From: Thornton, CO
Sep 5, 2008
rating: 5.12a 7a+ 25 VIII+ E5 6a
Given the same holds and moves, of course it would be 5.10 if it was less overhanging, If it was slabby, it'd be 5.8.
But it is 5.12, and it's a really good route. The crux is basically a 3-bolt, V4 boulder problem, followed by some 5.10 jug hauling and a few moves of 5.11 up higher. Do it.