Home - Destinations - iPhone/Android - Gyms - Partners - Forum - Photos - Deals - What's New
 ADVANCED
Lurkers suck



View Latest Posts in This Forum or All Forums


Page 2 of 23.  <Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next>
 
By KCP
From Eldorado Springs, CO
Dec 15, 2007
KC

TP in SLC wrote:
I think only the first sentence of Marc post was incorrect. Growing up in Utar I find they do "follow" Joesphs teachings......


Of course they follow the teachings of Joseph Smith - those being teachings of Christianity and Jesus Christ.

I too agree with Marc's final statement, although I would include religion, in its entirety, in his statement. People blindly accept The Bible as the spoken word of a god.


FLAG
By Marc H
From Lafayette, CO
Dec 15, 2007
The Cathedral Spires in RMNP, left to right: Stiletto, Sharkstooth, Forbidden Tower, Petit Grepon, The Saber, The Foil, The Moon & The Jackknife.

Ken Cangi wrote:
This is incorrect. Not only do they believe in Jesus Christ, but their church is called: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.


I should have said that Mormons believe in the teachings of the bible, as interpreted by Joseph Smith. A man whom they hold as a prophet, which is laughable IMO, considering his record here on earth.

--Marc


FLAG
By Richard Radcliffe
From Louisville, CO
Dec 15, 2007

Marc Horan wrote:
...Joseph Smith. A man whom they hold as a prophet, which is laughable IMO, considering his record here on earth.

He's no different than any other "prophet". Anyone who claims to be a conduit to a higher power that doesn't exist is either a charlatan or psychotic.


FLAG
By KCP
From Eldorado Springs, CO
Dec 15, 2007
KC

Richard Radcliffe wrote:
He's no different than any other "prophet". Anyone who claims to be a conduit to a higher power that doesn't exist is either a charlatan or psychotic.


Behold the wonder of the Flying Spaghetti Monster. Made a true Pastafarian out of me.


FLAG
By Charlie S
From Ogden, UT
Dec 15, 2007
Starting out on Bushwhack Crack

Chances are if the Christians aren't making eye contact, they're a poor example. I try to make eye contact at least. You can call on me otherwise.

And yes, I'm a lurker, sometimes. If I have nothing important to say, then I don't say it.

However, baseball in a climbing group? Haha, I thought I could escape from baseball here!

And yeah, this weather is depressing. My climbing area's under a foot of snow. Where's global warming when you need it?


FLAG
By bsmoot
Dec 15, 2007
Me in the 70's

Hey Marc:

The "teachings of Joseph Smith" include what's known as the "Word of Wisdom" which is: no tobacco, no alcohol, no hippie lettuce, no acid, no cam hooks on Zion Trade routes, and no GUMBIES!

Kum ba yah Bra!


FLAG
By Marc H
From Lafayette, CO
Dec 15, 2007
The Cathedral Spires in RMNP, left to right: Stiletto, Sharkstooth, Forbidden Tower, Petit Grepon, The Saber, The Foil, The Moon & The Jackknife.

bsmoot wrote:
Hey Marc: The "teachings of Joseph Smith" include what's known as the "Word of Wisdom" which is: no tobacco, no alcohol, no hippie lettuce, no acid, no cam hooks on Zion Trade routes, and no GUMBIES! Kum ba yah Bra!


Does that mean I'm not invited into their religion? Just like black people weren't invited until 1978? Maybe my alcohol-swilling, hippie lettuce-smoking, cam-hooking, gumby ass might be invited one day!! Woohoo!! I look forward to it.

--Marc


FLAG
By Tony B
From Around Boulder, CO
Dec 15, 2007
Tony Bubb enjoying the good "clipping holds" (hardy-har-har) while climbing 'Circumcision (6b)' at Nanyang Wall, in the Batu Caves area of K.L., Malaysia. Photo by Kenny Low, December 2006

I don't lurk, but I also don't post every time I log in. As often as that might be then, many 'lukers' probably post more often than me as a percentage of their logins.

So here's some 'noise' for you, since I've been lurking on this subject:
It seems that prophet in a modern sense confuses the English language. Is it a Prophet or Profit? Is the near-homonym a coincidence?

"I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ."
- Mohandas Gandhi (October 2, 1869 - January 30, 1948)

So what is the big difference between mormanism and Christianity really, in the big picture? Other than antiquity, I see very little. A good Christian or Jew could have as many wives as they could afford in their day! And furthermore, their priests and Rabbis could (or still can) be married. And both had leaders running their followers around in the desert or found 'tablets' given by God. Shoot, if that's God's M.O., why not do it twice in 5000 years?

