Welcome to the Gunks 

This used to be rated 5.9. We thought it had five 5.9 cruxes, the slab, the first roof, the scary moves to the second roof, the second roof itself (the actual crux), and the roof on P2. The slab approach was always scary for me, and the second roof never felt easy. If you do P2, you have a bunch of junky climbing above the P2 crux as you wander up and eventually a bit right to a tree that you can belay and rap from.

I've done this route 5-6 times. The face climbing (about 5.9-) after the first roof is not well protected: if you fell, you'd hit a ledge. Certainly, if you climbed the initial unprotected slab and the first roof without difficulty that section shouldn't stop you, but the potential for a nasty fall is there if you make a mistake.

I thought this was the hardest 5.10 that I have ever done at the gunks. Perhaps it was late in the day (our last climb), but I rarely fall on a gunks 10. I fell three times on this climb. The slab was difficult (hard to reach the big holds for this short climber), the roofs were easy relative to the R section on the orange rock. I took a fall trying to move from the slopers to the horizontal under the roof. All in all, a hard climb, I thought much harder than Feast of Fools, Interstice, Mothers Day party, Retribution, Nose dive etc. I am not sure I would repeat this any time soon.