhAT! NO ON BELAY PUT ME ON BELAY!!" lol This is amazing. Yeah, probably. My partner and I ended up agreeing to join another party for a 5.4 friction down-climb to the anchors of Open Book for a double rope rappel to 'save time' on the decent. So yeah, sounds about right. haha. |  FLAG |
By gearwhore From Orange, CA May 1, 2012
| Although the "Noobs" you talk about worry me at Tahquitz - it's SoCal dude...most everything has a line of people waiting. Get up earlier or move out of state. |  FLAG |
By Nelson Day From Victorville, CA May 1, 2012
| Well, I don't think the intention of this post is to determine who's dick is bigger (west coast or east coast), but to try to encourage people to do some easier SINGLE pitch cragging before getting on some more committing multi-pitch routes in Tahquitz and making fools of themselves... |  FLAG |
By Ryan Williams Administrator From London (sort of) May 1, 2012
| gearwhore wrote: Although the "Noobs" you talk about worry me at Tahquitz - it's SoCal dude...most everything has a line of people waiting. Get up earlier or move out of state. East vs. West argument solved ;) |  FLAG |
By Catherine Conner From Phoenix, AZ May 1, 2012
| ...or sleep in longer and head up after the morning crowds... |  FLAG |
By Ryan Williams Administrator From London (sort of) May 1, 2012
| Nelson Day wrote: Well, I don't think the intention of this post is to determine who's dick is bigger (west coast or east coast), but to try to encourage people to do some easier SINGLE pitch cragging before getting on some more committing multi-pitch routes in Tahquitz and making fools of themselves... Although I joke around a lot about E vs. W, it's never a pissing contest... just a conversation about the positives and negatives of both. Some people have a hard time in NC because of the style of the climbing, not because the routes are sandbagged. Gunks/Dacks is the same. I'm sure plenty of east coasters get destroyed out west as well. I know I have (at least before I learned how to crack climb). There are places in every region of the US that are graded correctly, and there are also places in every region that are soft. You could say the same for every country in the world. |  FLAG |
By Souljah May 1, 2012
| Even the leader who can "crush" one pitch 5.11 is a relative novice on his first multi-pitch routes. To the MP neophyte, common sense would dictate that climbing a large formation with a 45 minute approach should not be underestimated > seek qualified parental guidance. Sermonizing aside, Tahquitz has seen it's share of epics and I'm sure it will see more. I was climbing at Suicide the day of that horrendous accident on the moderate 'Sahara Terror' in 1984. Buckle up & climb safe guys. PS: Who's Reardon ? |  FLAG |
By alleyehave May 1, 2012
| Maureen Aldridge wrote: This is amazing. Yeah, probably. My partner and I ended up agreeing to join another party for a 5.4 friction down-climb to the anchors of Open Book for a double rope rappel to 'save time' on the decent. So yeah, sounds about right. haha. I always find it interesting that people scour the false summit for 45 minutes looking for rap bolts, when it takes all of 15 minutes to do the friction descent..not to mention a walk off is always safer than a rap in my mind...besides, that double rope rap from the top of open books can easily get your rope stuck when pulling at the next station, its not fun... |  FLAG |
By Nick Zmyewski From Newark, Delaware May 1, 2012
| I always find the whole E vs W and whether the grades are stiffer than each other interesting, because alot of the places I have climbed (with the exception of Red Rocks and Red River) say that their grades are sandbagged (i.e. J tree, Yose, Gunks, Tahquitz). I never considered them sandbagged; I guess when everything you climb is "sandbagged" nothing is. P.S. Climbed Just Another Jam 5.7+ in Zion and THAT was sandbagged |  FLAG |
By Chris D From the couch May 2, 2012
| alleyehave wrote: I always find it interesting that people scour the false summit for 45 minutes looking for rap bolts, when it takes all of 15 minutes to do the friction descent..not to mention a walk off is always safer than a rap in my mind... +1 Plus, it's fun to show first-timers the descent. "Seriously? We're going down there??" The descent is cool because it's so improbable. I've never rapped off Tahquitz, but have seen some people having trouble doing so, and getting in the way of people trying to climb. |  FLAG |
By Maureen Aldridge May 2, 2012
| alleyehave wrote: I always find it interesting that people scour the false summit for 45 minutes looking for rap bolts, when it takes all of 15 minutes to do the friction descent..not to mention a walk off is always safer than a rap in my mind...besides, that double rope rap from the top of open books can easily get your rope stuck when pulling at the next station, its not fun... I'm inclined to agree with you! My follower forgot her flash light, and since we'd already done the friction decent once before that day (walking off from another route), and found it was wet, she was less interested in doing it again, in the dark... either way, we got sucked in by the 2nd party. And yes, I'm beginning to agree with you, rappelling off Tahquitz seemed more dangerous than the actual climbing, cuz yes, our rope did... almost.... get stuck. =/ |  FLAG |
By susan peplow From Joshua Tree May 2, 2012
| Will S, you made my night. This was my last read before heading to bed and chuckled at both the little league comment as well as the follow up........Royal Robbins/YDS/first 5.9.....:) snicker. I always like hitting Tahquitz early season on those classic lines like Sahara Terror and the Long Climb as they were almost for certain to yield you some sort of stuck or bootied gear. |  FLAG |