I don't find LDS any 'nuttier' than Christians. But yet Christians thed to pick on them. Why? Let's face it, faith is either genetic or socially conditioned, which is why something like 80%(*) of all people carry the banner of the faith of their parents. Why pick on any particular one?

(*) = High 80's by my recollection, but I don't recall the exact % nor all of the qualifiers, but depending on what you call a faith or how finely you sub-divide. Yes, there are many exceptions- I am one of them.


FLAG
By Umph!
Dec 15, 2007

I feel so dirty - fiddlin' with my mouse while viewing others.

I just spent two days climbing a demoralizing little nubbin' out in the Morman's desert. . . snow makes things very freaky.

GeorgeR, you're a fool. . . welcome to your lot. And I'm sure you're twice the man as most of us are (not as good as the women of course).

John Glime. Ooufta. I won't entertain you this time. . . okay, maybe a little.
Funny how tolerance is so one-sided with some people (most people?). Buddha would not be pleased with your instigations.
I wonder: do you spread your ideologies to your students? I have a great friend (really, a great friend) who is an anti-christian/American/republican, and we argue like little 'ol ladies at a bridge match (no, I'm not republican). Point is, he's a teacher, and he does provide his POV when applicable. So, how is one better than the other?
Mormons, in general, TRY to be truly good people. . . and that is commendable. . . I can think of other religions, which I won't mention (Islam. . . shit!), where this doesn't fit.
Mormons didn't allow blacks until 1878? - (Horan) Wow, that's a HUGE step ahead of the southern democrats (you know, those friendly folk who are for the black community). Hell, that's just following the slaying of John Brown (well, 20 years). Sounds like them Mormon's were a step ahead of nearly everyone.
I've known and have worked with some Morman folk, and they've always left a good impression with me.
Now I'm not a practising Anyone, but I do attempt tolerance. . . sometimes.

Read for the winter: "Behold, A Pale Horse". or "Creature from Jekyl Island". Either are a good starting point and should put a happy, healthy glow in your heart for the Christmas. . . oops, I'm sorry. . . the Holiday season.

Bubb, my grandparents were missionaries in the Phillipines, and elsewhere, and they never had the slightest clue as to what a Profit felt like (they only tried to follow their Prophet). In fact, they sacrificed their entire lives for what they felt to be the betterment of others - and from what I understand, in most cases that was the outcome.

McHugh, funny as usual!


FLAG
By Tony B
From Around Boulder, CO
Dec 15, 2007
Tony Bubb enjoying the good "clipping holds" (hardy-har-har) while climbing 'Circumcision (6b)' at Nanyang Wall, in the Batu Caves area of K.L., Malaysia. Photo by Kenny Low, December 2006

cameron wrote:
Bubb, my grandparents were missionaries in the Phillipines, and elsewhere, and they never had the slightest clue as to what a Profit felt like (they only tried to follow their Prophet). In fact, they sacrificed their entire lives for what they felt to be the betterment of others - and from what I understand, in most cases that was the outcome.


Fine. But read what I wrote, which was nothing about missionaries.
So unless your parents professed to be PROPHETS I made no comment about them, other than that it was likely that they followed the religion of their parents.


FLAG
By Andrew Gram
Administrator
From Salt Lake City, UT
Dec 15, 2007
Andrew Gram

Yeah John, the Broncos sure do suck this year. At least now I don't have to bother finding a TV on sunday when I am traveling through Central America in January and February. Anyway, just move up to Park City like me and you won't be a political/religious minority anymore. Its the Mormon demilitarized zone.

Way to take a light hearted smackdown and turn it into a bully pulpit Marc Horan. Everything anyone believes about religion is completely ludicrous to someone outside of that religion, so it is pointless and never leads to any good to throw that stone in an online climbing forum.


FLAG
By Umph!
Dec 15, 2007

Okay Bubb.
Your seemingly anti-christian rhetoric makes its point. My point was in contrast, showing that some christian people do a lot of good, and have truly good intentions (not Profitable/monetary ones).

Again, I feel very, very dirty.
Back to lurking, until next month - ciao!


FLAG
By Tony B
From Around Boulder, CO
Dec 16, 2007
Tony Bubb enjoying the good "clipping holds" (hardy-har-har) while climbing 'Circumcision (6b)' at Nanyang Wall, in the Batu Caves area of K.L., Malaysia. Photo by Kenny Low, December 2006

Cameron,
If your parents as missionaries did more than just preach, then I am sure that by my metrics they did some good.
Personally, my situation does not permit me to go work abroad for my life. Instead of that I choose to pay for those who do, but I happen to support non-religious charities most of the time, because logic would dictate that for every minute spent building churches, worshiping and preaching, one has to spend a minute less building water filtration systems, distributing medicine, and teaching.

