Super Direct 

The first pitch is great; the opening moves are hard and non-intuitive. I think the old Kelley guide's rating of 5.9 is right on.

I thought P2 was pretty crappy by comparison with the first pitch. The so-called "chimney" described in the Select guide is actually a wide crack choked with vegetation, which my partner and I avoided entirely.

Opening is indeed the business - getting around to/up and over the roof. Mercifully it protects well with small .3/.4? BD cams and a bomber nut protects the pull over move (if you can hang on to plug it in!). From there it's fairly casual by comparison. Traverses pretty far left to the chimney when you reach the top of the main crack.

The second pitch has it's moments, and there are several lines possible. The most enjoyable that I've found is to go straight up the overhanging bit after the crappy chimney. It's pretty easy but is quite exposed for the grade - maybe 5.5? Sort of Gunks-esque.

I have no idea if we did the right start to this, or the right line at all for that matter. We started up a steep finger crack with a couple of roofs, which was hard enough to make the 5.8 rating seem like a joke. Bomber nuts abound but I had real issues with the rope getting stuck in the crack. It made me cringe to abandon these nut placements for less elegant cams outside of the main crack, but drag became infinitely better once I did. After the initial crank, the rest of the climb is a routefinding adventure.

That sounds about right sanz. 5.8 at Moore's is usually fairly hard. Have you done Airshow yet?

This felt 10 times harder than Airshow to me, but maybe I just suck at overhanging finger cracks.

I think Super DIrect just feels hard because you could hit the ground if you blow the crux. If the moves were 50 feet up a clean face it would probably feel about has hard as Air Show, which also gets 8+.