By x15x15 May 2, 2012
| susan peplow wrote: Will S, you made my night. This was my last read before heading to bed and chuckled at both the little league comment as well as the follow up........Royal Robbins/YDS/first 5.9.....:) snicker. I always like hitting Tahquitz early season on those classic lines like Sahara Terror and the Long Climb as they were almost for certain to yield you some sort of stuck or bootied gear. tis the season for a new rack!!! early sunday morning jaunts up whitemaidens, up coffin nail, down jenson jaunt, up fingertrip, down the trough, then finish the morning aerobic workout on angels fright. run to the summit for a midmorning snack with a few extra pieces of gear, then back home to watch the crowds crawl all over the rock. repeat monday, or tuesday... for best gear selection... |  FLAG |
By randy88fj62 May 2, 2012
| x15x15 wrote: tis the season for a new rack!!! early sunday morning jaunts up whitemaidens, up coffin nail, down jenson jaunt, up fingertrip, down the trough, then finish the morning aerobic workout on angels fright. run to the summit for a midmorning snack with a few extra pieces of gear, then back home to watch the crowds crawl all over the rock. repeat monday, or tuesday... for best gear selection... I was there this past weekend. I scored a double length dyneema sling, dmm wiregate, and a WC med size nut. Gotta love scared bootied gear. There was a really old rigid stem friend backed into a lower crack on lunch ledge. It looks like it's been there for a long time. I was able to pull on the trigger wires to no avail. There was also a really stuck pink tricam on fingertrip that would've needed a hammer to get out. |  FLAG |
By Jeff Chrisler From Boulder, CO May 2, 2012
| Sure sure the Gunks and the East Coast is so hard. Right. I've been there as well as Seneca, and sure the climbs are sandbagged, but 5.7 in both places are like a 5.8-5.9 elsewhere until you get used to the climbing and it starts to feel like 5.7 again. I just think it's ludicrous to tell people not to go somewhere when they even when they are starting out. Sure, raining down debris is not cool, but get over the fact that you have to wait or didn't get out early enough for the climb you wanted. Plus, you were a noob at some point. I'm sure you wouldn't have appreciated a similar sentiment. |  FLAG |
By DexterRutecki May 2, 2012
| I have climbed the gunks and guess what.... 5.7 felt like 5.7 at most other places I have climbed around the US that were not super soft. 5.7 at the gunks is no harder than 5.7 in NC or vedauwoo. Every climbing style is different and takes a bit of getting used to. But Gunks climbers.... PLEASE stop spraying about how hard your grades are. No one cares and they really are not that different than countless other areas. |  FLAG |
By Jeff Chrisler From Boulder, CO May 2, 2012
| DexterRutecki wrote: Every climbing style is different and takes a bit of getting used to. exactly |  FLAG |
By Colonel Mustard From Reno, NV May 3, 2012
| Souljah wrote: Even the leader who can "crush" one pitch 5.11 is a relative novice on his first multi-pitch routes. To the MP neophyte, common sense would dictate that climbing a large formation with a 45 minute approach should not be underestimated > seek qualified parental guidance. Sermonizing aside, Tahquitz has seen it's share of epics and I'm sure it will see more. I was climbing at Suicide the day of that horrendous accident on the moderate 'Sahara Terror' in 1984. Buckle up & climb safe guys. PS: Who's Reardon ? I'd take that 5.11 neophyte over a lot of people. 5.11 followers are awesome! As stated, that 45 minute approach should not be underestimated... My second day climbing there, it became extremely epic thanks to an epic hangover. I got straight tooled on Open Book, felt like I was going to implode. For the sake of semantics, it would have been better getting tooled on The Mechanics Route, but I would probably also have died. Reardon soloed... a lot. Like The Pirate at Taquitz, amongst others. Although the naysayers will say otherwise before showing you evidence of the faked moon landing.
DexterRutecki wrote: I have climbed the gunks and guess what.... 5.7 felt like 5.7 at most other places I have climbed around the US that were not super soft. 5.7 at the gunks is no harder than 5.7 in NC or vedauwoo. I really need to climb the Gunks one of these days to see for myself. I even have a place to crash at in New Paltz! It sounds to me like a fair number of people who climb there are a bit insulated from other areas, and the Gunks are different enough to throw off your average fat legged traddie visiting from other areas. Hell, I know my fatted trad calves would probably quake under an easy overhang there! |  FLAG |
By jarthur From Westminster, CO May 3, 2012
| Jeff Chrisler wrote: Sure sure the Gunks and the East Coast is so hard. Right. I've been there as well as Seneca, and sure the climbs are sandbagged, but 5.7 in both places are like a 5.8-5.9 elsewhere until you get used to the climbing and it starts to feel like 5.7 again. I just think it's ludicrous to tell people not to go somewhere when they even when they are starting out. Sure, raining down debris is not cool, but get over the fact that you have to wait or didn't get out early enough for the climb you wanted. Plus, you were a noob at some point. I'm sure you wouldn't have appreciated a similar sentiment. Hey Jeff, I've been waiting to hear someone call these Gunkies out for so long. I'm just glad it was one of my boys. |  FLAG |
By Rob Selter From running springs Ca May 3, 2012
| I totaly CRUSHED fingertrip. dose this mean I am no longer a inexperienced climber mountainloin? |  FLAG |
|