I have always had some other internal questions about missionaries though. By the christian dogma, they may have a negative effect. If I correctly recall from my 12 years of cristian schooling, those who have heard the word an did not follow it are damned, while those that never heard the word are not.
Following that Dogma, one can only conclude that 'spreading the good word' necessarily leads to the numbers of the league of the damned, such as myself. If I'd never heard of Jesus, I wouldn't have to face the possibility of eternal damnation for not having been given the gift of faith, right? So it would not have been better for me never to have 'heard the word' at all?

I was in a Hindu temple in Singapore's 'Little India' district with she who was my girlfriend at the time. I observed and pointed out to her a sign bearing the principle tenets of the Hindu faith. The last on the list, perhaps coincidentally or perhaps so as to leave a lasting final impression, read: (to paraphrase)

'Never preach that your religion is superior to that of any other man.'

She nodded and said :
"The Christians could stand to learn that lesson."

Note- as it so happens, she was a Christian.


FLAG
By samg
Dec 16, 2007

The religion bashing is boring and pointless.

-Your friendly neighborhood Atheist Jew (that's me).


FLAG
By kirra
Dec 16, 2007
Stan Marsh South Park CO. <br />We only have 1shot at this <br />because 'Kenny' is not comin' back

Tony Bubb wrote:
'Never preach that your religion is superior to that of any other man.'


Lurking over...... I wish someone could teach this to the Radical Islamic Jihads that are blowing up everyone in the name of Mohammed..!!!

cameron - Is that book BAPH still in print..? Dang, I still have my original paper-bound copy and owe that write to the dawning of my personal solidarity -- what a blast from the past.

I'd like to know why the Jews are always being picked on. I thought it was only the Natzi's but then heard tonight that the Christians slaughtered them in the 14th cent. blaming them for the plague. It's just not fair. Just because they make the best bagels, people need to get over it. Maybe this religion topic came up because we've been plummeted with f-in' X-mas carols night & day for weeks now. Makes me want to escape to Canada or anywhere till they stop. WWJD - What would Jesus do..?

On Barry Bonds - If he didn't swallow does it still count???


FLAG
By KCP
From Eldorado Springs, CO
Dec 16, 2007
KC

Kirra wrote:
Lurking over...... I wish someone could teach this to the Radical Islamic Jihads that are blowing up everyone in the name of Mohammed..!!!


Is what they're doing any more radical than what our presidential oil merchants have done to Iraq, and desire to do in Iran?

Kirra wrote:
I'd like to know why the Jews are always being picked on. I thought it was only the Natzi's but then heard tonight that the Christians slaughtered them in the 14th cent. blaming them for the plague.


I am less surprised at your first comment, after reading your second one. I don't know if you went to college, but I am a little surprised that you are so unaware of one of the most documented and discussed stories in the history of religion and mankind - the history and persecution of the Jews.

I am constantly reminded of why history repeats itself.


FLAG
By Marc H
From Lafayette, CO
Dec 16, 2007
The Cathedral Spires in RMNP, left to right: Stiletto, Sharkstooth, Forbidden Tower, Petit Grepon, The Saber, The Foil, The Moon & The Jackknife.

Andrew Gram wrote:
Way to take a light hearted smackdown and turn it into a bully pulpit Marc Horan.


LOL.. it's always me that's creating the problems around here, isn't it Andrew?!?!

Andrew--

I realize that you are never going to like anything I write because you have a biased opinion about me regarding what was probably my first post on MP.com. Let there be no confusion about it, Andrew: I don't care what you think about me. I never have; I never will.

I couldn't have less respect for anyone that I've never met before.

Peace
Marc

cameron wrote:
Mormons didn't allow blacks until 1878?


Uh.. no. Blacks were not welcome into the Mormon religion until 1978. And only because congress pressured them.

Less than 30 years ago, Mormons starting allowing black people into their religion to get congressional pressure off of the religion, not because they had a change of heart and realized that discriminating against someone because of the color of their skin is f'in wrong!!

--Marc

Edit: I just went back and fixed my original post from 1878 to 1978.


FLAG
By KCP
From Eldorado Springs, CO
Dec 16, 2007
KC

Marc Horan wrote:
Uh.. no. Blacks were not welcome into the Mormon religion until 1978. And only because congress pressured them. Less than 30 years ago.


This is not exactly true. It is more involved than that.

Here is a brief background regarding Blacks in the Mormon Church. This link is only one of many easily accessible and historical references to this topic.

