By Woodchuck ATC May 30, 2012
| If first arrival does not have their rope off the route in a respectable amount of time, be prepared to move that rope or share that rope at DL. Respect, ask, share and get along. |  FLAG |
By Doug Hemken Administrator May 30, 2012
| Thanks, Michael. We typically do *much* better than first-come first-serve. Mark really succinctly gets to the heart of how we actually have been making sharing work around here for the last 30-40 years. |  FLAG |
By Juggler May 30, 2012
| Share and share alike...I say. Might get a little WET rapelling IN Devil's Lake.... ;) |  FLAG |
By Josh Olson From madison, wisconsin May 31, 2012
| Woodchuck ATC wrote: If first arrival does not have their rope off the route in a respectable amount of time, be prepared to move that rope or share that rope at DL. Respect, ask, share and get along. Fantastic way to meet people too. Shared ropes at the lake with tons of characters, never a bad experience. In Swartling's guidebook, doesn't it say the ethic is the leader has the right of way? Is that still the ethic for you guys, or is that a thing of the past? |  FLAG |
By Doug Hemken Administrator May 31, 2012
| Josh, I don't find that in the recent, 3rd edition. You'd have to tell me what page that's on, about leaders having right-of-way? That was kind of the prevailing attitude among climbers in the 1970s, but I think it fell by the wayside in the 80s. At Devils Lake it is pretty unrealistic to expect that 95% of climbers will always yield priority to the 5% who lead. If 5 people are waiting in line to TR "Brinton's", would you really expect to waltz up and make them all step aside while your buddy tries to do his first lead on it? (On the other hand, if there is a rope but no one is actually climbing, I'm seldom shy about asking if I can pull their rope off to one side while I lead. "Respect, ask, share." There will be times when you make others feel rushed, and there will be times when you wait longer than you think necessary, but in general it works pretty well.) |  FLAG |
By Woodchuck ATC May 31, 2012
| I waited over an hour once in the Gunks, semi-patiently, as some noobs were setting up their first rap down a very popular route. They looked ready to descend any minute, but it stretched out for an hour as we stood beneath ready to get climbing on the route. Coaching sometimes helps to speed things along. |  FLAG |
By Josh Olson From madison, wisconsin Jun 1, 2012
| Doug Hemken wrote: Josh, I don't find that in the recent, 3rd edition. You'd have to tell me what page that's on, about leaders having right-of-way? That was kind of the prevailing attitude among climbers in the 1970s, but I think it fell by the wayside in the 80s. At Devils Lake it is pretty unrealistic to expect that 95% of climbers will always yield priority to the 5% who lead. If 5 people are waiting in line to TR "Brinton's", would you really expect to waltz up and make them all step aside while your buddy tries to do his first lead on it? (On the other hand, if there is a rope but no one is actually climbing, I'm seldom shy about asking if I can pull their rope off to one side while I lead. "Respect, ask, share." There will be times when you make others feel rushed, and there will be times when you wait longer than you think necessary, but in general it works pretty well.) I don't have the third edition to find it, and it wouldn't be the first time I was wrong. But, I remember my first trip to the lake to toprope some classics. I had a guy come up, show me a page in a guidebook, and ask me to move so he could lead. I'm not saying its the best ethic, or even a good one, just wondering if it is still the case. |  FLAG |
By Woodchuck ATC Jun 1, 2012
| I just read my 3rd edition and under ethics' on pgs 14-16, there is only mention of not hogging routes. No leader preference listed. Without reading the rest of the entire book, I doubt if there is anything about this mentioned in some paragraph hidden in some chapter. Seems there is nothing designating that leaders still have the right-of-way on any route. |  FLAG |
|