Sly Willie Snores 

I've done this route a couple of times and think it's worth doing. However, I don't think it's a world class, best of T-Wall outing. IMHO, giving this route 4 stars diminishes true classics like Mrs. Socrates, Sugar in the Raw, Psychopath, Stepping Stone, etc. Good route? Yes. Great Route? No

How about "great" route for the grade?

If you don't think it's a four-star route, don't give it four stars. Complaining about how other climbers rate a climb is kind of lame.

The goal of my comment wasn't to "complain" about how others rate routes but to express my opinion. Looking at MPs scale:
1 star = OK
2 stars = Good
3 stars = Great
4 stars = Classic

In my opinion, 4 star, "classic" routes should be special, world-class routes. They should be the ones that, if you're visiting a crag for a short period of time, must be done to really sample a given grade at a given crag. As such, the list of classics should be select and special to really differentiate the world-class gems. This doesn't mean that 1, 2, or 3 star routes aren't good or great routes in any way.

I'm a fan of Dave Pegg's Rifle book where he was very sparing in giving out the max stars. This makes it easy when visiting to identify the great (at least to him) routes.

I agree, good route, but not the first one you should do. It stays drier than Sugar in the Raw, though, so that's useful.