I think incomplete and prejudiced comments, like the ones that you have posted, seriously hurt your credibility, and they infer a personal antipathy toward these people and their religion.

I feel the need to clarify my earlier reference to blind adherence to what I believe are false prophets. I was referring to some - not all - members of organized religions. I have some very dear friends in SLC, who are practicing Mormons, and they are highly educated and discerning people. I have had lengthy debates with them about the legitimacy of a higher power, and most of them will admit that their religious conclusions essentially boil down to faith.

Faith fills the voids inherent in happenstance. Without it, humans would have to confront the idea that their associations with family and friends are not eternal and will expire at the end of their ephemeral time on this planet. Call it greedy, but humans need to believe that there is more to life than what we experience during our time on Earth. The idea that we eventually fade to complete unconsciousness is too difficult a pill for most human beings to swallow.

My personal belief is that life is what we can measure. That might make me seem limited or short-sighted to some, although it works for me. I take comfort in believing that this is all that there is. It gives me a sense of control over my options, and it causes me to more intimately appreciate the here and now. It also helps me to practice humanity on a more immediate level, instead of feeling that I will somehow be forgiven for transgressions against my fellow man, in an afterlife, as long as I give myself over to God.

It is because of the power of faith that I have learned to respect people's beliefs in religion. What is wrong with believing is something that motivates you to be a better and more compassionate human being?


FLAG
By kirra
Dec 16, 2007
Stan Marsh South Park CO. <br />We only have 1shot at this <br />because 'Kenny' is not comin' back

Ken Cangi wrote:
I am less surprised at your first comment, after reading your second one. I don't know if you went to college, but I am a little surprised that you are so unaware of one of the most documented and discussed stories in the history of religion and mankind - the history and persecution of the Jews.


oh - 'scuse me for sharing Ken...I am completely aware of their persecution, it's the negative details that I choose not to remember....like your post.

Ken Cangi wrote:
I am constantly reminded of why history repeats itself.


...and I am constantly reminded why there are so many lurkers here on mp. Do you do anything else other that occupy space and belch CO2 here on planet Earth..? ...oh yeah...and attempt to be witty in your enthusiasm to persecute others -- koombaya kenny & give it up to a better bagel baker than yerself ~Cheers..!


FLAG
By KCP
From Eldorado Springs, CO
Dec 16, 2007
KC

Kirra wrote:
oh - 'scuse me for sharing Ken...I am completely aware of their persecution, it's the negative details that I choose not to remember....like your post. ...and I am constantly reminded why there are so many lurkers here on mp. Do you do anything else other that occupy space and belch CO2 here on planet Earth..? ...oh yeah...and attempt to be witty in your enthusiasm to persecute others -- koombaya kenny & give it up to a better bagel baker than yerself ~Cheers..!


Kirra, You said this:

Kirra wrote:
I'd like to know why the Jews are always being picked on. I thought it was only the Natzi's but then heard tonight that the Christians slaughtered them in the 14th cent. blaming them for the plague.


Please explain to me how that sentence reflects a complete understanding of their persecution, when it states the opposite.


I can only go by what you wrote. I am not a mind reader. Try to look at what you wrote, from an outsider's perspective. If you took a moment to temper your hostility, you might see that I was not attacking you. Temper tantrums rarely garner support for one's position. I was merely pointing out what seems to be a pervasive problem in our society.


FLAG
By Marc H
From Lafayette, CO
Dec 16, 2007
The Cathedral Spires in RMNP, left to right: Stiletto, Sharkstooth, Forbidden Tower, Petit Grepon, The Saber, The Foil, The Moon & The Jackknife.

Ken Cangi wrote:
I think incomplete and prejudiced comments, like the ones that you have posted, seriously hurt your credibility, and they infer a personal antipathy toward these people and their religion.



I have never claimed to be an expert on religion. I have stated some facts surrounding Mormonism as I understand them. I referred to the link you provided, although I only looked at it for a few minutes; I did not read the whole thing. In the short time I was on the page, I found this:

From 1848 until 1978 (130 years) black Mormons could not partake of the Higher Ordinances of Mormon Temples (Endowments and Sealings) nor could black Mormon men be ordained to any office in the priesthood (there were only two exceptions to this rule, the son and grandson of Elijah Abel); which every single Mormon male is supposed to hold after the age of 12.

Call my statements incomplete if you like. Anyone who reads one or two sentences about an entire religion and thinks that the thoughts/ideas/facts are complete is a fool. I assumed most people would understand this.

I don't have any antipathy towards Mormons or Mormonism. What I absolutely can't stand is people forcing others to live with their ideals and way of life. (ie religious people making it illegal to sell beer over 3.2% alcohol.) It's one thing to have personal convictions; it's an entirely different thing to force your personal convictions on others. This feeling is not directed exclusively at Mormons. There are areas of the Bible Belt (in Tennesse and such) that also mix church and state.

--Marc


FLAG
By Tico
Dec 16, 2007

Marc Horan wrote:
It's one thing to have personal convictions; it's an entirely different thing to force your personal convictions on others. This feeling is not directed exclusively at Mormons. There are areas of the Bible Belt (in Tennesse and such) that also mix church and state. --Marc


I'd posit that the vast majority of governments on earth mix secular and spiritual matters. You don't have to look to the South or Utah for laws based on Christianity in the US, for example. Forcing one's convictions on others, in some way or another, is a human trait, and one that's not likely to ever fade.


FLAG
By Marc H
From Lafayette, CO
Dec 16, 2007
The Cathedral Spires in RMNP, left to right: Stiletto, Sharkstooth, Forbidden Tower, Petit Grepon, The Saber, The Foil, The Moon & The Jackknife.

Ken Cangi wrote:
Call it greedy, but humans need to believe that there is more to life than what we experience during our time on Earth. The idea that we eventually fade to complete unconsciousness is too difficult a pill for most human beings to swallow.


For the record, I think this is a profound statement. I believe this is the the reason for religion. Humans want to believe that we, as a species, are far too important to simply vanish once our brains stop working. IMO, it's a very arrogant philosophy, but maybe it's true. All that I can really know, is that I'll probably never really know anything. I, personally, believe that my time on Earth is all that I have.

Hopefully my little manifest will help others understand where my other statements came from.

--Marc


FLAG
By Marc H
From Lafayette, CO
Dec 16, 2007
The Cathedral Spires in RMNP, left to right: Stiletto, Sharkstooth, Forbidden Tower, Petit Grepon, The Saber, The Foil, The Moon & The Jackknife.

Tico wrote:
I'd posit that the vast majority of governments on earth mix secular and spiritual matters. You don't have to look to the South or Utah for laws based on Christianity in the US, for example. Forcing one's convictions on others, in some way or another, is a human trait, and one that's not likely to ever fade.


I agree that it's far more prevalent than it should be. But I will not be complacent about it.

--Marc


FLAG
By KCP
From Eldorado Springs, CO
Dec 16, 2007
KC

This:

Marc Horan wrote:
Uh.. no. Blacks were not welcome into the Mormon religion until 1978. And only because congress pressured them. Less than 30 years ago.


is not this:

"From 1848 until 1978 (130 years) black Mormons could not partake of the Higher Ordinances of Mormon Temples (Endowments and Sealings) nor could black Mormon men be ordained to any office in the priesthood (there were only two exceptions to this rule, the son and grandson of Elijah Abel); which every single Mormon male is supposed to hold after the age of 12."

which is what I was trying to point out.

Marc Horan wrote:
What I absolutely can't stand is people forcing others to live with their ideals and way of life. (ie religious people making it illegal to sell beer over 3.2% alcohol.) It's one thing to have personal convictions; it's an entirely different thing to force your personal convictions on others.


First of all, it is not illegal to sell full-strength beer in Utah. It is just managed through state-run liquor stores.

Secondly, Mormons are not forcing their ideals on others. Most members of the LDS church have no problem with the way liquor is managed in their state, and people who move there and complain have only to realize that they went there by choice. It is no secret to anyone with a pulse that Utah was founded by Mormons and that they are pro-active in the management of their state's affairs. However, with approximately fifty percent of Salt Lake's population being non-LDS, in conjunction with the rapid growth of the city, the political infrastructure is slowly changing. People like Rocky Anderson - love him or hate him - are acquiring a strong following of progressive entrepreneurs and secular residents of SLC.

I have to say that there are some advantages to Utah's liquor management - one of them being higher accountability. Every ounce of alcohol served in Utah establishments is metered out on a clicker system, which measures each shot. This helps tavern owners to keep track of their inventory, and it deters bartenders from over-pouring for the sake of increasing their tips. Consequently, the bartenders are held to a higher level of accountability, and the patrons can not blame their high intoxication levels on over-pouring by the bartenders. Are there flaws in the system? Of course, but can you name a system that doesn't have flaws in it?

Marc Horan wrote:
This feeling is not directed exclusively at Mormons. There are areas of the Bible Belt (in Tennesse and such) that also mix church and state.


It occurs in all segments of society.

Interesting discussion.


FLAG

Page 2 of 23.  <Prev  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next>